Archaeological sites located in agricultural settings are subject to a number of post-depositional processes which can alter their original systemic context. This article presents a case that artifacts may be introduced to agricultural fields as secondary deposits in sediment transported during agricultural activities. As the practice of transporting sediment from one location to another in agricultural settings appear to be widespread, caution should be taken when assigning behavioral significance to surface records in such contexts.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AckerlyN. W. (ED.) 1994Historic and Modern Irrigation Systems in El Paso, Texas, Volume I: Overview, Bureau of Reclamation, Albuquerque District Office, Albuquerque, New Mexico.
2.
AmmermanA. J.1985Plow-Zone Experiments in Calabria, Italy, Journal of Field Archaeology, 12:1, pp. 33–40.
3.
AmmermanA. J. and FeldmanM.1978Replicated Collection of Site Surfaces, American Antiquity, 43, pp. 734–747.
4.
BinfordL. R.BinfordS. R.WhallonR., and HardinM. A.1970Archaeology at Hatchery West, Society for American Archaeology Memoirs24.
5.
CarterD. L.BrockwayC. E., and TanjiK. K.1993Controlling Erosion and Sediment Loss from Furrow-Irrigated Cropland, Journal of Irrigation and Engineering, 119:6, pp. 975–988.
6.
DonkinR. A.1979Agricultural Terracing in the Aboriginal New World, Viking Fund Publications in Anthropology, 56, The University of Arizona Press, Tucson.
7.
DunnellR. C. and SimekJ. F.1995Artifact Size and Plowzone Processes, Journal of Field Archaeology, 22:3, pp. 305–309.
8.
FrinkD. S.1984Artifact Behavior Within the Plow Zone, Journal of Field Archaeology, 11, pp. 356–363.
9.
HallS. A.1992Surficial Geology of the Lower Valley, in El Valle Bajo: The Culture History of the Lower Rio Grande Valley of El Paso, PetersonJ. A. and BrownD. O. (eds.), pp. 10–32, Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso, and Hicks and Company, Austin.
10.
HallS. A.1996Geoarchaeology of the Tigua HUD Property, El Paso County, Texas, in Living on the River's Edge: Archaeological Test Excavations at the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, Texas, Volume I, LeachJ. D.HouserN. P.HarrisonR. D.PetersonJ. A., and MauldinR. P. (eds.), pp. 201–205, Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso.
11.
HouserN. P.1996The Historical Settlement of Ysleta del Sur Pueblo: Analysis and Interpretation of Indian Settlement and Non-Indian Encroachment Within the Center of the Pueblo and Outlying Farm Lands of the Ysleta Grant, in Living on the River's Edge: Archaeological Test Excavations at the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, Texas, Volume I, LeachJ. D.HouserN. P.HarrisonR. D.PetersonJ. A., and MauldinR. P. (eds.), pp. I-1 to I-51, Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso.
12.
JacoH. B.1971Soil Survey of El Paso County, Texas, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service.
13.
KoluvekP. K.TanjiK. K., and TroutT. J.1993Overview of Soil Erosion From Irrigation, Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering, 119:6, pp. 929–947.
14.
LeachJ. D.1996Origin of Artifacts in Plow-Zone Proveniences, in Living on the River's Edge: Archaeological Test Excavations at the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, Texas, Volume I, LeachJ. D.HouserN. P.HarrisonR. D.PetersonJ. A., and MauldinR. P. (eds.), pp. 239–254. Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso.
15.
LeachJ. D.1997Looking for Sites in All the Wrong Places: Secondary Formation Processes and the Origin of Artifacts in Plow-Zone Proveniences, in Proceedings of the Ninth Jornada-Mogollon Conference, MauldinR. P.LeachJ. D., and RuthS. (eds.), pp. 151–165, Centra de Investigaciones Arqueologicas, Publications in Archaeology No. 12.
16.
LeachJ. D.HouserN. P.HarrisonR. D.PetersonJ. A., and MauldinR. P.1996Living on the River's Edge: Archaeological Test Excavations at the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, Texas, Volume I, Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso.
17.
LewarchD. E. and O'BrienM. J.1981aThe Expanding Role of Surface Assemblages in Archaeological Research, in Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory, Vol. 4, SchifferM. B. (ed.), pp. 297–342.
18.
LewarchD. E. and O'BrienM. J.1981bEffect on Short-Term Tillage on Aggregate Provenience Surface Pattern, in Plowzone Archaeology: Contributions to Theory and Technique, O'BrienM. J. and LewarchD. E. (eds.), pp. 7–49, Publications in Anthropology No. 27, Vanderbilt University, Nashville.
19.
LopezM. A.1996Oral History, in Living on the River's Edge: Archaeological Test Excavations at the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, Texas, Volume I, LeachJ. D.HouserN. P.HarrisonR. D.PetersonJ. A., and MauldinR. P. (eds.), pp. F-l to F-4, Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso.
20.
MalloufR. J.1982An Analysis of Plow-Damaged Artifacts: The Brookeen Creek Cache (41HI86), Hill County, Texas, Journal of Field Archaeology, 9:1, pp. 79–98.
21.
MauldinR. P.1996Modeling the Flow of the Rio Grande from A.D. 1600 to 1900: Implications for Making a Living on the River's Edge, in Living on the River's Edge: Archaeological Test Excavations at the Ysleta del Sur Pueblo, Texas, Volume I, LeachJ. D.HouserN. P.HarrisonR. D.PetersonJ. A., and MauldinR. P. (eds.), pp. 45–59, Archaeological Research, Inc., El Paso.
22.
NeelyJ. E.CaranS. C. and WinsboroughB. M.1990Irrigated Agriculture at Hierve El Agua, Oaxaca, Mexico, in Debating Oaxaca Archaeology, MarcusJoyce (ed.), pp. 115–189. Anthropological Papers Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan No. 84.
23.
O'BrienM. J. and LewarchD. E.1981Plowzone Archaeology: Contributions to Theory and Technique, Publications in Anthroplogy No. 27, Vanderbilt University, Nashville.
24.
OdellG. H. and CowanF.1987Estimating Tillage Effects on Artifact Distribution, American Antiquity, 52, pp. 456–484.
25.
OrndorffH.1957History of the Development of Agriculture in the El Paso Valley, M. A. thesis, Texas Western College of the University of Texas, on File at UTEP.
26.
PetersonJ. A.1993Whose History? Whose Place? A Cultural History of the Lower Rio Grande Valley of El Paso, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Anthropology, The University of Texas at Austin.
27.
RedmanC. L. and WatsonP. J.1970Systematic Intensive Surface Collection, American Antiquity, 35, pp. 279–291.
28.
ReynoldsP. J.1982The Ploughzone, in Festschrift zum 100 jahrigen Bestehen der Abteilung für Vorgeschichte. Nuremberg: Naturhistorische Gesellschaft, pp. 315–340.
29.
RiordanT. B.1988The Interpretation of 17th Century Sites through Plow Zone Surface Collections: Examples from St. Mary's City, Maryland, Historical Archaeology, 22:2, pp. 2–16.
30.
RobertsD. G. and BarretD.1984Nightsoil Disposal Practices of the 19th Century and the Origin of Artifacts in Plowzone Proveniences, Historical Archaeology, 18, pp. 108–115.
31.
RoperD. C.1976Lateral Displacement of Artifacts Due to Plowing, American Antiquity, 41, pp. 372–375.
32.
SchifferM. B.1987Formation Processes of the Archaeological Record, University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.
33.
ShottM. J.1995Reliability of Archaeology Records on Cultivated Surfaces: Michigan Case Study, Journal of Field Archaeology, 22:4, pp. 475–490.
34.
StewartG. R. and DonnellyM.1943Soil and Water Economy in the Pueblo South West, Scientific Monthly, 56, pp. 31–44, 134–144.
35.
TroutT. J. and NeiblingW. H.1993Erosion and Sedimentation Processes on Irrigated Fields, Journal of Irrigation and Engineering, 119:6, pp. 947–963.
36.
TurbowitzN. L.1978The Persistence of Settlement Pattern in a Cultivated Field, in Essays in Northeastern Archaeology in Memory of Marian E. White, EnglebrechtW. and GraysonD. K. (eds.), pp. 41–66, Occasional Publications in Northeastern Archaeology 5, Franklin Pierce College, Rindge, New Hampshire.
37.
WaechterS. A.1995CA-MOD-3129/H (TAS-34/H) Site Report (M.P. 056+400; Private), in Report on Archaeological Test Investigations Along the Proposed Tuscarora Pipeline, from Malin, Oregon to Tracy, Nevada, Volume II: Site Reports—Prehistoric Sites. Part I: Modoc Rim and Pi River Valley Sites, DalacorteM. G.RenoR. L.BurkeT. D.MikesellS. D., and McGuireK. R. (eds.), pp. 3.2–1–3.2–6, Far Western Anthropological Group, Inc. and JRP Associates, Inc.
38.
WilkenG. C.1969Drained-Field Agriculture: An Intensive Farming System in Tlaxcala, Mexico, Geographical Review, 59, pp. 215–241.
39.
WilkinsonT.J.1982The Definition of Ancient Manured Zones by Means of Extensive Sherd-Sampling Techniques, Journal of Field Archaeology, 9, pp. 323–333.
40.
WoodburyR. B. and NeelyJ. A.1972Water Control Systems of the Tehuacan Valley, in The Prehistory of the Tehuacan Valley, Volume IC, Chronology and Irrigation, MacNeishR. S. (ed.), pp. 81–153, University of Texas Press, Austin and London.
41.
YorstonR. M.GaffneyV. L., and ReynoldsP. J.1990Simulation of Artefact Movement Due to Cultivation, Journal of Archaeological Science, 17, pp. 67–83.
42.
ZimmermanJ. D.1966Irrigation, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
