Panic disorder with or without phobic avoidance has recently been delineated as a distinct nosological entity. Several controlled studies have demonstrated the efficacy of various pharmacological agents in controlling panic attacks. Behaviour therapy, especially desensitisation, is of value in alleviating phobic avoidance but has not yet been shown to be effective in the alleviation of panic attacks. No systematic studies comparing pharmacological and psychological treatments in panic disorder are available.
References
1.
AMERICAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION (1980) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd ednAmerican Psychiatric Association, Washington DC
2.
AndrewsJ. D. W. (1966) Psychotherapy of phobiasPsychological Bulletin66, 455–80
3.
BarlowD. H.MavissakalianM. (1981) Directions in the assessment and treatment of phobia: The next decade, in Phobia, Psychological and Pharmacological Treatments, Guildford Press, pp. 199–245
4.
BackA. T.RushA. J. (1975) A cognitive model of anxiety formation and anxiety resolution, in SarasonI. G.SpielbergerC. D. (eds), Stress and Anxiety, Vol. 2, John Wiley and Son
5.
ClarkeC.JacksonJ. A. (1983) Hypnosis and Behaviour Therapy, Springer
6.
CooperJ. E.GelderM. G.MarksI. M. (1965) Results of behaviour therapy in 77 psychiatric patientsBritish Medical Journal1, 1222–5
7.
CoryellW.NoyesR.ClancyJ. (1982) Excess mortality in panic disorder. A comparison with primary unipolar depressionArchives of General Psychiatry39, 701–3
8.
EmmelkampP. M. G.MerschP. P. (1982) Cognition and exposure in vivo in the treatment of agoraphobia. Short term and delayed effectsCognitive Therapy and Research6, 77–88
9.
EmmelkampP. M. G.WesselsH. (1975) Flooding in imagination v. flooding in vivo: A comparison with agoraphobicsBehaviour Research and Therapy13, 7–15
10.
EmmelkampP. M. G.KuipersA. C. M.EggerettJ. B. (1978) Cognitive modification versus prolonged exposure in vivo: a comparison with agoraphobics as subjectsBehaviour Research and Therapy16, 35–41
11.
EvansL.BestJ.MooreG. (1980) Zimelidine — a serotonin uptake blocker in the treatment of phobic anxietyProgress in Neuropharmacology4, 75–9
12.
EyH.BernardB.BrissetC. (1974) Manuel de Psychiatrie, Masson, Paris
13.
FenichelO. (1945) The Psychoanalytic Theory of the Neuroses, W. W. Norton & Co., New York
14.
FreidmanP.GoldsteinJ. (1974) Phobic reactions, in ArietiS.BrodieE. G. (eds), American Handbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn, New YorkBasic Books
15.
FreudS. (1919) Turnings in the ways of psychoanalytic therapy, reprinted as chapter 34 in Collected Papers, Vol. 2, Hogarth Press, London, 1974
16.
GelderM. G.MarksI. M. (1966) Severe agoraphobia: A controlled prospective trial of behaviour therapyBritish Journal of Psychiatry112, 309–19
17.
GelderM. G.MarksI. M. (1968) Desensitisation and phobias: a crossover studyBritish Journal of Psychiatry114, 323–8
18.
GelderM. G.MarksI. M.WolffH. H. (1967) Desensitisation and psychotherapy in the treatment of phobic states. A controlled enquiryBritish Journal of Psychiatry113, 53–73
19.
GelderM. G.BancroftJ. H. J.GothD. H. (1973) Specific and non-specific factors in behaviour therapyBritish Journal of Psychiatry123, 445–62
20.
GertzH. D. (1970) The treatment of the phobic and obsessional patients using paradoxical intention, in FranklV. E. (ed.), Psychotherapy and existentialism: Selected papers on logotherapy, Souvenir Press, New York
21.
GhoshA.MarksI. M.CarrA. C. (1984) Controlled study of self-exposure treatment for phobics: preliminary communicationJournal of the Royal Society of Medicine77, 483–7
22.
GlogerS.GrunhausL.BirmacherB.TrandertT. (1981) Treatment of spontaneous panic attacks with chlomipramineAmerican Journal of Psychiatry138, 1215–17
23.
GrunhausL.GlogerS.BirmacherB. (1984) Chlomipramine treatment for panic attacks in patients with mitral valve prolapseJournal of Clinical Psychiatry45, 25–7
24.
Hoehn-SaricR.MerchantA. F.KeyserM. L.SmithV. K. (1981) Effects of Clonidine on anxiety disordersArchives of General Psychiatry38, 1278–82
25.
JacobsenE. (1938) Progressive Relaxation, University of Chicago Press, Chicago
26.
JuddF. K.BurrowsG. D. (1985) Classification of anxiety and phobic disordersAustralian Family Physician14, 865–70
27.
JuddF. K.NormanT. R.BurrowsG. D. (1986) Pharmacological treatment of panic disorderInternational Clinical Psychopharmacology1, 3–16
28.
KleinD. F. (1964) Delineation of two drug-responsive anxiety syndromesPsychopharmacologia5, 397–408
29.
KleinD. F. (1981) Anxiety reconceptualised, in KleinD. F.RabkinJ. G. (eds), Anxiety, New Research and Changing Concepts, Raven Press, New York, pp. 235–62
30.
KleinD. F.FinkM. (1962) Psychiatric reaction patterns to imipramineAmerican Journal of Psychiatry119, 432–8
31.
KleinD.ZitrinC.WoernerM.RossD. (1983) Treatment of phobias II. Behaviour therapy and supportive psychotherapy: are there any specific ingredients?Archives of General Psychiatry40, 139–45
32.
KoczkasS.HolmbergA.WedinL. (1981) A pilot study of the effect of the 5-HT-uptake inhibitor zimelidine on phobic anxietyActa Psychiatrica Scandinavia (Suppl) 63, 328–41
33.
LiebowitzM. R.FyerA. J.McGrathP.KleinD. F. (1981) Clonidine treatment of panic disorderPsychopharmacology Bulletin17, 122–3
34.
LipsedgeJ. S.HattoffJ.HugginsP. (1973) The management of severe agoraphobia. A comparison of iproniazid and systematic desensitisationPsychopharmacologia32, 67–80
35.
MarksI. M.BoulougourisJ.MarsetP. (1971) Flooding versus desensitisation in the treatment of phobic patients: A cross-over studyBritish Journal of Psychiatry119, 353–75
36.
MarksI. M.GelderM. G.EdwardsJ. G. (1968) Hypnosis and desensitisation for phobias: a controlled prospective trialBritish Journal of Psychiatry114, 1263–74
37.
MarksI. M.GrayS.CohenD. (1983) Imipramine and brief therapist-aided exposure in agoraphobics having self-exposure homeworkArchives of General Psychiatry40, 153–62
38.
MathewsA. M.JohnstonD. W.ShawP. M.GelderM. G. (1974) Process variables and the prediction of outcome in behaviour therapyBritish Journal of Psychiatry125, 256–84
39.
MathewsA. M.JohnsonD. W.LancashireM. (1976) Imaginal flooding and exposure to real phobic situations. Treatment outcome with agoraphobic patientsBritish Journal of Psychiatry129, 362–71
40.
MathewsA. M.TeasdaleJ.MunbyM. (1977) A home based treatment programme for agoraphobiaBehaviour Therapy8, 915–24
41.
MavissakalianM.MichelsonL. (1982) Agoraphobia: Behavioural and pharmacological treatments, preliminary outcome, and process findingsPsychopharmacology Bulletin18, 91–103
42.
MavissakalianM.MichelsonL.DealyR. S. (1983) Pharmacological treatment of agoraphobia. Imipramine versus imipramine with programmed practiceBritish Journal of Psychiatry143, 348–55
43.
MountjoyC. Q.RothM.GarsideR. F.LeitchI. M. (1977) A clinical trial of phenelzine in anxiety depressive and phobic neurosesBritish Journal of Psychiatry131, 486–92
44.
NoyesR.AndersonD. J.ClancyJ. (1984) Diazepam and propranolol in panic disorder and agoraphobiaArchives of General Psychiatry41, 287–92
45.
NoyesR.ClancyJ.HoenkP. R.SlymenD. J. (1978) Anxiety neurosis and physical illnessComprehensive Psychiatry19, 407–13
46.
OstL.JerremalmA.JanssonL. (1984) Individual response patterns and the effects of different behavioural methods in the treatment of agoraphobiaBehaviour Research and Therapy22, 697–707
47.
PecknoldJ. C.McClureD. J.AppeltauerL. (1982) Does trytophan potentiate chlomipramine in the treatment of agoraphobic and social phobic patients?British Journal of Psychiatry140, 484–90
48.
QuitkinF. M.RifkinA.KaplanJ. (1972) Phobic anxiety syndrome complicated by drug dependence and addictionArchives of General Psychiatry27, 159–62
49.
RaskinM.PinskerH.PeckeH. V. S.DickmanW. (1982) Panic and generalised anxiety disorderArchives of General Psychiatry39, 687–9
50.
RobinsL. N.HelzerJ. E.WeissmanM. M. (1984) Lifetime prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders in three sitesArchives of General Psychiatry41, 949–58
51.
SargeantW.DallyP. J. (1962) Treatment of anxiety states with antidepressant drugsBritish Medical Journal1, 6–9
52.
SheehanD. V. (1982a) Panic attacks and phobiasNew England Journal of Medicine307, 156–8
53.
SheehanD. V. (1982b) Current views on the treatment of panic and phobic disordersDrug Therapy12, 49–63
54.
SheehanD. V. (1983) The Anxiety Disease, Charles Scribner's Sons, New York
55.
SheehanD. V.SheehanK. H. (1982) The classification of anxiety and hysterical states. Part II. Towards a more heuristic classificationJournal of Clinical Psychopharmacology2, 386–93
56.
SheehanD. V.BallengerJ.JacobsonG. (1980) Treatment of endogenous anxiety with phobic, hysterical and hypochondriacal symptomsArchives of General Psychiatry37, 51–9
57.
SolyomLHesaltineG. F. D.McClureD. J. (1973) Behaviour therapy versus drug therapy in the treatment of phobic neurosesCanadian Psychiatric Association Journal18, 25–31
58.
SolyomC.SolyomL.LaPierreY. (1981) Phenelzine and exposure in the treatment of phobiasBiological Psychiatry16, 239–47
59.
SpitzerR. L.EndicottJ.RobinsE. (1978) Research diagnostic criteria rationale and reliabilityArchives of General Psychiatry35, 773–82
60.
StampflT.LevisD. (1967) Essentials of implosive therapyJournal of Abnormal Psychology72, 496–503
61.
TerhuneW. B. (1949) The phobic syndrome. A study of eighty-six patients with phobic reactionsArchives of Neurology and Psychiatry62, 162–72
62.
TuckerW. I. (1956) Diagnosis and treatment of the phobic reactionAmerican Journal of Psychiatry112, 825–30
63.
TyrerP.CandyJ.KellyD. (1973) Phenelzine in phobic anxiety: a controlled trialPsychological Medicine3, 120–4
64.
YukselS.MarksI.RommE.GhoshA. (1984) Slow versus rapid exposure in-vivo of phobicsBehavioural Psychotherapy12, 249–56
65.
ZitrinC. M.KleinD. F.WoernerM. G. (1978) Behaviour therapy, supportive psychotherapy, imipramine and phobiasArchives of General Psychiatry35, 307–16
66.
ZitrinC. M.KleinD. F.WoernerM. G. (1980) Treatment of agoraphobia with group exposure in vivo and imipramineArchives of General Psychiatry37, 63–72
67.
ZitrinC. M.WoernerM. G.KleinD. F. (1981) Differentiation of panic anxiety from anticipatory anxiety and avoidance behaviour, in KleinD. F.RabkinJ. (eds), Anxiety: New Research and Changing Concepts, Raven Press, New York
68.
ZitrinC. M.KleinD. F.WoernerM. G.RossD. C. (1983) Treatment of phobias. I. Comparison of imipramine hydrochloride and placeboArchives of General Psychiatry40, 125–38