Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

Medical examiners provide critical diagnostic and testimonial information in abusive head trauma cases. Courtroom challenges to these diagnostic criteria and contested expert testimony have raised concerns about ethical and professional conduct of practitioners. Legal evidentiary standards for expert testimony, ethical guidelines established by medical organizations, and proposed standards for ethical practice provide a background for examination of several common challenges and testimonial claims in these cases.

Keywords

Forensic pathology Ethics Expert Testimony Law Child abuse

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Case

M.E.

Graham

M.A.

Handy

T.C.

. Position paper on fatal abusive head injuries in infants and young children. Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 2001 Jun; 22(2): 112–22.

Case

M.E.

. Head injury in child abuse. In: Monteleone

J.A.

, editor. Child maltreatment: a clinical guide and reference. 2d ed. St. Louis (MO): G. W. Medical Publishing; 1998. p. 87–103.

Case

M.E.

. Forensic pathology of child brain trauma. Brain Pathol. 2008 Oct; 18(4): 562–4.

Case

M.E.

. Inflicted traumatic brain injury in infants and young children. Brain Pathol. 2008 Oct; 18(4): 571–82.

Spitz

, editor. Spitz and Fisher's medicolegal investigation of death. 4th ed. Springfield (IL): Charles C. Thomas Publisher Ltd; 2006. 1358 p.

Gill

J.R.

Goldfelder

L.B.

Armbrustmacher

. Fatal head injury in children younger than 2 years in New York City and an overview of the shaken baby syndrome. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2009 Apr; 133(4): 619–27.

Gulino

. Autopsy findings. In: Frazier

Rauth-Farly

Alexander

Parrish

, editors. Abusive head trauma in infants and children: a medical, legal, and forensic reference. 1st ed. St. Louis (MO): G.W. Medical Publishing; 2006. p. 297–313.

Boos

S.C.

. Abusive head trauma as a medical diagnosis. In: Frazier

Rauth-Farly

Alexander

Parrish

, editors. Abusive head trauma in infants and children: a medical, legal, and forensic reference. 1st ed. St. Louis (MO): G.W. Medical Publishing; 2006. p. 49–71.

Kleinman

P.K.

Barnes

P.D.

. Head trauma. In; Kleinman

P.K.

, editor. Diagnostic imaging of child abuse. 2d ed. St. Louis (MO): Mosby; 1998. p. 285–342.

10.

Reece

R.M.

Nicholson

C.E.

, editors. Inflicted childhood neurotrauma : proceedings of a conference : October 10 and 11, 2002, Bethesda, Maryland. Elk Grove Village (IL): American Academy of Pediatrics; 2003. 287 p.

11.

Christian

C.W.

Block

, Committee on Child Abuse and Neglect, American Academy of Pediatrics. Abusive head trauma in infants and children. Pediatrics. 2009 May; 123(5): 1409–11.

12.

Jenny

, editor. Child abuse and neglect: diagnosis, treatment and evidence—expert consult: online and print. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2010. 688 p.

13.

Albert

D.M.

Blanchard

J.W.

Knox

B.L.

. Ensuring appropriate expert testimony for cases involving the “shaken baby”. JAMA. 2012 Jul 4; 308(1): 39–40.

14.

Narang

. A Daubert Analysis of Abusive Head Trauma/Shaken Baby Syndrome. Houston J Health Law Policy. 2011; 11: 505–633.

15.

Chadwick

D.L.

Krous

H.F.

. Irresponsible medical testimony by medical experts in cases involving the physical abuse and neglect of children. Child Maltreat. 1997 Nov; 2(4): 313–21.

16.

Chadwick

D.L.

Kirschner

R.H.

Reece

R.M.

. Shaken baby syndrome–a forensic pediatric response. Pediatrics. 1998 Feb; 101(2): 321–3.

17.

Block

R.W.

. Child abuse–controversies and imposters. Curr Probl Pediatr. 1999 Oct; 29(9): 249–72.

18.

National Center on Shaken Baby Syndrome [Internet]. Holmgren BK. Farmington (UT): the Center; c2013. Irresponsible expert testimony; 1999 [cited 2013 Aug 18]. Available from: http://dontshake.org/sbs.php?topNavID=3&subNavID=28&subnav_1=96&navID=115.

19.

Slovis

T.L.

Strouse

P.J.

Coley

B.D.

Rigsby

C.K.

. The creation of non-disease: an assault on the diagnosis of child abuse. Pediatr Radiol. 2012 Aug; 42(8): 903–5.

20.

Inquiry into pediatric forensic pathology in Ontario: report. Toronto (ON): Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General; 2008. 94 p.

21.

Siegel

. Judging parents as murderers on 4 specks of blood. Los Angeles Times [Internet]. 1999 Jul 11 [cited 2013 Aug 18]; News Available from: http://articles.latimes.com/1999/jul/11/news/mn-54984.

22.

Notice of disciplinary actions: member censure. AANS Neurosurg [Internet]. 2013 May [cited 2013 Aug 18]; 22(2). Available from: http://www.aansneurosurgeon.org/210613/8/3268.

23.

R v Henderson; R v Butler; R v Oyediran, [2010] EWCA (Crim) 1269 [188], [190] (Eng.).

24.

Judgment, R v Lorraine Harris, et al. 2005 EWCA Crim 1980. London: Royal Courts of Justice; 2005 Jul 21.

25.

Moreno

Holmgren

. The Supreme Court screws up the science: there is no abusive head trauma/shaken baby syndrome controversy. Utah Law Rev. Forthcoming 2013.

26.

Foucar

. Pathology expert witness testimony and pathology practice: a tale of 2 standards. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2005 Oct; 129(10): 1268–76.

27.

Krous

H.F.

Langston

. The role of the pediatric pathologist as expert witness in a case of neonatal death. Pediatr Dev Pathol. 2008 May-Jun; 11(3): 200–5.

28.

Kaufman

H.H.

. The expert witness. Neither Frye nor Daubert solved the problem: what can be done? Sci Justice. 2001 Jan-Mar; 41(1): 7–20.

29.

Finkel

. Clash act: peer review of expert witness testimony. CAP Today [Internet]. 2006 Oct [cited 2013 Aug 18]; 20(10): 5. Available from: http://www.cap.org/apps/cap.portal?_nfpb=true&cntvwrPtlt_actionOverride=%2Fportlets%2FcontentViewer%2Fshow&_windowLabel=cntvwrPtlt&cntvwrPtlt%7BactionForm.contentreference%7D=cap_today%2Ffeature_stories%2F1006ExpertWit.html&_state=maximized&_pageLabel=cntvwr.

30.

Committee on Medical Liability and Risk Management.

Policy statement–Expert witness participation in civil and criminal proceedings.

Pediatrics. 2009 Jul; 124(1): 428–38.

31.

Austin v American Association of Neurological Surgeons, 253 F.3d 967 (7th Cir. 2001).

32.

Brent

R.L.

. The irresponsible expert witness: a failure of biomedical graduate education and professional accountability. Pediatrics. 1982 Nov; 70(5): 754–62.

33.

Code of medical ethics: current opinions with annotations. Chicago: American Medical Association; 1997. 191 p.

34.

Goldrich

M.S.

. Report of the Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs. Chicago: American Medical Association; 2004 Jun. 9 p. CEJA Report No.: 12-A-04.

35.

Statement on the physician expert witness. Bull Am Coll Surg. 2000 Jun; 85(6): 24–5.

36.

Policy statement #7–12, medical expert: reports and testimony. Toronto: College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario; 2012. 8 p.

37.

American Academy of Forensic Sciences [Internet]. Colorado Springs (CO): the Academy; c1996–2013. AAFS bylaws: article II, code of ethics and conduct; [cited 2013 Aug 18]. Available from: http://www.aafs.org/aafs-bylaws#Art2.

38.

Finkel

. Expert witness guidelines for the specialty of pathology. CAP Today [Internet]. 2006 Jul [cited 2013 Aug 18]; 20(7): 5. Available from: http://www.cap.org/apps/cap.portal?_nfpb=true&cntvwrPtlt_actionOverride=%2Fportlets%2FcontentViewer%2Fshow&_windowLabel=cntvwrPtlt&cntvwrPtlt%7BactionForm.contentreference%7D=cap_today%2Ffeature_stories%2F0706ExpertSide.html&_state=maximized&_pageLabel=cntvwr.

39.

American Medical Association [Internet]. Chicago: American Medical Association; c1995–2013. Opinion 9.07-medical testimony; 2004 Jun [cited 2013 Aug 18]. Available from: http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/medical-ethics/code-medical-ethics/opinion907.page.

40.

Barnes

P.D.

. Ethical issues in imaging nonaccidental injury: child abuse. Top Magn Reson Imaging. 2002 Apr; 13(2): 85–93.

41.

Federal rules of evidence [Internet]. Arlington (VA): Federal Evidence Review; [cited 2013 Aug 18]. 45 p. Available from: http://federalevidence.com/downloads/rules.of.evidence.pdf.

42.

Daubert v Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993).

43.

Kumho Tire Company v Patrick Carmichael, 526 U.S. 137 (1999).

44.

General Electric Co. v Joiner, 522 U.S. 136 (1997).

45.

State v Cressey, 628 A.2d 696 (N.H. 1993).

46.

People v Beckley, 456 N.W.2d 391 (Mich.1990).

47.

State v Batangan, 799 P.2d 48 (Hawaii 1990).

48.

Gutheil

T.G.

Hauser

White

M.S.

. “The whole truth” versus “the admissible truth”: an ethics dilemma for expert witnesses. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 2003; 31(4): 422–7.

49.

Appelbaum

P.S.

. Psychiatric ethics in the courtroom. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 1984; 12(3): 225–31.

50.

Bono

J.P.

Swienton

A.R.

Upshaw Downs

J.C.

. Ethics in Forensic Science. 1st ed. Waltham (MA): Elsevier; 2012. Chapter 13, Ethics in testimony; p. 343–76.

51.

Stern

. Preparing and presenting expert witness testimony in child abuse litigation. Thousand Oaks (CA): Sage Publishing; 1997. 208 p.

52.

Blackett

W.B.

. AANS testimony rules rewritten: new rules for neurosurgical medical/legal expert opinion services. AANS Bulletin. 2004 Spring; 13(1): 9–10.

53.

Graham

M.H.

. Expert witness testimony and the federal rules of evidence: insuring adequate assurance of trustworthiness. Univ Illinois Law Rev. 1986; 43–90.

54.

Graham

M.H.

. The expert witness predicament: determining “reliable” under the gatekeeping test of Daubert, Kumho and the proposed amended rule 702 of the federal rules of evidence. Univ Miami Law Rev. 2000; 54: 317.

55.

Greeley

C.S.

. Infant fatality. Semin Pediatr Neurol. 2010 Dec; 17(4): 275–8; author reply 279–80.

56.

Narang

Melville

J.D.

Greeley

C.S.

. A Daubert analysis of abusive head trauma/shaken baby syndrome–part II: an examination of the differential diagnosis. Houston J Health Law Policy. Forthcoming 2013.

57.

Myers

J.E.B.

. Evidence in child abuse and neglect cases. 3d ed. Somerset (NJ): John Wiley & Sons; 1997. 600 p.

58.

Lyon

T.D.

Gilles

E.E.

Cory

. Medical evidence of physical abuse in infants and young children. Pacific Law J. 1996; 28: 93–167.

59.

Marco

C.H.

. Certainty of expert opinion. In: Wecht

C.H.

, editor. Forensic Sciences. Vol. 1. San Francisco: Matthew Bender & Company; 2012. p. 1–54.

60.

Imwinkelried

E.J.

Giannelli

P.C.

Gilligan

F.A.

Lederer

F.I.

. Courtroom criminal evidence. 5th ed. San Francisco: Matthew Bender & Company; 2011. 2 vol.

61.

Hanzlick

Hunsaker

J.C.

Davis

G.J.

. A guide for manner of death classification. Atlanta: National Association of Medical Examiners; 2002. 29 p.

62.

Angela O'Brien v United States, 962 A.2d 282 (D.C. App. 2008).

63.

State v Young, 1998 WL 258466 (Tenn. Crim. App.).

64.

Chein v Shumsky, 373 F.3d 978 (9th Cir. 2004).

65.

Bronston v United States, 409 U.S. 32 (1973).

66.

Annotation: incomplete, misleading, or unresponsive but literally true statements as perjury. Am Law Rep 3d. 1976, 1995 Supp.; 69: 993.

67.

Feldman

. Commentary on “congenital rickets” article. Pediatr Radiol. 2009 Oct; 39(10): 1127–9; author reply 1130–2.

68.

State v Werts, 677 N.W.2d 734 (IA. Sup. 2004).

69.

Melinek

Thomas

L.C.

Oliver

W.R.

. National Association of Medical Examiners position paper: medical examiner, coroner, and forensic pathologist independence. Acad Forensic Pathol. 2013 Mar; 3(1): 93–8.

70.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Miles Ferguson, 2007-GS-26–4843; 2009 Nov 4.

71.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Andrew Neal Davis, 2001-A-391; 2008 Jun 30.

72.

Geddes

J.F.

Tasker

R.C.

Hackshaw

A.K.

. Dural haemorrhage in non-traumatic infant deaths: does it explain the bleeding in ‘shaken baby syndrome’? Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol. 2003 Feb; 29(1): 14–22.

73.

Cohen

M.C.

Scheimberg

. Evidence of occurrence of intradural and subdural hemorrhage in the perinatal and neonatal period in the context of hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy: an observational study from two referral institutions in the United Kingdom. Pediatr Dev Pathol. 2009 May; 12(3): 169–76.

74.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Audrey Edmunds, 96 CF 555; 2013 Jan 25–26.

75.

Matshes

E.W.

Lew

E.O.

. Do resuscitation-related injuries kill infants and children? Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 2010 Jun; 31(2): 178–85.

76.

Maguire

Mann

John

. Does cardiopulmonary resuscitation cause rib fractures in children? A systematic review. Child Abuse Negl. 2006 Jul; 30(7): 739–51.

77.

Spevak

M.R.

Kleinman

P.K.

Belanger

P.L.

. Cardio-pulmonary resuscitation and rib fractures in infants. A postmortem radiologic-pathologic study. JAMA. 1994 Aug 24–31; 272(8): 617–8.

78.

Odom

Christ

Kerr

. Prevalence of retinal hemorrhages in pediatric patients after in-hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation: a prospective study. Pediatrics. 1997 Jun; 99(6): E3.

79.

Levin

A.V.

. Eye injuries in child abuse. In: Jenny

, editor. Child abuse and neglect: diagnosis, treatment and evidence–expert consult: Online and Print. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2010. p. 402–12.

80.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Dwaniko Sudberry, 2008-C-3011; 2010 Jul 14.

81.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Elroy Willis, CR95–7824; 1997 Apr 22.

82.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Roger E. Yoksh, WD#54873; 1997 Jun 3.

83.

Binebaum

Rogers

D.L.

Forbes

B.J.

. Patterns of retinal hemorrhage associated with increased intracranial pressure in children. Pediatrics. 2013 Aug; 132(2): e430–4.

84.

Knox

B.L.

Rorke-Adams

L.B.

Dias

M.S.

. Subdural hematoma rebleeding. In: Frasier

Hinds

, editors. Abusive head trauma pocket atlas. St. Louis (MO): STM Learning. Forthcoming 2013.

85.

Transcript of Testimony, People v Adrian Thomas, Indictment No. 08–1074; 2009 Oct 16.

86.

Transcipt of Testimony, State v Everado Mendoza, Case No. 071908696; 2008 Nov 10.

87.

State of Washington v Erenderia Hernandez, 2005 Wash. App. Lexis 223.

88.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Christopher Davis and Raymond Martin, Indictments No. 04-CR-205 and 04-CR-076; 2006 Mar 29.

89.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Russell Maze, 2002-D-2361; 2008 Jun 9.

90.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Zavian Thomas, No. D-1-DC-06–301206.

91.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Jeffery Alan Baker, CR-FE-2010–0010630; 2013 Apr 18–19.

92.

Duhaime

A.C.

Gennarelli

T.A.

Thibault

L.E.

. The shaken baby syndrome. A clinical, pathological, and biomechanical study. J Neurosurg. 1987 Mar; 66(3): 409–15.

93.

Prange

M.T.

Coats

Duhaime

A.C.

Margulies

S.S.

. Anthropomorphic simulations of falls, shakes, and inflicted impacts in infants. J Neurosurg. 2003 Jul; 99(1): 143–50.

94.

Cory

C.Z.

Jones

B.M.

. Can shaking alone cause fatal brain injury? A biomechanical assessment of the Duhaime shaken baby syndrome model. Med Sci Law. 2003 Oct; 43(4): 317–33.

95.

Bandak

F.A.

. Shaken baby syndrome: a biomechanics analysis of injury mechanisms. Forensic Sci Int. 2005 Jun 30; 151(1): 71–9.

96.

Squier

. Shaken baby syndrome: the quest for evidence. Dev Med Child Neurol. 2008 Jan; 50(1): 10–4.

97.

Dias

M.S.

. The case for shaking. In: Jenny

, editor. Child abuse and neglect: diagnosis, treatment and evidence–expert consult: Online and Print. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2010. p. 364–72.

98.

Margulies

Coats

. Biomechanincs of head trauma in infants and young children. In: Jenny

, editor. Child abuse and neglect: diagnosis, treatment and evidence–expert consult: Online and Print. Philadelphia: Saunders; 2010. p. 359–63.

99.

Margulies

Prange

Myers

B.S.

. Shaken baby syndrome: a flawed biomechanical analysis. Forensic Sci Int. 2006 Dec 20; 164(2–3): 278–9; author reply 282–3.

100.

Raghupathi

Margulies

S.S.

. Traumatic axonal injury after closed head injury in the neonatal pig. J Neurotrauma. 2002 Jul; 19(7): 843–53.

101.

Raghupathi

Mehr

M.F.

Helfaer

M.A.

Margulies

S.S.

. Traumatic axonal injury is exacerbated following repetitive closed head injury in the neonatal pig. J Neurotrauma. 2004 Mar; 21(3): 307–16.

102.

Bayly

P.V.

Cohen

T.S.

Leister

E.P.

. Deformation of the human brain induced by mild acceleration. J Neurotrauma. 2005 Aug; 22(8): 845–56.

103.

Finnie

J.W.

Blumbergs

P.C.

Manavis

. Neuropathological changes in a lamb model of non-accidental head injury (the shaken baby syndrome). J Clin Neurosci. 2012 Aug; 19(8): 1159–64.

104.

Sandoz

Dutshke

Liu

. In vivo biomechanical response of ovine heads to shaken baby syndrome events. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin. 2012; 15 Suppl 1: 293–4.

105.

Duhaime

A.C.

Alario

A.J.

Lewander

W.J.

. Head injury in very young children: mechanisms, injury types, and ophthalmologic findings in 100 hospitalized patients younger than 2 years of age. Pediatrics. 1992 Aug; 90(2 Pt 1): 179–85.

106.

Duhaime

A.C.

Christian

C.W.

Rorke

L.B.

Zimmerman

R.A.

. Nonaccidental head injury in infants–the “shaken-baby syndrome”. N Engl J Med. 1998 Jun 18; 338(25): 1822–9.

107.

Myers

J.E.B.

. Myers on evidence of interpersonal violence: child maltreatment, intimate partner violence, rape, stalking, and elder abuse. 5th ed. New York: Wolters Kluwer Law & Business; 2011. 1316 p.

108.

Hettler

Greenes

D.S.

. Can the initial history predict whether a child with a head injury has been abused? Pediatrics. 2003 Mar; 111(3): 602–7.

109.

Parrish

R.N.

, Prosecuting a case. In: Frazier

Rauth-Farly

Alexander

Parrish

, editors. Abusive head trauma in infants and children: a medical, legal, and forensic reference. 1st ed. St. Louis (MO): G.W. Medical Publishing; 2006. p. 393–420.

110.

State v Burchell, 2002 WL 31520651 (Tenn. Crim. App.).

111.

Donohoe

. Evidence-based medicine and shaken baby syndrome: part I: literature review, 1966–1998. Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 2003 Sep; 24(3): 239–42.

112.

Transcript of Testimony, State v Tawny Cabreo; 2005 Mar 4.

Ethical Issues in Forensic Testimony Involving Abusive Head Trauma

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References