This article reviews the reactions to higher-level National Vocational Qualifications (NVQs) in the United Kingdom in the context of certification levels by level and subject. The most successful higher NVQs are linked to professional qualifying routes, have generic application across a range of sectors or fill gaps where qualifications were not previously established. Research among the main stakeholders to gauge their attitudes towards higher NVQs shows that, among positive aspects, some adverse attitudes still exist surrounding issues of comparability, the assessment experience and the design of occupational standards. Suggestions for overcoming these issues are given. However, the wider picture shows that support for occupational standards is strong and it is the use of standards, which may or may not involve NVQs, that will help to drive forward new policy initiatives addressing participation in the sector.
References
1.
BeaumontG. (1996) Review of 100 NVQs and SVQs. A report submitted to the Department for Education and Employment. London: NCVQ/SCOTVEC.
2.
BoyatzisR. (1982) The Competent Manager: A model for effective performance. New York: Wiley.
3.
BrownP. (1999) Client-based Management Qualifications – a case of win-win?Journal of Management Development, 18(4), pp. 350–361.
4.
BrownR. (1993) Meta-competence: A recipe for re-framing the competence debate, Personnel Review, 22(6), pp. 25–36.
5.
BurgoyneJ. (1993) The Competence Movement: Issues, stakeholders and prospects, Personnel Review, 22(6), pp. 6–13.
6.
Committee of Vice Chancellors and Principals (1995) A Strategy for Vocational Higher Education, Competence & Assessment, June, pp. 16–32.
7.
DeardenL.McIntoshS.MyckM.VignolesA. (2000) The Returns to Academic and Vocational Qualifications in Britain. London: Centre for the Economics of Education, London School of Economics.
8.
Department for Education and Skills (2003) The Future of Higher Education. White Paper, Cm 5735. Norwich: The Stationery Office.
9.
EcclestoneK. (1997) Energising or Enervating: Implications of National Vocational Qualifications in professional development, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 49, pp. 65–79.
10.
Education Department (1994) Costs and Obstacles to Employers Implementing NVQs and SVQs. 21 December. Sheffield: Employment Department.
11.
Education Department (1995) Qualification Mapping: Management NVQs/SVQs and higher education. Report No. 28, March. Sheffield: Employment Department.
12.
ErautM. (2001) The Role and Use of Vocational Qualification, National Institute Economic Review, 178, October, pp. 88–98.
13.
ErautM.SteadmanS.JamesJ. (2001) Evaluation of Higher Level S/NVQs. Research Report No. 9. Brighton: Institute of Education, University of Sussex.
14.
FullerA. (1994) New Approaches to Management Training and Qualifications – perceptions of use and exchange, Journal of Management Development, 13, pp. 23–34.
15.
GrugulisI. (1997a) Managerial Work and Management Training: A critique of the management NVQs. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Warwick.
16.
GrugulisI. (1997b) The Consequences of Competence: A critical assessment of the Management NVQ, Personnel Review, 26(6), pp. 428–444.
17.
GrugulisI. (1998) ‘Real’ Managers Don't Do NVQs: A review of the new management ‘standards’, Employee Relations, 20(4), pp. 383–403.
18.
GrugulisI. (2000) The Management NVQ: A critique of the myth of relevance, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 52, pp. 79–99.
HillierY. (1999) Higher Level Vocational Qualifications: The candidates' experience, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 51(2), pp. 199–227.
21.
HolmanD.HallL. (1997) Competence in Management Development: Rites and wrongs, British Journal of Management, 7, pp. 191–202.
22.
HylandT. (1996) National Vocational Qualifications, Skills Training and Employers' Needs: Beyond Beaumont and Dearing, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 48, pp. 349–365.
23.
HylandT.MatlayH. (1998) Lifelong Learning and the ‘New Deal’ Vocationalism: Vocational training, qualifications and the small business sector, British Journal of Educational Studies, 46, pp. 399–414.
24.
LittleB.ConnorH.LebeauY. (2003) Vocational Higher Education. Does it Meet Employers' Needs?London: Learning and Skills Development Association.
25.
Loan-ClarkeJ. (1996) The Management Charter Initiative – a critique of management standards/NVQs, Journal of Management Development, 15(6), pp. 4–17.
26.
Manpower Services Commission (MSC) (1981) A New Training Initiative: Agenda for action. Sheffield: MSC.
27.
Manpower Services Commission (MSC) (1986) Review of Vocational Qualifications in England and Wales. Sheffield: MSC.
28.
MatlayH. (1999) Employers' Perceptions and Implementation of S/NVQs in Britain: A critical overview, International Journal of Training and Development, 3, pp. 132–141.
29.
MatlayH. (2000) S/NVQs in Britain: Employer-led or ignored?Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 52, pp. 135–148.
30.
National Council for Vocational Qualifications (NCVQ) (1996) Report on the Responses to the 'Review of 100 NVQs/SVQs. London: NCQV.
31.
National Council for Vocational Qualifications (NCVQ) (1987) The National Council for Vocational Qualification: Its key purposes and aims. London: NCVQ.
32.
Qualifications and Curriculum Authority (2003).
33.
RandallJ. (1995) National Vocational Qualifications in Higher Education – a possible model, Competence & Assessment, June, pp. 10–15.
34.
SwailesS. (1997a) Management Development and Management NVQs, Journal of Management Development, 16, pp. 405–417.
35.
SwailesS. (1997b) Management NVQs in Higher Education: Reflections on experience, Education + Training, 39(3), pp. 96–104.
36.
SwailesS.BrownP. (1999) NVQs in Management: Some pedagogic and marketing implications, Journal of Management Development, 18, pp. 794–804.
37.
TaylorM. (1996) Accessing Higher Educational Awards through National Vocational Qualifications in Management, Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 48, pp. 295–309.
38.
ThomasS.GrimesD. (2003) Evaluating the Integration of Key Skills and NVQs into an Undergraduate Degree Programme: A case study from the graduate apprenticeship initiative, Education + Training, 45(7), pp. 383–391.
39.
University Vocational Awards Council (UVAC) (2000) The Utilisation of National Vocational Qualifications in Higher Education Institutions in England and Wales. Bolton: UVAC.
40.
University Vocational Awards Council (UVAC) (2003) National Occupational Standards Toolkit. Bolton: UVAC.
41.
WelshB. (1996) Developing Managers for the Smaller Business. London: Institute of Management.
42.
WheelerR, (1997) The Process of Change in Higher Education: The impact of enterprise in higher education (EHE); higher education for capability (HEC); and the National Vocational Qualifications on selected disciplines/areas of study in four universities. Unpublished D.Phil. thesis, University of Sussex.
43.
WilliamsS. (1999) Policy Failure in Vocational Education and Training: The introduction of National Vocational Qualifications (1986–1990), Education + Training, 41(5), pp. 216–226.
44.
WintertonJ.WintertonR. (1997) Does Management Development Add Value?British Journal of Management, 8, Special Issue, S65–S76.
