Using both quantitative and qualitative data collected in Portland, Oregon during 1989, this study tests two contradictory models of ethnic identity: primordialism and circumstantialism. Two questions are addressed: 1) does the third generation of Japanese Americans retain ethnic identity or has the group achieved complete identificational assimilation?; and 2) what factors impacted the group's identificational assimilation? The study suggests that there is attenuation of ethnic identity between successive generations. However, multivariate analyses indicate that the seemingly different ethnic identity of the second and third generations does not necessarily evidence the significance of generation in the identificational assimilation. Childhood and adult social networks are found to have the greatest effect on ethnic identity. This study also found that generational shift does not lead to identificational assimilation if and when successive generations are placed in the same circumstances.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AsamenJoy K.BerryGordon L.1987. “Self-Concept, Alienation, and Perceived Prejudice: Implications for Counseling Asian Americans.”Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development15: 146–160.
2.
BonacichEdnaModellJohn1980. The Economic Basis of Ethnic Solidarity: Small Business in the Japanese American Community. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
3.
ConnorJohn W.1977. Tradition and Change in Three Generations of Japanese Americans. Chicago, IL: Nelson-Hall.
4.
DashefskyArnoldShapiroHoward M.1974. Ethnic Identification Among American Jews. Lexington, MA: Heath.
5.
EriksonEric1950. Childhood and Society. New York, NY: Norton.
6.
FugitaStephen S.O'BrienDavid J.1985. “Structural Assimilation, Ethnic Group Membership, and Political Participation Among Japanese Americans: A Research Note.”Social Forces63: 986–995.
7.
GlaserDaniel1958. “Dynamics of Ethnic Identification.”American Sociological Review23: 31–40.
8.
GlazerNathanMoynihanDaniel1975. Ethnicity: Theory and Experience. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
9.
GordonMilton1964. Assimilation in American Life: The Role of Race, Religion, and National Origins. New York: Oxford University Press.
10.
GreeleyAndrew M.1974. Ethnicity in the United States: A Preliminary Reconnaissance. New York: Wiley.
11.
GreenbergStanley B.1980. Race and State in Capitalist Development. London: Yale University Press.
12.
HayanoDavid1981. “Ethnic Identification and Disidentification: Japanese-American Views of Chinese-Americans.”Ethnic Groups3: 157–171.
13.
HosokawaBill1969. Nisei—The Quiet Americans. New York: Morrow.
14.
JohnstonRuth1969. The Assimilation Myth: A Study of Second Generation Polish Immigrants in Western Australia. The Hague: Marinus Nijhoff.
15.
KendisKaoru Oguri1989. A Matter of Comfort—Ethnic Maintenance and Ethnic Style Among Third-Generation Japanese Americans. New York: AMS.
16.
KieferChristie. W.1974. Changing Culture, Changing Lives. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
17.
KitanoHarry1976. Japanese Americans: The Evolution of A Subculture. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
18.
LazerwitzBernardRowitzLouis1964. “The Three-Generations Hypothesis.”American Journal of Sociology69: 529–538.
19.
LebraTakie Sugiyama1972. “Acculturation Dilemma: The Function of Japanese Moral Values for Americanization.”Council on Anthropology and Education Newsletter3: 6–13.
20.
LevineGene N.MonteroDarrel1973. “Socioeconomic Mobility Among Three Generations of Japanese Americans.”Journal of Social Issues29: 33–48.
21.
LevineGene N.RhodesColbert1981. The Japanese-American Community: A Three-Generation Study. New York: Praeger.
22.
LymanStanford M.1968. “The Race Relations Cycle of Robert E. Park.”Pacific Sociological Review2: 16–22.
23.
MasudaMinoruMatsumotoGary H.MeredithGerald1970. “Ethnic Identification: Honolulu and Seattle Japanese-Americans.”Journal of Cross Cultural Psychology1: 63–76.
24.
MaykovichMinako K.1972. Japanese American Identity Dilemma. Tokyo: Waseda University Press.
25.
MonteroDarrel1980. Japanese Americans: Changing Patterns of Ethnic Affiliation Over Three Generations. Boulder, CO: Westview.
26.
NewtonBarbara J.BuckElizabeth B.KunikuraDon T.ColferCarol P.ScholsbergDeborah1988. “Ethnic Identity among Japanese-Americans in Hawaii: A Critique of Hansen's Third-Generation Return Hypothesis.”International Journal of Intercultural Relations12: 305–315.
27.
OmiMichaelWinantHoward1986. Racial Formation in the United States. New York: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
28.
ParentiMichael1970. “Ethnic Politics and the Persistence of Ethnic Identification.” In The Ethnic Factor in American Politics, edited by HawkinsBrett W.LorinskasRobert A.Columbus, OH: Merrill.
29.
ParkRobert E.1950. Race and Culture. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
30.
PavlakThomas J.1976. Ethnic Identification and Political Behavior. San Francisco: R and E Research Associates.
31.
ScottGeorge M.1990. “A Resynthesis of the Primordial and Circumstantial Approaches to Ethnic Group Solidarity: Towards an Explanatory Model.”Ethnic and Racial Studies13: 147–171.
32.
SueStanleyKitanoHarry1973. “Stereotypes as a Measure of Success.”Journal of Social Issues29: 83–98.
33.
TsurukiMakoto1976. Japanese Americans. Tokyo, Japan: Kodansha.
34.
UyekiEugene S.1960. “Correlates of Ethnic Identification.”American Journal of Sociology65: 468–474.
35.
WoodenWayne S.LeonJoseph J.ToshimaMichelle T.1988. “Ethnic Identity among Sansei and Yonsei Church Affiliated Youth in Los Angeles and Honolulu.”Psychological Reports62: 268–270.
36.
WoodrumEric1978. “Japanese American Social Adaptation over Three Generations.” Ph.D. diss., University of Texas, Austin.
37.
WoodrumEric1981. “An Assessment of Japanese American Assimilation, Pluralism, and Subordination.”American Journal of Sociology87: 157–169.
38.
WoodrumEric1985. “Religion and Economics Among Japanese Americans: A Weberian Study.”Social Forces64: 191–204.
