The terms ‘sustainability’ and ‘sustainable development’ have become established in the popular vernacular in the 25 years or so since the publication of the report of the Brundtland Commission. Often, ‘sustainability’ is thought to represent some long-term goal and ‘sustainable development’ a means or process by which to achieve it. Two fundamental and conflicting philosophical positions underlying these terms are identified. In particular, the commonly held notion that sustainable development can be a pathway to sustainability is challenged, and the expedient view that both terms ultimately serve holistic development is questioned. Furthermore, it is argued that perpetuating the unclear and misleading distinction between the two positions will limit the development of efficacious policy, as it will not resonate with the broadest possible gamut of beliefs and value systems.
AckoffR.L.1979. ‘The future of operational research is past’. Journal of the Operational Research Society30(2): 93–104.
2.
AntalF.1935. ‘Reflections on Classicism and Romanticism’. Burlington Magazine for Connoisseurs66(385): 159–168.
3.
AttfieldR.1987. A Theory of Value and Obligation. New York, USA: Croom Helm.
4.
BagheriA. and HjorthP.. 2007. ‘Planning for sustainable development: a paradigm shift towards a process-based approach’. Sustainable Development15(2): 83–96. CrossRef.
5.
BasiagoA.D.1995. ‘Methods of defining “sustainability”’. Sustainable Development3(3): 109–119. CrossRef.
6.
BaumgärtneraS., BeckerC., FrankK., MüllerB. and QuaasM.. 2008. ‘Relating the philosophy and practice of ecological economics: the role of concepts, models, and case studies in inter- and transdisciplinary sustainability research’. Ecological Economics67(3): 384–393. CrossRef.
7.
BeardsleyM.C.1965. ‘Intrinsic value’. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research26(1): 1–17. CrossRef.
8.
BeckermanW.1994. “‘Sustainable development”: is it a useful concept?’. Environmental Values3(3): 191–209. CrossRef.
9.
BeckermanW.1995. ‘How would you like your sustainability, sir? Weak or strong? A reply to my critics’. Environmental Values4(2): 167–179. CrossRef.
10.
BeltonV. and StewartT.J.. 2002. Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: an Integrated Approach. Norwell, MA, USA: Kluwer Academic Publishers. CrossRef.
11.
Ben-DavidJ. and SullivanT.A.. 1975. ‘Sociology of science’. Annual Review of Sociology1: 203–222. CrossRef.
12.
BloorD.1973. ‘Wittgenstein and Mannheim on the sociology of mathematics’. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A4(2): 173–191. CrossRef.
13.
BrocklesbyJ. and CummingsS.. 1996. ‘Foucault plays Habermas: an alternative philosophical underpinning for critical systems thinking’. Journal of the Operational Research Society47(6): 741–754.
14.
BrundtlandG.1987. Our Common Future: World Commission on Environment and Development. (This edition, with additional material, published in 1990.) Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
15.
BryerR.A.1997. ‘Accounting for the “Bourgeois Revolution” in the English East India Company 1600–1657’. The Fifth Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Accounting Conference, UMIST/University of Manchester.
16.
CallicottJ.1986. ‘On the intrinsic value of non-human species’, in NortonB.G. (ed.), The Preservation of Species: the Value of Biological Diversity, pp. 138–172. Princeton, NJ, USA: Princeton University Press.
17.
ClaytonA.M. and RadcliffeN.J.. 1996. Sustainability: A Systems Approach. London, UK: Earthscan Publications Ltd.
18.
CostanzaR., CumberlandJ.L., DalyH.E., GoodlandR. and NorgaardR.. 1997. An Introduction to Ecological Economics. Boca Raton, FL, USA: St. Lucie Press.
19.
CraftsN.F.1984. ‘Economic growth in France and Britain, 1830–1910: a review of the evidence’. Journal of Economic History44(1): 49–67. CrossRef.
20.
CyphersP.1992. ‘The consumption of paradise’. Art Journal51(2): 52–56. CrossRef.
DeweyJ.1922. ‘Valuation and experimental knowledge’. Philosophical Review31(4): 325–351. CrossRef.
23.
DeweyJ.1942. ‘The ambiguity of “intrinsic good”’. Journal of Philosophy39(12): 328–330. CrossRef.
24.
DobsonA.1998. Justice and the Environment: Conceptions of Environmental Sustainability and Dimensions of Social Justice. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
25.
EhrenfeldJ.R.2008. Sustainability by Design: A Subversive Strategy for Controlling Our Consumer Culture. New Haven, CT, USA: Yale University Press.
26.
EhrlichP.R. and HoldrenJ.P.. 1971. ‘Impact of population growth’. Science, New Series171(3977): 1212–1217.
27.
EkinsP., SimonS., DeutschL., FolkeC. and De GrootR.. 2003. ‘A framework for the practical application of the concepts of critical natural capital and strong sustain-ability’. Ecological Economics44(2–3): 165–185. CrossRef.
28.
ElvinM.1994. ‘Three thousand years of unsustainable growth: China's environment from archaic times to the present’. East Asian History6: 7–46.
29.
ElvinM.1998. ‘The environmental legacy of Imperial China’. China Quarterly156 (Special Issue: China's Environment): 733–756.
30.
FeyerabendP.1975. Against Method. London, UK: Verso.
31.
GroveR.H.1995. Green Imperialism: Colonial Expansion, Tropical Island Edens, and the Origins of Environmentalism, 1600–1860. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
32.
Grove-WhiteR.1997. ‘The environmental “valuation” controversy: observations on its recent history and significance’, in FosterJ. (ed.), Valuing Nature? Economics, Ethics and Environment, pp. 21–30. London, UK: Routledge.
33.
HabermasJ.1976. ‘The analytical theory of science and dialectics (1)’, in AdornoT.W. and AlbertH. (eds), The Positivist Dispute in German Sociology, pp. 131–144. London, UK: Heinemann.
34.
HackingI.1981. ‘Introduction – scientific revolutions’, in HackingI. (ed.), Scientific Revolutions, pp. 1–5. New York, USA: Oxford University Press.
35.
HargroveE.1992. ‘Weak anthropocentric intrinsic value’. Monist 17(2): 183–205 (reprinted in A. Light et al. (2003), Environmental Ethics: an Anthology, pp. 175–190. Maldon, MA, USA: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
36.
HarrisonJ.F.1973. The Birth and Growth of Industrial England 1714–1867. Orlando, FL, USA: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich Inc.
37.
HectorD.C.2011. ‘Sydney's water sewerage and drainage system’. Journal and Proceedings of the Royal Society of New South Wales144(439–440): 3–26.
38.
HectorD.C., ChristensenC.B. and PetrieJ.. 2009. ‘A problem-structuring method for complex societal decisions: its philosophical and psychological dimensions’. European Journal of Operational Research193(3): 693–708. CrossRef.
39.
HodgsonG.1997. ‘Economics, environmental policy and transcendence of utilitarianism’, in FosterJ. (ed.), Valuing Nature? Economics, Ethics and Environment, pp. 48–62. London, UK: Routledge. CrossRef.
40.
HollandA.1997. ‘Substitutability: why strong sustainability is weak and absurdly strong sustainability is not absurd’, in FosterJ. (ed.), Valuing Nature? Economics, Ethics and Environment, pp. 119–133. London, UK: Routledge. CrossRef.
41.
HughesJ.D.1994. ‘Ecology in Imperial Rome’, in WallD. (ed.), Green History: a Reader in Environmental Literature, Philosophy and Politics, pp. 37–40. London, UK: Routledge.
42.
JacksonT.2009. Prosperity Without Growth? The Transition to a Sustainable Economy. London, UK: Sustainable Development Commission.
43.
JacobsM.1995. ‘Sustainable development, capital substitution and economic humility: a response to Beckerman’. Environmental Values4(1): 57–68.
44.
KatzE.1987. ‘Searching for intrinsic value – pragmatism and despair in environmental ethics’. Environmental Ethics9(3): 231–241. CrossRef.
45.
KeatR.1997. ‘Values and preferences in neoclassical environmental economics’, in FosterJ. (ed.), Valuing Nature? Economics, Ethics and Environment, pp. 32–45. London, UK: Routledge. CrossRef.
46.
KincheloeJ.L. and McLarenP.L.. 1994. ‘Rethinking critical theory and qualitative research’, in DenzinN.K. and LincolnY.S. (eds), Handbook of Qualitative Research, pp. 138–141. Thousand Oaks, CA, USA: Sage Publications.
47.
LakatosI.1974. ‘Science and pseudoscience’. Conceptus8: 5–9.
48.
LeeK.1996. ‘The source and locus of intrinsic value: a re-examination’. Environmental Ethics18(3): 297–309 (reprinted in A. Light et al. 2003. Environmental Ethics: an Anthology, pp. 154–162. Maldon, MA, USA: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.). CrossRef.
49.
LightA. and KatzE.. 1996. How Pragmatism is an Environmental Ethic. London, UK: Routledge.
50.
LightA. and RolstonH.III.2003. Environmental Ethics: an Anthology. Malden, MA, USA: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
51.
LoorbachD. and RotmansJ.. 2006. ‘Managing transitions for sustainable development’, in OlsthoornX. and WieczorekA.J. (eds), Understanding Industrial Transformation: Views from Different Disciplines, Dordrecht, Netherlands: Springer. CrossRef.
52.
LozanoR.2008. ‘Envisioning sustainability three-dimensionally’. Journal of Cleaner Production16(17): 1838–1846. CrossRef.
53.
LumS.2009. Sydney's Desalination Plant: Lessons for Critical Infrastructure under the NSW Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979. University of NSW.
MaddisonA.2003. The World Economy: Historical Statistics. Paris, France: OECD Publications Service. CrossRef.
56.
MeadowsD.H. and MeadowsD.L.. 1972. The Limits to Growth. New York, USA: Universe Books.
57.
MertonR.K.1937. ‘The sociology of knowledge’. Isis27(3): 493–503. CrossRef.
58.
MingersJ.1980. ‘Towards an appropriate social theory for applied systems thinking: critical theory and soft systems methodology’. Journal of Applied Systems Analysis7: 41–49.
59.
MitchellT.F.1989. ‘Johann Christian Reinehart and the transformation of heroic landscape, 1790–1800’. Art Bulletin71(4): 646–659. CrossRef.
60.
MogJ.M.2004. ‘Struggling with sustainability – a comparative framework for evaluating sustainable development programs’. World Development31(12): 2139–2160. CrossRef.
61.
MokyrJ.1974. ‘The Industrial Revolution in the Low Countries in the first half of the 19th century: comparative case study’. Journal of Economic History34(2): 365–391. CrossRef.
62.
MooreG.E.1912. Ethics (this edition Ethics and The Nature of Moral Philosophy, with an introduction by William H. Shaw). New York, USA: Oxford University Press.
63.
MundaG.1997. ‘Environmental economics, ecological economics and the concept of sustainable development’. Environmental Values6(2): 213–233. CrossRef.
64.
NortonB.G.2005. Sustainability: a Philosophy of Adaptive Ecosystem Management. Chicago, Illinois, USA: University of Chicago Press. CrossRef.
65.
NortonB.G. and NoonanD.. 2007. ‘Ecology and valuation: big changes needed’. Ecological Economics63(4): 664–675. CrossRef.
66.
O'NeillJ.1992. ‘The varieties of intrinsic value’. Monist75(2): 119–137. CrossRef.
67.
O'NeillJ., HollandA. and LightA.. 2008. Environmental Values. Oxford, UK: Routledge.
68.
OvertonM.1985. ‘The diffusion of agricultural innovations in early modern England: turnips and clover in Norfolk and Suffolk, 1580–1740’. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series10(2): 205–221. CrossRef.
69.
PearceD.2002. ‘An intellectual history of environmental economics’. Annual Review of Energy and the Environment27: 57–81. CrossRef.
70.
PearceD., MarkandyaA. and BarbierE.B.. 1989. Blueprint for a Green Economy. London, UK: Earthscan Publications Ltd.
71.
PezzoliK.1997. ‘Sustainable development: A transdisciplinary overview of the literature’. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management40(5): 549–601. CrossRef.
PopperK.R.1976. ‘Logic of the social sciences’, in AdornoT.W. and AlbertH. (eds), The Positivist dispute in German sociology, London, UK: Heinemann.
74.
PutnamH.1981. ‘The corroboration of theories’, in HackingI. (ed.), Scientific Revolutions, pp. 61–79. New York, USA: Oxford University Press.
75.
Ramos-MartinJ.2003. ‘Empiricism in ecological economics: a perspective from complex systems theory’. Ecological Economics46(3): 387–398. CrossRef.
76.
RaynerS. and MaloneE.L.. 1998. ‘Natural science and the social sciences’, in RaynerS. and MaloneE.L. (eds), Better Environmental Decisions: Strategies for Governments, Businesses, and Communities, pp. 34–69. Columbus, Ohio, USA: Batelle Press.
77.
RobinsonJ.2004. ‘Squaring the circle? Some thoughts on the idea of sustainable development’. Ecological Economics48(4): 369–384. CrossRef.
78.
RolstonH.III2005. ‘F/actual knowing: putting facts and values in place’. Ethics and the Environment10(2): 137–174.
79.
RøpkeI.2004. ‘The early history of modern ecological economics’. Ecological Economics50(3–4): 293–314. CrossRef.
80.
RosenthalS.B. and BuchholzR.A.. 1996. ‘How pragmatism is an environmental ethic’, in LightA. and KatzE. (eds), Environmental Pragmatism, pp. 38–49. London, UK: Routledge.
81.
Roxbee CoxJ.1997. ‘The relations between preservation value and existence value’, in FosterJ. (ed.), Valuing Nature? Economics, Ethics and Environment, pp. 103–117. London, UK: Routledge. CrossRef.
82.
SachsJ.D.2005. Investing in Development: A practical plan to achieve the Millennium Development Goals. New York, USA: United Nations Millennium Project.
83.
SaganC., ToonO.B. and PollackJ.B.. 1979. ‘Anthropogenic albedo changes and the Earth's climate’. Science, New Series, 206(4425): 1363–1368.
84.
SchmidtL.B.1930. ‘The agricultural revolution in the United States – 1860–1930’. Science, New Series72(1876): 585–594.
85.
SpangenbergJ.H.2005. ‘Economic sustainability of the economy: concepts and indicators’. International Journal of Sustainable Development, 8(1–2): 47–64. CrossRef.
86.
SpashC.1999. ‘The development of environmental thinking in economics’. Environmental Values8(4): 413–435. CrossRef.
87.
SpashC. and AslaksenI.. 2012. Re-establishing an Ecological Discourse in the Debate over the Value of Ecosystems and Biodiversity. Vienna: WU Vienna University of Economics and Business.
88.
SpashC. and VatnA.. 2006. ‘Transferring environmental value estimates: issues and alternatives’. Ecological Economics60(2): 379–388. CrossRef.
89.
TurnerR.K.1993. Sustainable Environmental Economics and Management: Principles and Practice.London, UK: Belhaven Press.
90.
UlrichW.1988. ‘Systems thinking, systems practice, and practical philosophy: a program of research’. Systems Practice1(2): 137–163. CrossRef.
91.
United Nations. 26 August–4 September2002. Report of the World Summit on Sustainable Development. Johannesburg, South Africa: United Nations.
92.
UNDFSD.1993. Agenda 21: Earth Summit – The United Nations Programme of Action from Rio. New York, USA: United Nations Division for Sustainable Development.
93.
von BertalanffyL.1950. ‘An Outline of General System Theory’. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science1(2): 134–165. CrossRef.
94.
WaasT., HugéJ., VerbruggenA. and WrightT.. 2012. ‘Sustainable development: a bird's eye view’. Sustainability3: 1637–1661. CrossRef.
95.
WallD.1994. Green History: a Reader in Environmental Literature, Philosophy and Politics. London, UK: Routledge.
WiersumK.F.1995. ‘200 years of sustainability in forestry: lessons from history’. Environmental Management19(3): 321–329. CrossRef.
98.
WilkinsonR.G.1988. ‘The English Industrial Revolution’, in WorsterD. (ed.), The Ends of the Earth: Perspectives on Modern Environmental History, pp. 80–102. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
