Making Catholic Schools Research Relevant: Assessing Contemporary Trends in the Field of Catholic Education

Abstract

Despite the outsized influence the Catholic school sector in the United States has on policymaking, research into the organization of Catholic schools has not kept pace with contemporary educational research trends. In this brief paper, we diagnose how conceptual and empirical decisions made within the field of Catholic education resulted in the field’s relative isolation from other research communities and highlight additional explanations for the diminished relevance of research into Catholic schooling in the United States in recent years. Following this diagnosis and synthesis, we argue that Catholic educational research would be enhanced by considering contemporary organizational and policy research trends and propose new directions that may allow U.S. Catholic school researchers to increase their field’s relevance.

Keywords

educational policy historical analysis organization theory/change private education

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdulkadiroglu

Pathak

P. A.

Schellenberg

Walters

C. R.

(2020). Do parents value school effectiveness? American Economic Review, 110(5), 1502–1539. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20172040

Abdulkadiroglu

Pathak

P. A.

Walters

C. R.

(2018). Free to choose: Can school choice reduce student achievement? American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 10(1), 175–206. https://doi.org/10.1257/app.20160634

Altonji

J. G.

Elder

T. E.

Taber

C. R.

(2005a). An evaluation of instrumental variable strategies for estimating the effects of Catholic schooling. Journal of Human Resources, 40(4), 791–821. https://doi.org/10.3368/jhr.XL.4.791

Altonji

J. G.

Elder

T. E.

Taber

C. R.

(2005b). Selecting on observed and unobserved variables: Assessing the effectiveness of Catholic schools. Journal of Political Economy, 113(1), 151–184. https://doi.org/10.1086/426036

Anderson

K. P.

Wolf

P. J.

(2017, April 3). Evaluating school vouchers: Evidence from a within-study comparison. University of Arkansas Department of Education Reform Working Paper Series [EDRE Working Paper 2017–10]. http://www.uaedreform.org/downloads/2017/04/evaluating-school-vouchers-evidence-from-a-within-study-comparison.pdf

Angrist

J. D.

Pathak

P. A.

Walters

C. R.

(2013). Explaining charter school effectiveness. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5(4), 1–27. http://dx.doi.org/10.1257/app.5.4.1

Barnum

(2021, November 5). How will fights about race and suburban schools change education politics? Chalkbeat. https://www.chalkbeat.org/2021/11/5/22766008/election-virginia-youngkin-schools-covid-critical-race-theory

Ben-Porath

(2021, September). A broader conception of school choice. Phi Delta Kappan, 103(1), 8–13. https://kappanonline.org/broader-conception-school-choice-ben-porath/

Berends

(2020). Social perspectives on school choice. In Berends

Primus

Springer

M. G.

(Eds.), Handbook of research on school choice (2nd ed., pp. 32–45). Routledge.

10.

Berends

Lucas

S. R.

Peñaloza

R. V.

(2008). How changes in families and schools are related to trends in Black-White test scores. Sociology of Education, 81(4), 313–344. http://www.jstor.org/stable/20452744

11.

Berends

Waddington

R. J.

(2018). School choice in Indianapolis: Effects of charter, magnet, private, and traditional public schools. Education Finance and Policy, 13(2), 227–255. https://doi.org/10.1162/edfp_a_00225

12.

Berlant

(2011). Cruel optimism. Duke University Press.

13.

Berman

E. P.

(2022). Thinking like an economist: How efficiency replaced equality in U.S. public policy. Princeton University Press.

14.

Biesta

G. J. J.

(2014). The beautiful risk of education. Paradigm.

15.

Bifulco

(2012). Can nonexperimental estimates replace estimates based on random assignment in evaluations of school choice? A within-study comparison. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 31(3), 729–751. https://doi.org/10.1002/pam.20637

16.

Bonfiglio

Boyle

M. J.

Faggella-Luby

Smith

(2020). Inclusion in Catholic schools: An introduction to the special issue. Journal of Catholic Education, 23(2), 1–4.

17.

Brinig

M. F.

Garnett

N. S.

(2014). Lost classroom, lost community: Catholic schools’ importance in urban America. University of Chicago Press.

18.

Britzman

D. P.

(2009). The very thought of education: Psychoanalysis and the impossible professions. SUNY Press.

19.

Bryk

(2008). Catholic schools, Catholic education, and Catholic educational research: A conversation with Anthony Bryk. Journal of Catholic Education, 12(2), 135–147. http://dx.doi.org/10.15365/joce.1202022013

20.

Bryk

A. S.

Lee

V. E.

Holland

P. B.

(1993). Catholic schools and the common good. Harvard University Press.

21.

Burch

Crowson

R. L.

(2020). Local schooling and organizational change: New insights from the perspective of institutional theory. Peabody Journal of Education, 95(4), 331–335. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2020.1800171

22.

Cattaro

G. M.

Cooper

B. S.

(2007). Developments in Catholic schools in the USA: Politics, policy, and prophesy. In Grace

G. R.

O’Keefe

(Eds.), International handbook of Catholic education: Challenges for school systems in the 21st century (pp. 61–83). Springer.

23.

Coleman

Hoffer

Kilgore

(1982). Cognitive outcomes in public and private schools. Sociology of Education, 55(2), 65–76. https://doi.org/10.2307/2112288

24.

Cook

M. D.

Evans

W. N.

(2000). Families or schools? Explaining the convergence in White and Black academic performance. Journal of Labor Economics, 18(4), 729–754. https://doi.org/10.1086/209975

25.

D’Alfonso

S. P.

(2021). Exploring the experiences of Black students in a predominantly White, all-male, suburban Catholic high school: A critical narrative qualitative study [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. Seton Hall University.

26.

Dallavis

J. W.

Kuhfield

Tarasawa

Ponisciak

(2021). Achievement growth in K–8 Catholic schools using NWEA data. Journal of Catholic Education, 24(2), 1–19. http://dx.doi.org/10.15365/joce.2402012021

27.

Davies

(2013). Are there Catholic school effects in Ontario, Canada? European Sociological Review, 29(4), 871–883. https://doi.org/10.1093/esr/jcs065

28.

Davies

Quirke

(2007). The impact of sector on school organizations: Institutional and market logics. Sociology of Education, 80(1), 66–90. https://doi.org/10.1177/003804070708000104

29.

Dobbie

Fryer

R. G.

(2013). Getting beneath the veil of effective schools: Evidence from New York City. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5(4), 28–60. http://dx.doi.org/10.1257/app.5.4.28

30.

Elder

Jepsen

(2014). Are Catholic primary schools more effective than public primary schools? Journal of Urban Economics, 80, 28–38. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jue.2013.10.001

31.

Evans

W. N.

Schwab

R. M.

(1995). Finishing high school and starting college: Do Catholic schools make a difference? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(4), 941–974. https://doi.org/10.2307/2946645

32.

Freeman

K. J.

Berends

(2016). The Catholic school advantage in a changing social landscape: Consistency or increasing fragility? Journal of School Choice, 10(1), 22–47. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2015.1132937

33.

Fortson

Gleason

Kopa

Verbitsky-Savitz

(2014). Horseshoes, hand grenades, and treatment effects? Reassessing whether nonexperimental estimators are biased. Economics of Education Review, 44, 100–113. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2014.11.001

34.

Goldhaber

D. D.

Eide

E. R.

(2003). Methodological thoughts on measuring the impact of private sector competition on the educational marketplace. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 25(2), 217–232. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3699550

35.

Grace

G. R.

O’Keefe

(Eds.) (2007). International handbook of Catholic education: Challenges for school systems in the 21st century. Springer.

36.

Greenblatt

(2021). School choice advances in the states: Advocates describe the “breakthrough” year. Education Next, 21(4), 18–25. https://www.educationnext.org/school-choice-advances-in-states-advocates-describe-breakthrough-year/

37.

Greteman

A. J.

(2020). Ambivalence in two parts: Legacies of Catholic languaging. In Juzwik

M. M.

Stone

J. C.

Burke

K. J.

Dávila

(Eds.), Legacies of Christian languaging and literacies in American education: Perspectives on English Language Arts curriculum, teaching, and learning. Routledge.

38.

Henderson

M. B.

Peterson

P. E.

West

M. R.

(2020). Pandemic parent survey finds perverse pattern: Students are more likely to be attending school in person where Covid is spreading more rapidly. EdNext, 21(2), 34–49. https://www.educationnext.org/pandemic-parent-survey-finds-perverse-pattern-students-more-likely-to-be-attending-school-in-person-where-covid-is-spreading-more-rapidly/

39.

Hunt

T. C.

Joseph

E. A.

Nuzzi

R. J.

(Eds.) (2001). Handbook of research on Catholic education. Information Age Publishing.

40.

Hussar

Zhang

Hein

Wang

Roberts

Cui

Smith

Bullock Mann

Barmer

Dilig

(2020). The condition of education 2020 (NCES 2020–144). U.S. Department of Education National Center for Education Statistics. https://nces.ed.gov/pubsearch/pubsinfo.asp?pubid=2020144

41.

Jabbar

Creed

(2020). Choice, competition, and cognition: How Arizona charter school leaders interpret and respond to market pressures. Peabody Journal of Education, 95(4), 374–391. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.2020.1800174

42.

Jabbar

Fong

C. J.

Germain

Sanchez

Sun

W.-L.

Devall

(2022). The competitive effects of school choice on student achievement: A systematic review. Educational Policy, 36(2), 247–281. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904819874756

43.

Lareau

Goyette

(Eds.) (2014). Choosing homes, choosing schools. Russell Sage Foundation.

44.

Losito

W. F.

Rogus

J. F.

(1997). Introducing the journal. Journal of Catholic Education, 1(1), 3–5. http://dx.doi.org/10.15365/joce.0101011997

45.

Lubienski

C. A.

Lubienski

S. T.

(2014). The public school advantage: Why public schools outperform private schools. University of Chicago Press.

46.

Marks

H. M.

(2009). Perspectives on Catholic schools. In Berends

Springer

M. G.

Ballou

Walberg

H. J.

(Eds.), Handbook of research on school choice (1st ed., pp. 479–500). Routledge.

47.

McCullough

M. K.

(2018). Introduction to the special issue: Recognizing 20 years of research in Catholic education. Journal of Catholic Education, 21(3), 1–3. https://doi.org/10.15365/joce.2103012018

48.

Mehta

(2013). The allure of order: High hopes, dashed expectations, and the troubled quest to remake American schooling. Oxford University Press.

49.

Mehta

Fine

(2019). In search of deeper learning: The quest to remake the American high school. Harvard University Press.

50.

Miller

A. F.

Park

Conway

Cownie

C. T.

Reyes

Reynoso

Smith

(2021). Examining the legacy of urban Catholic schooling in the U.S.: A systematic literature review. Urban Review, advanced online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256–021–00619-w.

51.

Miserandino

(2019). The funding and future of Catholic education in the United States. British Journal of Religious Education, 41(1), 105–114. https://doi.org/10.1080/01416200.2017.1352484

52.

Morgan

S. L.

(2001). Counterfactuals, causal effect heterogeneity, and the Catholic school effect on learning. Sociology of Education, 74(4), 341–374. https://doi.org/10.2307/2673139

53.

Mullen

L. K.

(2021). Moments matter: Toward more humanizing practices of inclusion in catholic education [Doctoral dissertation]. California State University East Bay. Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (2649312465).

54.

Murnane

R. J.

Reardon

S. F.

(2018). Long-term trends in private school enrollments by family income. AERA Open, 4(1), 1–24. https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858417751355

55.

Neal

(1997). The effects of Catholic secondary schooling on educational achievement. Journal of Labor Economics, 15(1), 98–123. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2535316

56.

Neal

(1998). What have we learned about the benefits of private schooling? Economic Policy Review, 4(1), 79–86. https://ssrn.com/abstract=1023730

57.

Neumerski

C. M.

Cohen

D. K.

(2019). The heart of the matter: How reforms unsettle organizational identity. Educational Policy, 33(6), 882–915. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904819866918

58.

Neville

M. L.

(2019). “Racism is a God-damned thing”: The implications of historical and contemporary Catholic racism in ELA classrooms. In Juzwik

M. M.

Stone

J. C.

Burke

K. J.

Davila

(Eds.), Legacies of Christian languaging and literacies in American education: Perspectives on English language arts curriculum, teaching, and learning (pp. 82–95). Routledge.

59.

Noble

(2022). The impact of leadership transitions on school change [Doctoral dissertation]. Boston College. Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (2702463267).

60.

O’Keefe

J. M.

Goldschmidt

E. P.

(2014). Courageous, comprehensive, and collaborative: The renewal of Catholic education in the twenty-first century. In Bauch

P. A.

(Ed.), Catholic schools in the public interest: Past, present, and future directions (pp. 221–244). Information Age Publishing.

61.

Ospino

Wyttenbach

(2022). Cultivating talent: A summary report of findings from the national study examining pathways to increase the presence of Hispanic teachers and leaders in Catholic schools. Boston College Lynch School of Education and Human Development, Roche Center for Catholic Education, and School of Theology and Ministry. https://www.bc.edu/content/dam/bc1/schools/lsoe/sites/roche/cultivating-talent-report/Cultivating%20Talent%20Report%20-%201.27.22.pdf

62.

Ozar

Weitzel-O’Neill

(Eds.). (2012). National standards and benchmarks for effective Catholic elementary and secondary schools. Center for School Effectiveness, School of Education, Loyola University Chicago in partnership with Roche Center for Catholic Education, Boston College. https://www.catholicschoolstandards.org/images/docs/standards/Catholic-School-Standards-English.pdf

63.

Peurach

D. J.

Cohen

D. K.

Yurkofsky

M. M.

Spillane

J. P.

(2019). From mass schooling to education systems: Changing patterns in the organization and management of instruction. Review of Research in Education, 43(1), 32–67. https://doi-org.proxy.bc.edu/10.3102/0091732X18821131

64.

Porter-Magee

(2021, August 27). Leading schools with vision in a time of change. The Thomas B. Fordham Institute. https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/leading-schools-vision-time-change

65.

Rodriguez

P. J.

Briscoe

(2019). “This is your worth”: Is the Catholic school advantage in urban Catholic schools’ college culture disappearing in a neoliberal era? Education and Urban Society, 51(1), 3–32. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124517714847

66.

Santa Maria

M. I.

(2022). Challenging racism in Catholic schools through intimate school leadership: Counternarratives of Black Catholic school leaders [Doctoral dissertation]. Loyola Marymount University. Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (2703980834).

67.

Schneider

Berkshire

(2020). A wolf at the schoolhouse door: The dismantling of public education and the future of school. New Press.

68.

Schoenig

Staud

(2014). Introduction to the focus section: 2013 Catholic Higher Education Collaborative (CHEC) conference on Catholic school financing. Journal of Catholic Education, 18(1), 154–165. http://dx.doi.org/10.15365/joce.1801082014

69.

Scott

Holme

J. J.

(2016). The political economy of market-based educational policies: Race and reform in urban school districts, 1915 to 2016. Review of Research in Education, 40(1), 250–297. https://doi.org/10.3102/0091732X16681001

70.

Shulman

(2014). The course of educational change: Challenge and opportunity. Journal of Catholic Education, 18(1), 166–173. http://dx.doi.org/10.15365/joce.1801092014

71.

Spillane

J. P.

Seelig

J. L.

Blaushild

N. L.

Cohen

D. K.

Peurach

D. J.

(2019). Educational system building in a changing educational sector: Environment, organization, and the technical core. Educational Policy, 33(6), 846–881. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904819866269

72.

Staud

(Ed.). (2008). The Carnegie conversation on Catholic education. Alliance for Catholic Education Press.

73.

Tentler

L. W.

(2020). American Catholics: A history. Yale University Press.

74.

Thomas

D. J.

Johnson

M. W.

Clark

Harrison

Jr. (2020). When the mirage fades: Black boys encountering antiblackness in a predominantly White Catholic high school. Race Ethnicity and Education, advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/13613324.2020.1798376

75.

U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. (2005). Renewing our commitment to Catholic elementary and secondary schools in the third millennium. U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. https://www.usccb.org/beliefs-and-teachings/how-we-teach/catholic-education/upload/renewing-our-commitment-2005.pdf

76.

U.S. Department of Education. (2008, September). Preserving a critical national asset: America’s disadvantaged students and the crisis in faith-based urban schools. U.S. Department of Education. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED503755.pdf

77.

West

(2018). Privatization in American education: Rhetoric vs. facts. Education Next, 18(4), 5. https://www.educationnext.org/privatization-american-education-rhetoric-vs-facts/

78.

Whittle

(Ed.). (2017). Vatican II and new thinking about Catholic education: The impact and legacy of Gravissimum Educationis. Routledge.

79.

Whittle

(Ed.). (2018). Researching Catholic education: Contemporary perspectives. Springer.

80.

Whittle

(Ed.). (2022). New thinking, new scholarship, and new research in Catholic education: Responses to the work of Professor Gerald Grace. Routledge.

81.

Wolf

P. J.

(2020). Private school choice programs: What do we know about their effects on outcomes for disadvantaged students? Hoover Education Success Initiative. Hoover Institution, Stanford University. https://www.hoover.org/research/private-school-choice-programs-what-do-we-know-about-their-effects-outcomes-disadvantaged

82.

Yurkofsky

M. M.

(2020). Technical ceremonies: Rationalization, opacity, and the restructuring of educational organizations. Harvard Educational Review, 90(3), 446–473. https://doi.org/10.17763/1943–5045–90.3.446

83.

Yurkofsky

(2022). Environmental, technical, and representational uncertainty: A framework for making sense of the hidden complexity of educational change. Educational Researcher, advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X221078590