The Long-Term Solvency of Teacher Pension Plans: How We Got to Now and Prospects for Recovery

Abstract

The COVID-related financial market decline and economic recession have raised new concerns regarding the financial sustainability of retirement plans for state and local government employees, the largest group of whom is public school teachers. Using data from the Public Plans Database and the National Income and Product Accounts, I analyze teacher pension plans over the 2001–2019 period, seeking to answer questions regarding teacher pensions’ funded status, investment decisions and returns, adequacy of contributions, and generosity of benefits. These data show that teacher pension funding peaked at the beginning of the 2001–2019 period due to the tech bubble’s inflation of asset values, but then it declined thereafter due to investment returns that significantly underperformed assumptions, failures by sponsoring governments to consistently make full contributions, and increases in the generosity of pension benefits. School districts will face substantial funding challenges in the post-COVID period, as investment losses are factored into contribution rates, government revenues available to make contributions shrink, and education funding from state governments comes under pressure. I outline several policy alternatives that policymakers may consider, but none would make restoring teacher pensions to full funding a painless process.

Keywords

administration aging career development case studies demography descriptive analysis economics of education educational policy educational reform longitudinal studies policy analysis

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Actuarial Standards Board. (2020). Proposed revision of ASOP no. 4—Measuring pension obligations and determining pension plan costs or contributions (second exposure draft).

Aldeman

Robson

(2017, May 16). Why most teachers get a bad deal on pensions. Education Next. https://www.educationnext.org/why-most-teachers-get-bad-deal-pensions-state-plans-winners-losers/

Aubry

J.-P.

Crawford

C. V.

(2019). Impact of public sector assumed returns on investment choices. Boston College Center for Retirement Research Working Paper.

Barro

Buck

(2010). Underfunded teacher pension plans: It’s worse than you think. Civic report no. 61. Manhattan Institute for Policy Research.

Biggs

A. G.

(2011). An options pricing method for calculating the market price of public sector pension liabilities. Public Budgeting & Finance, 31(3), 94–118.

Biggs

A. G.

(2014). The public pension quadrilemma: the intersection of investment risk and contribution risk. Journal of Retirement, 2(1), 115–127.

Biggs

A. G.

(2015). The state of public pension funding: Are government employee plans back on track? American Enterprise Institute, Economic Perspectives.

Biggs

A. G.

(2018). Connecting evidence-based research to pension reform: Costs and cross-subsidies: Reconciling two strands of teacher pension analysis. RAND Corporation, WR-1253.

Biggs

A. G.

(2019a). The growth of salaries and benefits in the federal government, state and local governments and public education, 1998–2017. AEI Economic Policy Working Paper Series.

10.

Biggs

A. G.

(2019b). How much should the poor save for retirement? Data and simulations on retirement income adequacy among low-earning households. Pension Research Council WP2019-15.

11.

Bureau of Economic Analysis. (2020). National Income and Product Accounts.

12.

Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. Public Plans Database.

13.

Clemens

Veuger

(2020). Implications of the COVID-19 pandemic for state government tax revenues. Working paper no. w27426. National Bureau of Economic Research.

14.

Costrell

(2015). Assessing the impact of investment shortfalls on unfunded pension liabilities: The allure of neat, but faulty counterfactuals. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, Forthcoming.

15.

Fitzpatrick

M. D.

(2015). How much are public school teachers willing to pay for their retirement benefits? American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 7(4), 165–188.

16.

Johnston

A. C.

(2020). Teacher preferences, working conditions, and compensation structure. Working paper, Economics Department, University of California at Merced. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3532779

17.

Koedel

Podgursky

(2016). Teacher pensions. In Handbook of the economics of education (Vol. 5, pp. 281–303). Elsevier.

18.

Munnell

A. H.

Aubry

J.-P.

Hurwitz

Quinby

(2012). How retirement provisions affect tenure of state and local workers. Center for Retirement Research, State and Local Pensions 27.

19.

Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan. (2019). 2018 annual report.

20.

Sgouros

(2017). Funding public pensions. Haas Institute. http://haasinstitute.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/funding_public_pensions_-_publish.pdf

21.

Society of Actuaries. (2014, February 24). Report of the Blue Ribbon Panel on Public Pension Plan Funding.