In this critical, political discourse analysis, we trace how two concepts, equity and quality, became discursively linked and contested in the administration of postsecondary education policy over time (1968–1994)—a developmental process we refer to as (e)quality politics. By engaging in a historical analysis, we investigate (a) the racialized political origins and discursive processes by which arguments over educational “quality” are advanced as part of an antiequity policy paradigm and (b) how this paradigm reinscribes racial inequity into administrative and organizational action over time. We illustrate how, once an (e)quality politics paradigm is established, racialized policy designs can persist, even in the absence of explicit references to racialized social constructions of target populations in later periods of policy development.
AgnewS. (1971). “Threat to educational standards,” speech at Republican fundraising dinner, Des Moines, Iowa, April 14, 1970. In WallersteinI. M.StarrP. (Eds.), The university crisis reader: The liberal university under attack (p. 320). Vintage Books.
2.
AldrichH. E.FiolC. M. (1994). Fools rush in? The institutional context of industry creation. The Academy of Management Review, 19(4), 645–670.
3.
AlonS.TiendaM. (2007). Diversity, opportunity, and the shifting meritocracy in higher education. American Sociological Review, 72(4), 487–511.
4.
AuW. (2016). Meritocracy 2.0: High-stakes, standardized testing as a racial project of neoliberal multiculturalism. Educational Policy, 30(1), 39–62.
5.
AugoustinosM.TuffinK.EveryD. (2005). New racism, meritocracy and individualism: Constraining affirmative action in education. Discourse & Society, 3(16), 315–340.
6.
BakerD. J. (2019). Pathways to racial equity in higher education: Modeling the antecedents of state affirmative action bans. American Educational Research Journal, 56(5), 1861–1895.
7.
BeatonA. M.TougasF. (2001). Reactions to affirmative action: Group membership and social justice. Social Justice Research, 14(1), 61–78.
8.
BellD. A. (1991). Racial realism. Connecticut Law Review, 24(2), 363–380.
9.
BellD. A. (1980). Brown v. Board of Education and the interest-convergence dilemma. Harvard Law Review, 93(3), 518–533.
10.
BellE. (2019). Free college for whom? How policy design and public management shape program access and success. [Doctoral dissertation, The University of Oklahoma].
11.
BellE. (2020). The politics of designing tuition-free college: How socially constructed target populations influence policy support. The Journal of Higher Education, 91(6), 888–926. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2019.1706015
12.
BennettW. J. (1984). To reclaim a legacy: A report on the humanities in higher education. National Endowment for the Humanities. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED247880
13.
BennettW. J. (1988, February4). Address before the National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities.
14.
BergerP. L.LuckmannT. (1991). The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge. Penguin Books.
15.
BergerP. L.LuckmannT. (1966). The social construction of reality. Anchor Books.
16.
BillinghamC. M.KimelbergS. M.FaudeS.HuntM. O. (2020). In search of a safe school: Racialized perceptions of security and the school choice process. The Sociological Quarterly, 61(3), 474–499.
17.
Bonilla-SilvaE. (2013). Racism without racists: Color-blind racism and the persistence of racial inequality in America (4th ed.). Rowman & Littlefield.
18.
BronfenbrennerU. (1967). The psychological costs of quality and equality in education. Child Development, 38(4), 909–925.
19.
Brown v. Board of Education (1954), 347 U.S. 483.
20.
ChristianM.SeamsterL.RayV. (2021). Critical race theory and empirical sociology. American Behavioral Scientist, 65(8), 1019–1026. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219859646
21.
ClarkeM. (2014). The sublime objects of education policy: Quality, equity and ideology. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 35(4), 584–598.
22.
ClemensE. S.CookJ. M. (1999). Politics and institutionalism: Explaining durability and change. Annual Review of Sociology, 25(1), 441–466.
23.
Cochran-SmithM.FriesK. (2011). Teacher education for diversity. In BallA. F.TysonC. A. (Eds.), Studying diversity in teacher education (pp. 339–361). Rowman & Littlefield.
24.
ColyvasJ. A. (2007). From divergent meanings to common practices: The early institutionalization of technology transfer in the life sciences at Stanford University. Research Policy, 36(4), 456–476.
25.
ColyvasJ. A.PowellW. W. (2006). Roads to institutionalization: The remaking of boundaries between public and private science. Research in Organizational Behavior, 27, 305–353.
26.
Congressional Research Service. (1985). Reauthorization of the Higher Education Act: Program descriptions, issues, and options. https://archive.org/details/ERIC_ED260608
27.
CopelandK. D.MamiseishviliK. (2017). The Arkansas lottery scholarship act: An examination of the policy design process. Educational Policy, 31(1), 108–136.
28.
CorcoranS. P.Baker-SmithC. (2018). Pathways to an elite education: Application, admission, and matriculation to New York City’s specialized high schools. Education Finance and Policy, 13(2), 256–279.
29.
CreswellJ. W. (2018). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. Sage.
30.
CucchiaraM. (2013). Are we doing damage? Choosing an urban public school in an era of parental anxiety. Anthropology & Education Quarterly, 44(1), 75–93.
31.
Darling-HammondL. (2007). Third annual Brown lecture in education research—The flat earth and education: How America’s commitment to equity will determine our future. Educational Researcher, 36(6), 318–334.
32.
DelgadoR.StefancicJ.HarrisA. (2012). Critical race theory: An introduction (2nd ed.). New York University Press.
33.
Department of Labor and Health, Education, and Welfare appropriations for 1974: Hearings before House Subcommittee on Departments of Labor and Health, Education, and Welfare Appropriations, Committee on Appropriations, H.R., 93rd Cong. (1974) (testimony of Sidney P. Marland, Jr.).
34.
Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and related agencies appropriations for Fiscal Year 1983: Hearings before Subcommittee of the Senate Committee on Appropriations, Sen., 98th Cong. (1982) (testimony of Albert Manley).
35.
Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and related agencies appropriations for 1991: Hearings before Subcommittee of the House Committee on Appropriations, H.R., 101st Cong. (1990).
36.
DiamondJ. B. (2018). Race and white supremacy in the sociology of education: Shifting the intellectual gaze. In MehtaJ.DaviesS. (Eds.), Education in a new society: Renewing the sociology of education (pp. 345–362). University of Chicago Press.
37.
EdgertonR. (1973). Viewpoint: Washington’s new reform fund. Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning, 5(1), 13–14.
38.
EmirbayerM.DesmondM. (2015). The racial order. University of Chicago Press.
39.
EnosR. D. (2016). What the demolition of public housing teaches us about the impact of racial threat on political behavior. American Journal of Political Science, 60(1), 123–142.
40.
EspelandW.YungV. (2019). Ethical dimensions of quantification. Social Science Information, 58(2), 238–260.
FinnC. E. (1972). The national foundation for higher education: Death of an idea. The Magazine of Higher Learning, 4(2), 22–31.
45.
FreidusA. (2022). Segregation, diversity, and pathology: School quality and student demographics in gentrifying New York. Educational Policy, 36(4), 822–848.
46.
FreidusA.EwingE. L. (2022). Good schools, bad schools: Race, school quality, and neoliberal educational policy. Educational Policy, 36(4), 763–768.
47.
FulcherG. (1989). Disabling policies? A comparative approach to education policy and disability. Routledge.
48.
The Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education. (1975). Program information and application procedures, national project ii alternatives to the revolving door: Effective learning for low-achieving students. Department of Education.
49.
The Fund for the Improvement of Postsecondary Education. (1992). Comprehensive program information and application procedures. Department of Education.
50.
GándaraD. (2019). Does evidence matter? An analysis of evidence use in performance-funding policy design. The Review of Higher Education, 42(3), 991–1022.
51.
GándaraD. (2020). How the sausage is made: An examination of a state funding model design process. The Journal of Higher Education, 91(2), 192–221.
52.
GándaraD.AcevedoR.CervantesD.QuirozM. A. (2023). Advancing a framework of racialized administrative burdens in Higher Education Policy [EdWorkingPaper No. 23-697]. Annenberg Institute for School Reform at Brown University.
53.
GándaraD.JonesS. (2020). Who deserves benefits in higher education? A policy discourse analysis of a process surrounding reauthorization of the higher education act. The Review of Higher Education, 44(1), 121–157.
54.
GarciaN. M.LópezN.VélezV. N. (2018). QuantCrit: Rectifying quantitative methods through critical race theory. Race Ethnicity and Education, 21(2), 149–157.
55.
GarrowE. E. (2014). Does race matter in government funding of nonprofit human service organizations? The interaction of neighborhood poverty and race. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 24(2), 381–405.
56.
GeeJ. P. (1999). An introduction to discourse analysis: Theory and method. Routledge.
57.
GillbornD.WarmingtonP.DemackS. (2018). QuantCrit: Education, policy, “big data” and principles for a critical race theory of statistics. Race Ethnicity and Education, 21(2), 158–179.
58.
GoyetteK. A.FarrieD.FreelyJ. (2012). This school’s gone downhill: Racial change and perceived school quality among whites. Social Problems, 59(2), 155–176.
59.
GreenT. L.GermainE.CastroA. J.Latham SikesC.SanchezJ.HorneJ. (2022). Gentrifying Neighborhoods, Gentrifying Schools? An emerging typology of school changes in a gentrifying urban school district. Urban Education, 57(1), 3–31.
60.
Guzman-AlvarezA.PageL. C. (2021). Disproportionate burden: Estimating the cost of FAFSA verification for public colleges and universities. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 43(3), 545–551.
61.
HagoodL. P. (2019). The financial benefits and burdens of performance funding in higher education. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 41(2), 189–213.
62.
HaileyC. A. (2022). Racialized perceptions of anticipated school belonging. Educational Policy, 36(4), 879–910.
63.
Haney-LópezI. (2014). Dog whistle politics: How coded racial appeals have reinvented racism and wrecked the middle class. Oxford University Press.
64.
HarperS. R. (2012). Race without racism: How higher education researchers minimize racist institutional norms. The Review of Higher Education, 36(1), 9–29.
65.
HernándezL. E. (2022). The importance of being “woke”: Charter management organizations and the growth of social consciousness as a school quality marker. Educational Policy, 36(4), 796–821.
66.
Higher education amendments of 1969, part 1: Hearing before the U.S. House Special Subcommittee on Education of the Committee on Education and Labor. 91st Cong. (1970) (testimony of Paul Smith).
67.
HilalM. (2014). Too damn Muslim to be trusted: The war on terror and the Muslim American response [Doctoral dissertation, American University].
68.
HirshbergD. (2002). Race, ideology and the social construction of target populations: A new perspective on education policymaking. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED468289
69.
HowarthD. R.NorvalA. J.StavrakakisY. (Eds.) (2000). Discourse theory and political analysis: Identities, hegemonies and social change. Manchester University Press.
70.
HyattD. (2013a). The critical higher education policy discourse analysis framework. Theory and Method in Higher Education Research, 9, 41–59.
71.
HyattD. (2013b). The critical policy discourse analysis frame: Helping doctoral students engage with the educational policy analysis. Teaching in Higher Education, 18(8), 833–845.
72.
JabbarH.DaramolaE. J.MarshJ. A.Enoch-StevensT.AlonsoJ.AllbrightT. N. (2022). Social construction is racial construction: Examining the target populations in school-choice policies. American Journal of Education, 128(3), 487–518.
73.
JacksonC. K. (2009). Student demographics, teacher sorting, and teacher quality: Evidence from the end of school desegregation. Journal of Labor Economics, 27(2), 213–256. https://doi.org/10.1086/599334
74.
JencksC.BrownM. (1975). The effects of desegregation on student achievement: Some new evidence from the equality of educational opportunity survey. Sociology of Education, 48(1), 126–140. https://doi.org/10.2307/2112054
75.
JeppersonR. (1991). Institutions, institutional effects, and institutionalism. In PowellW. W.DiMaggioP. J. (Eds.), The new institutionalism in organizational analysis (pp. 143–163). University of Chicago Press.
76.
KingD. S.SmithR. M. (2011). Still a house divided: Race and politics in Obama’s America. Princeton University Press.
77.
KlinknerP. A.SmithR. M. (2002). The unsteady March: The rise and decline of racial equality in America. University of Chicago Press.
78.
KnoesterM.AuW. (2017). Standardized testing and school segregation: Like tinder for fire?Race Ethnicity and Education, 20(1), 1–14.
79.
LewisA. E.DiamondJ. B. (2015). Despite the best intentions: How racial inequality thrives in good schools. Oxford University Press.
80.
LieraR. (2020). Equity advocates using equity-mindedness to interrupt faculty hiring’s racial structure. Teachers College Record, 9(122), 1–42.
81.
LieraR.ChingC. (2019). Reconceptualizing “merit” and “fit”: An equity-minded approach to hiring. In KezarA.PosseltJ. (Eds.), Higher education administration for social justice and equity (pp. 111–131). Routledge.
82.
LieraR.HernandezT. E. (2021). Color-evasive racism in the final stage of faculty searches: Examining search committee hiring practices that jeopardize racial equity policy. The Review of Higher Education, 45(2), 181–209.
83.
MasseyD. S.DentonN. A. (1993). Segregation and the making of the underclass. The Urban Sociology Reader, 96(2), 191–201.
84.
MaxwellJ. A. (2012). Qualitative research design: An interactive approach. Sage.
85.
McCamblyH.ColyvasJ. A. (2022). Institutionalizing inequality anew: Grantmaking and racialized postsecondary organizations. Review of Higher Education, 46(1), 67–107.
86.
McCamblyH.MulroyQ. (2022). The rise of (e)quality politics: The political development of higher education policy, 1969–1999 [EdWorkingPapers.com]. Annenberg Institute at Brown University.
87.
McDermottK. A. (2007). “Expanding the moral community” or “blaming the victim”? The politics of state education accountability policy. American Educational Research Journal, 44(1), 77–111.
88.
McNettI. (1973). The federals as reformers. Change: The Magazine of Higher Education, 5(1), 12–61.
89.
MorrisonJ. E. (1993). Colorblindness, individuality, and merit: An analysis of the rhetoric against affirmative action. Iowa Law Review, 79(2), 313–366.
90.
MoynihanD. P. (1975). The politics of higher education. Daedalus, 104(1), 128–147.
91.
NewmanF.CannonW.CavellS.CohenA.EdgertonR.GibbonsJ.KramerM.RhodesJ.SingletonR. (1971). Report on higher education. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.
92.
NixonR. M. (1975). Public papers of the presidents of the United States: Richard Nixon: Containing the public messages speeches and statements of the president. U.S. Government Publishing Office.
93.
O’DayJ. A.SmithM. S. (2016). Quality and equality in American education: Systemic problems, systemic solutions. In KirschA.BraunH. (Eds.), The dynamics of opportunity in America (pp. 297–358). Springer.
94.
OrfieldG.JarvieD. (2020). Unequal public schools makes affirmative action essential for equal opportunity. UCLA: The Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles.
95.
PatashnikE. M. (2022). Backlash politics in America’s disunited and polarized state. Studies in American Political Development, 36(2), 151–155.
96.
PierceJ. J.SiddikiS.JonesM. D.SchumacherK.PattisonA.PetersonH. (2014). Social construction and policy design: A review of past applications. Policy Studies Journal, 42(1), 1–29. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12040
97.
PoonO.LeeD. H.GalvezE.Song EnglerJ.SérránoB.RazaA.HurtadoJ. M.ChunN. K. (2023). A Möbius model of racialized organizations: Durability of racial inequalities in admissions. The Journal of Higher Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2023.2203630
98.
PoonO. A.SegoshiM. S.TangL.SurlaK. L.NguyenC.SquireD. D. (2019). Asian Americans, affirmative action, and the political economy of racism: A multidimensional model of raceclass frames. Harvard Educational Review, 89(2), 201–226.
99.
Posey-MaddoxL.McDonough KimelbergS.CucchiaraM. (2014). Middle-class parents and urban public schools: Current research and future directions. Sociology Compass, 8(4), 446–456.
100.
PosseltJ. R. (2014). Toward inclusive excellence in graduate education: Constructing merit and diversity in PhD admissions. American Journal of Education, 4(120), 481–514.
101.
PosseltJ. R.ReyesK. A.SlayK. E.KamimuraA.PorterK. B. (2017). Equity efforts as boundary work: How symbolic and social boundaries shape access and inclusion in graduate education. Teachers College Record, 119(10), 1–38.
102.
Quality in higher education: Hearings before Senate Subcommittee on Education, Arts, and the Humanities, Committee on Labor and Education, Sen., 99th Cong. (1986).
103.
RayV. (2019). A theory of racialized organizations. American Sociological Review, 84(1), 26–53.
104.
RayV.HerdP.MoynihanD. (2023). Racialized burdens: Applying racialized organization theory to the administrative state. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 33(1), 139–152. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muac001
105.
RayV.PurifoyD. (2019). The colorblind organization. In WootenM. E. (Ed.), Race, organizations, and the organizing process (Vol. 60, pp. 131–150). Emerald Publishing.
106.
Reauthorization of the higher education act and related measures: Hearings before House Subcommittee on Postsecondary Education, Committee on Education and Labor, H.R., 96th Cong. (1979).
107.
Reauthorization of the higher education act vol. 8: Hearings before House Subcommittee on Postsecondary Education, Committee on Education and Labor, H.R., 99th Cong. (1985).
108.
ReberS. J. (2010). School desegregation and educational attainment for Blacks. Journal of Human Resources, 45(4), 893–914.
109.
ReichG.BarthJ. (2010). Educating citizens or defying federal authority? A comparative study of in-state tuition for undocumented students. Policy Studies Journal, 38(3), 419–445.
110.
RossingerK. O.Sarita FordK.ChoiJ. (2021). The role of selective college admissions criteria in interrupting or reproducing racial and economic inequities. The Journal of Higher Education, 92(1), 31–55.
111.
RothsteinR. (2017). The color of law: A forgotten history of how our government segregated America. Liveright Publishing.
112.
Sattin-BajajC.RodaA. (2020). Opportunity hoarding in school choice contexts: The role of policy design in promoting middle-class parents’ exclusionary behaviors. Educational Policy, 34(7), 992–1035.
113.
SchneibergM. (1999). Political and institutional conditions for governance by association: Private order and price controls in American fire insurance. Politics and Society, 27(1), 66–102.
114.
SchneibergM.ClemensE. (2006). The typical tools for the job: Research strategies in institutional analysis. Sociological Theory, 24(3), 195–227.
115.
SchneiderA.IngramH. (1993). Social construction of target populations: Implications for politics and policy. American Political Science Review, 87(2), 334–347.
116.
SchneiderA.IngramH. (2019). Social constructions, anticipatory feedback strategies, and deceptive public policy. Policy Studies Journal, 47(2), 206–236.
117.
SchneiderJ. (2011). Excellence for all: How a new breed of reformers is transforming America’s public schools. Vanderbilt University Press.
118.
SchramS. F.SossJ.FordingR. C.HouserL. (2009). Deciding to discipline: Race, choice, and punishment at the frontlines of welfare reform. American Sociological Review, 74(3), 398–422.
119.
SensoyO.DiAngeloR. (2017). Is everyone really equal? An introduction to key concepts in social justice education. Teachers College Press.
120.
SettlesI. H.JonesM. K.BuchananN. T.BrasselS. T. (2022). Epistemic exclusion of women faculty and faculty of color: Understanding Scholar(ly) devaluation as a predictor of turnover intentions. The Journal of Higher Education, 93(1), 31–55.
121.
ShawJ. (2009). The diversity paradox: EDs student diversity enhance or challenge excellence?Journal of Further and Higher Education, 33(4), 321–331.
122.
SeamsterL.HenricksK. (2015). A second redemption? Racism, backlash politics, and public education. Humanity & Society, 39(4), 363–375.
123.
SidneyM. S. (2005). Contested images of race and place: The politics of housing discrimination. In SchneiderA. L.IngramH. M. (Eds.), Deserving and entitled: Social constructions and public policy (pp. 111–137). State University of New York Press.
124.
SossJ. (1999). Lessons of welfare: Policy design, political learning, and political action. American Political Science Review, 93(2), 363–380.
125.
SossJ.FordingR. C.SchramS. F. (2008). The color of devolution: Race, federalism, and the politics of social control. American Journal of Political Science, 52(3), 536–553.
126.
SteenslandB. (2008). Why do policy frames change? Actor-idea coevolution in debates over welfare reform. Social Forces, 86(3), 1027–1054.
127.
SuléV. T.Winkle-WagnerR.MarambaD. C. (2017). Who deserves a seat? Colorblind public opinion of college admissions policy. Equity & Excellence in Education, 50(2), 196–208.
128.
SuspitsynaT. (2012). Higher education for economic advancement and engaged citizenship: An analysis of the U.S. Department of Education discourse. The Journal of Higher Education, 83(1), 49–72.
129.
SyeedE. (2022). The space beyond equity: A blueprint of radical possibilities in school design. Educational Policy, 36(4), 769–795.
130.
ThornhillT. (2019). We want black students, just not you: How white admissions counselors screen Black prospective students. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity, 5(4), 456–470.
131.
TrounstineJ. (2018). Segregation by design: Local politics and inequality in American cities. Cambridge University Press.
VentrescaM. J.MohrJ. W. (2017). Archival research methods. In BaumJ. A. C. (Ed.), The Blackwell companion to organizations (pp. 805–828). John Wiley & Sons.
134.
WarikooN. K. (2016). The diversity bargain: And other dilemmas of race, admissions, and meritocracy at elite universities. University of Chicago Press.
135.
WeaverV. M. (2007). Frontlash: Race and the development of punitive crime policy. Studies in American Political Development, 21(2), 230–265.
136.
WeinbergM. (1975). A relationship between school desegregation and academic achievement: A review of the research the courts, social science, and school desegregation. Law and Contemporary Problems, 39(2), 241–270.
137.
WelchK.PayneA. A. (2010). Racial threat and punitive school discipline. Social Problems, 57(1), 25–48.
138.
WilkinsC. L.KaiserC. R. (2014). Racial progress as threat to the status hierarchy: Implications for perceptions of anti-white bias. Psychological Science, 25(2), 439–446.
