Objective: The aim of the paper is to devise an ethical argument to support the contention that post-termination patient–therapist sexual contact (PTSC) is always unethical.
Method: Arguments both defending and condemning post-termination PTSC are reviewed and their strengths and weaknesses explored.
Results: Analysis of these arguments reveals a strong case for the universal condemnation of post-termination PTSC.
Conclusions: Ethical codes, including that of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, should be amended to explicitly prohibit post-termination PTSC.
References
1.
GartrellNHermanJOlarteSFeldsteinMLocalioR.Psychiatrist–patient sexual contact: results of a national surey. I: Prevalence. American Journal of Psychiatry1986; 143:1126–1131.
2.
LeggettA.A survey of Australian psychiatrists’ attitudes and practices regarding physical contact with patients. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1994; 28:448–497.
3.
HermanJGartrellNOlarteSFeldsteinMLocalioR.Psychiatrist–patient sexual contact: results of a national survey. II: Psychiatrists’ attitudes. American Journal of Psychiatry1987; 144:164–169.
4.
Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.RANZCP Code of Ethics. August 1992.
5.
PargiterRBlochS.Developing a code of ethics for psychiatry: the Australasian experience. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1994; 28:188–196.
6.
Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.Sexual relationships with patients. Ethical guideline #8. October 1990.
7.
BeauchampTChildressV.Principles of biomedical ethics. 3rd ed.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1989.
8.
BouhoustsosJHolroydJLermanHSexual intimacy between psychotherapists and patients. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice1983; 14:185–196.
9.
BrodskyAM.Sex between patient and therapist: psychology's data and response. In: GabbardGO, ed. Sexual exploitation in professional relationships. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1989:15–25.
10.
GutheilTG.Borderline personality disorder, boundary violations and patient–therapist sex: medicolegal pitfalls. American Journal of Psychiatry1989; 146:597–602.
11.
PopeKS.Therapist–patient sex syndrome: a guide for attorneys and subsequent therapists to assessing damage. In: GabbardGO, ed. Sexual exploitation in professional relationships. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1989:39–55.
12.
StrasburgerLHJorgensonLRandiesR.Criminalisation of psychotherapist–patient sex. American Journal of Psychiatry1991; 148:859–863.
13.
MastersMJohnsonV.Principles of the new sex therapy. American Journal of Psychiatry1976; 133:548–554.
14.
KardenerSHFullerMMenschIN.Characteristics of ‘erotic’ practitioners. American Journal of Psychiatry1976; 133:1324–1325.
15.
BarnhouseRT.Sex between patient and therapist. Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis1978; 6:533–546.
16.
GabbardGOPopeKS.Sexual intimacies after termination: ethical and legal aspects. In: GabbardGO, ed. Sexual exploitation in professional relationships. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, 1989:115–127.
17.
ConteHRKarasuTB.Malpractice in psychotherapy: an overview. American Journal of Psychotherapy1990; 44:232–247.
18.
SerbanG.Sexual activity in therapy: legal and ethical issues. American Journal of Psychotherapy1981; 35:76–85.
19.
AppelbaumPSJorgensonL.Psychotherapist–patient contact after termination of treatment: an analysis and a proposal. American Journal of Psychiatry1991; 148:1466–1473.
20.
KarasuTB.The ethics of psychotherapy. American Journal of Psychiatry1980; 137:1502–1512.
21.
SreenivasanU.Sexual exploitation of patients. The position of the Canadian Psychiatric Association. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry1989; 34:234–235.
American Medical Association.Code of ethics. July 1988.
24.
Australian Medical Association.Code of ethics. July 1992.
25.
World Medical Association.Declaration of Geneva, 1948.
26.
GillonR.Philosophical medical ethics. Chichester: Wiley, 1985.
27.
MearesR.The pursuit of intimacy. Melbourne: Thomas Nelson, 1977.
28.
MearesRAndersonJ.Intimate space: on the developmental significance of exchange. Contemporary Psychoanalysis1993; 29:595–612.
29.
PerrIN.Legal aspects of sexual therapies. Journal of Legal Medicine1975; 3:33–38.
30.
MarmorJ.Sexual acting-out in psychotherapy. American Journal of Psychoanalysis1972; 32:3–8.
31.
American Psychiatric Association.The principles of medical ethics with annotations especially applicable to psychiatry. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1989.
