This paper explores the context of environmental justice (EJ) in Scotland, and presents a case study whereby the main attributes for an indicator of EJ were identified, encompassing procedural and distributive aspects of justice. Through a participatory process, weights were assigned using a Multi-Criteria Analysis tool, the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). Results show that overall, environmental injustices are mostly associated by respondents to unequal distribution of health burdens due to pollution, yet greater weight is attached to procedural justice by community environmental activists. The paper suggests that AHP may be applied to many situations and could form a basis for the development of tools to address and deliver EJ in Scotland.
AlphonceC.B. (1997). Application of the Analytical Hierarchy Process in Agriculture to Developing Countries. Agricultural Systems53 (1): 97–113.
2.
AtkinsonG., MachadoF. and MouratoS. (2000). Balancing Competing Principles of Environmental Equity. Environment and Planning A32: 1791–1806.
3.
DalyH.E. and CobbJ.B. (1989). For the Common Good: Redirecting the Economy Towards Community, the Environment and a Sustainable Future.London: Green Print.
4.
DobsonA. (1998). Justice and the Environment. Oxford: OUP.
5.
DunionK. (2003). Troublemakers: The Struggle for Environmental Justice in Scotland.Edinburgh: EUP
6.
DunionK. and ScandrettE. (2003). The Campaign for Environmental Justice in Scotland as a Response to Poverty in a Northern Nation. In AgyemanJ., BullardR.D. and EvansB. B (eds.), Just Sustainabilities: Development in an Unequal World, pp. 311–22. London: Earthscan.
7.
Environment Agency (2002). Our Urban Future: Putting the Environment at the Heart of Urban Renewal.Bristol: United Kingdom.
8.
ESRC, Economic and Social Research Council Global Environmental Change Programme (2001). Environmental Justice: Rights and Means to a Healthy Environment for All. Special Briefing No 7. University of Sussex.
JacksonT. and MarksN. (1994). Measuring Sustainable Economic Welfare – a Pilot Index 1950–1990.London: New Economics Foundation and Stockholm Environment Institute.
16.
JenkinsP., KirkK and SmithH (2002). Getting Involved in Planning: Perceptions of the Wider Public.Edinburgh: Scottish Executive Social Research
17.
MitchellG. and DorlingD. (2003). An Environmental Justice Analysis of British Air Quality. Environment and Planning A, 3: 909–29.
18.
NobleM., SmithG., WrightG., DibbenC., LloydM., RatcliffeA., McLellanD., SigalaM. and AnttilaC. (2003). Scottish Indices of Deprivation. Social Deprivation Research Centre. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
PaavolaJ. and AdgerW.N. (2002). Justice and Adaptation to Climate Change. Tyndall Centre Working Paper 23.
21.
Partnership Agreement:A Partnership for a Better Scotland. (May 2003). Scottish Labour Party and Scottish Liberal Democrats
22.
SaatyT.L. (1980). The Analytical Hierarchy Process. New York: John Wiley.
23.
ScandrettE. (2000). Community Work, Sustainable Development and Environmental Justice. Scottish Journal of Community Work and Development, Vol 6. http://www.foe-scotland.org.uk/nation/ej2.html
Scottish Executive (2002). Social Justice: A Scotland Where Everyone Matters. Milestone Sources and Definitions.Annex to Social Justice Annual Report 2002. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
26.
Scottish Executive (2003a). Indicators of Sustainable Development for Scotland. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
27.
Scottish Executive (2003b). Your Place, Your Plan: a White Paper on Public Involvement in Planning.Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
28.
UNECE (1998). Aarhus Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters.
29.
Van der BerghJ.C.J.M and VerbruggenH. (1999). ‘Spatial sustainability, trade and indicators: an evaluation of the ecological footprint’ Ecological Economics, 29: 61–72.
30.
YearleyS., CinderbyS., ForresterJ., BaileyP. and RosenP. (2003). Participatory Modelling and the Local Governance of the Politics of UK Air Pollution: A Three-City Case Study. Environmental Values, 12: 247–62.
