This paper is about how we should evaluate our tendencies to find – or fail to find – different meanings in the natural world. It has three aims: (1) to show that some virtues and vices can be exhibited in our tendencies to find or to overlook the meanings of natural things, even if it is unclear whether any can only be exhibited in our relations with such things; (2) to categorise some of the relevant virtues and vices; and (3) to refute the objection that meaning-focused approaches to environmental philosophy, of the sort adopted by writers such as Alan Holland and myself, cannot adequately account for nature's independence from human concerns.
AttfieldR.2005. ‘Unprojected value, unfathomed caves and unspent nature: Reply to an editorial’. Environmental Values14: 513–18. CrossRef.
2.
Bosworth SmithR.1905. Bird Life and Bird Lore. London: John Murray. CrossRef.
3.
BradyE.2003. Aesthetics of the Natural Environment. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
4.
CarlsonA. [1979] 2004. ‘Appreciation of the natural environment’. In CarlsonA. and BerleantA. (eds.) The Aesthetics of Natural Environments (Toronto: Broadview), pp. 63–75.
5.
CockerM.2008. Crow Country. London: Vintage.
6.
CooperD. E.2003. Meaning. Chesham: Acumen.
7.
CooperD. E.2006. A Philosophy of Gardens. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
8.
EatonM. [1998] 2004. ‘Fact and fiction in the aesthetic appreciation of nature’. In CarlsonA. and BerleantA. (eds.), The Aesthetics of Natural Environments (Toronto: Broadview), pp. 170–81.
9.
FirthD.2008. ‘Do meaningful relationships with nature contribute to a worthwhile life?’ Environmental Values17 (2): 145–64. CrossRef.
10.
GaitaR.2003. The Philosopher's Dog. London: Routledge.
11.
GodlovitchS. [1994] 2004. ‘Icebreakers: Environmentalism and natural aesthetics’. In CarlsonA. and BerleantA. (eds.), The Aesthetics of Natural Environments (Toronto: Broadview), pp. 108–26.
12.
GriceH. P.1957. ‘Meaning’. The Philosophical Review66: 377–88. CrossRef.
HepburnR. W.1984. ‘Wonder’ and Other Essays: Eight Studies in Aesthetics and Neighbouring Fields. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
15.
HepburnR. W.1997. ‘Trivial and serious in aesthetic appreciation of nature’. In ChappellT. (ed.), The Philosophy of the Environment (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press), pp. 65–77.
16.
HillT. [1983] 2005. ‘Ideals of human excellence and preserving natural environments’. In SandlerR. and CafaroP. (eds.), Environmental Virtue Ethics (Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield), pp. 47–59.
17.
HollandA.2012. ‘The value space of meaningful relations’. In BradyE. and PhemisterP. (eds.), Transformative Values: Human-Environment Relations in Theory and Practice (Dordrecht: Springer), pp. 3–15. CrossRef.
18.
JamesS. P.2013. ‘Philistinism and the preservation of nature’. Philosophy88 (343): 101–114.
19.
JamesS. P.2009. The Presence of Nature: A Study in Phenomenology and Environmental Philosophy. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan.
20.
KazantzakisN.1958. Zorba the Greek, trans. WildmanC.. London: Faber and Faber.
MooreR. [1999] 2004. ‘Appreciating natural beauty as natural’. In CarlsonA. and BerleantA. (eds.), The Aesthetics of Natural Environments (Toronto: Broadview), pp. 214–31.
27.
MurdochI.1971. The Sovereignty of Good. Abingdon: Routledge.
28.
MynottJ.2009. Birdscapes: Birds in our Experience and Imagination. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
29.
RuskinJ. [1856] 1912. Selections from the Writings of John Ruskin. Edinburgh: W. P. Nimmo, Hay & Mitchell.
30.
SaitoY. [1998] 2004. ‘Appreciating nature on its own terms’. In CarlsonA. and BerleantA. (eds.), The Aesthetics of Natural Environments (Toronto: Broadview), pp. 141–55.
31.
SandlerR.2007. Character and Environment: A Virtue-Oriented Approach to Environmental Ethics. New York: Columbia University Press.
32.
VogelS.2003. ‘The nature of artifacts’. Environmental Ethics25 (2): 149–68. CrossRef.
33.
WhiteL.1947. ‘Natural science and naturalistic art in the Middle Ages’. The American Historical Review52 (3): 421–35. CrossRef.
34.
WittgensteinL. [1953] 1991. Philosophical Investigations (2nd edn), trans. AnscombeG. E. M.. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
