Dyslexia Subtype with Simultaneous Processing of Intraobject Spatial Relations in an “Ecological Syndrome”

Abstract

Three interrelated phenomena of a global visuospatial representation are discussed within the context of a subtype of “spatial dyslexia” as part of an “ecological syndrome.” (1) Results from a new test, Draw-A-Person-With-Face-In-Front (using simple measurement and requiring no graphic or aesthetic skills) showed in a third of 269 Australian Aboriginal school children a deficient representation of spatial relations within the natural pattern of the upper part of the human face. (2) The test performance apparently is an indicator of a similarly deficient representation of the spatial relations within written signs (single letters, short, isolated functional words, and novel or “nonwords” lacking strong semantic association and imageability). The test discriminates between two modes of visuospatial pictorial (and implied mental) representation, a simultaneous and merely “inter object”-related global kind vs a successive and “intraobject”-related one. Further support for such conceptualizing is found in a positive correlation between certain low literacy skills and the specific results (in 6000 examined cases) on the new drawing test. Both inabilities implicate a simultaneous global mode of visuospatial processing, which early in life promptly elicits the infants' in discriminate automatic “smiling response” and appears to be resorted to still later in life by persons with “spatial dyslexia.” (3) Such conceptualizing interrelates with the so far puzzling difference between “literal alexia” vs “verbal alexia” known to neuropathology (not implicated in the present cases but pointing to an underlying structuring process shared by pathological and by “ecological syndromes” alike).

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bodamer

Die Prosop-Agnosie des Physiognomieerkennens. [Prosopagnosia for the recognition of the physiognomy.]

Arch. Psychiat. Nervenkr., 1947, 6, 179–188.

Critchley

The dyslexic child. Springfield, IL: Thomas, 1970.

Cole

, & Scribner

Cross-cultural studies of memory and cognition. In Kail

R. V.

& Hagen

J. W.

(Eds.), Perspectives on the development of memory and cognition. New York: Wiley, 1977. Pp. 239–271.

Das

J. P.

Kirby

, & Jarman

R. F.

Simultaneous and successive synthesis: an alternative model for cognitive abilities. Psychol. Bull., 1975, 82, 87–103.

Davidson

G. R.

An ethnographic psychology of Aboriginal cognitive ability. Oceania, 1979, 49, 270–294.

Davidson

G. R.

Australian Aboriginal spatial cognition and dyslexia: a criticism of Pontius (1982). Percept, mot. Skills, 1984, 58, 627–634.

Davidson

G. R.

The myth of “ecological dyslexia:” a reply to Pontius (1984). Percept. mot. Skills, 1985, 60, 125–126.

Davidson

G. R.

, & Klich

L. Z.

Toward a recognition of Australian Aboriginal competence in cognitive functions. In Kirby

J. R.

(Ed.), Cognitive strategies and educational performance. New York: Academic Press, 1984. Pp. 155–292.

Faglioni

Scotti

, & Spinner

Impaired recognition of written letters following unilateral hemispheric damage. Cortex, 1969, 5, 120–133.

10.

Ganz

Innate and environmental factors in the development of visual form perception. In Held

Leibowitz

H. W.

, & Teuber

H. L.

(Eds.), Handbook of sensory physiology. Vol. 8. Perception. New York: Springer, 1978. Pp. 593–608.

11.

Gibson

E. J.

Gibson

J. J.

Pick

A. D.

, & Osser

H. A.

A developmental study of letter-like forms. J. comp. physiol. Psychol., 1962, 55, 897–906.

12.

Gibson

E. J.

, & Levin

The psychology of reading. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, 1975.

13.

Hanson

N. R.

The origin of hypothetico-deductive explanations. In Tweney

R. D.

Doherty

M. D.

, & Mynatt

C. R.

(Eds.), On scientific thinking. New York: Columbia Univer. Press, 1981. Pp. 305–312.

14.

Hayek

F. A.

The theory of complex phenomena. In Bunge

(Ed.), The critical approach to science and philosophy. London: Free Press of Glencoe, Collier & Macmillan, 1964. Pp. 332–349.

15.

Hofstadter

D. R.

Goedel, Escher, Bach. New York: Basic Books, 1979.

16.

Jahoda

Deutsch

, & Cook

S. W.

Research methods in social relations. Part II: Selected techniques. New York: Dryden, 1958.

17.

Kearins

Visual memory skills of Western desert and Queensland children of Australian Aboriginal descent, a reply to Drinkwater. Austral. J. Psychol., 1978, 30, 1–5.

18.

Lewin

Extinction threatens Australian anthropology. Science, 1984, 225, 393–394.

19.

Lewis

Observations on route finding and spatial orientation among the Aboriginal peoples of the Western Desert region of Central Australia. Oceania, 1976, 46, 249–282.

20.

Luria

A. R.

Higher cortical functions in man. New York: Basic Books, 1980.

21.

Podgorny

, & Garner

W. R.

Reaction time as a measure of inter- and intraobject visual similarity: letters of the alphabet. Percep. & Psychophys., 1979, 26, 37–52.

22.

Pontius

A. A.

Developmental phases in visual recognition of the human face pattern, exemplified by the ‘smiling response.’

Experientia, 1975, 31, 126–129.

23.

Pontius

A. A.

Dyslexia and specifically distorted drawings of the face—a new subgroup with prosopagnosia-like signs. Experientia, 1976, 32, 1432–1435.

24.

Pontius

A. A.

Body schema representations by wigmen of the Western Highlands of New Guinea: culturally determined scatter in some cortical functions of gnosis and praxia. J. Amer. Med. Womens' Assn, 1977, 32, 247–252.

25.

Pontius

A. A.

Pre-literate people in New Guinea and Indonesia draw specifically distorted faces, as do ‘Western’ dyslexics, using a paleo-visual representational mode. Experientia, 1980, 36, 83–86.

26.

Pontius

A. A.

Geometric figure-rotation task and face representation in dyslexia: role of spatial relations and orientation. Percept, mot. Skills, 1981, 53, 607–614.

27.

Pontius

A. A.

Face representation linked with literacy level in colonial American tombstone engravings and in Third World pre-literates' drawings: toward a cultural-evolutional neurology. Experientia, 1982, 38, 577–581. (a)

28.

Pontius

A. A.

Global spatial relations in face representation shown in “ecological dyslexia” of Australian Aboriginals and in “Western” dyslexics. Percept, mot. Skills, 1982, 55, 1191–1200. (b)

29.

Pontius

A. A.

Finger misrepresentation and dyscalculia in an ecological context: toward an ecological (cultural) evolutionary neuropsychiatry. Percept, mot. Skills, 1983, 57, 1191–1208. (a)

30.

Pontius

A. A.

Links between literacy skills and accurate spatial relations in representations of the face: comparison of preschoolers, school children, dyslexics, and mentally retarded. Percept, mot. Skills, 1983, 57, 659–666. (b)

31.

Pontius

A. A.

Pictorial misrepresentation of spatial relations of the face by certain chronic alcoholic men: an interpretation implicating spatial aspects of memory. Percept, mot. Skills, 1983, 57, 895–910. (c)

32.

Pontius

A. A.

Model of ecological (cultural) evolutionary neuropsychiatry. Percept. mot. Skills, 1984, 58, 143–148. (a)

33.

Pontius

A. A.

Representation of spatial relations on the specific test, Draw-A-Person-With-Face-In-Front, as indicative of literacy skills in Australian Aboriginals and “Westerners.”

Percept, mot. Skills, 1984, 59, 275–284. (b)

34.

Pontius

A. A.

Spatial aspects of memory implicated in face drawing of alcoholic men. Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sciences, 1985, 444, 297–300.

35.

Sasanuma

, & Fujimura

Selective impairment of phonetic and non-phonetic transcription of words in Japanese aphasic patients; kana vs kanji in visual recognition and writing. Cortex, 1971, 7, 1–18.

36.

Schmitz

C. A.

Oceanic art. New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1969.

37.

Sevush

, & Heilman

K. M.

A case of literal alexia: evidence for a disconnection syndrome. Brain & Lang., 1984, 22, 92–108.

38.

Varney

N. R.

Letter recognition and visual form discrimination in aphasic alexia. Neuropsychologia, 1981, 19, 795–800.

39.

Vellutino

F. R.

Dyslexia: theory and research. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1981.

40.

Werner

Comparative psychology of mental development. New York: International Universities Press, 1957. (Original 1948)

41.

Wolff

P. H.

Critical periods in human cognitive development. In Chess

, & Thomas

(Eds.), Annual progress in child psychiatry and development. New York: Brunner & Matzel, 1971. Pp. 155–165.