Four data sources were used to examine competing interpretations of self-rated health measures: whether they are best classified as summary indicators of both physical and psychological health status, or merely as surrogate measures of physical health. Multiple regression analysis revealed that, within each data source, measures of physical health and depression were each independently associated with general health status ratings after six socio-demographic indicators (sex, race, age, education, income, and residence) were held constant. These results were confirmed using both cross-sectional and longitudinal models, and using several different indicators of physical health. They suggest that researchers should be cautious in interpreting global health ratings, as they contain significant information regarding the psychological, as well as physical, health status of respondents.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
WareJ. E.Davies-AveryA., and DonaldC. A., Conceptualization and Measurement of Health for Adults in the Health Insurance Study: Vol. V—General Health Perceptions, Rand Corporations, Santa Monica, California, R-1987/5-HEW, 1978.
2.
CockerhamW. C.SharpK., and WilcoxJ. A., Aging and Perceived Health Status, Journal of Gerontology, 38, pp. 349–355, 1983.
3.
DesrochesH. F.KatmanB. D., and BallardT. H., Factors Influencing Reporting of Physical Symptoms by the Age of Patient, Geriatrics, 22, pp. 169–175, 1967.
4.
FillenbaumG. G., Social Context and Self-Assessments of Health among the Elderly, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 20, pp. 45–51, 1979.
5.
TesslerR. and MechanicD., Psychological Distress and Perceived Health Status, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 12, pp. 254–262, 1978.
6.
TissueT., Another Look at Self-Rated Health among the Elderly, Journal of Gerontology, 27, pp. 91–94, 1972.
7.
GarrityT. F., Vocational Adjustment after First Myocardial Infarction, Comparative Assessment of Several Variables Suggested in the Literature, Social Science and Medicine, 7, pp. 705–717, 1973.
8.
FerraroK. F., Self-Ratings of Health among the Old and the Old-Old, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 21, pp. 377–383, 1980.
9.
LinnM. W.HunterK. I., and LinnB. S., Self-Assessed Health, Impairment, and Disability in Anglo, Black, and Cuban Elderly, Medical Care, 23, pp. 282–288, 1980.
10.
FriedsamH. J. and MartinH. W., A Comparison of Self and Physicians' Health Ratings in an Older Population, Journal of Health and Human Behavior, 34, pp. 179–183, 1963.
11.
LaRueA.BankL.JarvikL., and HetlandM., Health in Old Age: How Do Physicians' Ratings and Self-Ratings Compare?, Journal of Gerontology, 34, pp. 687–691, 1979.
12.
MaddoxG. L., Some Correlates of Differences in Self-Assessment of Health Status among the Elderly, Journal of Gerontology, 17, pp. 180–185, 1962.
13.
MaddoxG. L. and DouglassE. B., Self-Assessment of Health: A Longitudinal Study of Elderly Subjects, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 14, pp. 87–93, 1973.
14.
IdlerE. L.KaslS. V., and LemkeJ. H., Self-Evaluated Health and Mortality among the Elderly in New Haven, Connecticut, and Iowa and Washington Counties, Iowa, 1982–1986, American Journal of Epidemiology, 131, pp. 91–103, 1990.
15.
KaplanG. A. and CamachoT., Perceived Health and Mortality: A Nine-Year Follow-Up of the Human Population Laboratory Cohort, American Journal of Epidemiology, 117, pp. 292–304, 1983.
16.
KaplanG.BarellV., and LuckyA., Subjective State of Health and Survival in Elderly Subjects, Journals of Gerontology: Social Science, 43, pp. S114–119, 1988.
17.
MosseyJ. M. and ShapiroE., Self-Rated Health: A Predictor of Mortality among the Elderly, American Journal of Public Health, 72, pp. 800–808, 1982.
18.
SingerE.GarfinkelR.CohenS. M., and SroleL., Mortality and Mental Health: Evidence from the Midtown Manhattan Re-Study, Social Science and Medicine, 10, pp. 517–525, 1976.
19.
WeinbergerM.DurnellJ. C.TierneyW. M.MartzB. L.HinerS. L.BarkerJ., and NeillP. J., Self-Rated Health as a Predictor of Hospital Admission and Nursing Home Placement in Elderly Public Housing Tenants, American Journal of Public Health, 76, pp. 457–459, 1986.
20.
JohnsonT. P.HendricksJ.TurnerH. B.StallonesL.MarxM. B., and GarrityT. F., Social Networks and Depression among the Elderly: Metropolitan/Nonmetropolitan Comparisons, Journal of Rural Health, 4, pp. 71–83, 1988.
21.
SuchmanE. A.PhillipsB. S., and StreibG. F., An Analysis of the Validity of Health Questionnaires, Social Forces, 36, pp. 223–232, 1958.
22.
PalmoreE. and LuikartC., Health and Social Factors Related to Life Satisfaction, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 13, pp. 68–80, 1972.
23.
WanT. T. H., Predicting Self-Assessed Health Status: A Multivariate Approach, Health Services Research, 11, pp. 464–477, 1976.
24.
WillitsF. K. and CriderD. M., Health Ratings and Life Satisfaction in Later Middle Years, Journals of Gerontology: Social Sciences, 43, pp. S172–176, 1988.
25.
GarrityT. F.SomesG. W., and MarxM. B., Factors Influencing Self-Assessment of Health, Social Science and Medicine, 12, pp. 77–81, 1978.
26.
HendricksJ. and TurnerH. B., Social Dimensions of Mental Illness among Rural Elderly Populations, International Journal of Aging and Human Development, 26, pp. 179–200, 1987–88.
27.
MarxM. B.StallonesL.GarrityT. F., and JohnsonT. P., Demographics of Pet Ownership among U. S. Adults 21–64 Years of Age, Anthrozoos, 2, pp. 33–37, 1988.
28.
DanchikK. M.SchoenbornC. A., and ElinsonJ., Highlights from Wave I of the National Survey of Personal Health Practices and Consequences, Department of Health and Human Services Publication No. (PHS) 81-1162, U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1981.
29.
BellocN. B.BreslowL., and HochstimJ. R., Measurement of Physical Health in a General Population Survey, American Journal of Epidemiology, 93, pp. 328–336, 1971.
30.
GoldenP. M., Public Use Data Tape Documentation: Wave I and Wave II of the National Survey of Personal Health Practices and Consequences, 1979–1980, U. S. Department of Health and Human Services, Hyattsville, Maryland, 1982.
31.
HochstimJ. R. and RenneK. S., Reliability of Response in a Sociomedical Population Study, Public Opinion Quarterly, 35, pp. 69–79, 1971.
32.
MeltzerJ. W. and HochstimJ. R., Reliability and Validity of Survey Data on Physical Health, Public Health Reports, 85, pp. 1075–1086, 1970.
33.
KaplanG. A. and KotterP. L., Self-Reports Predictive of Mortality from Ischemic Heart Disease: A Nine-Year Follow-Up of the Human Population Laboratory Cohort, Journal of Chronic Diseases, 38, pp. 195–201, 1985.
34.
RadloffL. S., The CES-D Scale: A Self-Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population, Applied Psychological Measurement, 1, pp. 385–401, 1977.
35.
ThoitsP. A., Dimensions of Live Events that Influence Psychological Distress: An Evaluation and Synthesis of the Literature, in Psychosocial Stress: Trends in Theory and Research, KaplanH. B. (ed.), Academic Press, New York, pp. 33–103, 1983.
36.
HimmelfarbS. A. and MurrellS. A., Reliability and Validity of Five Mental Health Scales in Older Persons, Journal of Gerontology, 38, pp. 333–339, 1983.
37.
OrmeJ. G.ReisJ., and HerzE. J., Factorial and Discriminant Validity of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression (CES-D) Scale, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 42, pp. 28–33, 1986.
38.
AneshenselC. S.FrerichsR. R.ClarkV. A., and YokopenicP. A., Measuring Depression in the Community: A Comparison of Telephone and Personal Interviews, Public Opinion Quarterly, 46, pp. 119–126, 1982.
39.
WareJ. E.JohnstonS. A.Davies-AveryA., and BrookR. H., Conceptualization and Measurement of Health for Adults in the Health Insurance Study: Vol III-Mental Health, Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, California, R-1987/3-HEW, 1979.
40.
RiesP. W., Americans Assess Their Health: United States, 1978, Department of Health and Human Services Publication No. (PHS) 83-1570, U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1983.
41.
KirschtJ. P., Social and Psychological Problems of Surveys on Health and Illness, Social Science and Medicine, 5, pp. 519–526, 1971.
42.
BergnerM., Measurement of Health Status, Medical Care, 23, pp. 696–704, 1985.
43.
ManningW. G.NewhouseJ. P., and WareJ. E., The Status of Health in Demand Estimation: Beyond Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor, Rand Corporation, Santa Monica, California, 1980.
44.
BergnerM. and RothmanM. L., Health Status Measures: An Overview and Guide for Selection, Annual Review of Public Health, 8, pp. 191–210, 1987.
45.
JabineT. B.StrafM. L.TanurJ. M., and TourangeauR., Cognitive Aspects of Survey Methodology: Building a Bridge between Disciplines, National Academy Press, Washington, D.C., 1984.
46.
AneshenselC. S. and YokopenicP. A., Tests for Comparability of a Causal Model of Depression under Two Conditions of Interviewing, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 49, pp. 1337–1348, 1985.
