Suicide is a major issue in surgically treated epileptic patients. A meta-analysis was performed comparing suicides in a sample of such patients and in the general population. The Index Medicus and the World Health Statistics Annual were searched to ascertain the suicide rates in the age groups indicated in the studies of epileptic patients for specific years and country. 11 studies were selected, comprising 2,425 patients, 24 of whom committed suicide. Data obtained for each study were processed together to calculate the mean number of suicides per 100,000 individuals with surgically treated epilepsy for each year. This meta-analysis shows that suicide in patients with epilepsy after surgical treatment is more frequent than in the general population. Results are discussed with particular attention to possible causative factors.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AltshulerL. L.DevinskyO.PostR. M.TheodoreW. (1990) Depression, anxiety, and temporal lobe epilepsy: laterality of focus and symptoms. Archives of Neurology, 47, 284–288.
2.
American Psychiatric Association. (2003) Practice guideline for the assessment and treatment of patients with suicidal behaviors. American Journal of Psychiatry, 160(Suppl.), 1–97.
3.
BaileyP. (1961) Surgical treatment of psychomotor epilepsy: five year follow-up. Southern Medical Journal, 54, 299–301.
4.
BaldessariniR. J.PompiliM.TondoL. (2006) Suicide risk in antidepressant trials. Archives of General Psychiatry, 63, 246–248.
5.
BaldessariniR. J.PompiliM.TondoL.TsapakisE.SoldaniE.FreddaG. L.HennenJ. (2005) Antidepressants and suicidal behavior: are we hurting or helping?Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 2, 73–75.
6.
BarracloughB. M. (1987) The suicide rate of epilepsy. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 76, 339–345.
7.
BladinP. F. (1992) Psychosocial difficulties and outcome after temporal lobectomy. Epilepsia, 33, 898–907.
8.
BlumerD.MontourisG.DaviesK.WylerA.PhillipsB.HermannB. (2002) Suicide in epilepsy: psychopathology, pathogenesis, and prevention. Epilepsy & Behavior, 3, 232–241.
9.
BlumerD.WakhluS.DaviesK.HermannB. (1998) Psychiatric outcome of temporal lobectomy for epilepsy: incidence and treatment of psychiatric complications. Epilepsia, 39, 478–486.
10.
BulpittC. J. (1988) Meta-analysis. Lancet, 2, 93–94.
11.
BurtonL. A.LabarD. (1999) Emotional status after right vs. left temporal lobectomy. Seizure, 8, 116–119.
12.
CamfieldC. S.CamfieldP. R.VeugelersP. J. (2002) Death in children with epilepsy: a population-based study. Lancet, 359, 1891–1895.
13.
ChovazC. J.McLachlanR. S.DerryP. A.CummingsA. L. (1994) Psychosocial function following temporal lobectomy: influence of seizure control and learned helplessness. Seizure, 3, 171–176.
14.
CockerellO. C.JohnsonA. L.SanderJ. W.HartY. M.GoodridgeD. M. (1994) Mortality from epilepsy results from a prospective population-based study. Lancet, 344, 918–921.
15.
EngelJ.Jr. (1989) Seizures and epilepsy. Philadelphia, PA: Davis.
16.
EngelJ.Jr. (1993) Update on surgical treatment of the epilepsies: summary of the Second International Palm Desert Conference on the Surgical Treatment of the Epilepsies (1992)Neurology, 43, 1612–1617.
17.
EngelJ.Jr. (1996) Surgery for seizures. The New England Journal of Medicine, 334, 647–652.
18.
EngelJ.Jr. (1998) Etiology as a risk factor for medically refractory epilepsy: a case for early surgical intervention. Neurology, 51, 1243–1244.
19.
FenwickP. (1993) Postscript: what should be included in a standard psychiatric assessment? In EngelJ.Jr. (Ed.), Surgical treatment of the epilepsies. New York: Raven Press. Pp. 706–709.
20.
FenwickP. B. C.BlumerD.CaplanR.FergusonS. M.SavardG.VictoroffJ. I. (1993) Presurgical psychiatric assessment. In EngelJ.Jr. (Ed.), Surgical treatment of the epilepsies. New York: Raven Press. Pp. 273–280.
21.
Flor-HenryP. (1983) Determinants of psychosis in epilepsy: laterality and forced normalization. Biological Psychiatry, 18, 1045–1057.
22.
GoldbergD. P. (1972) The detection of psychiatric illness by questionnaire. London: Oxford Univer. Press.
23.
GuldvogB.LoyningY.Hauglie-HanssenE.FloodS.BjornaesH. (1994a) Surgical treatment for partial epilepsy among Norwegian children and adolescents. Epilepsia, 35, 554–565.
24.
GulvogB.LoyningY.Hauglie-HanssenE.FloodS.BjornaesH. (1994b) Surgical treatment for partial epilepsy among Norwegian adults. Epilepsia, 35, 540–553.
25.
HarrisE. C.BarracloughB. (1997) Suicide as an outcome for mental disorders: a meta-analysis. British Journal of Psychiatry, 170, 205–228.
26.
HawtonK.FaggJ.MarsackP. (1980) Association between epilepsy and attempted suicide. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 43, 168–170.
27.
HennessyM. J.LanganY.ElwesR. D.BinnieC. D.PolkeyC. E.NashefL. (1999) A study of mortality after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery. Neurology, 53, 1276–1283.
28.
HermannB. P.WhitmanS.WylerA. R.AntonM. T.VanderzwaggR. (1990) Psychosocial predictors of psychopathology in epilepsy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 156, 98–105.
29.
HermannB. P.WylerA. R.SomesG. (1992) Preoperative psychological adjustment and surgical outcome are determinants of psychosocial status after anterior temporal lobectomy. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 55, 491–496.
30.
HorowitzM. J.CohenF. M. (1968) Temporal lobe epilepsy: effect of lobectomy on psychosocial functioning. Epilepsia, 9, 23–41.
31.
HovorkaJ.HermanE.NemocováI. I. (2000) Treatment of interictal depression with citalopram in patients with epilepsy. Epilepsy & Behavior, 1, 444–447.
32.
JacobsD. G. (Ed.) (1998) The Harvard Medical School guide to suicide assessment and intervention. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
33.
JallonP. (2004) Mortality in patients with epilepsy. Current Opinion in Neurology, 17, 141–146.
34.
JanzD. (1969) Die Epilepsien: spezielle Pathologie und Therapie. Stuttgart: George Thieme.
35.
JensenI. (1975) Temporal lobe epilepsy: late mortality in patients treated with unilateral temporal lobe resection. Acta Neurologica Scandinavica, 52, 374–380.
36.
JensenI.LarsenJ. K. (1979) Mental aspects of temporal lobe epilepsy: follow-up of 74 patients after resection of a temporal lobe. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 42, 256–265.
37.
JonesJ. E.HermannB. P.BarryJ. J.GilliamF. G.KannerA. M.MeadorK. J. (2003) Rates and risk factors for suicide, suicidal ideation, and suicide attempts in chronic epilepsy. Epilepsy & Behavior, 4(Suppl.), S31–S38.
38.
KanemotoK.KawasakiJ.MoriE. (1999) Violence and epilepsy: a close relationship between violence and postictal psychosis. Epilepsia, 40, 107–109.
39.
KannerA. M.KozakA. M.MarlisM. (2000) The use of sertraline in patients with epilepsy: is it safe?Epilepsy & Behavior, 1, 100–105.
40.
KaufmanK. R.SaucedoC.SchaefferJ.LevesqueM.ScannellT.GloubermanM. (1996) Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) for intractable depression following epilepsy neurosurgery. Seizure, 5, 307–312.
KimY. H.KimH. I. (1995) Assessing quality of life for the measurement of outcome after epilepsy surgery. Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, 49(Suppl.), S304–S305.
KrahnL. E.RummansT. A.PetersonG. C.CascinoG. D.MackayA. (1979) Self-poisoning, a complication of epilepsy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 277–282.
45.
KwanP.BrodieM. J. (2000) Epilepsy after the first drug fails: substitution or add-on?Seizure, 9, 464–468.
46.
MackayA. (1979) Self-poisoning—a complication of epilepsy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 277–282.
47.
MalmgrenK.SullivanM.EkstedtG.KullbergG.KumlienE. (1997) Health-related quality of life after epilepsy surgery: a Swedish multicenter study. Epilepsia, 38, 830–838.
48.
MatthewsW. S.BarabasG. (1981) Suicide and epilepsy: a review of the literature. Psychosomatics, 22, 515–524.
49.
McLachlanR. S.RoseK. J.DerryP. A.BonnarC.BlumeW. T.GirvinJ. P. (1997) Health-related quality of life and seizure control in temporal lobe epilepsy. Annals of Neurology, 41, 482–489.
50.
MendezM. F.DossR. C. (1992) Ictal and psychiatric aspects of suicide in epileptic patients. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 22, 231–237.
51.
MendezM. F.LanskaD. J.Manon-EspaillatR.BurnstineT. H. (1989) Causative factors for suicide attempts by overdose in epileptics. Archives of Neurology, 46, 1065–1068.
52.
MonkM. (1987) Epidemiology of suicide. Epidemiologic Reviews9, 51–69.
53.
MoscickiE. K. (1997) Identification of suicide risk factors using epidemiologic studies. Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 20, 499–517.
54.
NilssonL.AhlbomA.FarahmandB. Y.AsbergM.TomsonT. (2002) Risk factors for suicide in epilepsy: a case control study. Epilepsia, 43, 644–651.
55.
PerrineK.HermannB. P.MeadorK. J.VickreyB. G.CramerJ. A.HaysR. D.DevinskyO. (1995) The relationship of neuropsychological functioning to quality of life in epilepsy. Archives of Neurology, 52, 997–1003.
56.
PilcherW. H.RobertoD. W.FlaniginH. E.CrandallP. H.WieserH. G.OjemannG. A. (1993) Complications of epilepsy surgery. In EngelJ.Jr. (Ed.), Surgical treatment of epilepsies. New York: Raven Press. Pp. 565–581.
57.
PompiliM.GirardiP.RubertoA.TatarelliR. (2005) Suicide in the epilepsies: a meta-analytic investigation of 29 cohorts. Epilepsy & Behavior, 7, 305–310.
58.
PompiliM.MancinelliI.TatarelliR. (2003) Stigma as a cause of suicide. British Journal of Psychiatry, 183, 173–174.
59.
PompiliM.TondoL.BaldessariniR. J. (2005) Suicidal risk emerging during antidepressant treatment: recognition and intervention. Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 2, 66–72.
60.
QuiggM.BroshekD. K.Heidal-SchiltzS.MaedgenJ. W.BertramE. H. (2003) Depression in intractable partial epilepsy varies by laterality of focus and surgery. Epilepsia, 44, 419–424.
61.
RauschR.CrandellP. H. (1982) Psychological status related to surgical control of temporal lobe seizures. Epilepsia, 23, 191–202.
62.
RegisJ.ReyM.BartolomeiE.VladykaV.LiscakR.SchrottnerO.PendlG. (2004) Gamma knife surgery in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy: a prospective multicenter study. Epilepsia, 45, 504–515.
63.
RingH. A.MoriartyJ.TrimbleM. R. (1998) A prospective study of the early postsurgical psychiatric associations of epilepsy surgery. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 64, 601–604.
64.
RobertsonM. M. (1997) Suicide, parasuicide, and epilepsy. In EngelJ.Jr.PedleyT. A. (Eds.), Epilepsy: a comprehensive textbook. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott-Raven. Pp. 2141–2151.
65.
RoseK. J.DerryP. A.WiebeS.McLachlanR. S. (1996) Determinants of health-related quality of life after temporal lobe epilepsy surgery. Quality of Life Research, 5, 395–402.
66.
RyvlinP.KahaneP. (2003) Does epilepsy surgery lower the mortality of drug-resistant epilepsy?Epilepsy Research, 56, 105–120.
67.
SalanovaV.MarkandO.WorthR. (2002) Temporal lobe epilepsy surgery: outcome, complications, and late mortality rate in 215 patients. Epilepsia, 43, 170–174.
68.
SavardG.AndermannE.OlivierA.RemillardG. M. (1991) Postictal psychosis after partial complex seizures: a multiple case study. Epilepsia, 32, 225–231.
69.
SchmidtD.BertramE.RyvlinP.LüdersH. O. (2003) The impact of temporal lobe surgery on cure and mortality of drug-resistant epilepsy: summary of a workshop. Epilepsy Research, 56, 83–84.
70.
Seidman-RipleyJ. G.BoundV. K.AndermannE.OlivierA.GloorP.FeindelW. H. (1993) Psychosocial consequences of postoperative seizure relief. Epilepsia, 34, 248–254.
71.
SharbroughF. W. (1993) Electroconvulsive therapy for depression after temporal lobectomy for epilepsy. Convulsive Therapy, 9, 217–219.
72.
ShneidmanE. S. (1985) Definition of suicide. Northvale, NJ: Aronson.
73.
ShneidmanE. S. (1993) Suicide as psychache: a clinical approach to self-destructive behavior. Northvale, NJ: Aronson.
74.
SperlingM. R.FeldmanH.KinmanJ.LiporaceJ. D.O'ConnorM. J. (1999) Seizure control and mortality in epilepsy. Annals of Neurology, 46, 45–50.
75.
StepienL.BidzinskiJ.MazurowskiW. (1969) The results of surgical treatment of temporal lobe epilepsy. Polish Medical Journal, 8, 1184–1190.
76.
StevensJ. R. (1975) Interictal clinical manifestations of complex partial seizures. In PennyJ. K.DalyD. D. (Eds.), Advances in neurology, complex partial seizures and their treatment. Vol. 11. New York: Raven. Pp. 85–112.
77.
StraussE.WadaI. (1991) Psychiatric and psychosocial changes associated with anterior temporal lobectomy. In DevinskyO.TheodoreW. H. (Eds.), Epilepsy and behavior. New York: Wiley. Pp. 135–149.
78.
TaylorD. C. (1972) Mental state and temporal lobe epilepsy: a correlative account of 100 patients treated surgically. Epilepsia, 13, 727–765.
79.
TaylorD. C. (1993) Psychiatric and social issues in measuring the input and outcome of epilepsy surgery. In EngelJ.Jr. (Ed.), Surgical treatment of the epilepsies. New York: Raven.
80.
TaylorD. C.FalconerM. (1968) Clinical, socio-economic and psychological changes after temporal lobectomy for epilepsy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 114, 1247–1261.
81.
TaylorD. C.MarshS. (1977) Implications of long-term follow-up studies in epilepsy: with a note of the cause of death. In PennyJ. K. (Ed.), Epilepsy, the Eighth International Symposium. New York: Raven. Pp. 27–34.
82.
TheodoreW. H. (1991) What is uncontrolled epilepsy and who should be referred for epilepsy surgery? In SpencerS. S.SpencerD. D. (Eds.), Surgery for epilepsy. Bambridge, UK: Blackwell. Pp. 3–17.
83.
TrimbleM. R. (1992) Behaviour changes following temporal lobectomy, with special reference to psychosis. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 55, 89–91.
84.
VickreyB. G.HaysR. D.GraberJ.RauschR.EngelJ.Jr.BrookR. H. (1992) A health-related quality of life instrument for patients evaluated for epilepsy surgery. Medical Care, 30, 299–319.
85.
WilliamsD. (1956) The structure of emotions reflected in epileptic experiences. Brain, 79, 29–67.
86.
WilsonS. J.SalingM. M.LawrenceJ.BladinP. F. (1999) Outcome of temporal lobectomy: expectations and the prediction of perceived success. Epilepsy Research, 36, 1–14.
87.
World Health Organization. (2000) Figures and facts about suicide (adaptation of the 1999 document). Geneva: WHO.
88.
WrenchJ.WilsonS. J.BladinP. F. (2004) Mood disturbance before and after seizure surgery: a comparison of temporal and extratemporal resections. Epilepsia, 45, 534–543.
