This article describes how the tendency of post-Civil War medicine accorded with general social tendencies. Doctors' attitudes toward women reflected their anxiety about female emancipation and changing sex roles. The specialty of gynecology emerged in significant part as a reaction to female emancipation. The strong surgical emphasis in American gynecologic practice has continued. The operations, clitoridectomy and female castration, were intended to reimpose the traditional sexual order (the term “castration” and “female circumcision” implied women had become men). The paper goes on to describe the beginnings of psychosomatic medicine, the circularity of gynecologists' treatment of women, and the effects of this treatment. The operations were in part the expression of a symbiotic relation between doctor and patient. Because they expressed widespread and deep-seated beliefs, they were difficult to challenge.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CaplanR.Psychiatry and the Community in Nineteenth Century America, p. 140. Basic Books, New York, 1969.
2.
DainN.Concepts of Insanity in the United States, 1789–1865, pp. 10, 12, 26, 65–66. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, N. J., 1964.
3.
MeigsC.Woman: Her Diseases and Remedies, Ed. 2, p. 54. Blanchard and Lee, Philadelphia, 1851.
4.
BrighamA.Remarks on the Influence of Mental Cultivation and Mental Excitement Upon Health, Ed. 2, pp. vii, 80–81. Marsh, Capen, and Lyon, Boston, 1833.
5.
JarvisE.On the comparative liability of males and females to insanity, and their comparative curability and mortality when insane. American Journal of Insanity7: 155, 1850.
6.
RayI.Mental Hygiene, p. 54. Hafner Publishing Company, New York, 1968 (facsimile of 1863 edition).
7.
JarvisE.On the supposed increase of insanity. American Journal of Insanity8: 349, 1852.
8.
RayI.The insanity of women produced by desertion or seduction. American Journal of Insanity23: 267, 1866.
9.
Barker-BenfieldB.The Horrors of the Half-Known Life, Ch. 6 and Pt. 3. Harper and Row, New York, forthcoming.
10.
de TocquevilleA.Democracy in America, Vols. 1 and 2. Random House, Vintage edition, New York, 1945.
11.
MeyerD.The Positive Thinkers, pp. 51–56. Doubleday, Garden City, N.Y., 1965.
12.
WiebeR. H.The Search for Order, pp. xiii, 1, 5–6, 8, 52. Hill and Wang, American Century edition, New York, 1968.
13.
GardnerA. K.History of the Art of Midwifery, p. 4. Stringer and Townshend, New York, 1852. (Also published as introduction to Gardner's edition of Smith'sW. TylerThe Modern Practice of Midwifery, Robert M. DeWitt, New York, 1852.).
14.
GardnerA. K.Our Children, p. 210. Belknap and Bliss, Hartford, 1872.
15.
ShryockR. H.Medicine in America, pp. 189–190. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1966.
16.
ShryockR. H.Medicine and Society in America: 1660–1860, p. 147. Cornell University Press, Great Seal edition, Ithaca, N.Y., 1962.
17.
FishbeinM.A History of the American Medical Association, pp. 82–85. W. B. Saunders, Philadelphia, 1947.
18.
SmithH. N.Virgin Land, Ch. X. Vintage, New York, 1950.
19.
VestG. In Up From the Pedestal: Selected Writings in the History of American Feminism, edited by KraditorA., p. 195. Quadrangle Books, Chicago, 1968.
20.
GardnerA. K.New York Medical College for Women. Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper30(759): 71, April 19, 1870.
21.
ToddJ.Woman's Rights, p. 12. Lee and Shepard, Boston, 1867.
22.
GardnerA. K.Conjugal Sins, p. 195. J. S. Redfield, New York, 1870.
23.
MarcyH. O.The early history of abdominal surgery in America. Transactions of the Section on Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children of the American Medical Association, pp. 248–266, 1909.
24.
Transactions of the American Medical Association10:31, 1857.
25.
GardnerA. K.BarkerF.Remarks on puerperal fever. Transactions of the New York Academy of Medicine, 1858.
26.
ThomasT. G.Diseases of Women, Preface to 1st Edition. H. C. Lea, Philadelphia, 1868.
27.
StorerH. R.The Causation, Course and Treatment of Reflex Insanity in Women, p. 79. Lee and Shepard, Boston, 1871.
28.
Barker-BenfieldB.Sexual Surgery, forthcoming.
29.
SimsJ. M.Clinical Notes on Uterine Surgery, pp. 131–135, 206–207. William Wood, New York, 1866.
30.
BaldwinW. O. In The Story of My Life, by SimsJ. M., p. 433. D. Appleton, New York, 1885.
31.
ChadwickJ. R.Obstetrics and gynecological literature, 1876–1881. Transactions of the American Medical Association32: 255, 1881.
32.
Barker-BenfieldB.The spermatic economy. In The American Family in Social-Historical Perspective, edited by GordonM., St. Martin's Press, New York, 1973.
33.
BrownI. BakerOn the Curability of Certain Forms of Insanity, Epilepsy, Catalepsy. Robert Hardwicke, London, 1866.
34.
Meeting to consider the proposition of the Council for the removal of Mr. I. Baker Brown. Br. Med. J.1: Pp. 395–410, 1867.
35.
TaitL.Masturbation. The Medical News53(1):3, July 7, 1888.
36.
BunkerJ.Surgical manpower: A comparison of operations and surgeons in the United States and in England and Wales. New Engl. J. Med.282(3): 135–144, 1970.
37.
BunkerJ.When to operate?Saturday Review, pp. 30–31, August 22, 1970.
38.
NorrisF. S.We need women doctors. Letter to the Editor, Washington Evening Star, December 15, 1970.
39.
BolandeR. P.Ritualistic surgery—Circumcision and tonsillectomy. New Engl. J. Med.280(11): 591–597, 1969.
40.
KlemesrudeJ.Those who have been there aid breast surgery patients. New York Times, February 8, 1971.
41.
WeissE.EnglishO. S.Psychosomatic Medicine, Ed. 3, Ch. 19. W. B. Saunders, Philadelphia, 1957.
42.
Maternity Care in the World: Report of a Joint Group of the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics and the International Confederation of Midwives, pp. 173, 317. Pergamon Press, London, 1966.
43.
JeffersonT.Notes on Virginia, p. 133. Harper Torchbook, New York, 1964.
44.
MyersonA.AyerJ. B.PutnamT. J.KeelerC. E.AlexanderL.Eugenical Sterilization: A Reorientation of the Problem. Macmillan, New York, 1936.
45.
EngelmannG. J.The increasing sterility of American women. Transactions of the Section on Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children of the American Medical Association, pp. 271–295, 1901.
46.
HighamJ.Strangers in the Land, Ch. 6. Atheneum, New York, 1968.
47.
BrownR. M.Historical patterns of violence in America. In Violence in America, edited by GurrGraham, pp. 47–49. Signet, New York, 1969.
48.
BeisnerR. L.Twelve Against Empire: The Anti-Imperialists, 1898–1900, pp. 45–46. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1968.
49.
GilliamD. T.Oophorectomy for the insanity and epilepsy of the female: A plea for its more general adoption. Transactions of the American Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists9: 320,1896.
50.
GoodellW.Clinical notes on the extirpation of the ovaries for insanity. American Journal of Insanity38: 295,1882.
51.
FlexnerE.Century of Struggle, Chs. 11–13,15,16. Atheneum, New York, 1968.
52.
GoodellW.Lessons in Gynecology, pp. 270–276. D. G. Brinton, Philadelphia, 1879.
53.
Van de WarkerE.The fetich of the ovary. American Journal of Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children54: 369, 1906.
54.
MeyerJ.A case of insanity, caused by diseased ovaries, cured by their removal—A phenomenal triumph for operative treatment. Transactions of the American Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists7: 503–504, 1894.
55.
BrockmanD. C.Oophorectomy for grave functional nervous diseases occurring during menstruation. Transactions of the Western Surgical and Gynecological Association, pp. 104–110, 1900.
56.
DudleyA. P.Results of ovarian surgery. Transactions of the Section on Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children of the American Medical Association, pp. 188–189, 1900.
57.
Case of excessive masturbation. American Journal of Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children6: 294–295, 1873–1874.
58.
BatteyR.Normal ovariotomy-case. Atlanta Medical and Surgical Journal10(6): 323–325, 1872.
59.
GardnerA. K.The physical decline of American women. The Knickerbocker55(1): 37–52, 1860. (Also appended to Conjugal Sins, p. 218. J. S. Redfield, New York, 1870.).
60.
BatteyR.Normal ovariotomy. Atlanta Medical and Surgical Journal11(1): 20–21, 1873.
61.
DunnB. S.Conservation of the ovary. Transactions of the American Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists10: 209–224, 1897.
62.
EngelmannG. J.Cliterodectomy [sic]. The American Practitioner25: 3, 1882.
63.
Transactions of the woman's hospital society. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.43: 721, 1901.
64.
CushingE. W.Melancholia, masturbation: Cured by removal of both ovaries. In Report of the Annual Meeting of the Gynecological Society of Boston. J.A.M.A.8: 441–442, 1887.
65.
BlockA. J.Sexual perversion in the female. New Orleans Medical and Surgical Journal22(1): 6, 1894.
66.
ChurchA.Removal of ovaries and tubes in the insane and neurotic. American Journal of Obstetrics and the Diseases of Women and Children28: 494–495, 1893.
67.
Discussion of A. Church's “Removal of ovaries and tubes in the insane and neurotic.”American Journal of Obstetrics and the Diseases of Women and Children28: 569–573, 1893.
68.
PrattE. H.Circumcision of girls. Journal of Orificial Surgery6(9): 385–386, 1898.
69.
MantonW. P.The legal question in operations of the insane. Transactions of the American Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists6: 246, 1893.
70.
BurnhamJ.Psychoanalysis and American medicine: 1894–1918. Psychological Issues5(4): 73–81, 1967.
71.
HamiltonA.The abuse of oophorectomy in diseases of the nervous system. New York Medical Journal57: 180–183, 1893.
72.
EdesR.Points in the diagnosis and treatment of some obscure common neuroses. J.A.M.A.27: 1077–1082, 1896.
73.
EdesR.The relations of pelvic and nervous diseases. J.A.M.A.31: 1133–1136, 1898.
74.
Warner, Quoted in Report of the Annual Meeting of the Gynecological Society of Boston. J.A.M.A.8: 441–442, 1887.
75.
Symington-Brown, Quoted in Report of the Annual Meeting of the Gynecological Society of Boston. J.A.M.A.8: 441–442, 1887.
76.
PraegerE. A.Is so-called conservatism in gynecology conducive to the best results to the patient?Transactions of the American Association of Obstetricians and Gynecologists8: 322, 1895.
77.
CokenowerJ.A plea for conservative operations on the ovaries. Transactions of the Section on Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children of the American Medical Association, p. 298, 1904.
78.
GordonA.Nervous and mental disturbances following castration in women. J.A.M.A.63: 1347, 1914.
79.
MayoW.J.Conservation of the menstrual function. J.A.M.A.74(25): 1685, 1920.
80.
MantonW. P.Mental alienation in women and abdomino-pelvic disease. Transactions of the Section on Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children of the American Medical Association, pp. 9–20, 1909.
81.
Report of the Annual Meeting of the Gynecological Society of Boston. J.A.M.A.8: 441–442, 1887.
82.
ByfordH. T.Manual of Gynecology, Ed. 2, pp. 180–185. P. Blakiston, Philadelphia, 1897.
83.
PolakJ. O.Final results in conservative surgery of the ovaries. Transactions of the Section on Obstetrics and Diseases of Women and Children of the American Medical Association, p. 340, 1909.
84.
KellyH.The ethical side of the operation of oophorectomy. American Journal of Obstetrics27: 208–209, 1898.
85.
MacLeanD.Sexual mutilation. California Medical Journal15: 382–384, 1894.
