What is the impact of garden-based learning on academic outcomes in schools? To address this question, findings across 152 articles (1990–2010) were analyzed resulting in 48 studies that met the inclusion criteria for this synthesis. A review template with operational coding framework was developed. The synthesis results showed a preponderance of positive impacts on direct academic outcomes with the highest positive impact for science followed by math and language arts. Indirect academic outcomes were also measured with social development surfacing most frequently and positively. These results were consistent across programs, student samples, and school types and within the disparate research methodologies used. However, a common issue was lack of research rigor as there were troubling issues with incomplete descriptions of methodological procedures in general and sampling techniques and validity in particular. Recommendations for more systematic and rigorous research are provided to parallel the growing garden-based education movement.
*AguilarO. M.WaliczekT. M.ZajicekJ. M. (2008). Growing environmental stewards: The overall effect of a school gardening program on environmental attitudes and environmental locus of control of different demographic groups of elementary school children. HortTechnology, 18, 243–249.
2.
*AlexanderJ.NorthM. W.HendrenD. (1995). Master Gardener classroom garden project: An evaluation of the benefits to children. Children’s Environments, 12, 123–133.
3.
AzumaA. M.FisherA. (2001). Healthy farms, healthy kids: Evaluating the barriers and opportunities for farm-to-school programs. Venice, CA: Community Food Security Coalition.
4.
*BeckmanL. L.SmithC. (2008). An evaluation of inner-city youth garden program participants’ dietary behavior and garden and nutrition knowledge. Journal of Agricultural Education, 49, 11–24. doi:10.5032/jae.2008.04011
5.
BerenguerJ. (2007). The effect of empathy in pro-environmental attitudes and behaviors. Environment and Behavior, 39, 269–283. doi:10.1177/0013916506292937
6.
*BerryhillK. (2005). Stimulating science wonderment and developing scientific knowledge through multi-day field trips and post-field trip follow up (Master’s thesis). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 1448450)
7.
BirchL. (1990). Development of food acceptance patterns. Developmental Psychology, 26, 249-255.
8.
BlairD. (2009). The child in the garden: An evaluative review of the benefits of school gardening. Journal of Environmental Education, 40(2), 15–38. doi:10.3200/JOEE.40.2.15-38
9.
*BowkerR.TearleP. (2007). Gardening as a learning environment: A study of children’s perceptions and understanding of school gardens as part of an international project. Learning Environments Research, 10, 83–100. doi:10.1007/s10984-007-9025-0
10.
BrinkL.YostB. (2004). Transforming inner-city school grounds: Lessons from Learning Landscapes. Children, Youth and Environments, 14, 208–232.
11.
BrodaH. W. (2009). Schoolyard-enhanced learning: Using the outdoors as an instructional tool, K–8. Portland, ME: Stenhouse publishers.
12.
*BrunottsC. M. (1998). School gardening: A multifaceted learning tool. An evaluation of the Pittsburgh Civic Garden Center’s “Neighbors and Schools Gardening Together” (Master’s thesis). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 1392725)
13.
CanarisI. (1995). Growing foods for growing minds: Integrating gardening and nutrition education into the total curriculum. Children’s Environments, 12, 264–270.
14.
*CastagninoL. (2005). Gardens and grade level expectations: The link between environmental education and standardized assessments (Unpublished master’s thesis). Brown University, Providence, RI.
CooperH. M. (Ed.). (1998). Synthesizing research: A guide for literature reviews. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
17.
*Cutter-MackenzieA. (2009). Multicultural school gardens: Creating engaging garden spaces in learning about language, culture, and environment. Canadian Journal of Environmental Education, 14, 122-135.
18.
*DanforthP. (2005). An evaluation of the National Wildlife Foundation’s Schoolyard Habitat Program in the Houston Independent School District (Unpublished master’s thesis). Texas State University, San Marcos, TX.
19.
*DanforthP. E.WaliczekT. M.MaceyS. M.ZajicekJ. M. (2008). The effect of the National Wildlife Federation’s Schoolyard Habitat Program on fourth grade students’ standardized test scores. HortTechnology, 18, 356–360.
20.
DesmondD.GrieshopJ.SubramaniamA. (2002). Revisiting garden based learning in basic education: Philosophical roots, historical foundations, best practices and products, impacts, outcomes and future directions. Paris, France: Food and Agriculture Organization/United Nations International Institute for Educational Planning.
21.
DillonJ.RickinsonM.SandersD.TearneyK.BenefieldP. (2003). Improving the understanding of food, farming and land management amongst school-age children: A literature review. London: National Foundation for Educational Research and King’s College.
22.
*DirksA. E.OrvisK. (2005). An evaluation of the Junior Master Gardener Program in third grade classrooms. HortTechnology, 15, 443–447.
23.
*DriscollE. A. (2004). Fostering wonder and curiosity: Immersion field trips in the Michigan 4-H Children’s Garden (Master’s thesis). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 1422558)
EisenmannJ.GundersenC.LohmanG.GaraskyS.StewartS. (2011). Is food insecurity related to overweight and obesity in children and adolescents? A summary of studies, 1995–2009. Obesity Reviews, 12(5), e73–e83. doi:10.1111/j.1467-789X.2010.00820.x
26.
*FleenerA. W. (2008). The effects of the literature in the garden curriculum on life skills of children (Unpublished master’s thesis). Auburn University, Auburn, AL.
27.
*HarmonA. H. (1999). Food system knowledge, attitudes, and experiences (Doctoral dissertation). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 9960595)
28.
HarrisonK.BostK.McBrideB.DonovanS.Grigsby-ToussaintD.JuheeK.. . . JacobsohnG. (2011). Toward a developmental conceptualization of contributors to overweight and obesity in childhood: The six-Cs model. Child Development Perspectives, 5(1), 50–58. doi:10.1111/j.1750-8606.2010.00150.x
29.
Hayden-SmithR. (2006). Soldiers of the soil: A historical review of the United States school garden army. Davis, CA: University of California, 4-H Center for Youth Development.
30.
HedleyA.OgdenC.JohnsonC.CarrollM.CurtinL.FlegalK. (2004). Prevalence of overweight and obesity among U.S. children, adolescents, and adults. Journal of the American Medical Association, 291, 2847–2850. doi:10.1001/jama.291.23.2847
31.
*HendrenD. K. (1998). Evaluation of master gardeners’ classroom garden project on youth living in low-income, inner-city neighborhoods of San Antonio (Doctoral dissertation). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 9839567)
32.
HoughtonE. (2003). A breath of fresh air: Celebrating nature and school gardens. Toronto, Canada: Sumach Press.
33.
HowellD. A. (Ed.). (2002). Statistical methods for psychology (5th ed.). Belmont, CA: Duxbury/Thomson Learning.
34.
*KarshK.BushE.HinsonJ.BlanchardP. (2009). Integrating horticulture biology and environmental coastal issues into the middle school science curriculum. HortTechnology, 19, 813–817.
35.
KlemmerC. D.WaliczekT. M.ZajicekJ. M. (2005a). Development of a science achievement evaluation instrument for a school garden program. HortTechnology, 15, 433–438.
36.
*KlemmerC. D.WaliczekT. M.ZajicekJ. M. (2005b). Growing minds: The effect of a school gardening program on the science achievement of elementary students. HortTechnology, 15, 448–452.
37.
*KochS.WaliczekT. M.ZajicekJ. M. (2006). The effect of a summer garden program on the nutritional knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors of children. HortTechnology, 16, 620–625.
38.
*LekiesK. S.SheavlyM. E. (2007). Fostering children’s interests in gardening. Applied Environmental Education and Communication, 6(1), 67–75. doi:10.1080/15330150701319362
39.
LinebergerS. E.ZajicekJ. M. (2000). School gardens: Can a hands-on teaching tool affect students’ attitudes and behaviors regarding fruit and vegetables?HortTechnology, 10, 593–597.
40.
*LopezR.CampbellR.JenningsJ. (2008). Schoolyard improvements and standardized test scores: An ecological analysis. Boston, MA: University of Massachusetts, Boston, Mauricio Gaston Institute for Latino Community Development and Public Policy.
41.
LouvR. (2005). Last child in the woods: Saving our children from nature-deficit disorder. Chapel Hill, NC: Algonquin Press.
42.
*MabieR.BakerM. (1996a). A comparison of experiential instructional strategies upon the science process skills of urban elementary students. Journal of Agricultural Education, 37(2), 1–7. doi:10.5032/jae.1996.02001
43.
*MabieR.BakerM. (1996b). The influence of experiential instruction on urban elementary students’ knowledge of the food and fiber system. Journal of Extension, 34(6), 1–4.
44.
Mayer-SmithJ.BartoshO.PeteratL. (2009). Cultivating and reflecting on intergenerational environmental education on the farm. Canadian Journal of Environmental Education, 14, 107–121.
45.
*McArthurJ.HillW.TrammelG.MorrisC. (2010). Gardening with youth as a means of developing science, work and life skills. Children, Youth and Environments, 20, 301–317.
46.
*MillerD. L. (2007). The seeds of learning: Young children develop important skills through their gardening activities at a Midwestern early education program. Applied Environmental Education & Communication, 6, 49–66. doi:10.1080/15330150701318828
47.
*MillerW. A. (2001). The effect of an educational garden on environmental attitudes and knowledge (Master’s thesis). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 1407305)
48.
*MorganP. J.WarrenJ. M.LubansD. R.SaundersK. L.QuickG. I.CollinsC. E. (2010). The impact of nutrition education with and without a school garden on knowledge, vegetable intake and preferences and quality of school life among primary-school students. Public Health Nutrition, 13, 1931–1940. doi:10.1017/S1368980010000959
49.
*MorganS. C.HamiltonS. L.BentleyM. L.MyrieS. (2009). Environmental education in botanic gardens: Exploring Brooklyn Botanic Garden’s Project Green Reach. Journal of Environmental Education, 40(4), 35–52. doi:10.3200/JOEE.40.4.35-52
50.
*MorrisJ. L. (2000). The development, implementation, and evaluation of a garden-enhanced nutrition education program for elementary school children (Doctoral dissertation). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 9980530)
51.
*MorrisJ. L.NeustadterA.Zidenberg-CherrS. (2001). First-grade gardeners more likely to taste vegetables. California Agriculture, 55(1), 43–46. doi:10.3733/ca.v055n01p43
52.
*MorrisJ. L.Zidenberg-CherrS. (2002). Garden-enhanced nutrition curriculum improves fourth-grade school children’s knowledge of nutrition and preferences for some vegetables. Journal of American Dietetic Association, 102(1), 91–93. doi:10.1016/S0002-8223(02)90027-1
53.
National Science Foundation. (2010). Preparing the next generation of STEM innovators: Identifying and developing our nation’s human capital. Arlington, VA: National Science Board.
54.
NiklasT.YangS.BaranowskiT.ZakeriI.BerensonG. (2003). Eating patterns and obesity in children: The Bogalusa Heart Study. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 25, 9–16. doi:10.1016/S0749-3797(03)00098-9
55.
No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, Pub. L. No. 107-110, 115 Stat, 1425 (2002).
ObamaM. (2012). American grown: The story of the White House kitchen garden and gardens across America. New York, NY: Crown Publishers.
58.
*O’BrienS. A.ShoemakerC. A. (2006). An after-school gardening club to promote fruit and vegetable consumption among fourth grade students: The assessment of social cognitive theory constructs. HortTechnology, 16, 24–29.
59.
OzerE. (2006). The effects of school gardens on students and schools: Conceptualizations and considerations for maximizing healthy development. Health Education and Behavior, 34, 846–863. doi:10.1177/1090198106289002
60.
*ParmerS. M.Salisbury-GlennonJ.ShannonD.StruemplerB. (2009). School gardens: An experiential learning approach for a nutrition education program to increase fruit and vegetable knowledge, preference, and consumption among second-grade students. Journal of Nutrition Education & Behavior, 41, 212–217. doi:10.1016/j.jneb.2008.06.002
61.
*PiggA. E.WaliczekT. M.ZajicekJ. M. (2006). Effects of a gardening program on the academic progress of third, fourth, and fifth grade math and science students. HortTechnology, 16, 262–264.
62.
*RobinsonC. W.ZajicekJ. M. (2005). Growing minds: The effect of a one year school garden program on six constructs of life skills of elementary school children. HortTechnology, 15, 453–457.
63.
*SheffieldB. K. (1992). The affective and cognitive effects of an interdisciplinary garden-based curriculum on underachieving elementary students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 9224935)
64.
*SimoneM. F. (2003). Back to the basics: Student achievement and schoolyard naturalization (Unpublished master’s thesis). Trent University, Ontario, Canada.
65.
*SkellyS. M.BradleyJ. C. (2000). The importance of school gardens as perceived by Florida elementary school teachers. HortTechnology, 10, 229–231.
66.
*SkellyS. M.BradleyJ. C. (2007). The growing phenomenon of school gardens: Measuring their variation and their effect on students’ sense of responsibility and attitudes toward science and the environment. Applied Environmental Education & Communication, 6, 97–104. doi:10.1080/15330150701319438
67.
*SkellyS. M.ZajicekJ. M. (1998). The effect of an interdisciplinary garden program on the environmental attitudes of elementary school students. HortTechnology, 8, 579–583.
68.
*SmithL. L.MotsenbockerC. E. (2005). Impact of hands-on science through school gardening in Louisiana public elementary schools. HortTechnology, 15, 439–443.
69.
*SobaskiC. (2006). An investigation of interactivity at the Michigan 4-H Children’s Garden (Master’s thesis). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 1440632)
70.
*SomersetS.MarkwellK. (2008). Impact of a school-based food garden on attitudes and identification skills regarding vegetables and fruit: A 12-month intervention trial. Public Health Nutrition, 12, 214–221. doi:10.1017/S1368980008003327
71.
SuriH.ClarkeD. (2009). Advancements in research synthesis methods: From a methodologically inclusive perspective. Review of Educational Research, 79, 395–430. doi:10.3102/0034654308326349
72.
*ThorpL. G. (2001). The pull of the earth: An ethnographic study of an elementary school garden (Doctoral dissertation). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 3020122)
73.
*TitmanW. (1994). Special places, special people: The hidden curriculum of school grounds. Surrey, UK: World Wide Fund for Nature-United Kingdom.
74.
VivianA.CarrelE.BeckerT. (2011). Identifying children at risk for Type 2 diabetes in underserved communities. The Diabetes Communicator, 37, 519–527. doi:10.1177/0145721711406139
75.
*WaliczekT. M. (1997). The effect of school gardens on self-esteem, interpersonal relationships, attitude toward school, and environmental attitude in populations of children (Doctoral dissertation). Available from Proquest UMI Dissertation Publishing database. (Proquest No. 9815857)
76.
*WaliczekT. M.BradleyJ. C.ZajicekJ. M. (2001). The effect of school gardens on children’s interpersonal relationships and attitudes toward school. HortTechnology, 11, 466–468.
77.
*WaliczekT. M.LoganP.ZajicekJ. M. (2003). Exploring the impact of outdoor environmental activities on children using a qualitative text data analysis system. HortTechnology, 13, 684–688.
78.
*WaliczekT. M.ZajicekJ. M. (1999). School gardening: Improving environmental attitudes of children through hands-on learning. Journal of Environmental Horticulture, 17, 180–184.
79.
WilliamsD.BrownJ. (2012). Learning gardens and sustainability education: Bringing life to schools and schools to life. New York, NY: Routledge.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
