Arguing that knowledge in the social sciences is socially constructed through the selective interpretation of major works, we examine the fate of a classic article in organizational theory, DiMaggio and Powell's 1983 essay on institutional isomorphism. We show that one aspect of this article, the discussion of mimetic isomorphism, has received attention disproportionate to its role in the essay. A detailed examination of 26 articles in which researchers attempted to operationalize various components of DiMaggio and Powell's model shows that measures used to capture one of their concepts could have served as valid measures of one of the others. Findings show that DiMaggio and Powell's thesis has become socially constructed, as authors have selectively appropriated aspects of the work that accord with prevalent discourse in the field, and that centrally located researchers in sociology and organizational behavior are more likely than other scholars to invoke this dominant interpretation of their article.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdattoKikuColeStephen R.1981“The functions of classical theory in contemporary sociological research: The case of Max Weber.”Knowledge and Society: Studies in the Sociology of Culture, Past and Present, 3: 137–162.
2.
AldrichHoward E.1979Organizations and Environments. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
3.
BergerPeter L.LuckmannThomas1966The Social Construction of Reality. New York: Doubleday.
4.
BerleAdolf A.MeansGardiner C.1968The Modern Corporation and Private Property. (Originally published in 1932.) New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
5.
BoltonMichele Kremen1993“Organizational innovation and substandard performance: When is necessity the mother of invention.”Organization Science, 4: 57–75.
6.
BurnsLawton R.WholeyDouglas R.1993“Adoption and abandonment of matrix management programs: Effects of organizational characteristics and inter-organizational networks.”Academy of Management Journal, 36: 106–138.
7.
ChubinDaryl E.MoitraSoumyo1975“Content analysis of references: An alternative to citation counting.”Social Studies of Science, 5: 423–441.
8.
ColeStephen1975“The growth of scientific knowledge: Theories of deviance as a case study.” In CoserLewis A. (ed.), The Idea of Social Structure: Papers in Honor of Robert K. Merton: 175–220. New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich.
9.
1992Making Science. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
10.
CovaleskiMark A.DirsmithMark W.1988“An institutional perspective on the rise, social transformation, and fall of a university budget category.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 33: 562–587.
11.
CronbachLee J.1992“Four Psychological Bulletin articles in perspective.”Psychological Bulletin, 112(3): 389–392.
12.
DavisGerald F.1991“Agents without principles? The spread of the poison pill through the intercorporate network.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 36: 583–613.
13.
DiMaggioPaul J.PowellWalter W.1983“The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields.”American Sociological Review, 48: 147–160.
14.
1991“Introduction.” In PowellWalter W.DiMaggioPaul J. (eds.), The New Institutional-ism in Organizational Analysis: 1–38. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
15.
EscarpitRobert1971Sociology of Literature, 2d ed. Translated by Ernest Pick. London: Cass.
16.
FennellMary L.AlexanderJeffrey A.1987“Organizational boundary spanning in institutionalized environments.”Academy of Management Journal, 30: 456–476.
17.
FinlayWilliam1987“Industrial relations and firm behavior: Informal labor practices in the West Coast longshore industry.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 32: 49–67.
18.
FligsteinNeil1985“The spread of the multidivisional form among large firms, 1919–1979.”American Sociological Review, 50: 377–391.
19.
1987“The intraorganizational power struggle: Rise of finance personnel to top leadership in large corporations, 1919–1979.”American Sociological Review, 52: 44–58.
20.
1990The Transformation of Corporate Control. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
21.
GalaskiewiczJoseph1985“Professional networks and the institutionalization of a single mind set.”American Sociological Review, 50: 639–658.
22.
GalaskiewiczJosephBurtRonald S.1991“Interorganization contagion in corporate philanthropy.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 36: 88–105.
23.
GalaskiewiczJosephWassermanStanley1989“Mimetic processes within an interorganizational field: An empirical test.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 34: 454–479.
24.
GinsbergAriBuchholtzAnn1990“Converting to for-profit status: Corporate responsiveness to radical change.”Academy of Management Journal, 33: 445–477.
25.
GouldnerAlvin W.1954Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
26.
GreeningDaniel W.GrayBarbara1994“Testing a model of organizational response to social and political issues.”Academy of Management Journal, 37: 467–498.
27.
HamiltonRichard F.1996The Social Misconstruction of Reality. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
28.
HanShin-Kap1994“Mimetic isomorphism and its effect on the audit services market.”Social Forces, 73: 637–663.
29.
HannanMichael T.FreemanJohn H.1977“The population ecology of organizations.”American Journal of Sociology, 82: 929–964.
30.
HaunschildPamela R.1994“How much is that company worth? Interorganizational relationships, uncertainty, and acquisition premiums.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 39: 391–411.
31.
HavemanHeather A.1993“Follow the leader: Mimetic isomorphism and entry into new markets.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 38: 593–627.
32.
HirschPaul M.1997“Sociology without social structure: Neoinstitutional theory meets brave new world.”American Journal of Sociology, 102: 1702–1723.
33.
KanterRosabeth Moss1977Men and Women of the Corporation. New York: Basic Books.
34.
KnokeDavid1982“The spread of municipal reform: Temporal, spatial, and social dynamics.”American Journal of Sociology, 87: 1314–1339.
35.
KonradAlison M.LinnehanFrank1995“Formalized HRM structures: Coordinating equal employment opportunity or concealing organizational practices?”Academy of Management Journal, 38: 787–820.
36.
LatourBruno1987Science in Action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
37.
LawrencePaul R.LorschJay W.1967Organization and Environment. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
38.
LehrmanWilliam G.1994“Diversity in decline: Institutional environment and organizational failure in the American life insurance industry.”Social Forces, 73: 605–635.
39.
LevittBarbaraNassClifford1989“The lid on the garbage can: Institutional constraints on decision making in the technical core of college-text publishers.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 34: 190–207.
40.
LomiAlessandro1995“The population ecology of organizational founding: Location dependence and unobserved heterogeneity.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 40: 111–144.
41.
MertonRobert K.1987“Three fragments from a sociologist's notebooks: Establishing the phenomenon, specified ignorance, and strategic research materials.”Annual Review of Sociology, 13: 1–28. Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
42.
MeyerJohn W.RowanBrian1977“Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony.”American Journal of Sociology, 83: 340–363.
43.
MeyerJohn W.Richard-ScottW.1983Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
44.
MeziasStephen J.1990“An institutional model of organizational practice: Financial reporting at the Fortune 200.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 35: 431–457.
45.
MeziasStephen J.ScarsellettaMario1994“Resolving financial reporting problems: An institutional analysis of the process.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 39: 654–678.
46.
MizruchiMark S.Brewster-StearnsLinda1988“A longitudinal study of the formation of interlocking directorates.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 33: 194–210.
47.
MoravcsikMichael J.MurugesanPoovanalingum1975“Some results on the function and quality of citations.”Social Studies of Science, 5: 86–92.
48.
OliverChristine1988“The collective strategy framework: An application to competing predictions of isomorphism.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 33: 543–561.
49.
OrruMarcoWoolsey-BiggartNicoleHamiltonGary G.1991“Organizational isomorphism in East Asia.” In PowellWalter W.DiMaggioPaul J. (eds.), The New Institutional-ism in Organizational Analysis: 361–389. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
50.
PalmerDonald A.Devereaux-JenningsP.ZhouXueguang1993“Late adoption of the multidivisional form by large U.S. corporations: Institutional, political, and economic accounts.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 38: 100–131.
51.
PerrowCharles1986aComplex Organizations: A Critical Essay, 3rd ed.New York: Random House.
PfefferJeffrey1997New Directions for Organization Theory: Problems and Prospects. New York: Oxford University Press.
54.
PfefferJeffreySalancikGerald R.1978The External Control of Organizations: A Resource Dependence Perspective. New York: Harper & Row.
55.
PowellWalter W.1991“Expanding the scope of institutional analysis.” In PowellWalter W.DiMaggioPaul J. (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 183–203. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
56.
PowellWalter W.DiMaggioPaul J., (eds.) 1991The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
57.
RaoHayagreevaNeilsenEric H.1992“An ecology of agency arrangements: Mortality of savings and loan associations, 1960–1987.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 37: 448–470.
58.
RowanBrian1982“Organizational structure and the institutional environment: The case of public schools.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 27: 259–279.
59.
SaganCarl1997Billions and Billions. New York: Ballantine.
60.
SchoonhovenClaudia BirdEisenhardtKathleen M.LymanKatherine1990“Speeding products to market: Waiting time to first product introduction in new firms.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 35: 177–207.
61.
ScottRichardW.1991“Unpacking institutional arguments.” In PowellWalter W.DiMaggioPaul J. (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 164–182. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
62.
1996“The mandate is still being honored: In defense of Weber's disciples.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 41: 163–171.
63.
SelznickPhilip1949TVA and the Grass Roots. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
64.
SinghJitendra V.TuckerDavid J.MeinhardAgnes G.1991“Institutional change and ecological dynamics.” In PowellWalter W.DiMaggioPaul J. (eds.), The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis: 390–422. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
65.
SmallHenry G.1978“Cited documents as concept symbols.”Social Studies of Science, 8: 327–340.
66.
SternRobert N.BarleyStephen R.1996“Organizations and social systems: Organization theory's neglected mandate.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 41: 146–162.
67.
StrangDavidSouleSarah A.1998“Diffusion in organizations and social movements: From hybrid corn to poison pills.”Annual Review of Sociology, 24: 265–290. Palo Alto, CA: Annual Reviews.
68.
SuttonJohn R.DobbinFrankMeyerJohn W.Richard-ScottW.1994“The legalization of the workplace.”American Journal of Sociology, 99: 944–971.
69.
ThompsonJames D.1967Organizations in Action. New York: McGraw-Hill.
70.
TolbertPamela S.ZuckerLynne G.1983“Institutional sources of change in the formal structure of organizations: The diffusion of civil service reform, 1880–1935.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 28: 22–39.
71.
UsdikenBehlulPasadeosYorgo1995“Organizational analysis in North America and Europe: A comparison of co-citation networks.”Organization Studies, 16: 503–526.
72.
WilliamsonOliver E.1975Markets and Hierarchies: Analysis and Antitrust Implications. New York: Free Press.
73.
ZaldMayer N.1970Organizational Change: The Political Economy of the YMCA. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
74.
ZeitlinMaurice1974“Corporate ownership and control: The large corporation and the capitalist class.”American Journal of Sociology, 79: 1073–1119.
