Objectives: Interest in the work of Pierre Janet is presently undergoing a scholarly revival and, in the process, his contribution to dynamic psychiatry is increasingly being recognised. This article compares and contrasts Pierre Janet's early studies on hysteria and the neuroses with those of Freud. Method: The study surveys original works by Janet and Freud and contemporary scholarly exegeses. It particularly focuses on ideation and memory, consciousness and dissociation, psychological trauma, the self, therapeutic influence, and treatment by integration versus abreaction. Results: Grounds are presented for either preferring Janet's notions to Freud's, or for integrating them.
Conclusion: It is concluded that a number of Janet's contributions to psychopathology and psychotherapy, particularly in the field of dissociative disorders, deserve further exploration and application.
References
1.
JanetP.Etat mental des hystériques. Paris: Rueff et cie, 1892/1894. (Trans: The mental state of hystericals. New York: Putnams, 1901:526–528. Reprinted: Washington. DC: University Publications of America, 1977.).
2.
BreuerJFreudS.Studies on hysteria (1893–1895). SE 2. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:19–305.
3.
EllenbergerHF.The discovery of the unconscious: the history and evolution of dynamic psychiatry. New York: Basic Books, 1970.
4.
van der KolkBAvan der HartOPierre Janet and the breakdown of adaptation in psychological trauma. American Journal of Psychiatry1989; 146:1530–1540.
5.
BrownP.Pierre Janet: alienist reintegrated. Current Opinion in Psychiatry1991; 4:389–395.
6.
BrownPMacMillanMBMearesR.Janet and Freud go south. Australasian Psychiatry1995; 3:262–264.
7.
JanetP.A symposium on the subconscious. Journal of Abnormal Psychology1907; 2:58.
8.
van der KolkBABrownPvan der HartO.Pierre Janet on post-traumatic stress. Journal of Traumatic Stress1989; 2:365–378.
9.
van der HartOFriedmanB.A reader's guide to Pierre Janet on dissociation: a neglected intellectual heritage. Dissociation1989; 2:3–16.
10.
van der HartOHorstR.The dissociation theory of Pierre Janet. Journal of Traumatic Stress1989; 2:397–412.
11.
MacMillanMB.Freud and Janet on organic and hysterical paralyses: a mystery solved?International Review of Psychoanalysis1990; 17:189–203.
12.
MacMillanM.Freud evaluated: the completed arc. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1991.
13.
FreudS. SE 1. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:39,58.
14.
FreudS. SE 1. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:75.
15.
JanetP.L'anaesthésie hystérique. Archives de Neurologie1892; 23:323–352.
16.
JanetP.L'amnésie hystérique. Archives de Neurologie1892; 24:29–55.
17.
JanetP.La suggestion chez les hystériques. Archives de Neurologie1892; 24:448–469.
18.
FreudS.A short account of psychoanalysis (1923/1924). SE 19. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:19,193.
19.
CrocqLde VerbizierJ.Le traumatisme psychologique dans l'oeuvre de Pierre Janet. Annales Médico-Psychologiques (Paris)1989; 147:983–987.
20.
JanetP.Les actes inconscients et le dédoublement de la personalité pendant le somnambulisme provoqué. Revue Philosophique1886; 22:577–592.
21.
JanetP.L'anesthésie systematisée et la dissociation des phénomènes psychologiques. Revue Philosophique1887; 23:449–172.
22.
JanetP.Les actes inconscients et la mémoire pendant le somnambulisme. Revue Philosophique1888; 25:616–623.
23.
JanetP.L'automatisme psychologique. Paris: Felix Alcan, 1889. (Reprint: Paris: Societé Pierre Janet, Payot. 1973.).
24.
MacMillanMB.Delboeuf and Janet as influences in Freud's treatment of Emmy von N. Journal of the History of the Behavioural Sciences1979; 15:299–309.
25.
JanetP.Les médications psychologiques. Paris: Felix Alcan. 1919. (Trans: Psychological healing. New York: MacMillan, 1925:710.).
26.
van der HartOBrownPvan der KolkBAPierre Janet's treatment of post-traumatic stress. Journal of Traumatic Stress1989; 2:379–395.
27.
JanetP.L'Amnésie et la dissociation des souvenirs. Journal de Psychologie1904; 1:28–37.
28.
JanetP.L'état mentale des hystériques. 2nd ed.Paris: F. Alcan, 1911. (Reprint: Marseilles: Lafitte Reprints, 1983.).
29.
BriereJConteJ.Self-reported amnesia for abuse in adults molested as children. Journal of Traumatic Stress1993; 6:21–31.
30.
EngelGL.The need for a new medical model: a challenge for biological science. Science1977; 196:129–136.
31.
JanetP.Névroses et idées fixes. Paris: Felix Alcan, 1898. (Reprint: Paris: Societé Pierre Janet, Payot, 1990.).
32.
JanetP.La force et la faiblesse psychologiques. Paris: N Maloine, 1932:257.
33.
MearesRHorvathTB.Acute and chronic hysteria. British Journal of Psychiatry1972; 121:653–657.
34.
HorvathTFriedmanJMearesR.Attention in hysteria: a study of Janet's hypothesis by means of habituation and arousal measures. American Journal of Psychiatry1980; 137:217–220.
35.
GordonEKraiuhinCKellyPMearesRHowsonA.The neurophysiological study of somatization disorder. Comprehensive Psychiatry1986; 27:295–301.
36.
GordonEKraiuhinCMearesRHowsonA.Auditory evoked response potentials in somatization disorder. Journal of Psychiatric Research1986; 29:237–248.
37.
JamesLGordonEKraiuhinCHowsonAMearesR.Augmentation of auditory evoked potentials in somatization disorder. Journal of Psychiatric Research1990; 24:155–163.
38.
JamesLGordonEKraiuhinCMearesR.Janet's hypothesis: selective attention and auditory event-related potentials in somatization disorder. Comprehensive Psychiatry1989; 30:84–89.
39.
MearesRHampshireRGordonEKraiuhinC.Whose hysteria: Briquet's, Janet's or Freud's?Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1985; 19:256–263.
40.
FreudS.Sexuality in the aetiology of the neuroses (1898). SE 3. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:263–285.
41.
GloverE.The birth of the ego. London: Allen and Unwin, 1968.
42.
HartB.The concept of dissociation. British Journal of Medical Psychology1926; 6:241–256.
43.
AltschuleMD.The development of traditional psychopathology: a sourcebook. New York: John Wiley, 1976:39.
44.
JanetP.L'évolution psychologique de la personnalité. Paris: Chahine, 1929.
45.
JanetP.L'évolution de la mémoire et la notion du temps. Paris: Chahine, 1928:315.
46.
DelboeufJRL.Le magnétisme animal: a propos d'une visite a l'école de Nancy. Paris: Felix Alcan, 1889.
47.
MakariGJ.A history of Freud's first concept of transference. International Review of Psychoanalysis1992; 19:415–432.
48.
FreudS.On the history of the psychoanalytic movement (1914). SE 14. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:7–66.
49.
MacalpineIHunterRA.The importance of the concept of transference for present-day theories of mental disease. In: BossMFierzHKStokvisB, eds. International congress of psychotherapy, Zurich, 1954. Basle: S. Karger, 1955:515–521.
50.
van der HartOBrownP.Abreaction re-evaluated. Dissociation1992; 5:127–140.
51.
van der HartOSteeleKBoonSBrownP.The treatment of traumatic memories: synthesis, realisation, and integration. Dissociation1993; 6:162–180.
52.
FreudS.Introduction to psychoanalysis and the war neuroses (1919). SE 17. London: Hogarth Press, 1966:207–210.
