This article offers a critique of some recent work on gender, which, influenced by the linguistic turn, over-states the historical significance of identity. Drawing on the work of the First World War tank commander and later Kleinian psychoanalyst Wilfred Bion, the article offers some suggestions about what a history of masculinity in the First World War might look if emotional experience, rather than “identity,” was at the centre of study. Focusing on two men, one an officer and Regular soldier, the other a rank-and-file Volunteer, the article explores the emotional impact of the war on the domestic lives of veterans. The war, it argues, drew men into relationships of care that had traditionally been women's domain; in the process creating both a crisis and an opportunity for subjectivity. Many men returned home after the war with practical and emotional capacities that challenged traditional ideals of the “soldier hero.” Simultaneously, however, the widespread distress of veterans meant that women tended to be drawn back into traditional feminine roles, as nurses and mothers.
Army Service Records, Register no. 97913/17 and 97913/21.
2.
AsquithLady C. (1968). Lady Cynthia Asquith diaries 1915–18. London: Hutchinson.
3.
BarhamP. (2004). Forgotten lunatics of the Great War. New Haven: Yale University Press.
4.
BeckerA., & Audoin-RouzeauS. (2002). 14–18: Understanding the Great War (TemersonC., Trans.). New York: Hill and Wang. (Original work published 2000).
5.
BionW. R. (1984a). Attacks on linking. In Second thoughts (pp. 93–110). London: Karnac.
6.
BionW. R. (1984b). A theory of thinking. In Second thoughts (pp. 110–120). London: Karnac.
7.
BionW. R. (1984c). Learning from experience. London: Karnac.
8.
BionW. R. (1997). War memoirs 1917–19. London: Karnac.
9.
BourkeJ. (1996). Dismembering the male: Men's bodies, Britain and the Great War. London: Reaktion Books.
10.
BreakespeareW. (2005). Interviewee no. 042. In ThompsonP. & LummisT., Family life and work experience before 1918, 1870–1973 [computer file] (5th ed.). Colchester, Essex: UK Data Archive. SN: 2000.
11.
BrunerJ. (1991). The narrative construction of reality. Critical Inquiry, 18(1), 1–21.
12.
CarringtonC. (1965). Soldier from the wars returning. London: Arrow.
13.
CloeteS. (1972). A Victorian son: An autobiography, 1897–1922. London: Collins.
14.
ConnellR. W. (1995). Masculinities. Cambridge: Polity.
15.
DasS. (2005). Touch and intimacy in First World War literature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
16.
Di CeglieG. (2005). Symbol formation and the construction of the inner world. In BuddS. & RushbridgerR. (Eds.), Introducing psychoanalysis: Essential themes and topics (pp. 95–104). London: Routledge.
17.
DudinkS. (2004). Masculinity, effeminacy, time: Conceptual change in the Dutch age of democratic revolutions. In DudinkS.HagermanK., & ToshJ. (Eds.), Masculinities in politics and war. Gendering modern history (pp. 77–95). Manchester: Manchester University Press.
18.
DudinkS., & HagermanK. (2004). Masculinity in politics and war in the age of democratic revolutions, 1750–1850. In DudinkS.HagermanK., & ToshJ. (Eds.), Masculinities in politics and war: Gendering modern history (pp. 3–21). Manchester: Manchester University Press.
19.
DundickS.HagermanK., & ToshJ. (2004). Masculinities in politics and war: Gendering modern history. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
20.
EdleyN., & WetherellM. (1995). Men in perspective: Practice, power and identity. Hemel Hempstead, Herts: Prentice Hall/Harvester Wheatsheaf.
21.
FreudS. (1920). Beyond the pleasure principle. In Standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund FreudVolume XVIII (pp. 7–67). London: Hogarth Press.
22.
FussellP. (1975). The Great War and modern memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
23.
FletcherD. (2008). Isabel Chevenix Trench. A fond memory from her grand-daughter. Personal Communication.
24.
GravesR. (1960). Goodbye to all that. London: Penguin
25.
GravesR. P. (2004). Graves, Robert von Ranke (1895–1985). In Oxford dictionary of national biography. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
26.
HinshelwoodR. D. (1989). A dictionary of Kleinian thought. London: Free Association Books.
27.
LeedE. (1979). No man's land: Combat and identity in World War I. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
28.
LelandH. J. C.Captain (September 1916–December 1917). Letters to his wife, IWM 96/51/1.
29.
LelandH. J. C.Captain, Army Service Records, National Archives, Britain, WO374/41657.
30.
LightA. (1991). Forever England: Femininity, literature and conservatism between the Wars. London: Routledge.
31.
MichelS. (1993). Danger on the home front: Motherhood, sexuality, and disabled veterans in American postwar films. In CookeM. & WoollacottA. (Eds.), Gendering War Talk (pp. 260–279). Princeton: Princeton University Press.
32.
MiddlebrookJ. B. (November 1915–June 1917). Letters to parents and sister, and Memoir, IWM Conshelf.
33.
MosseG. (1990). Fallen soldiers: Reshaping the memory of the World Wars. New York: Oxford University Press.
34.
MosseG. (1996). The image of man. New York: Oxford University Press.
35.
MunroLieutenant H. A. (1915, May-September). Diary, IWM P374.
36.
MunroLieutenant H. A. (1915, October 21). Letter to Sherriff John Macmaster Campbell, IWM P374.
37.
RoperL. (1994). Oedipus and the devil: Witchcraft, sexuality and religion in early modern Europe. London: Routledge.
38.
RoperM. (2005a). Slipping out of view: Subjectivity and emotion in gender history. History Workshop Journal, 59, 57–73.
39.
RoperM. (2005b). Between manliness and masculinity: The “war generation” and the psychology of fear in Britain, 1914–1970. Journal of British Studies, 44(2), 343–363.
40.
RoperM., & ToshJ. (Eds.). (1991). Manful assertions. Masculinities in Britain since 1800, London: Routledge.
41.
Smith-RosenbergC. (2004). The Republican gentleman: The race to rhetorical stability in the new United States. In DudinkS.HagermanK., & ToshJ. (Eds.), Masculinities in politics and war: Gendering modern history (pp. 61–76). Manchester: Manchester University Press.
42.
TemplerC. G. (1984). Memoir, IWM 86/30/1.
43.
Van EmdenR., & HumphriesS. (2003). All quiet on the home front. London: Headline.
44.
WestRebecca. (1994). The return of the soldier. London: Virago.
45.
WinterD. (1979). Death's men: Soldiers of the Great War. London: Penguin.
46.
WinterJ. M. (1985). The Great War and the British people. Basingstoke, Hamps: Macmillan.
47.
WoodsMajor J. (1917, December 8). Letter to Mrs Leland, IWM 96/5/1.
48.
YoungA. (1999). W. H. R. Rivers and the war neuroses. Journal of the History of the Behavioural Sciences, 35(4), 359–378.
