The United Nations Convention and the Swedish curriculum for pre-school clearly state the right of children to express their views in all matters of concern to them. It is imperative, therefore, that an evaluation of the quality of early childhood education includes the voices of children. Without these, an essential part of how children experience quality within various childcare settings as well as an overall understanding of quality in early childhood education is missing. In a study carried out in a small community in Sweden, the quality of various pre-school settings was evaluated both by an external evaluator and by self-evaluations. From the results of the external evaluations, three pre-school units evaluated to be of low quality and three of good quality were selected for in-depth studies. Thirty-nine 5 year-old children from these pre-school units were interviewed about their conceptions of decision-making and how they experienced the opportunities for them to exercise influence in their pre-school setting. The results show that it is vital for the children to participate in decision-making and the meanings given by the children to the concept ‘to decide’, have been grouped into five qualitatively different categories.
References
1.
AnderssonM. (1999) The Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale (ECERS) as a Tool in Evaluating and Improving Quality in Pre-schools (Studies in Educational Sciences, 19). Stockholm: Institute of Education Press.
2.
BaeB. (1997) The Adult—Child Relationship: Spacious and narrow patterns, paper presented at the ENSAC (European Network for School-Age Childcare) Conference, Trondheim, Norway, 31 August-3 September.
3.
BartleyK. (1998) Barnpolitik och barnets rättigheter [Child Policy and the rights of the child] (Monograph from the Department of Sociology, Göteborgs universitet, 67). Gothenburg: Gothenburg University Department of Sociology.
4.
BredekampS. & CoppleC. (Eds) (1997) Developmentally Appropriate Practice in Early Childhood Programs, revised edn.Washington, DC: National Association for the Education of Young Children.
5.
BrunerJ. (1996) The Culture of Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
6.
DahlbergG.MossP. & PenceA. (1999) Beyond Quality in Early Childhood Education and Care — Postmodern perspectives. Pittsburgh: Falmer Press.
7.
DamonW. & PhelpsE. (1989) Strategic Uses of Peer Learning in Children's Education, in BerndtT. & LaddG. (Eds) Peer Relationships in Child Development. New York: Wiley.
8.
DeweyJ. ([1916] 1999) Demokrati och utbildning [Democracy and Education]Göteborg: Daidalos.
9.
DillenbourgP.BakerM.BlayeA. & O'MalleyC. (1996) The Evolution of Research on Collaborative Learning, in ReimannP. & SpadaH. (Eds) Learning in Humans and Machines, pp. 189–205. Oxford: Elsevier.
10.
DoverborgE. & SamuelssonPramling I. (2000) Att förstå barns tankar [To understand children's thinking], 2nd edn.Stockholm: Liber.
11.
DystheO. (1996) Det flerstämmiga klassrummet. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
12.
OgefeltDäversjö A. (1996) Perspektiv på kvalitet i förskolan — En observations och enkätstudie [Perspective on quality in pre-school — An observation and questionnaire study]. Gothenburg: Göteborg University Institute of Education.
13.
GesellA. & FrancesL. (1946) Barn åren fem till tio [Children between the age of five and ten]. Stockholm: Svenska Bokförlaget/Bonniers.
14.
HarmsT. & CliffordR. (1980) The Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University.
15.
HarmsT. & CliffordR. (1983) Assessing Pre-schools Environments with the Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale, in SpodekB. (Ed.) Evaluation in Early Childhood Education, Studies in Educational Evaluation, special issue, vol. 8.
16.
HundeideK. (Draft) Paper: From Early Interaction to Class-room Communication. University of Oslo, June 1999.
17.
JohanssonE. (1999) Etik i småbarns värld. Om värden och normer bland de yngsta barnen i förskolan [Ethics in the world of young children. About values and norms among the youngest children in pre-school]. Göteborg: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis.
18.
JonynieneZ. & SamuelssonPramling I. (1999) Swedish and Lithuanian Students' Experience of Their Rights, Child and Youth Care Forum, 28, pp. 271–392.
19.
KorczakJ. (1986) Janus Korczak — En humanistisk pedagog [Janus Korczak — The humanitarian pedagogue (trans. BrombergD.FichbeinS.HartmanS.LarssonZ. & WroblewskiM.)], Report No. 3/1986. Stockholm: Högskolan för lärarutbilning i Stockholm and Institutionen för pedagogik.
20.
KorczakJ. (1988) Barnets rätt till respekt [The child's right to be respected]. Stockholm: Natur och Kultur.
21.
KärrbyG. (1992) Kvalitet i pedagogiskt arbete med barn [Quality in pedagogical work with children]. Stockholm: Allmänna Förlaget.
22.
KärrbyG. (1997) Behåll och utveckla god kvalitet i förskoleverksamhet [Maintain and enhance good quality in early childhood education], in Socialstyrelsen (Ed.) Röster om den svenska barnomsorgen — En antologi [Voices about Swedish Childcare — An anthology]. Stockholm: Socialstyrelsen.
23.
KärrbyG. (1999) Conceptions of Quality in Early Childhood Education — An analysis of rationales for the rating of quality with the ECERS, paper presented at the EECERA (European Early Childhood Education Research Association) 9th European Conference in Helsinki, Finland, 1–4 September.
24.
KärrbyG. & GiotaJ. (1994) Dimensions of Quality in Swedish Day Care Centers — An analysis of Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale, Early Child Development and Care, 104, pp. 1–22.
25.
LangstedO. (1994) Looking at Quality from the Child's Perspective, in MossP. & PenceA.Valuing Quality in Early Childhood Services — New approaches to defining quality, pp. 28–42. London: Paul Chapman.
26.
LansdownG. (1996) The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child — Progress in the United Kingdom, in NutbrownC. (Ed.) Respectful Educators — Capable learners, children's rights and early education, pp. 1–10. London: Paul Chapman.
27.
Ministry of Education and Science in Sweden (1998a) Curriculum for Pre-school, Lpfö 98. Stockholm: Fritzes.
28.
Ministry of Education and Science in Sweden (1998b) Curriculum for the Compulsory School, the Pre-school Class and the After School Centre, Lpo 94. Stockholm: Fritzes.
29.
MooreC. & FryeD. (1991) The Acquisition and Utility of Theories of Mind, in FryeD. & MooreC. (Eds) Children's Theories of Mind — Mental states and social understanding, pp. 1–14. Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum.
30.
MossP. & PenceA. (1994) Valuing Quality in Early Childhood Services — New approaches to defining quality. London: Paul Chapman.
31.
National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) (1991) Accreditation Criteria and Procedures. Washington, DC: NAEYC.
32.
PhillipsD.A.ScarrS. & McCartneyK. (1987) Dimensions and Effects of Child Care Quality: The Bermuda Study, in PhillipsD. (Ed.) Quality in Child Care: What does research tell us? (Research Monographs of the National Association for the Education of Young Children). Washington, DC: NAEYC.
33.
PiagetJ. (1973) Språk och tanke hos barnet [The child's language and thought]. Lund: Gleerup Bokförlag.
34.
PramlingI. (1983) The Child's Conception of Learning. Göteborg: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis.
35.
PramlingI. (1994) Kunnandets grunder: Prövning av en fenomenografisk ansats till att utveckla barns sätt att uppfatta sin omvärld [The basics of knowledge. A phenomenographic approach to the development of children's conceptions of the world]. Göteborg: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis.
36.
PramlingI. & MalmL. (1997) Happiness and Sadness. Laering i lek og Social Samspill (DMMH's Publikasjonsserie No. 1, pp. 75–90). Trondheim: Dronning Mauds Minne, Høgskole for førskolelærerutdanning.
37.
SamuelssonPramling I. & SheridanS. (1999) Lärandets Grogrund [The basis of learning]. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
38.
PramlingI.KlerfeltA. & GraneldWilliams P. (1995) ‘Först var det roligt, sen’ blev det tråkigt och sen' vande man sig …' Barns Möte med Skolans Värld [First it was fun, then it became boring and then you got used to it — Children's meeting with the world of school] (Report No. 9). Gothenburg: Gothenburg University Institute of Education.
39.
RossbachH.G.CliffordR.M. & HarmsT. (1991) Dimension of Learning Environments. Cross-national Validation of the Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale, paper presented at the American Educational Research Association Annual Conference, Chicago.
40.
ReichRubinstein L. (1993) Samling i förskolan [Circle-time in pre-school]. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell.
41.
ScarrS.EisenbergM. & Deater-DeckardK. (1994) Measurement of Quality in Childcare Centers, Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 9, pp. 131–151.
42.
ScottW. (1996) Choices in Learning, in NutbrownC. (Ed.) Respectful Educators — Capable learners, children's rights and early education, pp. 34–43. London: Paul Chapman.
43.
SheridanS. (1997) Kvalitetsbedömningar med the Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale — En jämförelse mellan en extern utvärderares och förskolepersonals bedömning med ECERS [Evaluations of quality with the Early Childhood Environment Rating Scale — A comparison between external evaluations and pre-school teachers' self-evaluations of quality with the ECERS]. Göteborgs universiet: Institutionen för pedagogik.
44.
SheridanS. (2000) A Comparison of External and Self-evaluations of Quality in Early Childhood Education, Early Child Development and Care, 164, pp. 63–78.
45.
SheridanS. (2001) Quality Evaluation and Quality Enhancement in Pre-school — A model of competence development, Early Child Development and Care, 166, pp. 7–27.
46.
SheridanS. & SamuelssonPramling I. (2000) Pedagogisk kvalitet i barnehagen — Barns laering og utvikling i sentrum [Pedagogical quality in pre-school-focus on children's learning and development], in BlekenU.LarsenHeggen T. & RötnesK. (Eds) Barnehagepolitikk — For barn? Ti Innspill til debatt, pp. 113–147. Oslo: Pedagogiskt Forum.
47.
SheridanS. & SchusterK-M. (in press) Evaluations of Pedagogical Quality in Early Childhood Education — A cross-national perspective, forthcoming in Journal of Research in Childhood Education, 2001.
48.
Statens Offentliga Utredningar. (1996) Delbetänkande av Skolkommitén, Inflytande på riktigt — Om elevers rätt till inflytande, delaktighet och ansvar [Real influence — About pupils' rights to influence, participation and responsibility]. Stockholm: Fritzes.
49.
SylvaK. (1994) School Influences on Children's Development, Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 35, pp. 135–170.
50.
SylvaK.MelhuishE.SammonsP. & Siraj-BlatchfordI. (1999) The Effective Provision of Pre-school Education (EPPE) Project — A longitudinal study funded by the DfEE (1997–2003). London: University of London Institute of Education.
51.
SäljöR. (2000) Lärande i praktiken — Ett sociokulturellt perspektiv [Learning in practice — A sociocultural perspective]. Stockholm: Prisma.
52.
TietzeW.CryerD.BarrioJ.PalaciosJ. & WetzelG. (1996) Comparisons of Observed Process Quality in Early Child Care and Educational Programs in Five Countries, Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 11, pp. 447–475.
53.
TietzeW. & GiotaJ. (Manuscript) Cross-national Assessments of Process Quality by the ECERS — A study on methodological issues.
54.
United Nations Convention (1989) The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. New York: United Nations.
55.
Utbildningsdepartementet (1999) Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development — Country Note. Early Childhood Education and Care Policy in Sweden. Stockholm: Utbildningsdepartementet [Ministry of Education and Science in Sweden].
WinegarL.T. & ValsinerJ. (1992) Children's Development within Social Context. Volume 1. Metatheory and Theory. Hove: Lawrence Erlbaum.
58.
WoodheadM. (1998) Children's Rights and Children's Development: Rethinking the paradigm, in VerhellenE. (Ed.) Understanding Children's Rights: Collected papers presented at the Third International Interdisciplinary Course on Children' Rights. Ghent: Ghent University, Children's Rights Centre.
