Alternative interpretations of events leading to war with Japan in 1941 were evaluated. The standard version of the events was preferred by 31 of the 90 subjects who were enlisted to participate in the study by 20 students. The version of the events describing this story within the framework of the influence of Western colonization on the cultures of the countries of the Far East was endorsed by 50 subjects. Of the 90 subjects 9 were undecided. The major underlying issues were described based on content analysis of these subjects' responses.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABC television 20/20 broadcast, November 22, 1991, transcript 1149.
2.
BernasT. G. (Ed.) (1977) The American adventure. Vol. 2. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. Pp. C21–C22.
3.
BernsteinB. J. (1975) Roosevelt, Truman, and the atomic bomb: a reinterpretation. Political Science Quarterly, 90, 23–62.
4.
BernsteinB. J. (1995) Understanding the atomic bomb and the Japanese surrender. Diplomatic History, (Spring Issue), 263–266.
5.
GrewJ. C. (1942) Speech of the former United States ambassador to Japan Joseph C. Grew upon his return to Washington. Department of State Bulletin, August 29.
6.
HasegawaM. (1984) A postwar view of the Great East Asia war. Japan Echo, 11, 29–37.
7.
Hirohito, Emperor. (1945) Emperor Hirohito's broadcast to the Japanese people on surrender. New York Times, August 16, p. 1.
8.
HornP. V. (1941) Effects of allied economic blockade on Japan. The Conference Board Economic Record, II: 22, November 25.
9.
House Documents. (1943) Papers pertaining to foreign relations of the United States: Japan, 1931–1941. House Documents No. 339. United States Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
10.
House Documents. (1944) Events leading up to World War II: chronological history, 1931–1944. House Document No. 541. United States Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
11.
Joint Army-Navy Board. (1941) Aircraft requirements of the Chinese government. Joint Army-Navy Board Paper 355, Serial 691, July 18. National Archives, Washington, DC.
12.
KrauthammerC. (1995) History hijacked. Time, February 13, 145, 6, p. 90.
13.
KurusuS. (1942) Radio Tokyo Broadcast. Foreign Broadcast Intelligence Service, Federal Communications Commission, November 26.
14.
LinenthalE. (1995) Personal interview with Philip Nobile. Quoted in Nobile, 1995, p. 272.
15.
LobdellG. H. (1989) Culprits or scapegoats? Some views on Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. In CogarW. B. (Ed.), New interpretations in naval history. Annapolis, MD: Naval Institute Press. Pp. 247–278.
16.
NobileP. (1995) Judgment at the Smithsonian: the uncensored script of the Smithsonian's 50th anniversary exhibit of the Enola Gay. New York: Marlowe. P. 3.
17.
SlackmanM. (1990) Target: Pearl Harbor. Honolulu, HI: Univer. of Hawaii Press.
18.
Suzuki. (1945) Radio Tokyo Broadcast. Foreign Broadcast Intelligence Service, Federal Communications Commission, June 11.
19.
TolandJ. (1982) Infamy: Pearl Harbor and its aftermath. New York: Doubleday.
