Despite the pressures of an increasingly ageing population and an ever increasing scientific knowledge, the clinical characteristics of dementia remain poorly defined. This relative lack of clarity in clinical understanding has led to diverse diagnostic problems, including those of mistaken diagnosis as well as over- and under-diagnosis in different settings. This paper focuses on the syndromal and aetiological diagnosis of dementia by outlining current clinical definitions, considering differential diagnosis in detail and reviewing characteristics of common dementing disorders. The past emphasis on a search for treatable causes, the reliance on laboratory investigations and the concept of subcortical dementia are all questioned. Aspects of evaluation that are stressed include the value of brief objective cognitive testing, a knowledge of normal age-related cognitive changes, flexible criteria for Alzheimer's disease and a comprehensive individualised evaluation of the person. Broader assessment issues will be dealt with in a second paper.
References
1.
BeckJ. C.Dementia in the elderly: The silent epidemicAnn Intern Med97, 1982231–42
2.
WellsC.A deluge of dementiaPsychosomatics22, 1981832–40
3.
ROYAL COLLEGE OF PHYSICIANS' COMMITTEE ON GERIATRICS, Organic mental impairment in the elderly, J Royal Coll Physicians15, 1981142–67
4.
KatzmanR.The prevalence and malignancy of Alzheimer's DiseaseArch Neurol33, 1976217–18
5.
ArieT.JollyD.The rising tideBr Med J286, 1983325–6
6.
ThomasL.The problem of dementia, Discovery Aug. 198134–6
7.
HendersonA. S.The epidemiology of Alzheimer's DiseaseBr Med Bull42, 1986. 3–10
8.
KayD. W. K.BergmannK.Epidemiology of mental disorders among the aged in the community in BirenJ. E.SloanR. B. (eds), Handbook of Mental Health and Ageing.Prentice Hall. New Jersey, 198034–56
9.
KayD. W. K.HendersonA. S.ScottR.WilsonJ.RickwoodD.GraysonD. A.Dementia and depression among the elderly living in the Hobart communityPsychol Med15, 1985771–88
10.
HendersonA. S.KayD. W. K.The epidemiology of mental disorders in the aged in KayD. W. K.BurrowsD. (eds), Handbook of Studies on Psychiatry and Old Age, Elsevier Science, London, 198454–88
11.
RedickR. W.TaubeC. A.Demography and mental health care of the aged in BirrenJ. E.SloaneR. B. (eds), Handbook of Mental Health and Ageing.Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 198057–77
12.
SchneckM. K.ReisbergB.FerrisS. H.An overview of current concepts of Alzheimer's DiseaseAm J Psychiat139, 1982165–73
KatzmanR.Unpublished study quoted in C. E. Wells, PseudodementiaAm J Psychiat136, 1979895–900
32.
MalettaG. J.PirozzoloF. J.ThompsonG.MortimerJ. A.Organic mental disorders in a geriatric outpatient populationAm J Psychiat139, 1982521–3
33.
SmithJ. J.KilohL. G.The investigation of dementia: Results in 200 consecutive admissionsLancet (1), 1981824–7
34.
LarsenE. B.ReiflerB. V.FeatherstoneH. J.EnglishD. R.Dementia in elderly out-patients: a prospective studyAnn Intern Med100, 1984417–23
35.
HuttonJ. T.Results of clinical assessment for the dementia syndrome: Implications for epidemiological studies in MortimerJ. A.ShumanL. M. (eds), The Epidemiology of Dementia.Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1981
36.
RabinsP. V.The prevalence of reversible dementia in a psychiatric hospitalHosp Community Psychiatry32, 1981490–2
37.
RenvoizeE. B.GaskellR. K.KlarH. M.Results of investigations of 150 dementia patients consecutively admitted to a psychiatric hospitalBr J Psychiat147, 1984204–5
38.
FoxJ. H.TopelJ. L.HuckmanM. S.Dementia in the elderly: A search for treatable illnessJ Gerontology30, 1979557–64
39.
FreemonF. R.Evaluation of patients with progressive intellectual deteriorationArch Neurol33, 1976658–9
40.
SeltzerB.SherwinI.Organic brain syndromes: An empirical study and critical reviewAm J Psychiat135, 197813–21
41.
VictoratosB. L.LenmanJ. A. R.HerzbergL.Neurological investigation of dementiaBr J Psychiat130, 1977131–3
42.
GarciaC. A.RedingM. J.BlassJ. P.Over-diagnosis of dementiaJ Am Geriatr Soc24, 1981407–10
43.
FilinsonR.Diagnosis of senile dementia of the Alzheimer's type: The state of the artClin Geront2, 19843–23
44.
WilliamsonJ.StokoeI. H.GrayS.Old people at home: Their unreported needsLancet (1), 19641117–20
45.
GoldbergD.KayC.ThompsonL.Psychiatric morbidity in general practice and the communityPsychol Med6, 1976565–9
46.
FolksL.FordD.Psychiatric disorders in geriatric medicineSouth Med J78, 1985239–41
47.
FolsteinM. D.FolsteinS. E.McHughP. R.Mini-mental state: A practical method for grading the cognitive status of patientsJ Psychiatr Res12, 1975189–96
48.
JacobsJ. W.BernhardM. R.DelgardoA.StrainJ. J.Screening for organic mental syndromes in the medically illAnn Intern Med86, 197740–6
49.
AnthonyJ. C.LeRescheL.Von KorffM.Limits of the Mini-Mental State in screening for dementia among hospital patientsPsychol Med12, 1982397–408
50.
De PauloJ. R.FolsteinM.Psychiatric disturbances in neurological patientsAnn Neurol5, 19782225–8
51.
CavanaughS. V. A.The prevalence of emotional and cognitive dysfunction in a general medical population: Using the MMSE, GHQ and BDIGen Hosp Psychiatry5, 198315–24
52.
McCartneyJ. R.PalmateerL. M.Assessment of cognitive deficit in geriatric patients: A study of physician behaviourJ Am Geriatr Soc33, 1985467–71
53.
KnightsR.FolsteinM.Unsuspected cognitive disturbance in medical patientsAnn Intern Med87, 1977723–4
54.
CheahK. C.BeardO. N.Psychiatric findings in the population of a geriatric evaluation unit: ImplicationsJ Am Geriatr Soc28, 1980153–6
55.
BlassJ. P.Mental state tests in geriatricsJ Am Geriatr Soc33, 1982461–2
56.
ListonE. H.Occult presenile dementiaJ Nerv Ment Dis164, 1977263–7
57.
KendellR. E.The stability of psychiatric diagnosisBr J Psychiat124, 1974352–6
58.
HoffmanR. S.Diagnostic errors in the evaluation of behavioural disorders, JAMA, 1982964–7
59.
ListonE. H.Diagnostic delay in presenile dementiaJ Clin Psychiat39, 1978599–603
60.
GustafsonL.NilssonL.Differential diagnosis of presenile dementia on clinical groundsActa Psychiat Scand65, 1982194–209
61.
SimM.SussmanI.Alzheimer's Disease: Its natural history and differential diagnosisJ Ner Ment Dis135, 1962489–99
62.
MauleM. M.MilneJ. S.WilliamsonJ.Mental illness and physical health in older peopleAge Ageing13, 1985349–56
63.
PostF.Paranoid disorders in the elderlyPostgrad Med J53, 197352–6
GelderM.GathD.MayouR.Oxford Textbook of Psychiatry1st ednOxford University Press, Oxford, 1983
67.
RutterM.LeboviciS.EisenberG. L.A tri-axial classification of mental disorders in childhood: An international studyJ Child Psychol Psychiatry10, 196941–61
68.
AMERICAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION.Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd edn.American Psychiatric Association, Washington, DC1980
69.
WellsC. E.Diagnostic Evaluation and Treatment in WellsC. E. (ed.), Dementia.2nd edn.David, Philadelphia, 1977247–75
70.
WellsC. E.Refinements in the diagnosis of dementiaAm Psychiatry139, 1982621–2
71.
NINCD–ADRDS WORK GROUP.Criteria for the clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer's Disease, J Am Geriatr Soc33, 19822–3
72.
EisdorderC.CohenD.Diagnostic criteria for primary neuronal degeneration of the Alzheimer's type, J Family Practice11, 1980553–7
73.
JormA. F.HendersonA. S.Possible improvements to the diagnostic criteria for dementia in DSM-IIIBr J Psychiat147, 1985394–9
74.
RothM.The natural history of mental disorder in old ageJ Ment Sci101, 1955281–301
75.
GallantD. M.Differential diagnosis of confusion in the geriatric patientGeriatric Medicine Today4, 198572–81
WellsC. E.Organic brain disease: An overviewAm J Psychiat135, 19781–12
91.
FeinbergT.GoodmanB.Affective illness, dementia and pseudodementiaJ Clin Psychiat45, 198499–103
92.
YoungR. C.ManleyM. W.AlexopoulosG. S.I don't know' responses in elderly depressives and dementiaJ Am Geriatr Soc33, 1985253–7
93.
WellsC. E.Pseudodementia and the recognition of organicity in BensonP. D.BlumerR. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 2, Grune & Stratton, New York, ch. 8, 1982167–78
94.
WeingartnerH.CohenR. M.Memory learning impairments in progressive dementia and depressionAm J Psychiat139, 1982135–6
95.
WattsF. N.SharrockR.Description and measurement of concentration problems in depressed patientsPsychol Med15, 1985317–26
96.
RobertsonG.TaylorP. J.Some cognitive correlates of affective disordersPsychol Med15, 1985297–309
97.
WillnerP.Cognitive functioning in depression: A review of theory and researchPsychol Med14, 1984807–23
98.
CaineE. D.Pseudodementia: Current concepts and future directionsArch Gen Psychiat38, 19811359–64
99.
GrunhausL.DilsaverS.GredenJ. F.CarrolB. J.Depressive pseudodementia: A suggested diagnostic profileBiol Psychiatry18, 1983215–25
100.
JenikeM. A.DST as a clinical aid in elderly depressed patients: A reviewJ Am Geriatr Soc31, 198345–8
101.
SparJ. E.GernerR.Does the DST distinguish dementia from depression?Am J Psychiat139, 1982238–40
102.
McKeithI. G.Clinical use of the DST in a psychogeriatric populationBr J Psychiat145, 1984389–93
103.
LeggN. J.FrackqwakR. S. J.PET in dementiaInterdiscip Top Gerontol20, 198567–70
104.
CutlerN. R.DuaraR.CreasyH.Brain imaging, aging and dementiaAnn Intern Med101, 1984355–69
105.
FentonG. W.Electrophysiology of Alzheimer's DiseaseBr Med Bull42, 198629–33
106.
DevanandD. P.NelsonJ. C.Concurrent depression and dementia: Implications for diagnosis and treatmentJ Clin Psychiat46, 1985389–92
107.
McAllisterT. W.PriceT. R. P.Severe depressive pseudodementia with and without dementiaAm J Psychiat139, 1981626–9
108.
MahendraB.Depression and dementia: A multi-faceted relationshipPsychol Med15, 1985227–36
109.
MorstynR.HochanadelG.KaplanE.GutheilT. G.Depression vs. pseudodepression in dementiaJ Clin Psychiat43, 1982197–9
110.
ShrabergD.The myth of pseudodementia: Depression and the aging brainAm J Psychiat135, 1978601–3
SnowS. S.WellsC. E.Case studies in neuropsychiatry: Diagnosis and treatment of co-existing dementia and depressionJ Clin Psychiat42, 1981439–41
113.
RedingM.HaycoxJ.BlassJ.Depression in patients referred to a dementia clinic: A three year prospective studyArch Neurol42, 1985894–6
114.
ReiflerB. V.LarsonE.HanleyR.Co-existence of cognitive impairment and depression in geriatric out-patientsAm J Psychiat139, 1982623–6
115.
MeyersB. S.Mei-TalV.Empirical study on an inpatient psychogeriatric unit: Biological treatment in patients with depressive illnessInt J Psychiatry Med15, 1985111–24
116.
SnowdonJ.When is dementia presenile?Br Med J (1), 1971465
117.
PostF.Dementia, depression and pseudodementia in BensonD. F.BlumerD. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 1, Grune & Stratton, New York, 1975 ch. 6, 99–120
118.
MurphyE.The prognosis of depression in old ageBr J Psychiat142, 1983111–19
119.
KralV. A.The relationship between SDAT and depressionCan J Psychiat28, 1983304–5
120.
HachinskiV.LassenN. A.MarshallJ.Multi-infarct dementia: A cause of mental deterioration in the elderlyLancet (2), 1974207–9
La RueA.Memory loss and agingPsychiatr Clin North Am5, 198289–103
123.
ParnettiL.CiuffettiG.SignoriniE.SeninU.Memory impairment in the elderly: A three year follow upArch Gerontol Geriatr4, 198591–100
124.
BergmannK.The problem of early diagnosis in GlenA. M.WalleyL. F. (eds), Alzheimer's Disease: Early Recognition of Potentially Reversible Deficits, Churchill Livingstone, New York, 197668–77
125.
DraperB.The Diagnosis and Management of Dementia, dissertation submitted to the RANZCP, Melbourne, Aug. 1985
126.
LoversoF. L.Speech and language disturbancesNeurol Clin North Am2, 198437–50
127.
KirshnerH. S.WeggW. G.KellyM. P.WellsC. E.Language disturbance: An initial symptom of cortical degenerations and dementiaArch Neurol41, 1984491–6
128.
BreitnerJ. C. S.FolsteinM. F.Familial Alzheimer's Disease: A prevalent disorder with specific clinical featuresPsychol Med14, 198463–80
129.
BroeG. A.Patterns of Dementia Relevant to Diagnosis and Management, unpublished paper, Lidcombe Hospital, Sydney, 1982
130.
WalshK. W.Neuropsychology: A Clinical Approach1st ednChurchill Livingstone, Sydney, 1978
131.
BlumerD.BensonD. F.Personality changes with frontal and temporal lobe lesions in BensonD. F.BlumerD. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 1, Grune & Stratton, New York, 1975
132.
BroeG. A.Investigating dementiaBull Post-Grad Committee Med Syd Uni41, 198539–45
133.
PopplewellP. Y.HenschkeP. J.Acute admissions to a geriatric assessment unitMed J Aust (1), 1982343–4
134.
GurlandB. J.The borderlands of dementia: The influence of sociocultural characteristics on rates of dementia occurring in the seniumAging15, 198161–86
135.
FolsteinM.AnthonyJ. C.ParhadI.The meaning of cognitive impairment in the elderlyJ Am Geriatr Soc33, 1985228–35
136.
AndreasenN. C.Negative symptoms in schizophreniaArch Gen Psychiat39, 1982784–8
137.
GoetzK. L.Van KammenD. P.Computerised Axial Tomography and subtypes of schizophrenia: A review of the literatureJ Nerv Ment Dis174, 198631–41
138.
DeutschS. I.DavisK. L.Schizophrenia: A review of diagnostic and behavioural issues: II. Biological IssuesHosp Community Psychiatry34, 1983423–37
139.
CrowT. J.Molecular pathology of schizophrenia: More than one disease process?Br Med J (1), 198066–8
140.
RothM.WhiteC. B.Nuclear and non-nuclear schizophrenic syndromesMedicine35, 19821794–8
141.
BirdJ. M.CT scan studies and treatment response in schizophrenicsCan J Psychiatry30, 1985251–3
142.
PostF.Dementia, depression and pseudodementia in BensonD. F.BlumerD. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 1, Grune & Stratton, New York, 1975
KellerM. B.ManschreckT. C.The biologic mental state examination in LazareA. (ed.), Out-Patient Psychiatry.Williams and Wilkens, Baltimore, 1978 ch. 11, 203–14
157.
KleinL. E.RocaR. P.McArthurM.Diagnosing dementia: Uni-variant and multi-variant analysis of the MSE. J Am Geriatr Soc33, 1985483–8
158.
BlessedB.TomlinsonB. E.RothM.The association between quantitative measures of dementia and of senile changes in the cerebral grey matter of elderly subjectsBr J Psychiat114, 1968797–811
159.
PfeifferE.A short portable MSQ for the assessment of organic brain deficits in elderly patientsJ Am Geriatr Soc23, 1975433–41
160.
KahnR. L.GoldfarbA. I.PollackM.Brief objective measures for the determination of mental status in the agedAm J Psychiat117, 1960326–30
161.
McDonaldC.Clinical heterogeneity in senile dementiaBr J Psychiat115, 1969267–71
162.
HareM.Clinical check-list for the diagnosis of dementiaBr Med J (2), 1978266–8
163.
StorandtM.BothwinickJ.DanzigerW. Z.Psychometric differentiation of mild SDAT. Arch Neurol41, 1984497–9
164.
EslingerP. J.DamasioA. R.BentonA. L.AllanM.Neuropsychological detection of abnormal mental decline in older personsJAMA253, 1985670–4
165.
CaltagironeC.GainottiS. I.MasulloC.MiceliG.The value of some neuropsychological tests in the assessment of mental deteriorationActa Psychiatr Scand60, 197950–6
166.
NelsonA.FogelB. S.FaustD.Bedside cognitive screening instruments: A critical assessmentJ Nerv Ment Dis174, 198673–83
167.
BensonD. F.The treatable dementias in BensonD. F.BlumerD. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 2. Grune & Stratton, New York, 1982
168.
YesavageJ.Dementia: Differential diagnosis and treatmentGeriatrics34, 197951–9
169.
LarsonE. B.ReiflerB. V.CanfieldC.CohenG. D.Evaluating elderly out-patients with symptoms of dementiaHosp Community Psychiatry35, 1984425–7
170.
HachinskiV.Multi-infarct dementiaNeurol Clin North Am2, 198427–36
171.
GustafsonL.NilssonL.Differential diagnosis of presenile dementia on clinical groundsActa Psychiat Scand65, 1982194–209
172.
HarrisonM. J. G.ThomasD. J.BoulayG. H.MarshallJ.Multi-infarct dementiaJ Neurol Sci40, 197997–103
173.
ListonE. H.La RueA.Differential diagnosis of primary dementia and multi-infarct dementia: A critical review of the evidence. I: Clinical studies & II: Pathological studiesBiol Psychiat18, 19831451–65
174.
ListonE. H.La RueA.DSM-III diagnosis of multi-infarct dementiaComp Psychiatry27, 198654–9
175.
MolsaP. K.PauarL.VIRinneJ. O.Validity of the clinical diagnosis in dementia: A prospective clinicopathological studyJ Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry48, 19851085–90
176.
BuchtG.AdolfssonR.WinbladB.Dementia of the Alzheimer type and MID: Clinical description and diagnostic problemsJ Am Geriatr Soc32, 1984491–7
177.
LoebC.GandolfoC.Diagnostic evaluation of degenerative and vascular dementiaStroke14, 1983399–407
178.
RosenW. G.TerryR. D.FuldP. A.Pathological verification of ischaemia scores in differentiation of dementiasAnn Neurol7, 1980486–90
179.
CummingsJ. L.BensonD. F.Subcortical dementia: Review of an emerging conceptArch Neurol41, 1984874–9
180.
AlbertM. L.Subcortical dementiaAging7, 1978173–80
181.
McHughM. D.FolsteinP. R.Psychiatric syndromes of Huntington's Chorea: A clinical and phenomenologic study in BensonD. F.BlumerD. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 1, Grune & Stratton, New York, 1975
182.
BensonD. F.Clinical aspects of dementia, in J. C. Beck (mod), Dementia in the elderlyAn Intern Med97, 1982231–3
183.
MayeuxR.SternY.RosenJ.BensonD. F.Is subcortical dementia a recognizable clinical entity?Ann Neurol14, 1983278–83
184.
WellsC. E.Chronic brain disease: An update on alcoholism, Parkinson's Disease and dementiaHosp Community Psychiatry33, 1982111–26
185.
WhitehouseP.The concept of subcortical dementia: Another lookAnn Neurol19, 19861–6
186.
KatzmanR.Clinical presentation of the course of Alzheimer's Disease: The atypical patientInterdiscip Top Gerontol20, 198512–18
187.
CummingsJ. L.BensonF.Dementia of the Alzheimer typeJ Am Geriatr Soc34, 198612–19
188.
ReisbergB.FerrisS. H.CrookT.Signs, symptoms and course of age-associated cognitive declineAging19, 1982177–82
189.
HughesC. P.BergL.DanzigerW. L.A new scale for the staging of dementiaBr J Pyschiat140, 1982566–72
190.
RabinsP. V.Reversible dementia and the misdiagnosis of dementia: A reviewHosp Community Psychiatry34, 1983830–5
191.
CummingsJ.BensonD. F.Lo VermeS.Reversible dementia: Illustrative cases, definition and reviewJAMA243, 19802434–9
BradshawJ. R.ThomsonJ. L. G.CampbellM. J.CT scan in the investigation of dementiaBr Med J286, 1983277–80
203.
FoxJ.KaszniakA. W.HuckmanM.CT scanning — not very helpful in dementiaN Engl J Med300, 1979437–9
204.
JacobyR. J.LevyR.CT scanning and the investigation of dementia: A reviewJ R Soc Med73, 1980366–9
205.
McGeerP. L.Brain imaging in Alzheimer's diseaseBr Med Bull42, 198624–9
206.
WellsC. E.DuncanG. W.Dangers of over-reliance on computerized cranial tomographyAm J Psychiat134, 1977811–12
207.
PearlsonD. P.VoroffA. E.McHughP. R.The use of computed tomography in psychiatry: Recent applications to schizophrenia, manic-depressive illness and dementia syndromesJohns Hopkins Med J149, 1981194–202
208.
JacobyR. F.LevyR.DawsonJ. M.CT in elderly: I. The normal populationBr J Psychiat136, 1980249–55
209.
AshworthB.Who needs a CT scan? (editorial)Br Med J292, 1986845–6
210.
BensonD. F.The treatable dementias in BensonD. F.BlumerD. (eds), Psychiatric Aspects of Neurological Disease, Vol. 2, Grune & Stratton, New York, 1982
211.
WeinbergerD. R.Brain disease and psychiatric illness: When should a psychiatrist order a CAT scanAm J Psychiat141, 19841521–7
212.
JacobyR. J.LevyR.CT in the elderly: 3. affective disorderBr J Psychiat136, 1980270–5
213.
LevyR.JacobyR. J.CT in the elderly: 2. Senile dementia: Diagnosis and functional impairmentBr J Psychiat136, 1980256–69
214.
EslingerP. J.DamasioH.RadfordN. G.DamasioA. R.Examining the relationship between CT and neuropsychological measures in normal and demented elderlyJ Neurit Neurosurg Psychiatry47, 19841319–25
215.
BiglerE. D.HublerD. W.CullumC. N.TurkheimerE.Intellect and memory impairment in dementia: CAT volume correlationsJ Nerv Ment Dis173, 1985348–52
216.
NaguibM.LevyR.Predicting outcome in senile dementia: A CT studyBr J Psychiat140, 1982263–7
217.
AlbertM.MaeserM. A.LevineH. L.GarveyA. J.Ventricular size in patients with presenile dementia of the Alzheimer's typeArch Neurol41, 19841258–63
