Free accessResearch articleFirst published online 2004-3
The Role of Outcomes-Based National Qualifications in the Development of an Effective Vocational Education and Training System: The Case of England and Wales
This article analyses the increasingly diverse and sophisticated critique of ‘outcomes approaches’ in vocational qualifications; critique which has now moved well beyond the early claims of reductivism and behaviourism. Avoiding a naive position on extraction of points of consensus, this article attempts to extract key issues which have purchase on policy and practice relating to National Vocational Qualifications. It outlines not only the ways in which current policy and development processes associated with the qualifications may be defective, but also ways in which they might be enhanced. Crucially, the article points to the severe limitations of the concept of ‘competence’ which lies at the heart of outcomes approaches, and emphasises the need to reconsider a ‘formation’ model for initial vocational education and training, rather than a ‘competence’ model.
References
1.
BarnettR. (1992) What Effects? What Outcomes? in BarnettR. (Ed.) Learning to Effect. Buckingham: Society for Research into Higher Education (SRHE)/Open University Press.
2.
BarnettR. (1997) Higher Education: A critical business. Buckingham: SRHE/Open University Press.
3.
BeaumontG. (1996) Review of 100 NVQs and SVQs. London: Department for Education and Employment.
4.
BeckettD. (2002) Embodied Competence and Generic Skill, paper presented to PESGB Annual Conference, New College, Oxford, April.
5.
BergerP. (1982) The Social Construction of Reality. London: Pelican.
6.
BorehamN.SamurcayR. (1998) Models for the Analysis of Work Competence: A critical review paper for 3rd WHOLE conference, Siena, 2 December.
7.
BrownH.SmithH. (1989) Whose Ordinary Life is it Anyway, Disability, Handicap and Society, 4(2), pp. 105–119.
8.
ChomskyN. (1997) Media Control: The spectacular achievements of propaganda. New York: Seven Stories Press.
9.
ClarkeL.WallC. (1998) A Blueprint for Change: Construction skills training in Britain. Bristol: Policy Press.
10.
ClarkeL.WinchC. (2004) Apprenticeship, Skill and Occupational Identity, Educational Philosophy and Theory, 36, special edition on work-based learning.
11.
ClematideB. (1997) Beck and Jorgenson: A case study for the Leonardo Core Guide Project. Copenhagen: DTI Denmark.
12.
ColesM.CollarD. (2002) The Currency of Qualifications in the UK Labour Market. Working papers in research. London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
13.
Department for Education and Skills (DfES) (2001–02) National Information System for Vocational Qualifications (database). Sheffield: DfES.
14.
DreyfusH.DreyfusS. (1984) Putting Computers in their Proper Place: Analysis versus intuition in the classroom, in SloanD. (Ed.) The Computer in Education: A critical perspective. New York: Teachers College Press.
15.
ErautM. (1982) Curriculum and the Education of Adults. Brighton: Falmer Press.
16.
ErautM. (1998) Professional Knowledge, Practice and Mode of Cognition, in FoucherR. (Ed.) Proceedings of International Conference on Self-directed Learning. Montreal: University of Montreal GIRAT.
17.
GreenA. (1997) Education, Globalization and the Nation State. London: Macmillan.
18.
GreenJ. (2004) Managerial Modes of Accountability: Reclaiming the practical, Educational Philosophy and Theory, 36, special edition on work-based learning.
19.
HagerP.BecketD. (1985) Philosophical Underpinnings of the Integrated Conception of Competence, Educational Philosophy and Theory, 27, pp. 1–24.
LongmoreP. (1985) A Note on Language and Social Identity of Disabled People, American Behavioural Scientist, 28(3), pp. 419ff.
25.
LoweR. (1997) Schooling and Social Change 1964–1990. London: Routledge.
26.
LumG. (1999) Where's the Competence in Competence-based Education and Training?Journal of Philosophy of Education, 33(3), pp. 403–418.
27.
LumG. (2004) Competence and Discursive Knowledge, Educational Philosophy and Theory, 36, special edition on work-based learning, special edition on work-based learning.
28.
MacfarlaneE. (1993) Education 16–19 in Transition. London: Routledge.
29.
Manpower Services Commission (1981) A New Training Initiative: Agenda for action. Sheffield: Manpower Services Commission.
30.
MasseyA. (2004) Comparability of National Tests over Time: KS1, KS2 and KS3 standards between 1996 and 2001. London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
31.
MathewsD. (1987) Interview with David Mathews, London University, 30 November.
32.
McKelveyC.PetersH. (1991) NVQs and Language, Adults Learning, 3(3), p 65.
33.
MitchellL. (1989) The Definition of Standards and their Assessment, in BurkeJ. (Ed.) Competency Based Education and Training. Brighton: Falmer Press.
34.
MooreA. (1996) Masking the Fissure: Some thoughts on competences, reflection and closure in initial teacher training, British Journal of Educational Studies, 44, pp. 200–211.
35.
National Commission on Education (1993) Learning to Succeed. London: Heinemann.
36.
National Council for Vocational Qualifications (NCVQ) (1991) Guide to National Vocational Qualifications. London: NCVQ.
37.
OatesT. (1992) Core Skills and Transfer: Aiming high, Education and Training Technology International, 29(3), pp. 227–239.
38.
OatesT. (2002) Reviewing the Deep Trends in NVQs. Working papers in research. London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
39.
OatesT.FettesP. (1998) Key Skills Strategy Paper. Working papers in research. London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
40.
PollardA.TriggsP., with BroadfootP.McNessE.OsborneM. (2000) What Pupils Say – changing policy, practice and experience. London: Continuum.
TannenD. (Ed.) (1993) Gender and Conversational Interaction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
44.
TannenD. (1995) Talking from 9 to 5: How women's and men's conversational styles affect who gets heard, who gets credit, and what gets done at work. London: Virago.
45.
TapperT.SalterB. (1978) Education and the Political Order. London: Macmillan.
46.
UnwinL.FullerA. (2004) Learning as Apprentices in the Contemporary UK Workplace: Creating and managing expansive and restrictive participation. SKOPE Research Paper, Universities of Oxford and Warwick (in press).
47.
WinchC. (2002) Work, Well-being and Vocational Education, Journal of Applied Philosophy, 19, pp. 261–271.
48.
WolfA. (1995) Competence-based Assessment. Buckingham: Open University Press.
49.
WoodR. (1991) Assessment and Testing. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
