We evaluate the effects of grade retention on students’ academic, attendance, and disciplinary outcomes in Indiana. Using a regression discontinuity design, we show that third-grade retention increases achievement in English Language Arts (ELA) and math immediately and substantially, and the effects persist into middle school. We find no evidence of grade retention effects on student attendance or disciplinary incidents, again into middle school. Our findings combine to show that Indiana’s third-grade retention policy improves achievement for retained students without adverse impacts along (measured) nonacademic dimensions.
AllenC. S.ChenQ.WillsonV. L.HughesJ. N. (2009). Quality of research design moderates effects of grade retention on achievement: A meta-analytic, multilevel analysis. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 31(4), 480–499.
2.
AndersonG. E.JimersonS. R.WhippleA. D. (2005). Student ratings of stressful experiences at home and school: Loss of a parent and grade retention as superlative stressors. Journal of Applied School Psychology, 21(1), 1–20.
3.
AppersonJ.BuenoC.SassT. (2016). Do the cheated ever prosper? The long-run effects of test-score manipulation by teachers on student outcomes [Calder working paper no. 155]. Calder Publishing.
4.
BallouD. (2009). Test scaling and value-added measurement. Education Finance and Policy, 4(4), 351–383.
5.
BosA. E.PryorJ. B.ReederG. D.StutterheimS. E. (2013). Stigma: Advances in theory and research. Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 35(1), 1–9.
6.
CalonicoS.CattaneoM. D.FarrellM. H. (2020). Optimal bandwidth choice for robust bias-corrected inference in regression discontinuity designs. The Econometrics Journal, 23(2), 192–210.
7.
CattaneoM. D.JanssonM.MaX. (2018). Manipulation testing based on density discontinuity. The Stata Journal, 18(1), 234–261.
8.
ChaplinD. D.CookT. D.ZurovacJ.CoopersmithJ. S.FinucaneM. M.VollmerL. N.MorrisR. E. (2018). The internal and external validity of the regression discontinuity design: A meta-analysis of 15 within-study comparisons. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 37(2), 403–429.
9.
CrnicK.LambertyG. (1994). Reconsidering school readiness: Conceptual and applied perspectives. Early Education and Development, 5(2), 91–105.
10.
DiazJ.GrauN.ReyesT.RiveraJ. (2021). The impact of grade retention on juvenile crime. Economics of Education Review, 84, 1–16.
11.
EcclesJ. S.MidgleyC.WigfieldA.BuchananC. M.ReumanD.FlanaganC.Mac IverD. (1997). Development during adolescence: The impact of stage–environment fit on young adolescents’ experiences in schools and in families (1993). In NottermanJ. M. (Ed.), The evolution of psychology: Fifty years of the American Psychologist (pp. 475–501). American Psychological Association.
12.
ErenO.DepewB.BarnesS. (2017). Test-based promotion policies, dropping out, and juvenile crime. Journal of Public Economics, 153, 9–31.
13.
ErenO.LovenheimM. F.MocanH. N. (2022). The effect of grade retention on adult crime: Evidence from a test-based promotion policy. Journal of Labor Economics, 40(2), 361–395.
14.
FerrerE.ShaywitzB. A.HolahanJ. M.MarchioneK. E.MichaelsR.ShaywitzS. E. (2015). Achievement gap in reading is present as early as first grade and persists through adolescence. The Journal of Pediatrics, 167(5), 1121–1125.
15.
FiglioD. N. (2007). Boys named Sue: Disruptive children and their peers. Education Finance and Policy, 2(4), 376–394.
16.
GottfriedM. A. (2014). Chronic absenteeism and its effects on students’ academic and socioemotional outcomes. Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk, 19(2), 53–75.
17.
GreeneJ. P.WintersM. A. (2007). Revisiting grade retention: An evaluation of Florida’s test-based promotion policy. Education Finance and Policy, 2(4), 319–340.
18.
HahnJ.HausmanJ. (2005). Estimation with valid and invalid instruments. Annales d’Economie et de Statistique, 79–80, 25–57.
19.
HernandezD. J. (2011). Double jeopardy: How third-grade reading skills and poverty influence high school graduation. Annie E. Casey Foundation.
20.
HongG.RaudenbushS. W. (2005). Effects of kindergarten retention policy on children’s cognitive growth in reading and mathematics. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 27(3), 205–224.
21.
HongG.YuB. (2007). Early-grade retention and children’s reading and math learning in elementary years. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 29(4), 239–261.
22.
HwangN. (2018). Suspensions and achievement: Varying links by type, frequency, and subgroup. Educational Researcher, 47(6), 363–374.
23.
HwangN.PennerE. K.DavisonM.SanabriaT.HanselmanP.DominaT.PennerA. M. (2022). Reining in punitive discipline: Recent trends in exclusionary school discipline disparities. Socius, 8, Article 23780231221103044.
JacobB. A.LefgrenL. (2004). Remedial education and student achievement: A regression-discontinuity analysis. Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(1), 226–244.
26.
JacobB. A.LefgrenL. (2009). The effect of grade retention on high school completion. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 1(3), 33–58.
27.
JacobB. A.LevittS. D. (2003). Rotten apples: An investigation of the prevalence and predictors of teacher cheating. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(3), 843–877.
28.
KretschmannJ.VockM.LüdtkeO.JansenM.GronostajA. (2019). Effects of grade retention on students’ motivation: A longitudinal study over 3 years of secondary school. Journal of Educational Psychology, 111(8), 1432–1446.
29.
LeeD. S.LemieuxT. (2010). Regression discontinuity designs in economics. Journal of Economic Literature, 48(2), 281–355.
30.
ManacordaM. (2012). The cost of grade retention. Review of Economics and Statistics, 94(2), 596–606.
31.
MartorellP.MarianoL. T. (2018). The causal effects of grade retention on behavioral outcomes. Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 11(2), 192–216.
MonahanK. C.VanDerheiS.BechtoldJ.CauffmanE. (2014). From the school yard to the squad car: School discipline, truancy, and arrest. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 43(7), 1110–1122.
34.
OuS. R.ReynoldsA. J. (2010). Grade retention, postsecondary education, and public aid receipt. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 32(1), 118–139.
35.
ÖzekU. (2015). Hold back to move forward? Early grade retention and student misbehavior. Education Finance and Policy, 10(3), 350–377.
36.
Raffaele MendezL. M. (2003). Predictors of suspension and negative school outcomes: A longitudinal investigation. New Directions for Youth Development, 2003(99), 17–33.
37.
RoderickM.NagaokaJ. (2005). Retention under Chicago’s high-stakes testing program: Helpful, harmful, or harmless?Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 27(4), 309–340.
38.
SchwerdtG.WestM. R.WintersM. A. (2017). The effects of test-based retention on student outcomes over time: Regression discontinuity evidence from Florida. Journal of Public Economics, 152, 154–169.
39.
Van CanegemT.Van HoutteM.DemanetJ. (2022). Grade retention: A pathway to solitude? A cross-national multilevel analysis of the effects of being retained on students’ sense of belonging. Comparative Education Review, 66(4), 664–687.
40.
WintersM. A.GreeneJ. P. (2012). The medium-run effects of Florida’s test-based promotion policy. Education Finance and Policy, 7(3), 305–330.
41.
WuW.WestS. G.HughesJ. N. (2010). Effect of grade retention in first grade on psychosocial outcomes. Journal of Educational Psychology, 102(1), 135–152.
