A series of questions, generated by Rotton and Kelly in response to Cyr and Kalpin's refutation of literature reviews which recommended that attempts to validate the lunar hypothesis be terminated, are addressed. We maintain that it is preferable for researchers to question whether any hypothesis is deemed tenable only after the most advanced methodologies and statistical analyses have been applied rather than to stop all investigations in an area based on results generated by a series of methodologically inconsistent studies which were analyzed inappropriately.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CampbellD. E.BeetsJ. L. (1978) Lunacy and the moon. Psychological Bulletin, 85, 1123–1129.
2.
CyrJ. J.KalpinR. A. (1987) The lunar-lunacy relationship: a poorly evaluated hypothesis. Psychological Reports, 61, 391–400.
3.
GottmanJ. M. (1981) Time-series analysis: a comprehensive introduction for social scientists. New York: Cambridge Univer. Press.
4.
KellyI. W.RottonJ.CulverR. (1985–86) The moon was full and nothing happened: a review of studies on the moon and human behavior and lunar beliefs. The Skeptical Inquirer, 10, 129–143.
5.
LieberA. L. (1978) The lunar effect: biological tides and human emotions. New York: Anchor Press/Doubleday.
6.
LykkenD. T. (1968) Statistical significance in psychological research. Psychological Bulletin, 70, 151–159.
7.
McDowallD.McClearyR.MeidingerE. E.HayR. A.Jr. (1980) Interrupted time series analysis. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publ.
8.
OsbornR. D. (1968) The moon and the mental hospital: an investigation of one area of folklore. Journal of Psychiatric Nursing, 6, 88–93.
9.
OstromC. W.Jr. (1978) Time series analysis: regression techniques. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publ.
10.
RottonJ.KellyI. W. (1985) A scale for assessing belief in lunar effects: reliability and concurrent validity. Psychological Reports, 57, 239–245.
11.
RottonJ.KellyI. W. (1988) Comment on “The lunar-lunacy relationship”: more ado about the full moon. Psychological Reports, 61, 733–734.
12.
RottonJ.KellyI. W.ElorteguiP. (1986) Assessing belief in lunar effects: known groups validation. Psychological Reports, 59, 171–174.
13.
SanduleakN. (1985) The moon is acquitted of murder in Cleveland. The Skeptical Inquirer, 9, 236–242.
14.
StartupM. J.RussellJ. H. (1985) Lunar effects on personality test scores: a failure to replicate. Personality and Individual Differences, 6, 267–269.
15.
WilliamsE. A.GottmanJ. M. (1982) A user's guide to the Gottman-Williams time-series analysis computer programs for social scientists. New YorkCambridge Univer. Press.
