Repressive Legalism: How Postsecondary Administrators’ Responses to On-Campus Hate Speech Undermine a Focus on Inclusion

Abstract

Guided by legal, sociolegal, and higher education concepts, we use an embedded case study of university administrators at a public institution to examine how they negotiate and institutionalize principles of freedom of expression and inclusion in responses to the proliferation of on-campus hate speech following the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Our findings reveal that an institution's legal context and administrators’ interpretations of law and law-related pressures shape their understanding of hate speech–related incidents, and the permissible responses, in ways that make it nearly impossible to consider and implement inclusion-focused practices. We advance the concept of “repressive legalism” to explain these dynamics and discuss implications for policies and practices that support both open, robust expression and inclusion for students of color.

Keywords

freedom of expression higher education inclusion marginalized populations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anti-Defamation League. (2017). White supremacists on campus: Unprecedented recruitment efforts underway. https://www.adl.org/blog/white-supremacists-on-campus-unprecedented-recruitment-efforts-underway

Anti-Defamation League. (2019). White supremacists increase college recruiting efforts for third straight year. https://www.adl.org/news/press-releases/white-supremacists-increase-college-campus-recruiting-efforts-for-third

Anti-Defamation League. (2020). White supremacists double down on propaganda in 2019: A report from the center on extremism. https://www.adl.org/media/14038/download

Auerbach

Silverstein

L. B.

(2003). Qualitative data: An introduction to coding and analysis. New York University Press.

Baker

C. E.

(1989). Human liberty and freedom of speech. Oxford University Press.

Ben-Porath

S. R.

(2017). Free speech on campus. University of Pennsylvania Press.

Ben-Porath

S. R.

(2020). Campus free speech in polarized times. Law, Culture and the Humanities. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/1743872120953815

Brouillete

(2015, February 11). Guests wear ponchos, sombreros and construction gear at “border patrol” fraternity party. The Daily Texan. https://www.dailytexanonline.com/2015/02/09/guests-wear-ponchos-sombreros-and-construction-gear-at-border-patrol-fraternity-party

Byrne

J. P.

(1991). Racial insults and free speech within the university. Georgetown Law Journal, 79, 399–443.

10.

Chemerinsky

Gillman

(2017). Free speech on campus. Yale University Press.

11.

Cole

E. R.

Harper

S. R.

(2017). Race and rhetoric: An analysis of college presidents’ statements on campus racial incidents. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 10(4), 318–333. https://doi.org/10.1037/dhe0000044

12.

Creswell

J. W.

(2007). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches (2nd ed.). Sage.

13.

Davis

Harris

J. C.

(2016). But we didn't mean it like that: A critical race analysis of campus responses to racial incidents. Journal of Critical Scholarship on Higher Education and Student Affairs, 2(1), 25–30.

14.

Delgado

(1982). Words that wound: A tort action for racial insults, epithets, and name-calling. Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, 17, 133–181.

15.

Delgado

(1994). First Amendment formalism is giving way to First Amendment legal realism. Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, 29, 169–174.

16.

Delgado

Stefancic

(2018). Must we defend Nazis? Why the First Amendment should not protect hate speech and white supremacy. New York University Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvf3w49r

17.

Dey

E. L.

Hurtado

(1996). Faculty attitudes toward regulating speech on college campuses. Review of Higher Education, 20(1), 15–32. https://doi.org/10.1353/rhe.1996.0007

18.

Dickter

C. L.

(2012). Confronting hate: Heterosexuals’ responses to anti-gay comments. Journal of Homosexuality, 59(8), 1113–1130. https://doi.org/10.1080/00918369.2012.712817

19.

DiMaggio

P. J.

Powell

W. W.

(1983). The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review, 48(2), 147–160. https://doi.org/10.2307/2095101

20.

Dion

K. L.

Earn

B. M.

Yee

P. H.

(2007). The experience of being a victim of prejudice: An experimental approach. International Journal of Psychology, 13(3), 197–214. https://doi.org/10.1080/00207597808246625

21.

Dowd

A. C.

Bensimon

E. M.

(2015). Engaging the “race question”: Accountability and equity in U.S. higher education. Teachers College Press.

22.

Dunn

A. H.

Sondel

Baggett

H. C.

(2019). “I don't want to come off as pushing an agenda”: How contexts shaped teachers’ pedagogy in the days after the 2016 U.S. presidential election. American Educational Research Journal, 56(2), 444–476. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831218794892

23.

Dunning

(2018, October 2). Crowd forms as YCT rallies in support of Supreme Court Justice nominee Brett Kavanaugh at West Mall. The Daily Texan. https://thedailytexan.com/2018/10/02/crowd-forms-as-yct-rallies-in-support-of-supreme-court-justice-nominee-brett-kavanaugh-at

24.

Edelman

L. B.

Suchman

M. C.

(1997). The legal environments of organizations. Annual Review of Sociology, 23(1), 479–515. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.soc.23.1.479

25.

Espinosa

L. L.

Crandall

J. R.

Wilkinson

(2018, April 9). Free speech and campus inclusion: A survey of college presidents. Higher Education Today. https://www.higheredtoday.org/2018/04/09/free-speech-campus-inclusion-survey-college-presidents/

26.

Fenves

(2017a, November 4). Fighting hate on campus. https://president.utexas.edu/messages/fighting-hate-on-campus-november-2017

27.

Fenves

(2017b, March 8). Message from President Fenves on campus climate and town hall. https://president.utexas.edu/messages/president-fenves-campus-climate-town-hall

28.

Fenves

(2017c, February 13). When some try to divide us, Longhorns stand together: Diversity and inclusion are among our top priorities. https://t.co/akWRkPitSG?amp=1 [Tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/gregfenves/status/831229419335327746

29.

Fenves

(2017d, March 8). Message on hate and bias incident policy. https://president.utexas.edu/messages-speeches-2017/hate-and-bias-incident-policy

30.

Fleming

(1984). Blacks in college: A comparative study of students’ success in Black and White institutions. Jossey-Bass.

31.

Fries-Britt

S. L.

Turner

(2001). Facing stereotypes: A case study of Black students on a White campus. Journal of College Student Development, 42, 420–429.

32.

Garces

L. M.

Bilyalov

(2019). Navigating the quicksand: How postsecondary administrators understand the influence of affirmative action developments on racial diversity work. Teachers College Record, 121(3), 1–40.

33.

Garces

L. M.

Cogburn

C. D.

(2015). Beyond declines in student body diversity: How campus level administrators understand a prohibition on race-conscious postsecondary admissions policies. American Educational Research Journal, 52(5), 828–860. https://doi.org/10.3102/0002831215594878

34.

Garces

L. M.

Jayakumar

U. M.

(2014). Dynamic diversity: Toward a contextual understanding of critical mass. Educational Researcher, 43(3), 115–124. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x14529814

35.

Garcia

C. E.

Amberg

Weise

Winborn

(2020). Institutional responses to events challenging campus climates: Examining power in language. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 13(4), 345–354. https://doi.org/10.1037/dhe0000130

36.

Gibson

(2017, May 3). Racist flyers appear around campus Tuesday. The Daily Texan. https://www.dailytexanonline.com/2017/05/03/racist-flyers-appear-around-campus-tuesday

37.

Goldstone

(2006). Integrating the 40 acres: The 5-year struggle for racial equality at the University of Texas. University of Georgia Press.

38.

Gould

J. B.

(2005). Speak no evil: The triumph of hate speech regulation. University of Chicago Press.

39.

Gurin

Nagda

B. A.

Zúñiga

(2013). Dialogue across difference: Practice, theory, and research on intergroup dialogue. Russell Sage Foundation.

40.

Gusa

D. L.

(2010). White institutional presence: The impact of Whiteness on campus climate. Harvard Educational Review, 80(4), 464–490. https://doi.org/10.17763/haer.80.4.p5j483825u110002

41.

Hartman

R. G.

(1993). Hateful expression and first amendment values: Towards a theory of constitutional constraint on hate speech at colleges and universities after R.A.V. v. St. Paul. Journal of College and University Law, 19, 343–371.

42.

Hays

D. G.

Singh

A. A.

(2012). Qualitative inquiry in clinical and educational settings. Guilford Press.

43.

Hurd

Plaut

V. C.

(2018). Diversity entitlement: Does diversity-benefits ideology undermine inclusion? Northwestern University Law Review, 112, 1605–1635.

44.

Hurtado

Milem

J. F.

Clayton-Pedersen

A. R.

Allen

W. R.

(1998). Enhancing campus climates for racial/ethnic diversity: Educational policy and practice. Review of Higher Education, 21(3), 279–302. https://doi.org/10.1353/rhe.1998.0003

45.

Hurtado

Milem

J. F.

Clayton-Pedersen

A. R.

Allen

W. R.

(1999). Enacting diverse learning environments: Improving the climate for racial/ethnic diversity in higher education. Jossey-Bass.

46.

Hutchens

N. H.

Fernandez

(2018). Searching for balance with student free speech: Campus speech zones, institutional authority, and legislative prerogatives. Belmont Law Review, 5(5), 103–127. https://repository.belmont.edu/lawreview/vol5/iss1/5

47.

James

(2020, January 27). Speech First targets campus policies in lawsuit against Iowa State University. Ames Today. https://amestoday.com/stories/524410293-speech-first-targets-campus-policies-in-lawsuit-against-iowa-state-university

48.

Jayakumar

U. M.

Garces

L. M.

Park

(2018). Reclaiming diversity: Advancing the next generation of diversity research toward racial equity. In Paulsen

M. B.

(Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (Vol. 33, pp. 11–79). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-72490-4_2

49.

Jayakumar

U. M.

Museus

S. D.

(2012). Mapping the intersection of campus cultures and equitable outcomes among racially diverse student populations. In Museus

S. D.

Jayakumar

U. M.

(Eds.), Creating campus cultures: Fostering success among racially diverse student populations (pp. 1–27). Routledge.

50.

Johnson

R. B.

Christensen

L. B.

(2017). Educational research: Quantitative, qualitative, and mixed approaches (4th ed.). Sage.

51.

Kaplin

W. A.

(1992). A proposed process for managing the First Amendment aspects of campus hate speech. Journal of Higher Education, 63(5), 517–538. https://doi.org/10.2307/1982092

52.

Karst

K. L.

(1990). Boundaries and reasons: Freedom of expression and the subordination of groups. University of Illinois Law Review, 1990(1), 95–149.

53.

Korte

(2020, July 22). Group sues UT-Austin on behalf of white students who say they were unfairly denied admission. Austin American-Statesman. https://www.statesman.com/story/news/courts/2020/07/22/group-sues-ut-austin-on-behalf-of-white-students-who-say-they-were-unfairly-denied-admission/113883272/

54.

LaBlanc

B. H.

Fernandez

Hutchens

Melear

K. B.

(2020). The contested campus: Aligning professional values, social justice, and free speech. National Association of Student Personnel Administrators.

55.

Lawrence

C. R.

III . (1990). If he hollers let him go: Regulating racist speech on campus. Duke Law Journal, 1990(3), 431–483. https://doi.org/10.2307/1372554

56.

Ledesma

M. C.

(2016). Complicating the binary: Toward a discussion of campus climate health. Journal Committed to Social Change on Race and Ethnicity, 2(1), 6–35. https://doi.org/10.15763/issn.2642-2387.2016.2.1.5-35

57.

Leonardo

Porter

R. K.

(2010). Pedagogy of fear: Toward a Fanonian theory of “safety” in race dialogue. Race Ethnicity and Education, 13(2), 139–157. https://doi.org/10.1080/13613324.2010.482898

58.

Leitner

J. B.

Hehman

Ayduk

Mendoza-Denton

(2016). Blacks’ death rate due to circulatory diseases is positively related to Whites’ explicit racial bias: A nationwide investigation using project implicit. Psychological Science, 27(10), 1299–1311. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797616658450

59.

Levy

D. J.

Heissel

J. A.

Richeson

J. A.

Adam

E. K.

(2016). Psychological and biological responses to race-based social stress as pathways to disparities in educational outcomes. American Psychologist, 71(6), 455–473. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0040322

60.

Lincoln

Y. S.

Guba

E. G.

(1985). Naturalistic inquiry. Sage.

61.

Lyle

(2018, October 3). Texas state leaders weigh in on YCT protest as students claim free speech violations. The Daily Texan. https://dailytexanonline.com/2018/10/03/texas-state-leaders-weigh-in-on-yct-protest-as-students-claim-free-speech-violations

62.

Marfin

(2017, February 13). UT removes anti-Muslim posters from campus. The Daily Texan. https://www.dailytexanonline.com/2017/02/13/ut-removes-anti-muslim-posters-from-campus

63.

Matsuda

M. J.

(1989). Public response to racist speech: Considering the victim's story. Michigan Law Review, 87(8), 2320–2381. https://doi.org/10.2307/1289306

64.

Maxwell

J. A.

(2013). Qualitative research design (3rd ed.). SAGE.

65.

Mayhew

M. J.

Caldwell

R. J.

Goldman

E. G.

(2011). Defining campus violence: A phenomenological analysis of community stakeholder perspectives. Journal of College Student Development, 52(3), 253–269. https://doi.org/10.1353/csd.2011.0045

66.

Meyertons

Marfin

(2017, April 4). Racist posters target Chinese community in campus buildings. The Daily Texan. https://thedailytexan.com/2017/04/04/racist-posters-target-chinese-community-in-campus-buildings

67.

Milem

J. F.

Chang

M. J.

Antonio

A. L.

(2005). Making diversity work on campus: A research-based perspective. Association of American Colleges and Universities.

68.

Miller

R. A.

Guida

Smith

Ferguson

S. K.

Medina

(2017). Free speech tensions: Responding to bias on college and university campuses. Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice, 55(1), 27–39. https://doi.org/10.1080/19496591.2017.1363051

69.

Miller

R. A.

Guida

Smith

Ferguson

Medina

(2018). A balancing act: Whose interests do bias response teams serve? Review of Higher Education, 42(1), 313–337. https://doi.org/10.1353/rhe.2018.0031

70.

Molin

(2017, June 29). 10 years: DDCE's biggest milestones. Access & Excellence, 4, 4–5. Division of Diversity and Community Engagement.

71.

Moore

W. L.

Bell

J. M.

(2017). The right to be racist in college: Racist speech, White institutional space, and the First Amendment. Law & Policy, 39(2), 99–120. https://doi.org/10.1111/lapo.12076

72.

Moore

W. L.

Bell

J. M.

(2019). The limits of community: Deconstructing the White framing of racist speech in universities. American Behavioral Scientist, 63(13), 1760–1775. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764219842615

73.

Mullen

Smyth

J. M.

(2004). Immigrant suicide rates as a function of ethnophaulisms: Hate speech predicts death. Psychosomatic Medicine, 66(3), 343–348. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.psy.0000126197.59447.b3

74.

Museus

S. D.

(2014). The culturally engaging campus environments (CECE) model: A new theory of success among racially diverse college student populations. In Paulsen

M. B.

(Ed.), Higher education: Handbook of theory and research (Vol. 29, pp. 189–227). Springer.

75.

Museus

S. D.

Jayakumar

U. M.

(2012). Creating campus cultures: Fostering success among racially diverse student populations. Routledge.

76.

Museus

S. D.

Ledesma

M. C.

Parker

T. L.

(2015). Racism and racial equity in higher education. ASHE Higher Education Report, 42(1), 1–112. https://doi.org/10.1002/aehe.20067

77.

Museus

S. D.

Nichols

A. H.

Lambert

A. D.

(2008). Racial differences in the effects of campus racial climate on degree completion: A structural equation model. Review of Higher Education, 32(1), 107–134. https://doi.org/10.1353/rhe.0.0030

78.

Nguyen

(2016, October 26). Anti-affirmative-action bake sale causes protest, sparks discussion. The Daily Texan. https://www.dailytexanonline.com/2016/10/26/anti-affirmative-action-bake-sale-causes-protest-sparks-discussion

79.

Nielsen

L. B.

(2002). Subtle, pervasive, harmful: Racist and sexist remarks in public as hate speech. Journal of Social Issues, 58(2), 265–280. https://doi.org/10.1111/1540-4560.00260

80.

Pearce

(2015, March 10). Is Oklahoma University frat's racist chant protected by 1st Amendment? Los Angeles Times. https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-oklahoma-fraternity-explainer-20150310-story.html#page=1

81.

PEN America. (2019). Chasm in the classroom: Campus free speech in a divided America. https://pen.org/chasm-in-the-classroom-campus-free-speech-in-a-divided-america/

82.

Ragin

C. C.

(1992). “Casing” and the process of social inquiry. In Ragin

C. C.

Becker

H. S.

(Eds.), What is a case? Exploring the foundations of social inquiry (pp. 217–226). Cambridge University Press.

83.

Ramlo

(2020). Free speech on US university campuses: Differentiating perspectives using Q methodology. Studies in Higher Education, 45(7), 1488–1506. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2018.1555700

84.

Rankin

S. R.

Reason

R. D.

(2005). Differing perceptions: How students of color and white students perceive campus climate for underrepresented groups. Journal of College Student Development, 46(1), 43–61. https://doi.org/10.1353/csd.2005.0008

85.

Roth

M. S.

(2019). Safe enough spaces: A pragmatist's approach to inclusion, free speech, and political correctness on college campuses. Yale University Press. https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300248722

86.

Slagter

(2019, October 29). University of Michigan ends Bias Response Team in free speech lawsuit settlement. MLive. https://www.mlive.com/news/ann-arbor/2019/10/university-of-michigan-ends-bias-response-team-in-free-speech-lawsuit-settlement.html

87.

Strossen

(1990). Regulating racist speech on campus: A modest approach. Duke Law Journal, 1990(3), 484–573. https://doi.org/10.2307/1372555

88.

Sun

J. C.

McClellan

G. S.

(2020). Student clashes on campus: A leadership guide to free speech. Routledge.

89.

Texas Senate Bill 18, 86h. Leg., R.S. (2019).

90.

Thomason

(2019, March 21). Here’s what Trump's executive order on free speech says. The Chronicle of Higher Education. https://www.chronicle.com/article/heres-what-trumps-executive-order-on-free-speech-says/

91.

Tienda

(2013). Diversity ≠ inclusion: Promoting integration in higher education. Educational Researcher, 42(9), 467–475. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X13516164

92.

University of Texas at Austin. (2016). The plan: Background. https://diversity.utexas.edu/actionplan/

93.

University of Texas at Austin. (2020, July 13). UT diversity initiatives will redefine campus symbolism and will recruit, support and retain top talent. https://news.utexas.edu/2020/07/13/ut-diversity-initiatives-will-redefine-campus-symbolism-and-will-recruit-support-and-retain-top-talent/

94.

University of Texas at Austin. (2021). Speech First settlement and disbanding of the CCRT. https://news.utexas.edu/key-issues/speech-first-settlement-and-disbanding-of-the-ccrt/

95.

Waldron

(2012). The harm in hate speech. Harvard University Press.

96.

Yin

R. K.

(2014). Case study research design and methods (5th ed.). SAGE.

97.

Young Conservatives of Texas at the University of Texas. (2018, October 3). For immediate release: Yesterday, Young Conservatives of Texas at the University of Texas protested in solidarity with Judge Brett Kavanaugh. We believe he has been victim to a farcical smear campaign intended to destroy his good name and legacy [Status update]. https://www.facebook.com/YCTUT/posts/10155696334000849