It is argued that personality scales of neuroticism and anxiety are tapping the same personality trait and that this is a risk factor for neurotic disorders. To see whether this trait is modifiable, a meta-analysis was carried out of therapy outcome studies which included a measure of trait anxiety or neuroticism as a dependent measure. This meta-analysis showed that all psychological therapies are to some extent effective. However, rational-emotive and related therapies produced particularly large reductions in trait anxiety/neuroticism (around 1.25 standard deviations). The possibility that rational-emotive education programmes could be used to lower trait anxiety/neuroticism as a preventive measure is discussed.
References
1.
EysenckHJEysenckSBG. Manual of the Eysenck personality questionnaire. Sevenoaks, Kent: Hodder and Stoughton, 1975
2.
CattellRB. IPAT anxiety scale. Champaign, Illinois: Institute for Personality and Ability Testing, 1976
3.
WatsonDClarkLA. Negative affectivity: the disposition to experience aversive emotional states. Psychological Bulletin1984;96:465–490
4.
BraithwaiteVA. The Scale of Emotional Arousability: bridging the gap between the neuroticism construct and its measurement. Psychological Medicine1987;17:217–225
5.
HendersonSByrneDGDuncan-JonesP. Neurosis and the social environment. Sydney: Academic Press, 1981
6.
HorwoodLJFergussonDM. Neuroticism, depression and life events: A structural equation model. Social Psychiatry1986;21:63–71
7.
HirschfeldRMAKlermanGLAndreasenNCClaytonPJKellerMB. Psycho-social predictors of chronicity in depressed patients. British Journal of Psychiatry1986;148:648–654
8.
WeissmanMMPrusoffBAKlermanGL. Personality and the prediction of long-term outcome of depression. American Journal of Psychiatry1978;135:797–800
9.
JardineRMartinNGHendersonAS. Genetic covariation between neuroticism and the symptoms of anxiety and depression. Genetic Epidemiology1984;1:89–107
10.
ScarrSWebberPLWeinbergRAWittigMA. Personality resemblance among adolescents and their parents in biologically related and adoptive families. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1981;40:885–898
11.
EysenckHJ. The biological basis of personality. Springfield: C.C. Thomas, 1967
12.
GrayJA. The neuropsychology of anxiety: An enquiry into the functions of the septo-hippocampal system. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1982
13.
MartinM. Neuroticism as predisposition toward depression: A cognitive mechanism. Personality and Individual Differences1985;6:353–365
14.
GlassGVMcGawBSmithML. Meta-analysis in social research. Beverly Hills: Sage, 1981
15.
HedgesLV. Estimation of effect size from a series of independent experiments. Psychological Bulletin1982;92:490–499
16.
SpielbergerCDGorsuchRLLusheneRE. Manual for the state-trait anxiety inventory. Palo Alto, California: Consulting Psychologists Press
17.
JormAF. The dissemination of research findings: Some limitations revealed when attempting a meta-analysis. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1986;20:384–385
18.
HedgesLVOlkinI. Vote-counting methods in research synthesis. Psychological Bulletin1980;88:359–369
19.
HedgesLVOlkinI. Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Orlando: Academic Press, 1985
20.
HedgesLV. Distribution theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational Statistics1981;6:107–128
21.
AndrewsGMoranC. The treatment of agoraphobia with panic attacks: Are drugs really necessary?1987 Unpublished manuscript
22.
KnausWMcKeeverC. Rational-emotive education with learning disabled children. Journal of Learning Disabilities1977;10:10–14
23.
BlockJ. Effects of a rational-emotive mental health program on poorly achieving, disruptive high school students. Journal of Counseling Psychology1978;25:61–65
24.
di GiuseppeRKassinoveH. Effects of a rational-emotive school mental health program on children's emotional adjustment. Journal of Community Psychology1976;4:382–387
25.
KnausWBokorS. The effect of rational-emotive education lessons on anxiety and self-concept in sixth grade students. Rational Living1975;10:7–10
26.
OmizoMMCubberlyWEOmizoSA. The effects of rational-emotive education groups on self-concept and locus of control among learning disabled children. Exceptional Child1985;32:13–19
27.
AkinsTHollandsworthJGO'ConnellSJVisual and verbal modes of information processing and their relation to the effectiveness of cognitively-based anxiety-reduction techniques. Behaviour Research and Therapy1982;20:261–268.
28.
AllenGJEffectiveness of study counseling and desensitization in alleviating test anxiety in college students. Journal of Abnormal Psychology1971;77:282–289.
29.
AllenGJTreatment of test anxiety by group- administered and self-administered relaxation and study counselling. Behavior Therapy1973;4:349–360.
30.
AltmaierEMWoodwardM.Group vicarious desensitization of test anxiety. Journal of Counseling Psychology1981;28:467–496.
31.
AndrewsWRBehavioural and client-centred counseling of high school underachievers. Journal of Counseling Psychology1971;18:93–96.
32.
AntonWDAn evaluation of outcome variables in the systematic desensitization of test anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy1976;14:217–224.
33.
BarlowDHCohenASWaddellMTVermilyeaBBKloskoJSBlanchardEBdi NardoPAPanic and generalized anxiety disorders: Nature and treatment. Behaviour Therapy1984;15:431–449.
34.
BedellJRSystematic desensitization, relaxation-training and suggestion in the treatment of test anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy1976;14:309–311.
35.
BoswellPCMurrayEJEffects of meditation on psychological and physiological measures of anxiety. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1979;47:606–607.
36.
BoutinGETosiDJModification of irrational ideas and test anxiety through rational stage directed hypnotherapy (RSDH). Journal of Clinical Psychology1983;39:382–391.
37.
Chang-LiangRDenneyDRApplied relaxation as training in self-control. Journal of Counseling Psychology1976;23:183–189.
38.
CountsDKHollandsworthJGAlcornJDUse of electromyographic biofeedback and cue-controlled relaxation in the treatment of test anxiety. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1978;46:990–996.
39.
CraganMKDeffenbacherJLAnxiety management training and relaxation as self-control in the treatment of generalized anxiety in medical outpatients. Journal of Counseling Psychology1984;31:123–131.
40.
DaleyPCBloomLJDeffenbacherJLStewartR.Treatment effectiveness of anxiety management training in small and large group formats. Journal of Counseling Psychology1983;30:104–107.
41.
de BerryS.An evaluation of progressive muscle relaxation on stress related symptoms in a geriatric population. International Journal of Aging and Human Development1982;14:255–269.
42.
DeffenbacherJLDenimPMBrandonADHigh general anger: Correlates and treatment. Behaviour Research and Therapy1986;24:481–489.
43.
DeffenbacherJLMathisHMichaelsACTwo self-control procedures in the reduction of targeted and nontargeted anxieties. Journal of Counseling Psychology1979;26:120–127.
44.
DeffenbacherJLMichaelsACDaleyPCMichaelsT.A comparison of homogeneous and heterogeneous anxiety management training. Journal of Counseling Psychology1980;27:630–634.
45.
DeffenbacherJLMichaelsACMichaelsTDaleyPCComparison of anxiety management training and self-control desensitization. Journal of Counseling Psychology1980;27:232–239.
46.
DeffenbacherJLParksDHA comparison of traditional and sell-control desensitization. Journal of Counseling Psychology1979;26:93–97.
47.
di LoretoAOComparative psychotherapy: An experimental analysis. Chicago: Aldine, 1971.
48.
FlingSThomasAGallaherM.Participant characteristics and the effects of two types of meditation vs. quiet sitting. Journal of Clinical Psychology1981;37:784–790.
49.
FouldsMLHanniganPSA Gestalt marathon workshop: Effects on extraversion and neuroticism. Journal of College Student Personnel1976;17:50–54.
50.
GoldfriedMRLinehanMMSmithJLReduction of test anxiety through cognitive restructuring. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1978;46:32–39.
51.
GoldmanBLDomitorPJMurrayEJEffects of Zen meditation on anxiety reduction and perceptual functioning. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1979;47:551–556.
52.
GraffRWMacLeanDLovingA.Group reactive inhibition and reciprocal inhibitions therapies with anxious college students. Journal of Counseling Psychology1971;18:431–436.
53.
GraffRWWhiteheadGJle CompteMGroup treatment with divorced women using cognitive-behavioral and supportive-insight methods. Journal of Counseling Psychology1986;33:276–281.
54.
HazaleusSLDeffenbacherJLRelaxation and cognitive treatments of anger. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1986;54:222–226.
55.
HillenbergJBCollinsFLThe importance of home practice for progressive relaxation training. Behaviour Research and Therapy1983;21:633–642.
56.
HomeAMEffect of personality type in reducing specific anxiety with behavioural and psychodynamic therapy. Journal of Counseling Psychology1974;21:340–341.
57.
HomeAMMatsonJLA comparison of modeling, desensitization, flooding, study skills, and control groups for reducing test anxiety. Behavior Therapy1977;8:1–8.
58.
HurleyJDDifferential effects of hypnosis, biofeedback training, and trophotropic responses on anxiety, ego strength, and locus of control. Journal of Clinical Psychology1980;36:503–507.
59.
HussianRALawrencePSThe reduction of test, state, and trait anxiety by test-specific and generalized stress inoculation training. Cognitive Therapy and Research1978;2:25–37.
60.
HutchingsDFDenneyDRBasgallJHoustonBKAnxiety management and applied relaxation in reducing general anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy1980;18:181–190.
61.
JenniMAWollersheimJPCognitive therapy, stress management training, and the Type A behavior pattern. Cognitive Therapy and Research1979;3:61–73.
62.
KanterNJGoldfriedMRRelative effectiveness of rational restructuring and self-control desensitization in the reduction of interpersonal anxiety. Behavior Therapy1979;10:472–490.
63.
KilmannPRAuerbachSMEffects of marathon group therapy on trait and state anxiety. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1974;42:607–612.
64.
KipperDAGiladiD.Effectiveness of structured psychodrama and systematic desensitization in reducing test anxiety. Journal of Counseling Psychology1978;25:499–505.
65.
LehrerPMSchoicketSCarringtonPWoolfolkPLPsychophysiological and cognitive responses to stressful stimuli in subjects practicing progressive relaxation and clinically standardized meditation. Behaviour Research and Therapy1980;18:293–303.
66.
LehrerPMWoolfolkRLRooneyAJMcCannBCarringtonP.Progressive relaxation and meditation: A study of psychophysiological and therapeutic differences between two techniques. Behaviour Research and Therapy1983;21:651–162.
67.
LewisCEBiglanASteinbockE.Self-administered relaxation training and money deposits in the treatment of recurrent anxiety. Journal of Counsulting and Clinical Psychology1978;46:1274–1283.
68.
LipskyMJKassinoveHMillerNJEffects of rational-emotive therapy, rational role reversal, and rational-emotive imagery on the emotional adjustment of community mental health center patients. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1980;48:366–374.
69.
MarzillierJSLambertCKellettJ.A controlled evaluation of systematic desensitisation and social skills training for socially inadequate psychiatric patients. Behaviour Research and Therapy1976;14:225–238.
70.
MendoncaJDSiessTFCounseling for indecisiveness: Problem-solving and anxiety-management training. Journal of Counseling Psychology1976;23:339–347.
71.
MitchellKRInghamRJThe effects of general anxiety on group desensitization of test anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy1970;8:69–78.
72.
MitchellKRMitchellDMMigraine: An exploratory treatment application of programmed behaviour therapy techniques. Journal of Psychosomatic Research1971;15:137–157.
73.
MorrowGREffect of the cognitive hierarchy in systematic desensitization treatment of anticipatory nausea in cancer patients: A component comparison with relaxation only, counseling, and no treatment. Cognitive Therapy and Research1986;10:421–446.
74.
MosesANHollandsworthJCRelative effectiveness of education alone versus stress inoculation training in the treatment of dental phobia. Behavior Therapy1985;16:531–537.
75.
MunjackDCristolAGoldsteinAPhillipsDGoldbergAWhippleKStaplesFKannoP.Behavioural treatment of orgasmic dysfunction: A controlled study. British Journal of Psychiatry1976;129:497–502.
76.
OllendickTHNettleMDAn evaluation of the relaxation component of induced anxiety. Behavior Therapy1977;8:561–566.
77.
PuryearHBCayceCTThurstonMAAnxiety reduction associated with meditation: Home study. Perceptual and Motor Skills1976;43:527–531.
78.
ReedMSaslowC.The effects of relaxation instructions and EMG biofeedback on lest anxiety, general anxiety, and locus of control. Journal of Clinical Psychology1980;36:683–690.
79.
RussellRKMillerDEJuneLNA comparison between group systematic desensitization and cue-controlled relaxation in the treatment of test anxiety. Behavior Therapy1975;6:172–177.
80.
RussellRKWiseRStratoudakisJPTreatment of test anxiety by cue-controlled relaxation and systematic desensitization. Journal of Counseling Psychology1976;23:563–566.
81.
SchelverSRGutschKUThe effects of self-administered cognitive therapy on social-evaluative anxiety. Journal of Clinical Psychology1983;39:658–666.
82.
SharpJJFormanSGA comparison of two approaches to anxiety management training. Behavior Therapy1985;16:370–383.
83.
ShermanARMulacAMcCannMJSynergistic effect of self-relaxation and rehearsal feedback in the treatment of subjective and behavioral dimensions of speech anxiety. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1974;42:819–827.
84.
ShermanARPlummerILTraining in relaxation as a behavioral self-management skill: An exploratory investigation. Behavior Therapy1973;4:543–550.
85.
SmithJCPsychotherapeutic effects of transcendental meditation with controls for expectation of relief and daily sitting. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1976;44:630–637.
86.
ThompsonJGGriebsteinMGKuhlenschmidtSLEffects of EMG biofeedback and relaxation training in the prevention of academic underachievement. Journal of Counseling Psychology1980;27:97–106.
87.
TrussellRPUse of graduated behavior rehearsal, feedback, and systematic desensitization for speech anxiety. Journal of Counseling Psychology1978;25:14–20.
88.
van HasselJHBloomLJGonzalezAMAnxiety management with schizophrenic outpatients. Journal of Clinical Psychology1982;38:280–285.
89.
WellsJKHowardGSNowlinWFVargasMJPresurgical anxiety and postsurgical pain and adjustment: Effect of a stress inoculation procedure. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology1986;54:831–835.
90.
WoolfolkRLLehrerPMMcCannBSRooneyAJEffects of progressive relaxation and meditation on cognitive and somatic manifestations of daily stress. Behaviour Research and Therapy1982;20:461–467.
