Objective: The aim of this paper is to clarify elements of the role of a psychiatrist working in the public sector.
Method: The relevant literature was examined to help clarify some of the reasons psychiatrists have been leaving the public sector and to help define the key roles of a psychiatrist working in the public sector.
Results: Two principal roles for the consultant psychiatrist in the public sector are identified: the psychiatrist as a clinician and the psychiatrist as a manager. The management role is contrasted with the role as an administrator and important differences between these roles are identified. The management role includes planning, advocacy and managing human resources. The importance of professional development in the career path for the newly qualified psychiatrist is discussed.
Conclusions: The role of the psychiatrist in public sector psychiatry is a challenging and exciting one. Psychiatrists will start to return to the public sector when they recognise this new role for the consultant psychiatrist. This will be to the advantage of public sector psychiatry in general and to the job satisfaction of psychiatrists. The key features of the clinical role are the demonstration of sophisticated clinical skills, providing clinical leadership via supervision, being accountable for patient care and providing consultant opinion on complex clinical problems.
References
1.
LeonardDPThe state of public psychiatry. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1994; 28:371–374.
2.
LiptonG.The college and professional political attitudes. Australasian Psychiatry1995; 3:5–8.
3.
DeahlMTurnerT.General psychiatry in no-man's land. British Journal of Psychiatry1997; 171:6–8.
4.
FaulknerLRBloomJDBrayJDMaricleR.Psychiatric manpower and services in a community mental health system. Hospital and Community Psychiatry1987; 38:287–291.
5.
RanzJEilenbergJRosenhecksS.The psychiatrist's role as a medical director. Psychiatric Services1997; 48:915–920.
6.
EllardJ.Private psychiatry in a changing medical system. Australasian Psychiatry1994; 2:6–10.
7.
HarariE.The attack on private practice: reformation or deformation. Australasian Psychiatry1994; 2:213–215.
8.
DignamP.Psychiatry: profession, craft or service?Australasian Psychiatry1995; 3:79–80.
9.
DetreTMcDonaldMCManaged care and the future of psychiatry. Archives of General Psychiatry1997; 54:201–204.
10.
PardesH.A changing psychiatry for the future [Editorial]. American Journal of Psychiatry1996; 153:1383–1386.
11.
LiebermanJARushAJRedefining the role of psychiatry in medicine. American Journal of Psychiatry1996; 153:1388–1396.
12.
OlfsonMWeissmanMMGottliebJFEssential roles for psychiatry in the era of managed care. Archives of General Psychiatry1997; 54:206–208.
13.
MeyerRESotskySMManaged care and the role and training of psychiatrists. Health Affairs (Millwood)1995; 14:55–77.
14.
BurnsLRBeckerSWLeadership and managership. In: ShortellSMKaluznyAD, eds. Health care management: a text in organisation theory and behaviour, 2nd ed. Toronto: John Wiley and Sons, 1988:153–154.
15.
WilliamsSJEwellCMTomorrow's vice president of medical affairs. The Physician Executive1997; 23:16–20.
16.
MunetzMDA 12-step recovery program for community psychiatrists. Psychiatric Services1995; 46:313.
17.
VavalaD.The integration rush: some second thoughts. The Physician Executive1996; 22:5–8.
18.
CoddingtonDCMooreKDFischerEAMaking integrated care work. The Physician Executive1996; 22:24–28.
19.
RushAJAssessing outcomes in practice: a paradigm shift?Current Opinion in Psychiatry1996; 9:1–2.
20.
WoodTJScallyGO'NeillD.Management knowledge and skills required by UK and US medical directors. The Physician Executive1995; 21:26–29.
21.
EstesMLCore competencies for physician success. The Physician Executive1997; 23:9–13.
22.
SluyterGVMental health leadership training: a survey of state directors. Journal of Mental Health Administration1995; 22:201–204.
23.
SluyterGVTraining of mental health administrators: a state agency and university partnership. Administration and Policy in Mental Health1994; 22:175–179.
24.
LegniniMWDeveloping leaders vs training administrators in the health services. American Journal of Public Health1994; 84:1569–1572.
25.
TobinM.The transition from clinician to manager: a case study. Australian Health Review1993; 16:51–59.
26.
BurgoyneJLorbieckiA.Clinicians into management: the experience in context. Health Services Management Research1993; 6:248–259.
27.
SperryL.The practice of executive coaching and consultation. The Journal of the Academy of Organisational and Occupational Psychiatry1997; 6:1–5.
28.
GoldmanLNeillJRosenblattM.The business of education: a new paradigm. The Physician Executive1997; 23:21–24.
29.
SeverinoSKChungH.Health care reform: implications for academic psychiatric institutions. Journal of Mental Health Administration1995; 22:77–84.