To explore the association between subjective experiences of drinking and alcohol-related risk perceptions.
Methods
The data Is based on a questionnaire with questions about beliefs, use habits and experiences of alcohol and tobacco sent to a random sample of 3,000 Swedes aged 18 to 70 years (response rate= 1,623 Individuals, or 54%). In this study, those respondents who had ever been drinking alcohol were Included (1,536 individuals). The data were analysed statistically by cross tabs and multiple logistic regression.
Results
With some exceptions, the results generally showed that differences In subjective experiences of drinking were related to risk perceptions of alcohol consumption. In particular, those who had more negative than positive subjective experiences of alcohol consumption had substantially higher risk perceptions than those who had more positive than negative experiences, controlling for alcohol consumption and potential confounders. There were also several significant differences between Individuals differently involved in alcohol consumption, net of subjective experiences.
Conclusions
Subjective experiences of alcohol consumption appear to be an important construct in relation to alcohol-related risk perceptions. To understand the link between personal experiences and risk perceptions pertaining to alcohol consumption, both objective measures of personal experiences and subjective measures should be considered.
AasH.N., & LeighB., & AndersenN., & JakobsenR. (1998): Two-year longitudinal study of alcohol expectancies and drinking among Norwegian adolescents.Addiction93(3): 373–383
2.
AgostinelliG., & MillerW. (1994): Drinking and thinking: how does personal drinking affect judgments of prevalence and risk?Journal of Studies on Alcohol55(3): 327–337
3.
ArielyD., & ZaubermanG. (2000): On the making of an experience: the effects of breaking and combining experiences on their overall evaluation.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making13(2): 219–232
BarnettJ., & BreakwellG.M. (2001): Risk perception and experience: Hazard personality profiles and individual differences.Risk Analysis21(1): 171–177
6.
BarronG., & LeiderS., & StackJ. (2008): The effect of safe experience on a warnings’ impact: sex, drugs and rock-n-roll.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes106(2): 125–142
7.
BenthinA.Slovic,P., & SeversonH. (1993): A psychometric study of adolescent risk perception.Journal of Adolescence16(2): 153–168
8.
BrewerN.T., & GibbonsF.X., & GerrardM., & ChapmanG.B., & McCaulK.D., & WeinsteinN.D. (2007): Meta-analysis of the relationship between risk perception and health behavior: the example of vaccination.Health Psychology26(2): 136–145
9.
DawsonD.A., & GrantB.F., & StinsonF.S., & ZhouY. (2005): Effectiveness of the de-rived Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT-C) in screening for alcohol use disorders and risk drinking in the US general population.Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research29(5): 844–854
10.
DenscombeM. (2001): Critical incidents and the perception of health risks: the experiences of young people in relation to their use of alcohol and tobacco.Health, Risk & Society3(3): 293–306
11.
GerrardM., & GibbonsF.X., & BenthinA.C., & HesslingR.M. (1996): A longitudinal study of the reciprocal nature of risk behaviors and cognitions in adolescence: What you do shapes what you think, and vice versa.Health Psychology15(5): 344–354
12.
GreeningL., & StoppelbeinL., & ChandlerC.C., & ElkinT.D. (2005): Predictors of children's and adolescent's risk perception.Journal of Pediatric Psychology30(5): 425–435
13.
Halpern-FelsherB., & MillsteinS.G., & EllenJ.M., & AdlerN.E., & TschannJ.M., & BiehlM. (2001): The role of behavioral experience in judging risks.Health Psychology20(2): 120–126
14.
Harmon-JonesE., & MillsJ. (Eds.). (1999): Cognitive dissonance: progress on a pivotal theory in social psychology.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
15.
HemmelsteinN. (1995): Adolescent marijuana use and perception of risk.Journal of Alcohol and Drug Education41(1): 1–15
16.
KarlssonP. (2006). Margins of prevention. On older adolescents’ positive and negative beliefs about illicit drug use.Stockholm: Stockholm University, Department of Social Work
17.
KilmerJ.R., & HuntS., & LeeC.M., & NeighborsC. (2007): Marijuana use, risk perception, and consequences: is perceived risk congruent with reality?Addictive Behaviors32(12): 3026–3033
18.
LeeC.M., & PatrickM.E., & NeighborsC., & LewisM.A., & TollisonS.J., & LarimerM.E. (2010): Exploring the role of positive and negative consequences in understanding perceptions and evaluations of individual drinking events.Addictive Behaviors35(8): 764–770
19.
LeighB.C., & StacyA.W. (2004): Alcohol expectancies and drinking in different age groups.Addiction99(2): 215–227
20.
MillerP.Chomcynova,P., & BeckF. (2009): Predicting teenage beliefs concerning the harm alcohol and cannabis may do in eight European countries.Journal of Substance Use14(6): 364–374
21.
MillsteinS., & Halpern-FelsherB. (2002): Perceptions of risk and vulnerability.Journal of Adolescent Health31(1): 10–27
22.
MäkeläK., & MustonenH. (2000): Relationships of drinking behaviour, gender and age with reported negative and positive experiences related to drinking.Addiction95(5): 727–736
23.
ParkC.L. (2004): Positive and negative consequences of alcohol consumption in college students.Addictive Behaviors29(2): 311–321
24.
PomerleauO.F., & PomerlauC.S., & NamenekR.J. (1998): Early experiences with tobacco among women smokers, ex-smokers, and never-smokers.Addiction93(4): 595–599
25.
Roe-BerningS., & StrakerG. (1997): The associations between illusions of invulnerability and exposure to trauma.Journal of Traumatic Stress10(2): 319–327
26.
RossowI. (2008). Alcohol consumption and discounting.Addiction Research and Theory16 (6): 572–584
27.
SimonsohnU., & KarlssonN., & LoewensteinG., & ArielyD. (2008): The tree of experience in the forest of information: Over-weighting experienced relative to observed information.Games and Economic Behavior62(1): 263–286
28.
SlaterM.D., & RasinskiK.A. (2005): Media exposure and attention as mediating variables influencing social judgments.Journal of Communication55(4): 810–827
29.
SlovicP. (2000a). Rejoinder: The perils of Viscusi's analyses of smoking risk perceptions.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making13 (2): 273–276
30.
SlovicP. (2000b). What does it mean to know a cumulative risk? Adolescents’ perceptions of short-term and long-term consequences of smoking.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making13 (2): 259–266
31.
Twigger-RossC.L., & BreakwellG.M. (1999): Relating risk experience, venturesomeness and risk perception.Journal of Risk Research2(1): 73–83
32.
ViscusiK.W. (1990). Do smokers underestimate risks?Journal of Political Economy98 (6): 1253–1269
33.
ViscusiW.K. (2000). Comment: The perils of qualitative smoking risk measures.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making13 (2): 267–271
34.
WeinsteinN.D. (1989): Effects of personal experience on self-protective behaviour.Psychological Bulletin105(1): 31–50
35.
WeinsteinN.D. (1998): Accuracy of smokers’ risk perceptions.Annals of Behavioral Medicine20(2): 135–140
36.
WeinsteinN.D. (1993): Testing four competing theories of health protective behaviour.Health Psychology (12): 324–333.
