Effect of Information Quality on Compliance Behavior of Commuters Under Real-Time Traffic Information

Abstract

The compliance behavior of commuters under different advanced traveler information systems (ATIS) information strategies of varying information quality and credibility is investigated. A behavioral experiment involving commuters’ departure time and route decisions in response to traffic information in a simulated traffic system is conducted by using an interactive dynamic multiuser, computer-based simulator. By actually simulating traffic conditions in response to commuter decisions, the simulator provides stimuli to the participants that are always consistent with physically realistic traffic behavior and with their previous decisions. Event-count (frequency) models and dynamic, discrete-choice models are employed to capture the principal effects of the commuters’ experience with the traffic system and with the real-time information on user compliance. The analysis reveals that the information quality of ATIS strongly affects commuters’ compliance behavior. Switching “cost” and recent experience are found to influence their trip-making behavior as well. The analysis further shows that a higher compliance rate can be achieved under prescriptive information than descriptive information. A hierarchy of achievable compliance rates appears to exist in response to the type of information supplied, under which the highest compliance is obtained for reliable, predicted information and the least compliance for random information. Moreover, by providing posttrip feedback with performance information on recommendation or ex–post-best decision, higher compliance is attained.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

La Tour

S. A.

, and Peat

N. C.

. The Role of Situationally Produced Expectations, Others’ Experiences, and Prior Experience in Determining Consumer Satisfaction. In Advances in Consumer Research ( Olson

, ed.), Vol. 7, Association for Consumer Research, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1980.

Oliver

R. L.

, and Bearden

W. O.

. The Role of Involvement in Satisfaction Processes. In Advances in Consumer Research ( Bagozzi and Tybout , eds.), Vol. 9, Association for Consumer Research, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1983.

LeBarbera

P. A.

, and Mazursky

. A Longitudinal Assessment of Consumer Satisfaction/Dissatisfaction: The Dynamic Aspect of the Cognitive Process. Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 20, 1983, pp. 393–404.

Chen

, and Jovanis

P. P.

. Driver En Route Guidance Compliance Using a Travel Simulator: Statistical Analysis Using Repeated Observations. Project Report, Institute of Transportation Studies, University of California at Davis, 1997.

Mahmassani

H. S.

, and Herman

. Interactive Experiments for the Study of Tripmaker Behavior Dynamics in Congested Commuting Systems. In Developments in Dynamic and Activity-Based Approaches to Travel Analysis ( Jones

, ed.), Gower, Aldershot, England, 1990, pp. 272–298.

Adler

J. L.

, Recker

W. W.

, and McNally

M. G.

. A Conflict Model and Interactive Simulator (FASTCARS) for Predicting En Route Driver Behavior in Response to Real-Time Traffic Condition Information. Transportation, Vol. 20, No. 2, 1993, pp. 83–106.

Balmforth

P. J. A.

, Bonsall

P. W.

, and Palmer

I. A.

. PARKIT—A Parking Choice Simulator. Working paper, Institute for Transport Studies, University of Leeds, England, 1997.

Bonsall

P. W.

, and Parry

Using an Interactive Route-Choice Simulator to Investigate Drivers’ Compliance with Route Guidance Advice. In Transportation Research Record 1306, TRB, National Research Council, Washington, D.C., 1991, pp. 59–68.

Bonsall

P. W.

, Firmin

P. E.

, Anderson

M. E.

, Palmer

I. A.

, and Balmforth

P. J. A.

. Validating VLADIMIR: Can the Results of a Route Choice Simulator Be Trusted? Proc., 4th International Conference on Survey Methods in Transport, University of Leeds Press, Steeple Aston, U.K., 1996.

10.

Chen

P. S.

, and Mahmassani

H. S.

. Dynamic Interactive Simulator for Studying Commuter Behavior Under Real-Time Traffic Information Supply Strategies. In Transportation Research Record 1413, TRB, National Research Council, Washington, D.C., 1993, pp. 12–21.

11.

Koutsopoulos

H. N.

, Lotan

, and Yang

. A Driving Simulator and Its Application for Modeling Route Choice in the Presence of Information. Transportation Research, Vol. 2C, No. 2, 1994, pp. 91–107.

12.

Koutsopoulos

H. N.

, Polydoropoulou

, and Ben-Akiva

. Travel Simulators for Data Collection on Driver Behavior in the Presence of Information. Transportation Research, Vol. 3C, No. 3, 1995, pp. 143–159.

13.

Vaughn

K. M.

, Abdel-Aty

M. A.

, Kitamura

, Jovanis

P. P.

, Yang

, Kroll

N. E.

, Post

R. B.

, and Oppy

. Experimental Analysis and Modeling of Sequential Route Choice Behavior Under ATIS in a Simplistic Traffic Network. In Transportation Research Record 1408, TRB, National Research Council, Washington, D.C., 1993, pp. 75–82.

14.

Emmerink

R. H. M.

, Axhausen

K. W.

, Nijkamp

, and Rietveld

. The Potential of Information Provision in a Simulated Road Transport Network with Nonrecurrent Congestion. Transportation Research, Vol. 3C, No. 5, 1995, pp. 293–309.

15.

Mahmassani

H. S.

, and Liu

Y. H.

. Day-to-Day Dynamics of Commuter Behavior Under Real-Time Information. Report DTFH61-95-C-00017-F2, prepared for COMSIS Corporation, Center for Transportation Research, Austin, Tex., 1997.

16.

Mahmassani

H. S.

, and Chen

P. S.

. An Investigation of the Reliability of Real-Time Information for Route Choice Decisions in a Congested Traffic Network System. Transportation, No. 20, 1993, pp. 157–178.

17.

Abdel-Aty

M. A.

, Vaughn

K. M.

, Kitamura

, Jovanis

P. P.

, and Mannering

F. L.

. Models of Commuters’ Information Use and Route Choice: Initial Results Based on Southern California Commuter Route Choice Survey. In Transportation Research Record 1453, TRB, National Research Council, Washington, D.C., 1994, pp. 46–55.

18.

Cameron

A. C.

, and Trivedi

P. K.

. Econometric Models Based on Count Data: Comparisons and Applications of Some Estimators and Tests. Journal of Applied Econometrics, No. 1, 1986, pp. 29–53.

19.

Ben-Akiva

, and Bolduc

. Multinomial Probit with Logit Kernel and a General Parametric Specification of the Covariance Structure. Working paper, Department of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, 1996.

20.

Brownstone

, and Train

. Forecasting New-Product Penetration with Flexible Substitution Patterns. Working paper, Department of Economics, University of California, Irvine, 1996.

21.

Bhat

Recent Methodological Advances Relevant to Activity and Travel Behavior Analysis. Presented at International Association of Travel Behavior Research Conference, Austin, Tex., 1997.