This paper provides a simplified method for evaluating the evidence in favour of a causal claim. It analyses the evidence bearing upon such a claim in terms of two questions: Do the putative cause and effect covary, and can alternative non-causal explanations of the relationship be ruled out? The different research designs for assessing covariation are outlined, as are the ways in which these designs permit a researcher to decide between alternative explanations of the relationship.
References
1.
AsherH. B. (1976), Causal Modeling, Sage Publications, Beverly Hills
2.
BebbingtonP. (1980), Causal models and logical inference in epidemiological psychiatry, British Journal of Psychiatry136, 317–25
3.
BentlerP. M. (1980), Multivariate analysis with latent variables: Causal modeling, Annual Review of Psychology31, 419–56
4.
BirdK. D.HallW. (1986), Statistical power in psychiatric research, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry20, 189–200
5.
BrossI. (1967), Pertinency of an extraneous variable, Journal of Chronic Diseases20, 487–95
6.
CookT. D.CampbellD. T. (1979), Quasi-Experimentation: Design and Analysis Issues for Field Settings, Rand McNally, Chicago
7.
CooperT.DetreT.WeisS. M. (1981), Coronary-prone behavior and coronary heart disease: A critical review, Circulation63, 1199–215
8.
DuncanO. D. (1975), Introduction to Structural Equation Models, Academic Press, New York
9.
EvansA. S. (1976), Causation and disease: the Henle-Koch postulates revisited, Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine49, 175–95
10.
FeinsteinA. R. (1979a), Clinical biostatislics XLVII: Scientific standards versus statistical associations and biologic logic in the analysis of causation, Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics25, 481–92
11.
FeinsteinA. R. (1979b), Clinical biostatistics XLVIII: Efficacy of different research structures in preventing bias in the analysis of causation, Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics26, 129–41
12.
Y-JonesFinla R. (1981), Showing that life events are a cause of depression, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry15, 229–38
13.
FisherR. A. (1949). The Design of Experiments, Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh
14.
FriedmanM.ThoresonC. E.GillJ. J. (1984), Alteration of type A behavior and reduction in cardiac recurrences in post-myocardial infarction patients, American Heart Journal108, 237–48
15.
GlassG. V.SmithM. L.McGawB. (1981), Meta-analysis in Social Research, Sage Publications, Beverly Hills
16.
HallW.BirdK. D. (1985), The problem of multiple inference in psychiatric research, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry19, 265–74
17.
HillA. B. (1977), A Short Textbook of Statistics, Hodder and Stoughlon, London
18.
JenkinsC. D.RosenmanR.ZyszanskiS. J. (1974), Prediction of clinical coronary heart disease by a lest for the coronary-prone behavior pattern, New England Journal of Medicine290, 1271–5
19.
KennyD. A. (1979), Correlation and Causality, Wiley, New York
20.
LaveL. B.SeskinE. P. (1979), Epidemiology, causality and public policy, American Scientist61, 178–86
21.
MacKieJ. L. (1974), The Cement of the Universe, Clarendon Press, Oxford
22.
MeehlP. E. (1977), Specific etiology and other forms of strong influence: some quantitative meanings, Journal of Medicine and Philosophy2, 33–53
23.
PopperK. R. (1959). The Logic of Scientific Discovery, Hutchinson, London
24.
PopperK. R. (1963), Conjectures and Refutations, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London
25.
PopperK. R. (1972), Objective Knowledge, Oxford University Press, London
26.
PriceV. A. (1982), Type A Behavior Pattern, Academic Press, New York
27.
RiegelmanR. (1979), Contributory cause: unnecessary and insufficient, Postgraduate Medicine66, 177–9
28.
SchlesselmanJ. J. (1978), Assessing effects of confounding variables, American Journal of Epidemiology108, 3–8
29.
ScrivenM. (1971), The logic of cause, Theory and Decision2, 49–66
30.
SiegelJ. M. (1984), Type A behavior: Epidemiologic foundations and public health implications, Annual Review of Public Health5, 343–67
31.
SosaE. (ed.) (1975), Causation and Conditionals, Oxford University Press, London
32.
StehbensW. E. (1985), The concept of cause in disease, Journal of Chronic Diseases38, 947–50
33.
SuppesP. (1970), A Probabilistic Theory of Causation, North Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam
34.
SusserM. (1973), Causal Thinking in the Health Sciences: Concepts and Strategies in Epidemiology, Oxford University Press, London
35.
SusserM. (1977), Judgment and causal inference: criteria in epidemiological studies, American Journal of Epidemiology105, 1–15
36.
TaylorR. (1968), Causation, inEdwardsP. (ed.), The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Free Press, New York
37.
ThomasL. (1981), The Medusa and the Snail, Penguin, Harmondsworth
38.
WinchR. F.CampbellD. T. (1969), Proof? No. Evidence? Yes. The significance of tests of significance, The American Sociologist4, 140–3
