Abstract
Evolutionary explanations of human social behavior are increasing in popularity among social scientists. Unfortunately, many psychologists are ill-equipped to argue for or against evolutionary explanations. While numerous examples of inappropriate evolutionary analyses exist, the present article focuses upon one which is a subtle yet profound distortion in the service of maintaining the status quo of individual psychology. We hope our analysis will encourage others to be cautious when applying evolutionary principles to the psychological domain.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allen
L.
Sociobiology—another biological determinism . Bioscience , 1976 , 26 , 182 –186 .
2.
Barash
D. P.
Sociobiology and behavior . (2nd ed. ) New York : Elsevier , 1982 .
3.
Bixler
R. H.
Incest avoidance as a function of environment and heredity . Current Anthropology , 1981 , 22 , 639 –654 . (a)
4.
Bixler
R. H.
The incest controversy . Psychological Reports , 1981 , 49 , 267 –283 . (b)
5.
Danheiser
P. R.
Graziano
W. G.
Self-monitoring and cooperation as a self-presentational strategy . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 1982 , 42 , 497 –505 .
6.
Dawkins
R.
The selfish gene . Oxford : Oxford Univer. Press , 1976 .
7.
Gill
F. B.
Wolf
L. L.
Economics of feeding territoriality in golden-winged sunbird . Ecology , 1975 , 56 , 333 –345 .
8.
Hamilton
W. D.
The genetical evolution of social behaviour: I and II . Journal of Theoretical Biology , 1964 , 7 , 1 –52 .
9.
Hausfater
G.
Dominance and reproduction in baboons (Papio cynocephalus): a quantitative analysis . Contributions in Primatology , 1975 , 7 , 1 –150 .
10.
Hrdy
S. B.
The langurs of Abu . Cambridge, MA : Harvard Univer. Press , 1977 .
11.
Huber
R.
Lomax
S.
Robinson
S.
Huber
P.
Evolution: struggle or synergy? Journal of Individual Psychology , 1978 , 34 , 210 –220 .
12.
Kuhn
T. S.
The structure of scientific revolutions . (2nd ed. ) Chicago : Univer. of Chicago Press , 1970 .
13.
Leak
G. K.
Christopher
S. B.
Empathy from an evolutionary perspective . Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour , 1982 , 12 , 79 –82 . (a)
14.
Leak
G. K.
Christopher
S. B.
Freudian psychoanalysis and sociobiology: a synthesis . American Psychologist , 1982 , 37 , 313 –322 . (b)
15.
Piliavin
T. A.
Piliavin
I. M.
Effect of blood on reactions to a victim . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 1972 , 23 , 353 –361 .
16.
Trivers
R. L.
The evolution of reciprocal altruism . Quarterly Review of Biology , 1971 , 46 , 35 –57 .
17.
Wiens
J. A.
Group selection and Wynne-Edwards' hypothesis . American Scientist , 1966 , 54 , 273 –287 .
18.
Williams
G. C.
Adaptation and natural selection . Princeton, NJ : Princeton Univer. Press , 1966 .
19.
Wilson
E. O.
Sociobiology: the new synthesis . Cambridge, MA : Belknap Press , 1975 .
20.
Wilson
E. O.
Academic vigilantism and the political significance of sociobiology . Bioscience , 1976 , 26 , 183 –190 .
21.
Wynne-Edwards
V. C.
Animal dispersion in relation to social behaviour . New York : Hafner , 1962 .