Propensity of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Lines During Early Stage of Lineage Specification Controls Their Terminal Differentiation into Mature Cell Types

Abstract

Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) are able to stably maintain their characteristics for an unlimited period; nevertheless, substantial differences among cell lines in gene and protein expression not manifested during the undifferentiated state may appear when cells differentiate. It is widely accepted that developing an efficient protocol to control the differentiation of hESCs will enable us to produce adequate numbers of desired cell types with relative ease for diverse applications ranging from basic research to cell therapy and drug screening. Hence of late, there has been considerable interest in understanding whether and how hESC lines are equivalent or different to each other in their in vitro developmental tendencies. In this study, we compared the developmental competences of two hESC lines (HUES-9 and HUES-7) at molecular, cellular and functional levels, upon spontaneous differentiation without any added inducing agents. Both cell lines generated the three embryonic germ layers, extra-embryonic tissues and primordial germ cells during embryoid body (EB) formation. However HUES-9 showed a stronger propensity towards formation of neuroectodermal lineages, whereas HUES-7 differentiated preferentially into mesoderm and endoderm. Upon further differentiation, HUES-9 generated largely neural cells (neurons, oligodendrocytes, astrocytes and gangliosides) whereas HUES-7 formed mesendodermal derivatives, including cardiomyocytes, skeletal myocytes, endothelial cells, hepatocytes and pancreatic cells. Overall, our findings endorse the hypothesis that independently-derived hESCs biologically differ among themselves, thereby displaying varying differentiation propensity. These subtle differences not only highlight the importance of screening and deriving lines for lineage-specific differentiation but also indicate that individual lines may possess a repertoire of capabilities that is unique.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Thompson JA, Itskovitz-Eldor J, Shapiro SS, Waknitz MA, Swiergiel JJ, Marshall VS, Jones JM. Embryonic stem cell lines derived from human blastocysts. Science 282:1145–1147, 1998.

Keller G. Embryonic stem cell differentiation: emergence of a new era in biology and medicine. Genes Dev 19:1129–1155, 2005.

Hoffman LM, Carpenter MK. Characterization and culture of human embryonic stem cells. Nat Biotechnol 23(6):699–708, 2005.

Pal R, Khanna A. Similar pattern in cardiac differentiation of human embryonic stem cell lines, BG01V and ReliCellhES1, under low serum concentration supplemented with bone morphogenetic protein-2. Differentiation 75:112–122, 2007.

Denning C, Allegrucci C, Priddle H, Barbadillo-Munoz MD, Anderson D, Self T, Smith NM, Parkin CT, Young LE. Common culture conditions for maintenance and cardiomyocyte differentiation of the human embryonic stem cell lines, BG01 and HUES-7. Int J Dev Biol 50:27–37, 2006.

Oh SK, Kim HS, Ahn HJ, Seol HW, Kim YY, Park YB, Yoon CJ, Kim DW, Kim SH, Moon SY. Derivation and characterization of new human embryonic stem cell lines: SNUhES1, SNUhES2, and SNUhES3. Stem Cells 23:211–219, 2005.

Ward CM, Barrow KM, Stern PL. Significant variations in differentiation properties between independent mouse ES cell lines cultured under defined conditions. Exp Cell Res 293:229–238, 2004.

Bibikova M, Chudin E, Wu B, Zhou L, Garcia EW, Liu Y, Shin S, Plaia TW, Auerbach JM, Arking DE, Gonzalez R, Crook J, Davidson B, Schulz TC, Robins A, Khanna A, Sartipy P, Hyllner J, Vanguri P, Savant-Bhonsale S, Smith AK, Chakravarti A, Maitra A, Rao M, Barker DL, Loring JF, Fan JB. Human embryonic stem cells have a unique epigenetic signature. Genome Res 16(9):1075–1083, 2006.

Lagarkova MA, Volchkov PY, Lyakisheva AV, Philonenko ES, Kiselev SL. Diverse epigenetic profile of novel human embryonic stem cell lines. Cell Cycle 5:416–420, 2006.

10.

Hoffman LM, Hall L, Batten JL, Young H, Pardasani D, Baetge EE, Lawrence J, Carpenter MK. X-inactivation status varies in human embryonic stem cell lines. Stem Cells 23:1468–1478, 2005.

11.

Abeyta MJ, Clark AT, Rodriguez RT, Bodnar MS, Pera RA, Firpo MT. Unique gene expression signatures of independently-derived human embryonic stem cell lines. Hum Mol Genet 13:601–608, 2004.

12.

Rao RR, Calhoun JD, Qin X, Rekaya R, Clark JK, Stice SL. Comparative transcriptional profiling of two human embryonic stem cell lines. Biotechnol Bioeng 88:273–286, 2004.

13.

Skottman H, Stromberg AM, Matilainen E, Inzunza J, Hovatta O, Lahesmaa R. Unique gene expression signature by human embryonic stem cells cultured under serum free conditions correlates with their enhanced and prolonged growth in an undifferentiated stage. Stem Cells 24:151–167, 2005.

14.

Kitsberg D. Human embryonic stem cells for tissue engineering. Methods Mol Med 140:33–65, 2007.

15.

Pyle AD, Lock LF, Donovan PJ. Neurotrophins mediate human embryonic stem cell survival. Nat Biotechnol 24:344–350, 2006.

16.

Schatten G, Smith J, Navara C, Park JH, Pedersen R. Culture of human embryonic stem cells. Nat Methods 2:455–463, 2005.

17.

Peerani R, Rao BM, Bauwens C, Yin T, Wood GA, Nagy A Kumacheva E, Zandstra PW. Niche-mediated control of human embryonic stem cell self-renewal and differentiation. EMBO J 26: 4744–4755, 2007.

18.

Ng ES, Davis RP, Azzola L, Stanley EG, Elefanty AG. Forced aggregation of defined numbers of human embryonic stem cells into embryoid bodies fosters robust, reproducible hematopoietic differentiation. Blood 106:1601–1603, 2005.

19.

Ungrin MD, Joshi C, Nica A, Bauwens C, Zandstra PW. Reproducible, ultra high-throughput formation of multicellular organization from single cell suspension-derived human embryonic stem cell aggregates. PLoS One 3:e1565, 2008.

20.

Burridge PW, Anderson D, Priddle H, Barbadillo Munoz MD, Chamberlain S, Allegrucci C, Young LE, Denning C. Improved human embryonic stem cell embryoid body homogeneity and cardiomyocyte differentiation from a novel V-96 plate aggregation system highlights interline variability. Stem Cells 25:929–938, 2007.

21.

Chen Z, de Paiva CS, Luo L, Kretzer FL, Pflugfelder SC, Li DQ. Characterization of putative stem cell phenotype in human limbal epithelia. Stem Cells 22(3):355–366, 2004.

22.

Wilkinson DG, Bhatt S, Herrmann BG. Expression pattern of the mouse T gene and its role in mesoderm formation. Nature 343:657–659, 1990.

23.

Kamochi H, Kurokawa MS, Yoshikawa H, Ueda Y, Masuda C, Takada E, Watanabe K, Sakakibara M, Natuki Y, Kimura K, Beppu M, Aoki H, Suzuki N. Transplantation of myocyte precursors derived from embryonic stem cells transfected with IGFII gene in a mouse model of muscle injury. Transplantation 82:516–526, 2006.

24.

Chen Y, Soto-Gutierrez A, Navarro-Alvarez N, Rivas-Carrillo JD, Yamatsuji T, Shirakawa Y, Tanaka N, Basma H, Fox IJ, Kobayashi N. Instant hepatic differentiation of human embryonic stem cells using activin A and a deleted variant of HGF. Cell Transplant 15(10):865–871, 2006.

25.

Abe K, Niwa H, Iwase K, Takiguchi M, Mori M, Abe SI, Abe K, Yamamura KI. Endoderm-specific gene expression in embryonic stem cells differentiated to embryoid bodies. Exp Cell Res 229:27–34, 1996.

26.

Molkentin JD, Lin Q, Duncan SA, Olson EN. Requirement of the transcription factor GATA4 for heart tube formation and ventral morphogenesis. Genes Dev 11:1061–1072, 1997.

27.

Hyslop L, Stojkovic M, Armstrong L, Walter T, Stojkovic P, Przyborski S, Herbert M, Murdoch A, Strachan T, Lako M. Down-regulation of NANOG induces differentiation of human embryonic stem cells to extraembryonic lineages. Stem Cells 23:1035–1043, 2005.

28.

Henderson JK, Draper JS, Baillie HS, Fishel S, Thomson JA, Moore H, Andrews PW. Preimplantation human embryos and embryonic stem cells show comparable expression of stage-specific embryonic antigens. Stem Cells 20:329–337, 2002.

29.

Coucouvanis E, Martin GR. Signals for death and survival: a two-step mechanism for cavitation in the vertebrate embryo. Cell 83:279–287, 1995.

30.

Conley B, Ellis S, Gulluyan L, Mollard R. BMPs regulate differentiation of visceral putative visceral endoderm layer with human embryonic stem-cell-derived-embryoid bodies. Biochem Cell Bio 85: 121–132, 2007.

31.

Park YB, Kim YY, Oh SK, Chung SG, Ku S-Y, Kim SH, Choi YM, Moon SY. Alterations of proliferative and differentiation potentials of human embryonic stem cells during long-term culture. Exp Mol Med 40(1):98–108, 2008.

32.

Bhattacharya B, Miura T, Brandenberger R, Mejido J, Luo Y, Yang AX, Joshi BH, Ginis I, Thies RS, Amit M, Lyons I, Condie BG, Itskovitz-Eldor J, Rao MS, Puri RK. Gene expression in human embryonic stem cell lines: unique molecular signature. Blood 103(8): 2956–2964, 2004.

33.

Brimble S, Zeng X, Weiler DA, Luo Y, Liu Y, Lyons IG, Freed WJ, Rao MS, Robins AJ, Schulz TC. Karyotypic stability, genotyping, differentiation, feeder free maintenance and gene expression sampling in three human embryonic stem cell lines derived prior to August 9th 2001. Stem Cells Dev 3(6):585–597, 2004.

34.

Carpenter MK, Rosler ES, Fisk GJ, Brandenberger R, Ares X, Miura T, Lucero M, Rao MS. Properties of four human embryonic stem cell lines maintained in a feeder-free culture system. Dev Dyn 229:243–258, 2004.

35.

Mikkola M, Olsson C, Palgi J, Ustinov J, Palomaki T, Horelli-Kuitunen N, Knuutila S, Lundin K, Otonkoski T, Tuuri T. Distinct differentiation characteristics of individual human embryonic stem cell lines. BMC Dev Biol 8(6):40, 2006.

36.

Osafune K, Caron L, Borowiak M, Martinez RJ, Fitz-Gerald CS, Sato Y, Cowan CA, Chien KR, Melton DA. Marked differences in differentiation propensity among human embryonic stem cell lines. Nat Biotechnol 26:313–315, 2008.

37.

Plaia TW, Josephson R, Liu Y, Zeng X, Ording C, Toumadje A, Brimble SN, Sherrer ES, Uhl EW, Freed WJ, Schulz TC, Maitra A, Rao MS, Auerbach JM. Characterization of a new NIH registered variant human embryonic stem cell line BG01V. A tool for human embryonic stem cell research. Stem Cells 24(3):531–546, 2006.

38.

Pal R, Ravindran G. Assessment of pluripotency and multilineage differentiation potential of NTERA-2 cells as a model for studying human embryonic stem cells. Cell Prolif 39(6):585–598, 2006.

39.

Heng BC, Liu H, Rufaihah AJ, Cao T. Human embryonic stem cell (hES) colonies display a higher degree of spontaneous differentiation when passaged at lower densities. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol Anim 42:54–57, 2006.

40.

Prasad SM, Czepiel M, Cetinkaya C, Smigielska K, Weli SC, Lysdahl H, Gabrielsen A, Petersen K, Ehlers N, Fink T, Minger SL, Zachar V. Continuous hypoxic culturing maintains activation of Notch and allows long-term propagation of human embryonic stem cells without spontaneous differentiation. Cell Prolif 42:63–74, 2009.

41.

Hori Y, Rulifson IC, Tsai BC, Heit JJ, Cahoy JD, Kim SK. Growth inhibitors promote differentiation of insulin-producing tissue from embryonic stem cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99(25):16105–16110, 2002.

42.

Tropepe V, Hitoshi S, Sirard C. Mak TW, Rossant J, van der Kooy D. Direct neural fate specification from embryonic stem cells: a primitive mammalian neural stem cell stage acquired through a default mechanism. Neuron 30:65–78, 2001.

43.

Ramalho-Santos M, Yoon S, Matsuzaki Y, Mulligan RC, Melton DA. “ Stemness”: transcriptional profiling of embryonic and adult stem cells. Science 298:597–600, 2002.

44.

Munozsanjuan I, Brivanlou AH. Neural induction, the default model and embryonic stem cells. Nat Rev Neurosci 3:271–280, 2002.

45.

Tada S, Era T, Furusawa C, Sakurai H, Nishikawa S, Kinoshita M, Nakao K, Chiba T, Nishikawa S. Characterization of mesendoderm: a diverging point of the definitive endoderm and mesoderm in embryonic stem cell differentiation culture. Development 132:4363–4374, 2005.

46.

Pal R, Khanna A. Role of hepatocyte-like cells in differentiation of cardiomyocytes from mouse embryonic stem cells. Stem Cell Dev 14(2):153–161, 2005.

47.

Schultheiss TM, Xydas S, Lassar AB. Induction of avian myogenesis by anterior endoderm. Development 121:4203–4214, 1995.

48.

Perea-Gomez A, Vella FD, Shawlot W, Oulad-Abdelghani M, Chazaud C, Meno C, Pfister V, Chen L, Robertson E, Hamada H, Behringer RR, Ang SL. Nodal antagonists in the anterior visceral endoderm prevent the formation of multiple primitive streaks. Dev Cell 3:745–756, 2002.

49.

Vallier L, Reynolds D, Pedersen RA. Nodal inhibits differentiation of human embryonic stem cells along the neuroectodermal default pathway. Dev Biol 275:403–421, 2004.

50.

Tay Y, Zhang J, Thomson AM, Lim B, Rigoutsos I. MicroRNAs to Nanog, Oct4 and Sox2 coding regions modulate embryonic stem cell differentiation. Nature 455:1124–1128, 2008.

51.

Li XJ, Hu BY, Jones SA, Zhang YS, Lavaute T, Du ZW, Zhang SC. Directed differentiation of ventral spinal progenitors and motor neurons from human embryonic stem cells by small molecules. Stem Cells 26(4):886–893, 2008.

52.

Yan Y, Yang D, Zarnowska ED, Du Z, Werbel B, Valliere C, Pearce RA, Thomson JA, Zhang SC. Directed differentiation of dopaminergic neuronal subtypes from human embryonic stem cells. Stem Cells 23(5): 781–790, 2005.

53.

Zeng X, Chen J, Liu Y, Luo Y, Schulz TC, Robins AJ, Rao MS, Freed WJ. BG01V: a variant human embryonic stem cell line which exhibits rapid growth after passaging and reliable dopaminergic differentiation. Restor Neurol Neurosci 22:421–428, 2004.