Was Aldo Leopold a Pragmatist? Rescuing Leopold from the Imagination of Bryan Norton

Abstract

Aldo Leopold was a pragmatist in the vernacular sense of the word. Bryan G. Norton claims that Leopold was also heavily influenced by American Pragmatism, a formal school of philosophy. As evidence, Norton offers Leopold's misquotation of a definition of right (as truth) by political economist, A.T. Hadley, who was an admirer of the philosophy of William James. A search of Leopold's digitised literary remains reveals no other evidence that Leopold was directly influenced by any actual American Pragmatist or by Pragmatism (although he may have been indirectly influenced by Pragmatism early in his career). A 1923 reference, by Leopold, to Hadley and Hadley's putative definition of truth, cited by Norton, is dripping with irony. Leopold, as he matured philosophically, regarded a profound cultural shift from anthropocentric dominionism and consumerism to an evolutionary-ecological worldview and an associated non-anthropocentric ‘land ethic’ to be necessary for successful and sustainable conservation. Hadley espoused a brutal form of Social Darwinism and his philosophy, as expressed in the book of Hadley's that Norton cites, is politically reactionary, militaristic and unconcerned with conservation. Leopold's mature philosophy and Hadley's – far from consonant, as Norton claims – are diametrically opposed.

Keywords

Hadley conservation ecology evolution nonanthropocentric

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Callicott

J.B.

1987. ‘The conceptual foundations of “The Land Ethic”’. In Callicott

J.B.

(ed.), Companion to ‘A Sand County Almanac’: Interpretive and Critical Essays (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 186–217.

Darwin

1874. The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex. 2nd edn. New York: Crowell.

Emerson

R.W.

1899. ‘Civilization’. In Society and Solitude (Cambridge, MA: Riverside), pp. 21–37.

Flader

S.L.

1974. Thinking Like a Mountain: Aldo Leopold and the Evolution of an Ecological Attitude toward Deer, Wolves, and Forests. Columbia: University of Missouri Press.

Goodwin

C.D.

2008. ‘Ecologist meets economics: Aldo Leopold, 1887–1948’. Journal of the History of Economic Thought 30(4): 429–452.

James

1907. ‘What pragmatism means’. In Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking (New York: Longman, Green and Co.), pp. 17–32.

Hadley

A.T.

1885. Railroad Transportation: Its History and Laws. New York: Knickerbocker Press.

Hadley

A.T.

1896. Economics: An Account of the Relations between Private Property and Public Welfare. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons.

Hadley

A.T.

1913. Some Influences in Modern Philosophic Thought. New Haven: Yale University Press.

10.

Leopold

1949. A Sand County Almanac and Sketches Here and There. New York: Oxford University Press.

11.

Leopold

1987. ‘Foreword’. In Callicott

J.B.

(ed.), Companion to ‘A Sand County Almanac’: Interpretive and Critical Essays (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 281–288.

12.

Leopold

1991a. ‘Report to the American Game Conference on an American game policy’. In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 150–155. Originally published in Transactions, 17th American Game Conference (Dec. 1–2, 1930): 281–283.

13.

Leopold

1991b. ‘Game and wildlife conservation’. In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 164–168. Originally published in The Condor 34(2), 1932: 103–106.

14.

Leopold

1991c. ‘Some fundamentals in conservation in the Southwest’. In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 86–97. Originally published in Environmental Ethics 1(2), 1979: 131–141.

15.

Leopold

1991d. ‘The wilderness and its place in forest recreational policy’. In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 78–81. Originally published in Journal of Forestry 19(7), 1921: 718–721.

16.

Leopold

1991e. ‘The Arboretum and the university’. In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 209–211. Originally published in Parks and Recreation 18(2), 1934: 59–60.

17.

Leopold

1991f. ‘The farmer as a conservationist’. In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 255–265. Originally published in American Forests 45(6), 1939: 294–299, 316, 323.

18.

Leopold

1991g. ‘What is a weed?’ In Flader

S.L.

and Callicott

J.B.

(eds.), The River of the Mother of God and Other Essays by Aldo Leopold (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 306–309.

19.

Meine

1988. Aldo Leopold: His Life and Work. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

20.

Miller

Char

. 2004. Gifford Pinchot and the Making of Modern Environmentalism. Washington, D.C.: Island Press.

21.

Minteer

2006. The Landscape of Reform: Civic Pragmatism and Environmental Thought in America. Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.

22.

Newton

J.L.

2006. Aldo Leopold's Odyssey: Rediscovering the Author of ‘A Sand County Almanac’. Washington, D.C.: Island Press.

23.

Norton

B.G.

1988. ‘The constancy of Leopold's land ethic’. Conservation Biology 2(1): 93–102).

24.

Norton

B.G.

1991. Toward Unity Among Environmentalists. New York: Oxford University Press.

25.

Norton

B.G.

2005. Sustainability: A Philosophy of Adaptive Ecosystem Management. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

26.

Pinchot

1947. Breaking New Ground. New York: Harcourt Brace.

27.

Snow

1999. ‘Do economists know about lupines?’ In Meine

and Knight

R.L.

(eds.), The Essential Aldo Leopold: Quotations and Commentaries (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 190–200.

28.

Stephens

P.H.G.

2007. ‘Book review essay: sustainability, democracy, and pragmatism: Bryan Norton's philosophy of ecosystem management’, Organization and Environment 20(3): 386–392.

29.

Tallmadge

1987. ‘Anatomy of a classic’. In Callicott

J.B.

(ed.), Companion to ‘A Sand County Almanac’: Interpretive and Critical Essays (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press), pp. 110–127.

30.

Varner

1998. In Nature's Interests? Interests, Animal Rights, and Environmental Ethics. New York: Oxford University Press.