In the first half of the nineteenth century phrenology, which was claimed to be the first science of the mind, experienced enormous popularity in the western world. It gave rise to a widespread movement attracting the attention of the professional and lay members of society. In Australia, as elsewhere, it had influence in penology and criminology, psychiatry, notions of racial inferiority, education, anthropology and popular application. By the second half of the nineteenth century, following advances in the knowledge of neuro-anatomy, it became relegated to the status of a pseudo-science. As such, it remained popular with charlatans and the public well into the twentieth century.
References
1.
TurnbullD.Phrenology, the first science of man. Victoria: Deakin University Press1982; 5–19.
2.
ParssinenTM.Popular science and society: The phrenology movement in early Victorian Britain. Journal of Social History1974; 7:1.
3.
DaviesJD.Phrenology fad and science. A 19th century American crusade. New Haven: Yale University Press1955; 6–7, 79.
4.
GardinerM.Fads and fallacies in the name of science. New York: Dover1957; 293.
5.
MortonLT.A Medical bibliography (Garrison and Morton)4th ed.Aldershot, Hampshire: Gower1983; 179.
6.
AckerknechtMDValloisHV.Franz Joseph Gall. Inventor of phrenology and his collection. Madison, Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin Press 1956; 24–33.
7.
FinkAE.Causes of crime. Biological theories of crime in the United States 1800–1915. Reprint edition, Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press1985; 2.
8.
TemkinO.Gall and the phrenological movement. Bulletin of the History of Medicine1947; 21:309–312.
9.
de GiustinoD.Reforming the commonwealth of thieves. British phrenologists and Australia. Victorian Studies1971–72; 15: 451.
10.
HoareME.Doctor John Henderson and the Van Diemen's Land Scientific Society. Records of the Australian Academy of Science1968; 1:8.
11.
FordE.Bibliography of Australian medicine 1790–1900, Sydney. Sydney University Press1976; 241.
12.
NadelG.Australia's colonial culture. Ideas, men and institutions in mid-nineteenth century Eastern Australia. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press1957; 135–192.
13.
RoeM.Quest for authority in eastern Australia 1834–1851. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press in association with The Australian National University1965; 161–162.
14.
ParkerN.Murderer's skulls. In: PearnJ, ed. Pioneer medicine in Australia. Brisbane: Amphion Press1988; 93–98.
15.
The Australian encyclopaedia, Volume 4, 3rd ed.Sydney: The Grolier Society of Australia, 1977; 93–94.
16.
CooterR.Phrenology and British alienists, ca. 1825–1845. In: ScullA. ed. Madhouses, mad-doctors and madmen: the social history of psychiatry in the Victorian era. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press1981; 58–59.
17.
CooterR.The cultural meaning of popular science: Phrenology and the organisation of consent in nineteenth-century Britain. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1984; 28–32, 256.
18.
HunterRAMacalpineI.1899–1974 Three hundred years of psychiatry, 1535–1860; a history presented in selected English texts. London: Oxford University Press1963; 1030.
19.
DaxEC.Australia and New Zealand. In: HowellsJG, ed. World history of psychiatry, New York: Brunner/Mazel1975; 706.
20.
BostockJ.The dawn of Australian psychiatry. Sydney: Australian Medical Association, 1968: 21–39.
21.
McDonaldDI.Dr Francis Campbell and the Tarban Creek Asylum, 1848–1867. Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society1967; 53:222–257.
22.
BostockJ.A psychiatric centenary. Medical Journal of Australia1949; 1:765–766.
23.
JonesWE.Psychiatry: past, present and future. Medical Journal of Australia1939; 1:252.
24.
CooterRJ.Phrenology and the British alienists, c. 1825–1845. Part I: Converts to a doctrine. Medical History1976; 20: 4.
25.
CannonM.Australia in the Victorian age: Life in the cities. Melbourne: Nelson1975; 82, 422.
26.
PhillipsP.Kill or cure. Richmond, Victoria: Greenhouse1978; 142.
27.
AtkinsonAAvelingM, eds. Australians 1838. Sydney: Fairfax, Syme and Weldon1988; 65.
28.
MortonSG.Crania Americana. Philadelphia: John Pennington1839.
29.
MortonSG.Observations on the size of the brain in various races and families of man. Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences. Philadelphia 1849.
30.
RaingerR.Race, politics, and science: The Anthropological Society of London in the 1860s. Victorian Studies1978–79; 22:51–52.
31.
CoombeG.The constitution of man in relation to the natural laws. 8th ed.London: Cassell1893; vi.
32.
Editorial.New South Wales Medical Gazette1875; 5:330–333.
33.
KnaggsST.Phrenology scientifically examined and found wanting. In: Recreations of an Australian surgeon. Sydney: McClardy1888; 54–66.
34.
EdwardsG.Causation of insanity in nineteenth century Australia. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1982; 16:53–62.
