Objective: To determine to what extent ethics is taught and how it is taught to psychiatrists-in-training across Australasia.
Method: Anonymous mail-out survey of training directors.
Results: The questionnaire was completed by 23 of 25 training directors (response rate = 92%) who reported on 625 trainee psychiatrists. Individual one-to-one case supervision was adopted by 96% of the programs for teaching ethics; formal teaching in seminars or lectures was chosen as the second most common method in 70% of programs. Topics most commonly taught in formal seminars were so taught in only 70% of programs or less.
Conclusion: A uniform curriculum in psychiatric ethics is needed. The results are discussed in relation to identified needs for improvement.
References
1.
DawsonEM.Professional misconduct in psychiatry: sexual behaviour with patients. A report of recent New South Wales findings. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1994; 28:177–204.
2.
LeggettA.A survey of psychiatrists’ attitudes and practices regarding physical contact with patients. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1994; 28:488–497.
3.
Report of the Royal Commission into deep sleep therapy (Slattery Royal Commission). Sydney: New South Wales Government Printer, 1990.
4.
SullivanMDYoungerSJ.Depression, competence, and the right to refuse lifesaving medical treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry1994; 151:971–978.
5.
McCulloughLBCoverdaleJBayerTChervenakFA.Ethically justified guidelines for family planning interventions to prevent pregnancy in female patients with chronic mental illness. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology1992; 167:19–25.
6.
CoverdaleJBayerTLMcCulloughLBChervenakFA.Respecting the autonomy of chronic mentally ill women in decisions about contraception. Hospital and Community Psychiatry1993; 44:671–674.
7.
CoverdaleJChervenakFAMcCulloughLBBayerT.Ethically justified clinically comprehensive guidelines for the management of the depressed pregnant patient. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology1996; 174:169–173.
8.
Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.Code of ethics. Melbourne: Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, 1992.
9.
BeauchampTLChildressJF.Principles of biomedical ethics. 3rd ed.New York: Oxford University Press, 1989.
10.
HundertEM.A model for ethical problem solving in medicine with practical applicatons. American Journal of Psychiatry1987; 144:839–846.
11.
EngelhardtHTJr.CoverdaleJ.The psychiatric admission index: deciding when to admit a patient. Journal of Clinical Ethics1993; 4:315–318.
12.
BlochS.Teaching of psychiatric ethics. British Journal of Psychiatry1980; 136:300–301.
13.
JellinekMParmaleeD.Is there a role for medical ethics in postgraduate psychiatry courses?American Journal of Psychiatry1977; 134:1438–1439.
14.
AppelbaumPSReiserSJ.Ethics rounds: a model for teaching ethics in the psychiatric setting. Hospital and Community Psychiatry1981; 32:555–560.
15.
MofficHSCoverdaleJBayerTL.Ethics education for psychiatry. Journal of Clinical Ethics1991; 2:161–166.
16.
CoverdaleJBayerTLIsbellPMofficS.Are we teaching psychiatrists to be ethical?Academic Psychiatry1992; 16:199–205.
17.
GortonGESamuelSE.A national survey of training directors about education for prevention of psychiatrist–patient sexual exploitation. Academic Psychiatry1996; 20:92–98.
LovatTJMitchellKR.Bioethics for medical and health professionals: history principles and case studies. Wentworth Falls, NSW: Social Science Press, 1991.
20.
AnsleuSL.Deviance, conformity and control. 2nd ed.Melbourne: Longman, 1995.
21.
EdwardsRB, ed. Psychiatry and ethics: insanity, rational autonomy and mental health care. New York: Prometheus, 1982.
22.
QuadrioC.Sex and gender and the impaired therapist. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1992; 26:346–363.
23.
AnziaDJla PumaJ.An annotated bibliography of psychiatric medical ethics. Academic Psychiatry1991; 15:1–17.
24.
DyerARBlochS.Informed consent and the psychiatric patient. Journal of Medical Ethics1987; 13:12–16.
25.
PellegrinoED.Teaching medical ethics: some persistent questions and some responses. Academic Medicine1989; 64:701–703.
26.
MichelsR.Training in psychiatric ethics. In: BlochSChodoffP, eds. Psychiatric ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981.
27.
PellegrinoEDSieglerMSingerPA.Teaching clinical ethics. Journal of Clinical Ethics1990; 1:175–180.
28.
McCulloughLBChervenakFA.Ethics in obstetrics and gynecology. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994.
29.
ChiangEBayerTLCoverdaleJLomaxJWIIEvaluating the evaluations of psychiatry residents. Academic Psychiatry1992; 16:153–159.
