Card (1974) distinguished between the lethality of suicide methods and suicide risk. According to her interpretation of her data the two variables were clearly distinct. This report reconsiders Card's data and tests a revised hypothesis on a different set of data. The conclusion that a serious threat to life resulting from a suicide attempt indicates an increased risk of suicide in the future is consistent with previous work as well as with Card's data, provided an alternative analysis is adopted.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
TuckmanJ. and YoungmanW. F., A Scale for Assessing Suicide Risk of Attempted Suicides, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 24, pp. 17–19, 1968.
2.
CardJ. J., Lethality of Suicidal Methods and Suicide Risk: Two Distinct Concepts, Omega, 5: 1, pp. 37–45, 1974.
3.
SchmidtE. H.O'NealP., and RobinsE., Evaluation of Suicide Attempts as Guide to Therapy, Journal of American Medical Association, 155, pp. 549–557, 1954.
4.
GreerS. and LeeH. A., Subsequent Progress in Potentially Lethal Attempted Suicides, Acta Psychiatrics Scandinavica, 43, pp. 361–371, 1967.
5.
WeissJ. M. A. and ScottK. F., Suicide Attempters Ten Years Later, Comprehensive Psychiatry, 15, pp. 165–171, 1974.
6.
TuckmanJ. and YoungmanW. F., Identifying Suicide Risk Groups Among Attempted Suicides, Public Health Reports, 78, pp. 763–766, 1963.
7.
RosenD., The Serious Suicide Attempt: A Five Year Follow-up Study of 886 Patients, Presented at the 7th International Congress on Suicide Prevention, Amsterdam, August 1973.
8.
StengelE.CookN., and KreegerI. S., Attempted Suicide; Its Social Significance and Effects, Maudsley Monographs, No. 4, Chapman & Hall, 1958.
9.
RubensteinR.MosesR., and LitzT., On Attempted Suicides, A.M. A. Archives of Neurology and Psychiatry, 79, pp. 103–112, 1958.
10.
WeissJ.M.A.NunezN., and SchaieK.W., Quantification of Certain Trends in Attempted Suicide, In: Proceedings of the Third World Congress of Psychiatry, University of Toronto & McGill University Press, Montreal, 1961.
11.
DorpatT. L. and BoswellJ.W., An Evaluation of Suicidal Intent in Suicide Attempts, Comprehensive Psychiatry, 4, pp. 117–125, 1963.
12.
KesselN., Self-Poisoning, British Medical Journal, 2, pp. 1265–1270, 1965.
13.
GrahamJ.D.P. and HitchensR.A.N., Acute Poisoning and Its Prevention, British Journal of Preventive & Social Medicine, 21, pp. 108–114, 1967.
14.
HeyseH.KockottG., and FeuerleinW., The Serious Suicide Attempt: A Biometric Investigation of 100 Patients, Proceedings of the 5th International Conference of Suicide Prevention, London, 1969.
15.
RosenD., The Serious Suicide Attempt: Epidemiological and Follow-up Study of 886 Patients, American Journal of Psychiatry, 127, pp. 764–770, 1970.
16.
BirtchnellJ. and AlarconJ., Depression and Attempted Suicide: A Study of 91 Cases Seen in a Casualty Department, British Journal of Psychiatry, 118, pp. 289–296, 1971.
17.
BirtchnellJ. and AlarconJ., The Motivation and Emotional State of 91 Cases of Attempted Suicide, British Journal of Medical Psychology, 44, pp. 45–52, 1971.
18.
LeonC. A.PerdomoR.MartinezS., and CaffeyB., Psychological Characteristics of Frustrated Suicides, Social Psychiatry, 7, pp. 82–89, 1972.
19.
McHughP. R. and GoodellH., Suicidal Behavior: A Distinction in Patients With Sedative Poisoning Seen in a General Hospital, Archives of General Psychiatry, 25, pp. 456–464, 1971.
20.
SilverM. A.BohnertM.BeckA. T., and MarcusD., Relation of Depression of Attempted Suicide and Seriousness of Intent, Archives of General Psychiatry, 25, pp. 573–576, 1971.
21.
WeismanA. D. and WordenJ. W., Risk-Rescue Rating in Suicide Assessment, Archives of General Psychiatry, 26, pp. 553–560, 1972.
22.
MinkoffK.BergmanE.BeckA. T., and BeckR., Hopelessness, Depression and Attempted Suicide, American Journal of Psychiatry, 130, pp. 455–459, 1973.
23.
FreemanD. J.WilsonK.ThigpenJ., and McGeeR. K., Assessing Intention to Die in Self-Injury Behavior, In: Psychological Assessment of Suicidal Risk, NeuringerC. (ed.), Charles Thomas, Springfield, Illinois, 1974.
24.
PallisD. J. and SainsburyP., The Value of Assessing Intent in Attempted Suicide, To be submitted for publication.
25.
DavisF. B., The Relationship Between Suicide and Attempted Suicide: A Review of the Literature, Psychiatry Quarterly, 41, pp. 752–765, 1967.
26.
SchneidmanE. S. and FarberowN. L., Statistical Comparisons Between Attempted and Completed Suicides, In: The Cry for Help, FarberowN. L. and SchneidmanE. S. (eds.), McGraw-Hill, New York, 1961.
27.
OvenstoneI. M. K., Spectrum of Suicidal Behaviours in Edinburgh, British Journal of Preventive & Social Medicine, 27, pp. 27–35, 1973.
28.
BagleyC., Social Policy and the Prevention of Suicidal Behaviour, British Journal of Social Work, 3: 4, pp. 473–495, 1973.
29.
FoxK. and WeissmanM., Suicide Attempts and Drugs: Contradiction Between Method and Intent, Social Psychiatry, 10, pp. 31–38, 1975.
30.
BarracloughB. M.BunchJ.NelsonB. and SainsburyP., A Hundred Cases of Suicide: Clinical Aspects, British Journal of Psychiatry, 125, pp. 355–373, 1974.
31.
RockwellD. A., Physicians' Knowledge and Attitudes About Suicide, Journal of American Medical Association, 225, pp. 1347–1349, 1973.
32.
PaykelE. S.HallowellC.DressierD. M.ShapiroD. L. and WeissmanM. M., Treatment of Suicide Attempters, Archives of General Psychiatry, 31, pp. 487–491, 1974.
