Beyond the Headlines: Trends and Future Directions in the School Closure Literature

Abstract

With the looming impacts of COVID-19 on district budgets, the growth of school choice options, and population shifts across urban, suburban, and rural contexts, an increasing number of districts have closed schools and more districts are expected to follow this trend. Rich scholarship has examined school closures; however, this field of research is limited in scope and methodological approach, and overwhelmingly focuses on the mass urban school closures of the mid-2010s. This offers a timely opportunity to consider new directions in the field. In this article, we identify trends in the scholarship on school closures by examining the empirical research in this area over nearly two decades. We conclude by offering a research agenda for future scholarship on school closures.

Keywords

content analysis educational policy meta-analysis social context urban education

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agard

Ansari

Conner

Ferman

Pappas

L. N.

Shiller

(2019). Community-engaged research through the lens of school closures: Opportunities, challenges, contributions, and lingering questions. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 27(55). https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.27.2622

Allweiss

Grant

C. A.

Manning

(2015). Behind the photos and the tears: Media images, neoliberal discourses, racialized constructions of space and school closings in Chicago. Race Ethnicity and Education, 18(5), 611–631. https://doi.org/10.1080/13613324.2014.969223

Alsbury

T. L.

Shaw

N. L.

(2005). Policy implications for social justice in school district consolidation. Leadership and Policy in Schools, 4(2), 105–126. https://doi.org/10.1080/15700760590965578

Aviles

A. M.

Heybach

J. A.

(2017). Seeking stability in Chicago: School actions, (c)overt forms of racial injustice, and the slow violence of neoliberal rationality. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 25(58). https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.25.2634

Bard

Gardener

Wieland

(2006). Rural school consolidation: History, research summary, conclusions, and recommendations. Rural Educator, 27(2), 40–48. https://doi.org/10.35608/ruraled.v27i2.497

Bierbaum

A. H.

(2018a). School closures and the contested unmaking of Philadelphia’s neighborhoods. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 41(2), 202–216. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X18785018

Bierbaum

A. H.

(2018b). News media’s democratic functions in public education: An analysis of newspaper framings of public school closures. Urban Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085918756713

Billger

S. M.

Beck

F. D.

(2012). The determinants of high school closures: Lessons from longitudinal data throughout Illinois. Journal of Education Finance, 38(2), 83–101.

Borman

G. D.

(2012). The use of randomized trials to inform education policy. In Sykes

Schneider

Plank

D. N.

(Eds.), Handbook of education policy research (pp. 145–154). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203880968-19

10.

Brazil

(2019). The effects of public elementary school closures on neighborhood housing values in U.S. metropolitan areas, 2000–2010. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 231–258). Information Age.

11.

Brown

(2018, November 27). How schools are forced to close as rural populations dwindle. PBS NewsHour. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/how-schools-are-forced-to-close-as-rural-populations-dwindle

12.

Brummet

(2014). The effect of school closings on student achievement. Journal of Public Economics, 119(November), 10 8–124. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpubeco.2014.06.010

13.

Buras

K. L.

(2015). Charter schools, race, and urban space: Where the market meets grassroots resistance. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203067000

14.

Burdick-Will

Keels

Schuble

(2013). Closing and opening schools: The association between neighborhood characteristics and the location of new educational opportunities in a large urban district. Journal of Urban Affairs, 35(1), 59–80. https://doi.org/10.1111/juaf.12004

15.

Burnette

(2020, May 8). Devastated budgets and widening inequities: How the coronavirus collapse will impact schools. Education Week. https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2020/05/09/devastated-budgets-and-widening-inequities-how-the.html

16.

Carlson

Lavertu

(2016). Charter school closure and student achievement: Evidence from Ohio. Journal of Urban Economics, 95(September), 31–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jue.2016.07.001

17.

Center for Research on Education Outcomes. (2017). Lights off: Practice and impact of closing low-performing schools. https://credo.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj6481/f/closure_final_volume_i.pdf

18.

Davis

Oakley

Stover

(2019). School closings . . . Atlanta style: The convergence of poverty, segregration, and achievement. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 57–90). Information Age.

19.

Deeds

Pattillo

(2015). Organizational “failure” and institutional pluralism: A case study of an urban school closure. Urban Education, 50(4), 474–504. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085913519337

20.

de la Torre

Gordon

M. F.

Moore

Cowhy

(2015). School closings in Chicago: Understanding families’ choices and constraints for new school enrollment. University of Chicago Consortium on Chicago School Research. https://consortium.uchicago.edu/sites/default/files/2018-10/School%20Closings%20Report.pdf

21.

Diamond

J. B.

Posey-Maddox

Velázquez

M. D.

(2021). Reframing suburbs: Race, place, and opportunity in suburban educational spaces. Educational Researcher, 50(4), 249–255. http://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X20972676

22.

Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(2019). School closure in strained cities. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 9–56). Information Age.

23.

Engberg

Gill

Zamarro

Zimmer

(2012). Closing schools in a shrinking district: Do student outcomes depend on which schools are closed? Journal of Urban Economics, 71(2), 189–203. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jue.2011.10.001

24.

Ewing

E. L.

(2018). Ghosts in the schoolyard: Racism and school closings on Chicago’s South Side. University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226526331.001.0001

25.

Fay

(2017). The moral foundations of objections to school closure. Philosophy of Education Archive, 361–369. https://educationjournal.web.illinois.edu/archive/index.php/pes/article/view/4892.pdf

26.

Finnigan

K. S.

Lavner

(2012). A political analysis of community influence over school closure. Urban Review, 44(1), 133–151. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-011-0179-9

27.

Gallagher

Gold

(2017). Subtracting schools from communities. In Tilsley

(Ed.). Urban Institute. https://www.urban.org/features/subtracting-schools-communities

28.

Galletta

(2019). Complicating “sector” agnosticism: Relational and spatial displacement and dispossession through school closure in Cleveland. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 153–192). Information Age.

29.

Good

R. M.

(2017a). Histories that root us: Neighborhood, place, and the protest of school closures in Philadelphia. Urban Geography, 38(6), 861–883. https://doi.org/10.1080/02723638.2016.1182286

30.

Good

R. M.

(2017b). Invoking landscapes of spatialized inequality: Race, class, and place in Philadelphia’s school closure debate. Journal of Urban Affairs, 39(3), 358–380. https://doi.org/10.1080/07352166.2016.1245069

31.

Gordon

M. F.

de la Torre

Cowhy

J. R.

Moore

P. T.

Sartain

L. S.

Knight

(2018). School closings in Chicago: Staff and student experiences and academic outcomes. University of Chicago Consortium on School Research. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED589712.pdf

32.

Green

T. L.

(2017). “We felt they took the heart out of the community”: Examining a community-based response to urban school closure. education policy analysis archives, 25(21), 1–31. https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.25.2549

33.

Green

T. L.

Germain

Castro

A. J.

Latham Sikes

Sanchez

Horne

(2020). Gentrifying neighborhoods, gentrifying schools? An emerging typology of school changes in a gentrifying urban school district. Urban Education. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085920974090

34.

Green

T. L.

Sánchez

J. D.

Castro

A. J.

(2019). Closed schools, open markets: A hot spot spatial analysis of school closures and charter openings in Detroit. AERA Open, 5(2). https://doi.org/10.1177/2332858419850097

35.

Hsieh

H. F.

Shannon

S. E.

(2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative health research, 15(9), 1277–1288. https://doi.org/10.1177/1049732305276687

36.

Hyndman

Cleveland

Huffman

(2010). Consolidation of small, rural schools in one southeastern Kentucky district. American Educational History Journal, 37(1–2).

37.

Institute for Children, Poverty, and Homelessness. (2010). The impact of school closures on homeless students in New York City. https://rhyclearinghouse.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/docs/19697-The_Impact_of_School_Closures_on_Homeless.pdf

38.

Jack

Sludden

(2013). School closings in Philadelphia. Penn GSE Perspectives on Urban Education, 10(1). https://urbanedjournal.gse.upenn.edu/archive/volume-10-issue-1-summer-2013/school-closings-philadelphia

39.

Jankov

Caref

(2017). Segregation and inequality in Chicago public schools, transformed and intensified under corporate education reform. education policy analysis archives, 25(56). https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.25.2631

40.

Johnson

A. W.

(2013). “Turnaround” as shock therapy: Race, neoliberalism, and school reform. Urban Education, 48(2), 232–256. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085912441941

41.

Journey for Justice. (2014). Death by a thousand cuts: Racism, school closure, and public school sabotage. http://www.otlcampaign.org/blog/2014/05/21/death-thousand-cuts-racism-school-closures-and-public-school-sabotage

42.

Kamenetz

(2020, October 9). Enrollment is dropping in public schools around the country. National Public Radio. https://www.npr.org/2020/10/09/920316481/enrollment-is-dropping-in-public-schools-around-the-country

43.

Kang

Slay

K. E.

(2019). The costs and consequences of school governance change in Detroit: From Proposal A to the Educational Achievement Authority. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 91–124). Information Age.

44.

Khalifa

M. A.

Jennings

M. E.

Briscoe

Oleszweski

A. M.

Abdi

(2014). Racism? Administrative and community perspectives in data-driven decision making: Systemic perspectives versus technical-rational perspectives. Urban Education, 49(2), 147–181. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085913475635

45.

Killeen

Sipple

(2000). School consolidation and transportation policy: An empirical and institutional analysis. Rural School and Community Trust. https://www.ruraledu.org/user_uploads/file/school_consolidation_and_transportation_policy.pdf

46.

Kirshner

Gaertner

Pozzoboni

(2010). Tracing transitions: The effect of high school closure on displaced students. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 32(3), 407–429. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373710376823

47.

Kirshner

Pozzoboni

K. M.

(2011). Student interpretations of a school closure: Implications for student voice in equity-based school reform. Teachers College Record, 113(8), 1633–1667.

48.

Kneebone

Berube

(2013). Confronting suburban poverty in America. Brookings Institution Press.

49.

Kretchmar

(2014). Democracy (in) action: A critical policy analysis of New York City public school closings by teachers, students, administrators, and community members. Education and Urban Society, 46(1), 3–29. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124511424108

50.

Lee

Lubienski

(2017). The impact of school closures on equity of access in Chicago. Education and Urban Society, 49(1), 53–80. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124516630601

51.

Lipman

(2011). Contesting the city: Neoliberal urbanism and the cultural politics of education reform in Chicago. Discourse: Studies in the cultural politics of education, 32(2), 217–234.

52.

Lipman

(2013). The new political economy of urban education: Neoliberalism, race, and the right to the city. Routledge.

53.

Lipman

Person

A. S.

(2007). Students as collateral damage? A preliminary study of Renaissance 2010 school closings in the midsouth. Educational Policy, 21(3), 471–502. https://doi.org/10.1177/0895904806297734

54.

Love

B. L.

(2019). We want to do more than survive: Abolitionist teaching and the pursuit of educational freedom. Beacon Press.

55.

Lowery

(2019). The implications of colorblind decision-making about the closure, renovation or rebuild of (almost) every school in North Little Rock, Arkansas. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 193–230). Information Age.

56.

McWilliams

J. A.

Kitzmiller

E. M.

(2019). Mass school closures and the politics of race, value, and disposability in Philadelphia. Teachers College Record, 121(1).

57.

Miller

(2018, October 31). School, supporters fighting for survival. Bay State Banner. https://www.baystatebanner.com/2018/10/31/school-supporters-fighting-for-survival/

58.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2014). Rural education in America: Number of public school districts. https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/ruraled/tables/a.1.a.-1.asp

59.

National Center for Education Statistics. (2015). Rural education in America: Percentage of 5- to 17 year olds in families living in poverty. https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/ruraled/tables/a.1.a.-6.asp

60.

Nitta

K. A.

Holley

M. J.

Wrobel

S. L.

(2010). A phenomenological study of rural school consolidation. Journal of Research in Rural Education, 25(2), 1–19.

61.

Nuamah

S. A.

(2017). The paradox of educational attitudes: Racial differences in public opinion on school closure. Journal of Urban Affairs, 42(4), 554–570.

62.

Pappas

L. N.

(2012). School closings and parent engagement. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, 18(2), 165–172. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0028100

63.

Pearman

F. A.

(2019). Gentrification and academic achievement: A review of recent research. Review of Educational Research, 89(1), 125–165. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654318805924

64.

Pearman

F. A.

(2020). Gentrification, geography, and the declining enrollment of neighborhood schools. Urban Education, 55(2), 183–215. https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085919884342

65.

Pearman

F. A.

Swain

W. A.

(2017). School choice, gentrification, and the variable significance of racial stratification in urban neighborhoods. Sociology of Education, 90(3), 213–235. https://doi.org/10.1177/0038040717710494

66.

Pedroni

T. C.

(2011). Urban shrinkage as a performance of whiteness: Neoliberal urban restructuring, education, and racial containment in the post-industrial, global niche city. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 32(2), 203–215.

67.

Pew Charitable Trusts. (2011). Closing public schools in Philadelphia: Lessons from six urban districts. https://www.pewtrusts.org/-/media/assets/2011/10/19/closing_public_schools_philadelphia_report.pdf

68.

ross

k.m.

(2020). Black space in education: (Anti)blackness in schools and the afterlife of segregation. In Grant

C. A.

Dumas

M. J.

Woodson

A .N

. (Eds.). The future is Black: Afropressimism,fugitivity and radical hope in education. Routledge.

69.

Shiller

(2018). The disposability of Baltimore’s Black communities: A participatory action research project on the impact of school closings. Urban Review, 50(1), 23–44. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11256-017-0428-7

70.

Siegel-Hawley

Bridges

Shields

T. J.

(2017). Solidifying segregation or promoting diversity? School closure and rezoning in an urban district. Educational Administration Quarterly, 53(1), 107–141. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013161X16659346

71.

Stark

L. W.

Maton

R. M.

(2019). School closures and the political education of U.S. teachers. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 287–324). Information Age.

72.

Steinberg

M. P.

MacDonald

J. M.

(2019). The effects of closing urban schools on students’ academic and behavioral outcomes: Evidence from Philadelphia. Economics of Education Review, 69(April), 25–60. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econedurev.2018.12.005

73.

Stuit

(2012). Turnaround and closure rates in the charter and district sectors. Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk (JESPAR), 17(1–2), 40–54. https://doi.org/10.1080/10824669.2012.637032

74.

Surface

(2011). Assessing the impact of twenty-first century rural school consolidation. International Journal of Educational Leadership Preparation, 6(2).

75.

Syeed

(2019). An open and shut case: Gentrification and school closure decisions in Washington, D.C. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 125–152). Information Age.

76.

Tieken

M. C.

Auldridge-Reveles

T. R.

(2019). Rethinking the school closure research: School closure as spatial injustice. Review of Educational Research, 89(6), 917–953. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654319877151

77.

Tieken

M. C.

(2014). Why rural schools matter. University of North Carolina Press. https://doi.org/10.5149/northcarolina/9781469618487.001.0001

78.

Tsai

Khan

N. M.

Shi

Rainey

Gao

Zheteyeva

(2017). Evaluation of unintended social and economic consequences of an unplanned school closure in rural Illinois. Journal of School Health, 87(7), 546–553. https://doi.org/10.1111/josh.12525

79.

Vaughan

K. P.

Gutierrez

R. R.

(2017). Desire for democracy: Perspectives of parents impacted by 2013 Chicago school closings. education policy analysis archives, 25(57). https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.25.2637.

80.

Welsh

R. O.

Little

(2019). Closing costs: Examining the impact of school closures on African-American students’ educational outcomes. In Duncan-Shippy

E. M.

(Ed.), Shuttered schools: Race, community, and school closures in American cities (pp. 325–352). Information Age.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.20 MB