The trend in environmental management toward more adaptive, community-based, and holistic approaches will require new approaches to environmental valuation. In this paper, we offer a new valuation approach, one that embodies the core principles of adaptive management, which is experimental, multi-scalar, and place-based. In addition, we use hierarchy theory to incorporate spatial and temporal variability of natural systems into a multi-scalar management model. Our approach results in the consideration of multiple values within community-based ecosystem management, rather than an attempt to maximise a single variable such as economic efficiency. We then offer two heuristics – one procedural and one evaluative – to guide a community toward shared goals, and to develop indicators to measure progress toward these goals. We illustrate our approach by application to environmental and developmental decisions in the Southern Appalachians.
AllenT.F.H. and HoekstraT.W.1992. Toward a Unified Ecology: Complexity in Ecological Systems.New York: Columbia University Press.
4.
AllenT.F.H. and StarrT.B.1982. Hierarchy: Perspectives for Ecological Complexity.Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
5.
AriansenPer. 1997. ‘The Non-utility Value of Nature. An Investigation into Biodiversity and the Value of Natural Wholes’. In Skogforsk, Communications of the Norwegian Forest Research Institute, (Meddelelser fra Skogforsk) 47. Agricultural University of Norway, Aas, Norway.
6.
BlameyR.K., CommonM.S., and NortonT.W.1993. ‘Sustainability and Environmental Valuation’, Environmental Values, 2: 299–334.
7.
BurgessJ., HarrisonC.M., and LimbM.1988a. ‘Exploring Environmental Values Through the Medium of Small Groups. Part One: Theory and Practice’, Environment and Planning A, 20: 309–326.
8.
BurgessJ., HarrisonC.M., and LimbM.1988b. ‘Exploring Environmental Values Through the Medium of Small Groups. Part Two: Illustrations of a Group at Work’, Environment and Planning A, 20: 457–476.
9.
BurgessJ, HarrisonC.M., and FilusP.1998. ‘Environmental Communication and the Cultural Politics of Environmental Citizenship’, Environment and Planning A, 30(8): 1445–1460.
10.
CortnerH.J. and MooteM.A.1994. ‘Trends and Issues in Land and Water Resources Management: Setting the Agena for Change’, Environmental Management, 18: 167–173.
11.
DanielsS., and WalkerG.1996. ‘Collaborative Learning: Improving Public Deliberation in Ecosystem-Based Management’, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 16: 71–102.
12.
EhrenfeldD.1993. Beginning Again: People and Nature in the New Millennium.New York: Oxford University Press.
13.
FreemanR.1993. The Measurement of Environmental and Resource Values.Washington, D.C.: Resources for the Future.
14.
GlasserH.1995. Towards a Descriptive, Participatory Theory of Environmental Policy Analysis. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Davis.
15.
GregoryR., and KeeneyR. L.1994. ‘Creating Policy Alternatives Using Stakeholder Values’, Management Science, 40(8): 1035–1048.
16.
GregoryR., KeeneyR. L., and von WinterfeldtD.1992. ‘Adapting the Environmental Impact Statement Process to Inform Decisionmakers’, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 11(1): 58–75.
17.
GregoryR., LichtensteinS., and SlovicP.1993. ‘Valuing Environmental Resources: A Constructive Approach’, Journal of Risk Uncertainty, 7: 177–197.
18.
GretherD.M. and PlottC.R.1979. ‘Economic Theory of Choice and the Preference Reversal Phenomenon’, American Economic Review, 69: 623–638.
19.
GrumbineR. E.1994. ‘What Is Ecosystem Management?’ Conservation Biology, 1: 27–38.
20.
GundersenA.G.1995. The Environmental Promise of Democratic Deliberation.Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
21.
GundersonL., HollingC.S., and LightS.1995. ‘Barriers Broken and Bridges Built: A Synthesis’. In Barriers and Bridges.New York: Columbia University Press.
22.
HarrisonC.M., BurgessJ, and FiliusP.1996. ‘Rationalising Environmental Responsibilities: Comparison of Lay Publics in the UK and the Netherlands’, Global Environmental Change, 6(3): 215–234.
23.
HollingC.S.1978. ‘Adaptive Environmental Assessment and Management’, Wiley IIASA International Series on Applied Systems Analysis.New York: John Wiley & Sons.
24.
HollingC.S.1992. ‘Cross-Scale Morphology, Geometry and Dynamics of Ecosystems’, Ecological Monographs, 62(4): 447–502.
25.
HollingC.S.1996. ‘Engineering Resilience versus Ecological Resilience’, In SchulzeP.C. (ed.) Engineering within Ecological Constraints.Washington, D.C.: The National Academy Press.
26.
InnesJ.E. and BooherD.F.1999a. ‘Consensus Building as Role Playing and Bricolage: Toward a theory of collaborative planning’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 65(1): 9–26.
27.
InnesJ.E. and BooherD.F.1999b. ‘Consensus Building and Complex Adaptive Systems: A framework for evaluating collaborative planning’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 65(4): 412–423.
28.
KahnemanD., SlovicP., and TverskyA. (eds) 1982. Judgement under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases.New York: Cambridge University Press.
29.
KemmisDaniel. 1990. Community and Politics of Place.Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma.
30.
KemptonW., BosterJ.S., and HartleyJ.A.1995. Environmental Values in American Culture.Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
31.
KeeneyR. L.1996. ‘Value-focused Thinking: Identifying Decision Opportunities and Creating Alternatives’, European Journal of Operational Research, (92): 537–549.
32.
KuhnT.1996. Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 3rd Edn. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
33.
LeeK.1993. Compass and Gyroscope.Covelo, CA: Island Press.
34.
LeopoldA.1949. A Sand County Almanac.London: Oxford University Press.
35.
McClainR.J. and LeeR.G.1996) ‘Adaptive Management: Promises and Pitfalls’, Environmental Management, 20: 437–448.
36.
MaclarenV.1996. ‘Urban Sustainability Reporting’, Journal of the American Planning Association62(1): 184–202.
37.
MorrisonRoy. 1995. Ecological Democracy.Boston, MA: Boston South End Press.
38.
NortonB.G.1988. ‘The Constancy of Leopold's Land Ethic’, Conservation Biology, 2(1): 93–102.
39.
NortonB.G.1990. ‘Context and Hierarchy in Aldo Leopold's Theory of Environmental Management’, Ecological Economics, 2: 119–127.
40.
NortonB.G.1991. Toward Unity Among Environmentalists.New York: Oxford University Press.
41.
NortonB.G.1994. ‘Economists’ Preferences and the Preferences of Economists’, Environmental Values, 3: 311–332.
NortonB.G.1995b. ‘Ecological Integrity and Social Values: At What Scale?’ Ecosystem Health, 1: 228–241.
44.
NortonB.G.1996. ‘Integration or Reduction’. In LightA. and KatzE. (eds), Environmental Pragmatism.London: Routledge.
45.
NortonB.G.1999. ‘Ecology and Opportunity: Intergenerational Equity and Sustainable Options’. In DobsonA. (ed.), Fairness and Futurity.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
46.
NortonB.G., CostanzaR., and BishopR.1998. ‘The Evolution of Preferences: Why ‘Sovereign’ Preferences May Not Lead To Sustainable Policies And What To Do About It’, Ecological Economics, 24(2,3): 193–212.
47.
NortonB.G., and HannonB.1998. ‘Democracy and Sense of Place Value’, Philosophy and Geography, 3: 119–245.
48.
NortonB.G., and TomanM.1997. ‘Sustainability: Ecological and Economic Perspectives’, Land Economics, 73(4): 553–568.
49.
NortonB.G., and UlanowiczR.E.1992. ‘Scale and Biodiversity Policy: A Hierarchical Approach’, Ambio, 21: 244–249.
50.
O'NeillR.V., DeAngelisD.L., WaideJ.B., and AllenT.F.H.1986. A Hierarchical Concept of Ecosystems.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
51.
PageT.1977. Conservation and Economic Efficiency.Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
52.
ReichR.B.1988. ‘Policy Making in a Democracy’. In ReichR.B., (ed.), The Power of Public Ideas.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
53.
SabatierP.A.1998. ‘The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Revisions and Relevance for Europe’, Journal of European Public Policy5(1): 98–130.
54.
SagoffM.1988. The Economy of the Earth.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
55.
SagoffM.1998. ‘Aggregation and Deliberation in Valuing Environmental Public Goods: A Look Beyond Contingent Pricing’, Ecological Economics, 24(2,3): 213–230.
56.
SamsonF.B., and KnopfF.L. (eds) 1996. Ecosystem Management.New York: Springer-Verlag, Inc.
57.
ShepherdA.1998. ‘Post Project Monitoring and Impact Assessment’, In FittipaldiH. and PorterA. (eds), Environmental Methods Review: Retooling Impact Assessment for the New Century.Washington DC: Army Environmental Policy Institute.
58.
ShepherdA., and BowlerC.1997. ‘Beyond the Requirements: Improving Public Participation in EIA’, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 40(6): 725–738.
59.
Shrader-FrechetteK.S. and McCoyE.D.1994. Method in Ecology: Strategies in Conservation.New York: Cambridge University Press.
60.
SlovikP.1995. ‘The Construction of Preference’, American Psychologist, 50: 364–371.
61.
SlovicP., GriffinD. and TverskyA., 1990. ‘Compatibility Effects in Judgement and Choice’. In HogarthRobin M. (ed.) Insights in Decision Making: A Tribute to Hillel J. Einhorn, 5–27. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
StiglerG. J. and BeckerG. S.1977. ‘De gustibus non est disputandum’, American Economic Review, 67(March): 76–90.
64.
ToulminS.1972. Human Knowledge, Vol. 1. Princeton, NJ.: Princeton University Press.
65.
TverskyA., SlovicP. and KahnemanD.1990. ‘The Causes of Preference Reversal’, American Economic Review, 80: 204–217.
66.
United Nations Conference on Human Settlements (UNCHS), 1994. Report of the Expert Group Meeting on Urban Indicators for Country Reporting.Geneva: UNCHS (Habitat II).
67.
United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) Science Advisory Board, 1990. Reducing Risk: Setting Priorities and Strategies for Environmental Protection.
68.
VatnA., and BromleyD.W.1994. ‘Choices without Prices without Apologies’, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 26: 129–148.
69.
von WinterfeldtD., and EdwardsW.1986. Decision Analysis and Behavioral Research.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
70.
WaltersC.J.1997. ‘Challenges in Adaptive Management of Riparian and Coastal Ecosystems. Conservation Ecology1(2). http://www.consecol.org/vol1/iss2/art1
71.
WaltersC.J.1986. Adaptive Management of Natural Resources.New York: MacMillan.
72.
WeblerT., KastenholzH., and RennO.1995. ‘Public Participation in Impact Assessment: A Social Learning Perspective’, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 15: 443–463.
