I examine whether the impact of the Great Recession on school district spending, the allocation of resources, and student achievement varied depending on the strength of state’s teachers’ unions. Employing a diff-in-diff-in-diff identification strategy, I find that school districts in states with strong teachers’ unions experienced significantly larger declines in per-pupil expenditures during the economic downtown compared with otherwise similar districts in states with weak teachers’ unions. The larger decline in expenditures in strong union states, however, did not lead to a differential decline in student achievement relative to weak union states.
AndersonK.CowenJ.StrunkK. (2022). The impact of teacher labor market reforms on student achievement: Evidence from Michigan. Education Finance and Policy, 17, 666–692.
2.
BaronJ. (2018). The effect of teachers’ unions on student achievement in the short run: Evidence from Wisconsin’s Act 10. Economics of Education Review, 67(C), 40–57.
3.
BlackD.KolesnikovaN.TaylorL. J. (2014). Why do so few women work in New York (and so many in Minneapolis)? Labor supply of married women across US cities. Journal of Urban Economics, 79, 59–71.
4.
BoydD.LankfordH.LoebS.WyckoffJ. (2005). The draw of home: How teachers’ preferences for proximity disadvantage urban schools. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 24(1), 113–132.
5.
BrunnerE.HymanJ.JuA. (2020). School finance reforms, teachers’ unions, and the allocation of school resources. Review of Economics and Statistics, 102(3), 473–489.
6.
BrunnerE.SquiresT. (2013). The bargaining power of teachers’ unions and the allocation of school resources. Journal of Urban Economics, 76, 15–27.
7.
CandelariaC.ShoresK. (2019). Court-ordered finance reforms in the adequacy era: Heterogeneous causal effects and sensitivity. Education Finance and Policy, 14(1), 31–60.
8.
CardD.PayneA. A. (2002). School finance reform, the distribution of school spending, and the distribution of student test scores. Journal of Public Economics, 83(1), 49–82.
9.
CarruthersC.FiglioD.SassT. (2018). Did tenure reform in Florida affect student test scores. Evidence Speaks Reports, 2(52), 1–14.
10.
ChambersJ. (1977). The impact of collective bargaining for teachers on resource allocation in public school districts. Journal of Urban Economics, 4(3), 324–339.
11.
CowenJ.StrunkK. (2015). The impact of teachers’ unions on educational outcomes: What we know and what we need to learn. Economics of Education Review, 48, 208–223.
12.
EbertsR.StoneJ. (1984). Unions and public schools: The effect of collective bargaining on American education. Lexington Books.
13.
EbertsR.StoneJ. (1986). Teacher unions and the cost of public education. Economic Inquiry, 24(4), 631–643.
14.
EbertsR.StoneJ. (1987). Teacher unions and the productivity of public schools. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 40(3), 354–363.
15.
EvansW.SchwabR.WagnerK. (2019). The Great Recession and public education. Education Finance and Policy, 14(2), 298–326.
16.
FitzpatrickM. D. (2015). How much are public school teachers willing to pay for their retirement benefits?American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 7(4), 165–188.
17.
FrandsenB. (2016). The effects of collective bargaining rights on public employee compensation: Evidence from teachers, firefighters, and police. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 69(1), 84–112.
18.
GoldhaberD.GroutC.HoldenK.BrownN. (2015). Crossing the border? Exploring the cross-state mobility of the teacher workforce. Educational Researcher, 44(8), 421–431.
19.
GordonN. (2004). Do federal grants boost school spending? Evidence from Title I. Journal of Public Economics, 88(9–10), 1771–1792.
20.
HanE.KeefeJ. (2022). Teachers’ unions: Engaging teachers and improving student achievement in states that prohibit collective bargaining. Educational Policy, 36, 407–439. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904820901476
21.
HoxbyC. (1996). How teachers’ unions affect education production. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 111(3), 671–718.
22.
JacksonC. K.JohnsonR.PersicoC. (2016). The effects of school spending on educational and economic outcomes: Evidence from school finance reform. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 131(1), 157–218.
23.
JacksonC. K.RockoffJ.StaigerD. (2014). Teacher effects and teacher related policies. Annual Review of Economics, 6(1), 801–825.
24.
JacksonC. K.WiggerC.XiongH. (2018). Do school spending cuts matter? Evidence from the Great Recession. National Bureau of Economic Research.
25.
JacksonC. K.WiggerC.XiongH. (2021). Do school spending cuts matter? Evidence from the Great Recession. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 13(2), 304–335.
26.
JacobB.RothsteinJ. (2016). The measurement of student ability in modern assessment systems. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 30(3), 85–108.
27.
JorgensenR.MoulC. (2019). Medium-run consequences of Wisconsin’s Act 10: Teacher pay and employment. Advance online publication. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2969077
KimD.KoedelC.NiS.PodgurskyM. (2017). Labor market frictions and production efficiency in public schools. Economics of Education Review, 60, 54–67.
30.
LafortuneJ.RothsteinJ.SchanzenbachD. W. (2018). School finance reform and the distribution of student achievement. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 10(2), 1–26.
31.
LeachmanM.AlbaresN.MastersonK.WallaceM. (2016). Most states have cut school funding, and some continue cutting. Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
32.
LoebS.PageM. (2000). Examining the link between teacher wages and student outcomes: The importance of alternative labor market opportunities and non-pecuniary variation. Review of Economics and Statistics, 82(3), 393–408.
33.
LottJ.KennyL. (2013). State teacher union strength and student achievement. Economics of Education Review, 35(C), 93–103.
34.
LovenheimM. (2009). The effect of teachers’ unions on education production: Evidence from union election certifications in three Midwestern states. Journal of Labor Economics, 27(4), 525–587.
35.
LovenheimM.WillénA. (2019). The long-run effects of teacher collective bargaining. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11(3), 292–324.
36.
LubienskiS.LubienskiC. (2006). School sector and academic achievement: A multilevel analysis of NAEP mathematics data. American Educational Research Journal, 43(4), 651–698.
37.
MariannoB.BrunoP.StrunkK. (2021). The effect of teachers’ union contracts on school district efficiency: Longitudinal evidence from California. SAGE Open, 11(1), 2158244020988684.
38.
MariannoB.StrunkK. (2018). The bad end of the bargain? Revisiting the relationship between collective bargaining agreements and student achievement. Economics of Education Review, 65, 93–106.
39.
RoseH.SonstelieJ. (2010). School board politics, school district size, and the bargaining power of teachers’ unions. Journal of Urban Economics, 67(3), 438–450.
40.
RothJ. (2019). Union reform and teacher turnover: Evidence from Wisconsin’s Act 10. Harvard Kennedy School.
41.
ShoresK.SteinbergM. (2019). Schooling during the Great Recession: Patterns of school spending and student achievement using population data. AERA Open, 5(3), 2332858419877431. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858419877431
42.
StrunkK. (2011). Are teachers’ unions really to blame? Collective bargaining agreements and their relationships with district resource allocation and student performance in California. Education Finance and Policy, 6(3), 354–298.
43.
StrunkK.BarrettN.LincoveJ. A. (2017). When tenure ends: The short-run effects of the elimination of Louisiana’s teacher employment protections on teacher exit and retirement. Education Research Alliance for New Orleans.
44.
StrunkK.MariannoB. (2019). Negotiating the Great Recession: How teacher collective bargaining outcomes change in times of financial duress. AERA Open, 5(2), 2332858419855089.
45.
StrunkK.ReardonS. (2010). Measuring the strength of teachers’ unions: An empirical application of the partial independence item response approach. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 35(6), 629–670.
46.
SwainW.ReddingC. (2022). Teachers’ union power in a budget crunch: Lasting ramifications of differential spending responses to the Great Recession. Education Policy, 36, 343–376. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904819881161
47.
WinklerA.ScullJ.ZeehandelaarD. (2012). How strong are US teacher unions? A state-by-state comparison. Thomas B. Fordham Institute.
48.
YaganD. (2019). Employment hysteresis from the Great Recession. Journal of Political Economy, 127(5), 2505–2558.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
