This historiography chronicles educators’ efforts to teach for diversity through heightening awareness of immigrant experiences as well as discrimination against minoritized religious and racial groups in public school classrooms from the 1920s through the 1970s. This curriculum and pedagogical work was couched under various terms, such as intercultural education, intergroup education, human relations, and cultural pluralism. Drawing from published secondary research literature as well as primary archival sources, we aim to disrupt commonly held views that intercultural education/intergroup education met its demise in the 1950s and show how curriculum and pedagogy shifted after the landmark 1954 ruling of Brown v. Board of Education toward improving intergroup relations within the context of school desegregation. In the end we identify common themes across the decades that include the failure to recruit and support a diverse teaching force, the importance of teacher-led curriculum and professional development, and the lack of a sustained focus on race and racism in classroom practices.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsD. (1995). Education for extinction: American Indians and the boarding school experience, 1875–1928. Lawrence: University of Kansas.
2.
AllportG. W. (1945). Is intergroup education possible?Harvard Educational Review, 15(2), 83–76.
3.
American Council on Race Relations. (1948). Directory of agencies in intergroup education. Washington, DC: Author.
4.
BackA. (2003). Exposing the “whole segregation myth”: The Harlem Nine and New York City’s school desegregation battles. In TheoharisJ.WoodardK. (Eds.), Freedom North: Black freedom struggles outside the South, 1940–1980 (pp. 65–91). New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
5.
BanksC. A. M. (2005). Improving multicultural education: Lessons from the Intergroup Education Movement, 1933–1959. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
6.
BellD. (1992). Faces at the bottom of the well: The permanence of racism. New York, NY: Basic Books.
7.
BenedictR.WeltfishG. (1943). The races of mankind. New York, NY: Public Affairs Committee.
8.
BlantonC. K. (2004). The strange career of bilingual education in Texas, 1836–1981. College Station: Texas A&M University Press.
9.
BohanC. H. (2007). A rebellious Jersey girl: Rachel Davis DuBois, intercultural education pioneer. In TottenS.PedersonJ. (Eds.), Addressing social issues in the classroom and beyond: The pedagogical efforts of pioneers in the field (pp. 99–115). Charlotte, NC: Information Age.
10.
BristolT.MentorM. (2018). Policing and teaching: The positioning of Black male teachers as agents in the universal carceral apparatus. The Urban Review, 50, 218. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-018-0447-z
11.
Bureau of Publications. (1951). Cultural groups & human relations: Twelve lectures on educational problems of special cultural groups held at Teachers College, Columbia University, August 18 to September 7, 1949. New York, NY: Teachers College, Columbia University.
12.
BurkholderZ. (2007). Out to debunk the bunk: Antiracist teaching in the 1940s and today. Teachers College Record. Retrieved from http://www.tcrecord.org
13.
BurkholderZ. (2011). Color in the classroom: How American schools taught race, 1900–1954. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
14.
BurkholderZ. (2015). “A war of ideas”: The rise of conservative teachers in wartime New York City, 1938–1946. History of Education Quarterly, 55, 218–243.
15.
California State Department of Education. (1968). Improving ethnic distribution and intergroup relations: An advisory report to the Board of Education, Colton Joint Unified School District. Sacramento, CA: Author.
16.
California State Department of Education. (1971). Intergroup relations and the education of Mexican American children: An advisory report to the Board of Education, Norwalk-La Mirada Unified School District. Sacramento, CA: Author.
17.
CaliguriJ. P. (1970). Suburban interracial education projects: A resource booklet. Kansas City: University of Missouri.
18.
Carter AndrewsD. J.CastroE.ChoC. L.PetchauerE.RichmondG.FlodenR. (2019). Changing the narrative on diversifying the teaching workforce: A look at historical and contemporary factors that inform recruitment and retention of Teachers of Color. Journal of Teacher Education, 70(1), 6–12.
19.
ChattoC. I. (1945). Springfield’s experience with intergroup education. Harvard Educational Review, 15, 99–103.
20.
City-Wide Citizens Committee for Integrated Schools. (1964, March16). [Letter from Rev. Milton Galamison]. Elliot Linzer collection (Box1, Folder 6). New York, NY: Queens College Department of Special Collections and Archives.
21.
ColeS. (n.d.). Transcriptions of Stewart Cole Tapes #1 of 2. New York, NY: Bureau for Intercultural Education.
22.
ColeS. (1948–1949). A guide-sheet for the committee on a teachers’ manual on UNESCO for the schools of California. Pacific Coast Council on Intercultural Education (Stewart Cole). The National Conference of Christians and Jews Collection, Social Welfare History Archives. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.
23.
ColeS. G. (1953). Trends in intergroup education. Religious Education, 48(1), 29–37.
DixonR. J.Van TilW. (1978). Widening cultural horizons: Recommended approaches to intercultural education. Curriculum Bulletin, XXXII, 339.
36.
DossickJ. J. (1952). Fifth workshop: Field study in Puerto Rican education and culture. Journal of Educational Sociology, 26, 177–186.
37.
DuBoisR. D. (1936). Service Bureau for Intercultural Education, classroom materials, CA. 1933–1936. Rachel Davis DuBois Papers, Immigration History Research Center Archives, University of Minnesota.
38.
DuBoisR. D. (1955). Know your neighbors: A handbook for group conversation leaders. New York, NY: Workshop for Cultural Democracy.
39.
DuBoisR. D. (1984). All this and something more: Pioneering in intercultural education. Bryn Mawr, PA: Dorrance.
40.
DudziakM. (2011). Cold war civil rights: Race and the image of American democracy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
41.
EisenbergF. (n.d.). Problem curriculum (subject matter and activity program) has been curtailed, censored, and limited by the present Board of Education. Frances Eisenberg Papers: Communism and LA Schools, Department of Special Collections, Young Research Library, University of California, Los Angeles.
42.
FallaceT. (2018). American educators’ confrontation with fascism. Educational Researcher, 47(1), 46–52.
43.
FassP. (1989). The outside-in book: Minorities and the transformation of American education. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
44.
GarciaD. G. (2018). Strategies of segregation: Race, residence, and the struggle for educational equality. Oakland: University of California Press.
45.
GilbertA. R.SessionsR. P. (1969). Updating intergroup education in public schools: A study-action manual. Buckhannon: West Virginia Wesleyan College.
46.
GilesH. H. (1945). Intergroup education workshops and school problems. Journal of Educational Sociology, 18, 522–525.
47.
GilesH. H.PitkinV. E.IngramT. (1946). Problems of intercultural education. Review of Educational Research, 16(1), 39–45.
48.
GilesH. H.Van TilW. (1946). School and community projects. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 244, 34–41.
49.
GlickI. D.MeinkeD. L. (1972). Assessment of an intervention curriculum unit in intergroup education. Toledo, OH: Toledo University.
50.
GrahamP. A. (1967). Progressive education: From Arcady to academe: A history of the Progressive Education Association, 1919–1953. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
51.
HadleyH. M. (1969, January24). Visiting among European friends by Rachel Davis DuBois—Introducing “Group Conversation” (Quaker Dialogue) [Letter to Margaret S. Gibbins]. Rachel Davis DuBois papers, Box 21, Folder 6, Rachel Davis DuBois Papers, Immigration History Research Center Archives, University of Minnesota.
52.
HagerD. J. (1950). Some observations on the relationship between social science and intergroup education. Journal of Educational Sociology, 23, 278–290.
53.
HagerD. J. (1956). New problems in intercultural education. Journal of Educational Sociology, 30, 162–167.
54.
HallJ. D. (2005). The long civil rights movement and the political uses of the past. Journal of American History, 91, 1233–1263.
HarrisonH. J. (1953). A study of the work of the Coordinating Committee on Democratic Human Relations in the Detroit Public Schools from September, 1943 to June, 1952 (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Wayne State University, Detroit, MI.
57.
HartJ. (2004). Making democracy safe for the world: Race, propaganda, and the transformation of U.S. foreign policy during World War II. Pacific Historical Review, 73, 49–84.
58.
HartR. J. (2016). Battling minds: Conservatives, progressives, and UNESCO in post war United States. In KulnazarovaI.YdesenC. (Eds.), UNESCO without borders: Educational campaigns for international understanding (pp. 35–51). London, England: Routledge.
59.
HartmanA. (2008). Education and the cold war: The battle for the American school. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan.
60.
HinesM. (2017). The blackboard and the color line: Madeline Morgan and the alternative Black curriculum in Chicago’s public schools, 1941–1945 (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Loyola University Chicago, Chicago, IL.
61.
Houston Council on Human Relations. (1972). Black/Mexican-American project report. Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED068592
62.
Intercultural Education Workshop set by Pitt and Council on Intercultural Education. (1955). Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Collections.
63.
JohanekM.PuckettJ. L. (2007). Leonard Covello and the making of Benjamin Franklin High School: Education as if citizenship mattered. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
64.
JohnsonC. S. (1945, November24). [Letter to Miss Laurentine B. Collins]. Detroit Public Schools Community Relations Papers, Wayne State University Archives of Labor History and Urban Affairs and University Archives, Detroit, MI.
65.
JohnsonL. (2002). “Making democracy real”: Teacher union and community activism to promote diversity in the New York City public schools—1935–1950. Urban Education, 37, 566–588.
66.
JohnsonL. (2006). “One community’s total war against prejudice”: The Springfield Plan revisited. Theory & Research in Social Education, 34, 301–323.
67.
JohnsonL. (2017). “Educating for democratic living”: The City-Wide Citizens’ Committee on Harlem (CWCCH), 1941–1947. Historia Social y de la Educacion/Social and Education History, 6, 261–289.
68.
JohnsonL.PakY. (2005, November). “There ain’t no North any more”: Racial conflict and the struggle for intercultural education in Detroit and Los Angeles Schools—1943–1950. Paper presented at the History of Education Society Annual Meeting, Baltimore, MD.
69.
KarierC. J. (1986). The individual, society, and education: A history of American educational ideas (2nd ed.). Urbana-Champaign: University of Illinois Press.
KingM. L.Jr. (1964, December29). [Letter to R. D. DuBois]. Rachel Davis DuBois Papers, Box 34, Folder 1. Immigration History Research Center Archives, University of Minnesota.
74.
KlinebergO. (1945). A scientific basis for intergroup education. Harvard Educational Review, 15, 117–121.
75.
KridelC.BulloughR. V.Jr. (2007). Stories of the eight-year study: Reexamining secondary education in America. Albany: State University of New York Press.
76.
LaatsA. (2015). The other school reformers: Conservative activism in American education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
77.
LalS. (2004). 1930s Multiculturalism: Rachel Davis DuBois and the Bureau for Intercultural Education. Radical Teacher, 69, 18–22.
78.
LaskerB. (1929). Race attitudes in children. New York, NY: Henry Holt.
79.
LawrenceA. (2011). Lessons from an Indian day school: Negotiating colonization in northern New Mexico, 1902–1907. Lawrence: University of Kansas.
80.
Leinster quarterly meeting. (1969, November21). The Friend, p. 1454.
Los Angeles City Schools. (1950). Developing human relations in the elementary school. Los Angeles, CA: Author.
85.
Maryland State Department of Education. (1973). Toward understanding: Human relations in Maryland schools. Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED115640
86.
McWilliamsC. (1961). North from Mexico: The Spanish-speaking people of the United States. New York, NY: Monthly Review Press.
87.
MeadM. (1945). Group living as a part of intergroup education workshops. Journal of Educational Sociology, 18, 526–534.
88.
MeridethD.BurrE. W. (1947). Some problems of evaluation in intergroup education. Journal of Educational Sociology, 21(1), 43–52.
89.
MilnerR. (2017). Where’s the race in culturally relevant pedagogy?Teachers College Record, 119(1), 1–32.
90.
MirelJ. (2010). Patriotic pluralism: American education and European immigrants. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
91.
MontaltoN. (1982). A history of the Intercultural Educational Movement, 1924–1941. New York, NY: Garland.
92.
MoynihanD. (1965). The Negro family: The case for national action. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Labor.
93.
MuftiK. (2018). Revisiting Rachel Davis DuBois’ childhood and young adulthood: Reflections on the linked lives of an intercultural education pioneer. Quaker Studies, 23, 25–46.
94.
MurraW. F. (1945). Reading materials for intergroup education. Harvard Educational Review, 15, 147–155.
95.
MyrdalG. (1944). An American dilemma: The Negro problem and modern democracy. New York, NY: Harper.
96.
NafusC.LavineL. (1972). Calexico intercultural design: Content analysis schedule for bilingual education programs. Washington, DC: Division of Bilingual Education. Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?q=ED080022&id=ED080022
97.
OlneckM. (1989). Americanization and the education of immigrants, 1900–1925: An analysis of symbolic action. American Journal of Education, 97, 398–423.
98.
OlneckM. (1990). The recurring dream: Symbolism and ideology in intercultural and multicultural education. American Journal of Education, 2, 147–174.
99.
PaganE. (2003). Murder at the Sleepy Lagoon: Zoot suits, race, & riot in wartime L. A. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
100.
PakY. (2002). “If there is a better intercultural plan in any school system in America, I do not know where it is”: The San Diego City Schools intercultural education program, 1946–1949. Urban Education, 37, 588–609.
101.
ParisDAlimS. (Eds.). (2017). Culturally sustaining pedagogies: Teaching and learning for justice in a changing world. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
102.
PerezM. (2012). The color of youth: Mexicans and the power of schooling in Chicago, 1917–1939 (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana, IL.
103.
PerilloJ. (2006). White teachers and the Black psyche: Interculturalism and the psychology of race in the New York City high schools, 1940–1950. In BeattyB.CahanE. D.GrantJ. (Eds.), When science encounters the child: Education, parenting, and child welfare in 20th-Century America (pp. 157–174). New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
104.
PitkinV. E. (1947). Survey of intercultural policies of selected school systems. New York, NY: Bureau for Intercultural Education.
105.
Program for Action by Citizens in Education. (1970). A human relations curriculum development project created by the PACE Association. Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED045557
106.
RabinL. (2013). The social uses of classroom cinema: A history of the human relations film series at Benjamin Franklin High School in East Harlem, New York City, 1936–1955. Velvet Light Trap, 72, 58–71.
107.
Race Relations Institute. (1943). A monthly summary of events and trends in race relations. Nashville, TN: Fisk University.
108.
RafteryJ. (1992). Land of fair promise: Politics and reform in Los Angeles schools, 1885–1941. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
109.
SeamansH. L. (1945). 1945 Summer workshops in intergroup education. Journal of Educational Sociology, 18, 569–572.
110.
SeligD. (2008). Americans all: The cultural gifts movement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
111.
SevierB. R. (2008). The project in intergroup education and Sarason’s modal process of change: A historical exemplar of educational reform. Journal of Educational Change, 9, 123–151.
112.
SevierB. R. (2009). Between mutuality and diversity: The Project in Intergroup Education and the discourse of national unity in multicultural texts. Educational Foundations, 23, 21–47.
113.
ShafferR. (1996). Multicultural education in New York City during World War II. New York History, 77, 301–332.
114.
SleeterC. (2016). Wrestling with the problematics of whiteness in teacher education. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 29, 1065–1068.
115.
SnyderE. E. (1962). Social-cultural approach to intergroup education at the secondary school level. Journal of Educational Sociology, 35, 236–239.
116.
SokolJ. (2014). All eyes on us: Race and politics from Boston to Brooklyn: The conflicted soul of the Northeast. New York, NY: Basic Books.
117.
Southwest Intergroup Relations Council. (1970). A bilingual approach: Education for understanding. Austin, TX: Author.
118.
SugrueT. (1996). The origins of the urban crisis: Race and inequality in postwar Detroit. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
119.
Summary of Ninth Annual Convention, Southern Christian Leadership Conference, August9–13, 1965. Rachel Davis DuBois Papers, Box 34, Folder 5, Immigration History Research Center Archives, University of Minnesota.
120.
TabaH. (1947). What is evaluation up to and up against in intergroup education?Journal of Educational Sociology, 21(1), 19–24.
121.
TabaH. (1953). Research oriented programs in intergroup education in schools and colleges. Review of Educational Research, 23, 362–371.
122.
TabaH. (1962). Curriculum development: Theory and practice. New York, NY: Harcourt, Brace, & World.
123.
TabaH.BradyE.RobinsonJ. T. (1952). Intergroup education in public schools. Washington, DC: American Council on Education.
124.
TabaH.WilsonH. E. (1946). Intergroup education through the school curriculum. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 244, 19–25. doi:10.1177/000271624624400104
125.
TamuraE. (1993). Americanization, acculturation, and ethnic identity: The Nisei generation in Hawaii. Urbana: University of Illinois.
126.
TaylorC. (2013). Reds at the blackboard: Communism, civil rights, and the New York City Teachers Union. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
127.
ThomasL. (2010). Puerto Rican citizen: History and political identity in twentieth century New York City. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
128.
Van TilW. (1959). Chapter V: Instructional methods in intercultural and intergroup education. Review of Educational Research, 29, 367–377.
129.
VickeryW. E. (1953). Ten years of intergroup education workshops. Journal of Educational Sociology, 26, 292–302.
130.
VickeryW. E.ColeS. G. (1943). Intercultural education in American schools: Proposed objectives and methods. New York, NY: Harper.
131.
ViragW. F. (1973, November). Integrating the desegregated school: Some observations and suggestions. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the National Council for Social Studies, San Francisco, CA.
132.
WarrenJ. E. (1945). Facing the need for intergroup education. Journal of Educational Sociology, 18, 513–521.
133.
WechslerH. S. (2012). Making a religion of intergroup education: The National Conference of Christians and Jews, 1927–1957. Journal of Ecumenical Studies, 47(1), 3–40.
134.
WoodsonC. G. (1922). The Negro in our history. Washington, DC: Associated Publishers.
135.
WoyshnerC. (2018). “I feel I am really pleading the cause of my own people”: US southern white students’ study of African-American history and culture in the 1930s through art and the senses. History of Education, 47, 190–208. doi:10.1080/0046760X.2017.1420241
136.
WuE. D. (2014). The color of success: Asian Americans and the origins of the model minority. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
137.
YuH. (2001). Thinking Orientals: Migration, contact, and exoticism in modern America. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
138.
ZimmermanJ. (2004). Brown-ing the American textbook: History, psychology, and the origins of modern multiculturalism. History of Education Quarterly, 44, 46–69.
