Over the past 50 years the relationship between alcoholism and psychiatric disorders, such as depression, anxiety and schizophrenia, has been the subject of a great deal of research. Psychiatric problems have been seen as both a cause and a result of alcoholism. Whatever the relation between alcoholism and psychiatric disorder is, it may have significance for the development of differentially effective treatment strategies. Several authors have argued that the presence and nature of psychiatric symptoms should form the basis of a classification system for alcoholics. Given the potential rewards of such a system for both understanding the aetiology of alcoholism and developing effective treatment strategies, it is important to have a clear picture of the nature and extent of this relationship. This paper reviews critically the published studies of the association between alcoholism and psychiatric disorder and outlines directions for future research.
References
1.
BahnA.ChandlerC. (1961) Alcoholism in psychiatric clinic patientsQuart J Stud on Alc22, 411–17
2.
BarnesG. (1979) The alcoholic personality. A reanalysis of the literatureQuart J Stud on Alc40, 571–632
3.
BeckA.SteerR.McElroyM. (1982) Self-reported prevalence of depression in alcoholismDrug and Alcohol Dependence10, 185–90
4.
BowenR.CipywynkD.D'ArcyC.KeeganD. (1984) Types of depression in alcoholic patientsCan Med Assoc J130, 869–74
5.
CadoretR.WinokurG. (1974) Depression in alcoholismAnn NY Acad Science233, 34–9
6.
CapellH.HermanC. (1972) Alcohol and tension reduction: A reviewQuart J Stud Alc33, 33–64
7.
CrowleyT.CheslukD.DiltsS.HartR. (1974) Drug and alcohol abuse among psychiatric admissionsArch Gen Psychiat30, 13–20
8.
EllermanM. (1948) Social and clinical features of chronic alcoholismJ Nerv and Ment Dis107, 556–68
9.
FowlerR. C.LiskowB. L.VasantkumarL. (1977) Psychiatric illness and alcoholismAlcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research1, 125–8
10.
FreedE. (1975) Alcoholism and schizophrenia: The search for perspectives. A reviewQuart J Stud on Alc36, 853–81
11.
GillisL.KeetM. (1969) Prognostic factors and treatment results in hospitalised alcoholicsQuart J Stud on Alc30, 426–37
12.
HalikasJ.HerzogM.MirassouM.LyttleM. (1982) Psychiatric diagnosis among female alcoholics, in GalanterM. (ed.), Currents in Alcoholism, Vol. 8, Grune and Stratton, New York
13.
HodgsonR.StockwellT.RankinH. (1979) Can alcohol reduce tension?Behav Res and Therapy17, 459–66
KissinB. (1976) Patient characteristics and treatment specificity in alcoholism, in Recent Advances in the Study of Alcoholism. Proceedings of the First Mt Magnus Huss Symposium, Excerpta Medica, 110–22
17.
KrausJ. (1973) Alcoholism and drug dependence as factors in psychiatric hospital admissionsAust and NZ J of Psychiat7, 45–50
18.
McCourtW.WilliamsA.SchneiderL. (1971) Incidence of alcoholism in a state mental hospital populationQuart J Stud on Alc32, 1085–8
19.
McLellanA.DruleyK.CarsonJ. (1978) Evaluation of substance abuse problems in a psychiatric hospitalJ Clin Psychiat39, 425–30
20.
MulfordH. S.MillerD. (1960) Drinking in Iowa. IV. Preoccupation with alcohol and definitions of alcoholism, heavy drinking and problems due to drinkingQuart J Stud on Alc21, 279–91
21.
MullaneyJ.TrippettC. (1979) Alcohol dependence and phobias: Clinical description and relevanceBrit J Psychiat135, 565–73
22.
MullerJ.CheslukM.BaneH. (1967) Acute psychiatric services in the general hospital: III Statistical SurveyAmer J Psychiat124, 46–57
23.
NakamuraM.OverallJ.HollisterL.RadcliffeE. (1983) Factors affecting outcome of depressive symptoms in alcoholicsAlcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research7, 188–93
24.
O'FarrellT.ConnorsG.UpperD. (1983) Addictive behaviours among hospitalized psychiatric patientsAddictive Behaviours8, 329–33
25.
PenickE.PowellB.OthmerE. (1984) Subtyping alcoholics by coexisting psychiatric syndromes: Course, family history, outcome, in GoodwinD. (eds), Longitudinal Research in Alcoholism, Kluwer-Nijhoff, Boston, ch. 11
26.
PokornyA. (1965) The multiple readmission psychiatric patientPsychiatric Quarterly39, 70–8
27.
PowellB.PenickE.OthmerE. (1982) Prevalence of additional psychiatric syndromes among male alcoholicsJ Clin Psychiat43, 404–7
28.
RadaR. (1982) Alcoholism and sociopathy: Diagnostic and treatment implications, in PattisonE. M.KaufmanE. (eds), Encyclopaedic Handbook of Alcoholism, Gardner Press, New York, 647–54
29.
RimmerJ.ReichT.WinokurG. (1972) Alcoholism. V. Diagnosis and clinical variation among alcoholicsQuart J Stud on Alc33, 658–66
30.
RobinsE.GentryK.MunozR.MartenS. (1977) A contrast of the three more common illnesses with the ten less common in a study and 18 month follow-up of 314 psychiatric emergency room patientsArch Gen Psychiat34, 259–65
31.
RundD.SummersW.LevinM. (1981) Alcohol use and psychiatric illness in emergency patientsJAMA245, 1240–1
32.
SchuckitM. (1983) Alcoholic patients with secondary depressionAmer J Psychiat140, 711–14
33.
SchuckitM. (1986) Genetic and clinical implications of alcoholism and affective disorderAmer J Psychiat143, 140–7
34.
ShawJ.DorneyP.MorganD.RobinsonJ. (1975) Treatment of depression in alcoholicsAmer J Psychiat132, 641–4
35.
SmailP.StockwellT.CanterS.HodgsonR. (1984) Alcohol dependence and phobic anxiety states: A prevalence studyBrit J Psychiat144, 53–7
36.
SolomonJ.HansonM. (1982) Alcoholism and sociopathy, in SolomonJ. (ed.), Alcoholism in Clinical Psychiatry, Plenum Publishing Company, New York, 111–29
37.
TrierT.LevyR. (1969) Emergent, urgent and elective admissionsArch Gen Psychiat21, 423–30
38.
TyndelM. (1974) Psychiatric study of one thousand alcoholic patientsCan Psychiat Assoc J19, 21–2
39.
ViesselmanJ.SpaltL.TuasonV. (1975) Psychiatric disorders in a Community Mental Health Centre. II. Who gets readmitted?Comprehensive Psychiatry16, 485–94
40.
WallJ. (1937) A study of alcoholism in womenAmer J Psychiat93, 942–62
41.
WeingoldH.LachinJ.BellA. H.CoxeR. (1968) Depression as a symptom of alcoholismJournal Abnormal Psychology73, 195–7
42.
WeissK.RosenbergD. (1985) Prevalence of anxiety disorder among alcoholicsJ Clin Psychiat46, 3–5
43.
WeissmanM.MyersJ.HardingP. (1980) Prevalence and psychiatric hetrogeneity of alcoholism in a United States urban communityQuart J Stud on Alc41, 672–81
44.
WinokurG.ReichT.RimmerJ.PittsF. (1970) Alcoholism. III. Diagnosis and familiar psychiatric illness in 259 alcoholic probandsArch Gen Psychiat23, 104–11
45.
WoodruffR.GuzeS.ClaytonP.CarrD. (1973) Alcoholism and depressionArch Gen Psychiat28, 97–100
46.
ZielinskiJ. (1979) Psychological test data of depressed, non depressed and relapsed alcoholics receiving pharmacological aversionBrit J Addiction74, 175–82
