3 Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Sorbitan Stearate,Sorbitan Laurate,Sorbitan Sesquioleate,Sorbitan Oleate,Sorbitan Tristearate,Sorbitan Palmitate,and Sorbitan Trioleate
Free accessResearch articleFirst published online May, 1985
3 Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Sorbitan Stearate,Sorbitan Laurate,Sorbitan Sesquioleate,Sorbitan Oleate,Sorbitan Tristearate,Sorbitan Palmitate,and Sorbitan Trioleate
The Sorbitan esters, including Sorbitan Stearate, Sorbitan Laurate, Sorbitan Sesquioleate, Sorbitan Oleate, Sorbitan Tristearate, Sorbitan Palmitate, and Sorbitan Trioleate, are used in cosmetic products as emulsifiers and stabilizers at concentrations normally under 5 percent. Toxicity was reported in subchronic and chronic studies at concentrations above that normally used in cosmetics. They are generally mild skin irritants but nonsensitizers in animals. They have the potential to induce cutaneous irritation in humans but not sensitization to normal skin.
Carcinogenic studies using Sorbitan Stearate and Laurate were negative. At concentrations of 10 percent or greater, Sorbitan Laurate is a tumor promoter in mouse skin. It is concluded that the latter is not relevant to the use of the Sorbitan esters at low concentrations in cosmetics and that the Sorbitan esters reviewed in the report are safe as cosmetic ingredients under present conditions of concentration and use.
References
1.
1. Greenberg, L.A., and Lester, D. (1954). Handbook of Cosmetic Materials.New York: Interscience.
2.
2. Hawley, G.G. (ed.). (1971). The Condensed Chemical Dictionary, 8th ed.New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Co.
3.
3. Balsam, M.S., and Sagarin, E. (eds.). (1972). Cosmetics: Science and Technology.New York: Wiley Interscience.
4.
4. Gosselin, R.E., Hodge, H.C., Smith, R.P., and Gleason, M.N. (1976). Clinical Toxicology of Commercial Products, 4th ed.Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins.
5.
5. Estrin, N.F., Crosley, P.A., and Haynes, C. (eds.). (1982). CTFA Cosmetic Ingredient Dictionary, 3rd ed.Washington, DC: Cosmetic, Toiletry and Fragrance Association.
6.
6. COSMETIC, TOILETRY AND FRAGRANCE ASSOCIATION (CTFA). (November 18, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic Ingredient Chemical Description of Sorbitan Stearate (2–9–56).*
7.
7. CTFA. (1972). CTFA Standards (Part 3).
8.
8. JAPAN COSMETIC INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION (JCIA). (1979). Japan, Yakuji Nippo, Ltd.
9.
9. Windholz, M. (ed.). (1976). The Merck Index, 9th ed.Rahway, NJ: Merck & Co.
10.
10. CTFA. (November 18, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic ingredient chemical description of sorbitan laurate (2–9–53).*
11.
11. CTFA. (November 18, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic ingredient chemical description of sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–52).*
12.
12. CTFA. (November 18, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic ingredient chemical description of sorbitan oleate (2–9–54).*
13.
13. NATIONAL FORMULARY (NF). (1975). 14th ed.Washington, DC: American Pharmaceutical Association.
14.
14. CTFA. (November 20, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic ingredient chemical description of sorbitan tristearate (2–9–50).*
15.
15. CTFA. (November 18, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic ingredient chemical description of sorbitan palmitate (2–9–55).*
16.
16. CTFA. (November 20, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Cosmetic ingredient chemical description of sorbitan trioleate (2–9–51).*
17.
17. FOOD CHEMICALS CODEX. (1972). 2nd ed.Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
18.
18. Grzesiczak, A. (1978). Search for methods of analyses of excipients used in suppository and ointment bases (separation, isolation, and identification). Farm. Pol.34(5), 291–6.
19.
19. CTFA. (January 26, 1983). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished ultraviolet absorbance spectra for sorbitans laurate and palmitate.*
20.
20. CTFA. (June 28, 1983). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished ultraviolet absorbance spectra for sorbitans sesquioleate and trioleate.*
21.
21. Furia, T.E. (1980). Regulatory Status of Direct Food Additives.Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
22.
22. CTFA. (December 2, 1981: Date of Transmittal Letter). Unpublished human irritation studies and animal toxicology and irritation studies of Span 20 (sorbitan laurate), Span 40 (sorbitan palmitate), Span 60 (sorbitan stearate), Span 65 (sorbitan tristearate), Span 80 (sorbitan oleate), Span 85 (sorbitan trioleate) (2–9–6).*
23.
23. CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS, TITLE 21. (1982). Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
24.
24. FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION (FDA). (December 22, 1981). Computer printout of voluntary submission of cosmetic ingredient data.
25.
25. Wick, A.N., and Joseph, L. (1953). The metabolism of sorbitan monostearate. Food Res.18, 79.
26.
26. Wick, A.N., and Joseph, L. (1953). Sorbitan monostearate metabolism. Lack of deposition upon chronic feeding. J. Agric. Food Chem.1, 398.
27.
27. Mezei, M., Sager, R.W., Stewart, W.D., and Deruyter, A.L. (1966). Dermatitic effect of nonionic surfactants. I. Gross, microscopic, and metabolic changes in rabbit skin treated with nonionic surface-active agents. J. Pharm. Sci.55(6), 584–90.
28.
28. Mezei, M., and Sager, R.W. (1967). Dermatitic effect of nonionic surfactants. II. Changes in phospholipid and in deoxyribonucleic acid content of rabbit epidermis in vivo. J. Pharm. Sci.56(12), 1604–8.
29.
29. Mezei, M., and Ryan, K.J. (1972). Effect of surfactants on epidermal permeability in rabbits. J. Pharm. Sci.61(8), 1329–31.
30.
30. CTFA. (December 15, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished acute oral toxicity test of 100 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–40).*
31.
31. CTFA. (January 2, 1980). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished acute oral, dermal, and ocular toxicity of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–34).*
32.
32. ATLAS CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES (ACI). (1970). Toxicology report on Span 20 and Span 80 (1950). Summaries of toxicological data. Lifespan feeding studies on Sorbitan Monolaurate and Sorbitan Mono-oleate. Food Cosmet. Toxicol.8, 339.
33.
33. CTFA. (August 1972). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human patch test and animal toxicology and irritation test of sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–7).*
34.
34. CTFA. (November 4, 1968). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished acute oral toxicity test of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–12).*
35.
35. CTFA. (July 31, 1978). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished acute oral, dermal, and ocular testing of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan palmitate (2–9–26).*
36.
36. CTFA. (October 8, 1975). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished acute oral, dermal, and ocular testing of a product containing 5 percent sorbitan trioleate (2–9–19).*
37.
37. Treon, J.F. (1963). Physiological properties of selected nonionic surfactants. Proc. Sci. Sect. Toilet Goods Assoc.40, 40.
38.
38. CTFA. (December 15, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished primary rabbit skin irritation test of 50 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–42).*
39.
39. CTFA. (October 1968). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished primary dermal irritation in rabbits of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–13).*
40.
40. CTFA. (August 17, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished primary rabbit skin irritation of 5 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–44).*
41.
41. CTFA. (February 24, 1978). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished primary rabbit skin irritation of sorbitan oleate (2–9–45).*
42.
42. CTFA. (November 4, 1968). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished acute dermal toxicity test in rabbits of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–11).*
43.
43. CTFA. (October 1968). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished ophthalmic irritation in rabbits of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–14).*
44.
44. CTFA. (August 17, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished ocular irritation test in rabbits of 5 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–43).*
45.
45. Ringrose, A.T., and Waller, F.F. (1959). High level feeding of surface-active agents to chicks. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol.1, 548.
46.
46. Cater, B.R., Butterworth, K.R., Gaunt, I.F., Hooson, J., Grasso, P., and Gangolli, S.D. (1978). Short-term toxicity study of sorbitan monolaurate (Span 20) in rats. Food Cosmet. Toxicol.16(6), 519–26.
47.
47. Fitzhugh, O.G., Schouboe, P.J., and Nelson, A.A. (1960). Oral toxicities of lauric acid and certain lauric acid derivatives. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol.2, 59.
48.
48. Harris, R.S., Sherman, H., and Jetter, W.W. (1951). Nutritional and pathological effects of sorbitan monolaurate, polyoxyethylene sorbitan monolaurate and polyoxyethylene monolaurate when fed to hamsters. Arch. Biochem. Biophys.34, 259.
49.
49. Harris, R.S., Sherman, H., and Jetter, W.W. (1951). Nutritional and pathological effects of sorbitan monolaurate, polyoxyethylene sorbitan monolaurate, polyoxyethylene monolaurate and polyoxyethylene monostearate when fed to rats. Arch. Biochem. Biophys.34, 249.
50.
50. Ingram, A.J., Butterworth, K.R., Gaunt, I.F., Grasso, P., and Gangolli, S.D. (1978). Short-term toxicity study of sorbitan mono-oleate (Span 80) in rats. Food Cosmet. Toxicol.16(6), 535–42.
51.
51. CTFA. (October 1980). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished subchronic dermal toxicity study in rabbits of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–33).*
52.
52. CTFA. (March 19, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished subacute dermal toxicity study in rabbits of a product containing 1.0 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–47).*
53.
53. CTFA. (May 7, 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished subchronic dermal toxicity study in rabbits of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan palmitate (2–9–27).*
54.
54. CTFA. (April 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished subacute dermal toxicity study in rabbits of a product containing 5 percent sorbitan trioleate (2–9–20).*
55.
55. Hendy, R.J., Butterworth, K.R., Gaunt, I.F., Kiss, I.S., and Grasso, P. (1978). Long-term toxicity study of sorbitan monostearate (Span 60) in mice. Food Cosmet. Toxicol.16(6), 527–34.
56.
56. Oser, B.L., and Oser, M. (1956). Nutritional studies on rats on diets containing high levels of partial ester emulsifiers. 1. General plan and procedures: growth and food utilizatiion. J. Nutr.60, 367.
57.
57. Oser, B.L., and Oser, M. (1956). Nutritional studies on rats on diets containing high levels of partial ester emulsifiers. 2. Reproduction and lactation. J. Nutr.60, 489–505.
58.
58. Oser, B.L., and Oser, M. (1957). Nutritional studies on rats on diets containing high levels of partial ester emulsifiers. III. Clinical and metabolic observations. J. Nutr.61, 149.
59.
59. Oser, B.L., and Oser, M. (1957). Nutritional studies on rats on diets containing high levels of partial ester emulsifiers. IV. Mortality and post-mortem pathology: general conclusions. J. Nutr.61, 235.
60.
60. Inoue, K., Sunakawa, T., and Takayama, S. (1980). Studies of in vitro cell transformation and mutagenicity by surfactants and other compounds. Food Cosmet. Toxicol.18(3), 289–96.
61.
61. Saffiotti, U., and Shubik, P. (1963). Studies on promoting action in skin carcinogenesis. Natl. Cancer. Inst. Monogr.10, 489–507.
62.
62. Setala, H. (1956). Tumor promoting and co-carcinogenic effects of some non-ionic lipophilic-hydrophilic (surface active) agents: an experimental study on skin tumors in mice. Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Scand. [Suppl. 115].
63.
63. Gaudin, D., Gregg, R.S, and Yielding, K. (1971). DNA repair inhibition: a possible mechanism of action of co-carcinogens. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun.45, 630–6.
64.
64. Steigmann, F., Goldbert, E.M., and Schoolman, H.M. (1953). The effect of emulsifying agents (Tween 60 and Span 20) on the gastrointestinal tract. Am. J. Dig. Dis.
65.
65. Waldstein, Sheldon S., Schoolman, Harold M., and Popper, H. (July 1954). The effect of feeding large amounts of emulsifiers polyoxyethylene (20) sorbitan monostearate (Tween 60) and sorbitan monostearate (Span 60) to humans. Am. J. Dig. Dis. 181–5.
66.
66. Hannuksela, M., Kousa, M., and Pirila, V. (1976). Allergy to ingredients of vehicles. Contact Dermatitis2, 105–10.
67.
67. Hannuksela, M., Kousa, M., and Pirila, V. (1976). Contact sensitivity to emulsifiers. Contact Dermatitis2(4), 201–4.
68.
68. CTFA. (April 1980). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human repeated insult patch test of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–37).*
69.
69. CTFA. (April 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human repeated insult patch test of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–32).*
70.
70. CTFA. (July 30, 1973). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human skin irritation of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–36).*
71.
71. HILL TOP RESEARCH (HTR). (April 20, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative skin irritation test of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–31).*
72.
72. HTR. (April 20, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative skin irritation test of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–35).*
73.
73. LEO WINTER ASSOCIATES (LWA). (December 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human phototoxicity testing of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–39).*
74.
74. LWA. (December 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human photo-contact allergenicity of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan stearate (2–9–38).*
75.
75. HTR. (January 26, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished repeated insult patch test of a product containing 1.0 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–46).*
76.
76. CTFA. (December 12, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished allergic contact sensitization test of a product containing 1.0 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–48).*
77.
77. CTFA. (April 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human primary irritation/sensitization test of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–8).*
78.
78. CTFA. (September 27, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human primary irritation test of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–9).*
79.
79. CTFA. (October 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human primary irritation/sensitization test of a product containing 3 percent sorbitan sesquioleate (2–9–10).*
80.
80. PRODUCT INVESTIGATIONS (PI). (March 30, 1978). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human dermal irritation test of a product containing 1.75 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–4).*
81.
81. FOOD AND DRUG RESEARCH LABORATORIES (FDRL). (December 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished photoallergy, phototoxicity, and repeated insult patch tests of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–23).*
82.
82. LWA. (March 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human repeated insult patch test of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–22).*
83.
83. IVY RESEARCH LABORATORIES (IRL). (January 5, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished maximization test of a product containing 1.75 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–49).*
84.
84. IRL. (November 15, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished maximization test of a product containing sorbitan oleate (2–9–3).*
85.
85. HTR. (November 19, 1976). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative irritation test of a product containing 1.75 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–2).*
86.
86. HTR. (March 1, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative irritation test of a product containing 1.75 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–1).*
87.
87. HTR. (April 18, 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative irritation test of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–21).*
88.
88. HTR. (May 27, 1981). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative skin irritation test of a product containing 2 percent sorbitan oleate (2–9–24).*
89.
89. LWA. (August 1, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished repeated insult patch test of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan palmitate (2–9–30).*
90.
90. HTR. (October 6, 1978). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished cumulative irritation test of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan palmitate (2–9–25).*
91.
91. HTR. (October 6, 1977). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished cumulative irritation test of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan palmitate (2–9–29).*
92.
92. HTR. (October 17, 1979). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished human cumulative skin irritation test of a product containing 4 percent sorbitan palmitate (2–9–28).*
93.
93. LWA. (September 1978). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished repeated insult patch test of a product containing 5 percent sorbitan trioleate (2–9–15).*
94.
94. LWA. (March 1975). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished predictive patch test and in-use test of a product containing 5 percent sorbitan trioleate (2–9–18).*
95.
95. HTR. (October 6, 1978). Submission of data by CTFA. Unpublished cumulative irritation test of a product containing 5 percent sorbitan trioleate (2–9–16).* *Available upon request: Administrator, Cosmetic Ingredient Review, 1110 Vermont Ave., NW, Suite 810, Washington, DC 20005.
