The birth of industrial society produced demand for the services of professionals specialized in matters related to industrial safety. Three professions—safety engineering, industrial medicine, and ergonomics—are examined. These professions are observed to either submit to single sets of demands, to integrate contradictory demands, or to experience scission. Until the late 1960s their growth appears to have been relatively peaceful and uncontroversial. From this period onward, controversy breaks out over questions related to industrial safety, and professions and government administrations grow. Increasingly, the traditional approach of safety professionals is called into question, and they adopt new orientations. These changes are mapped through the examination of data drawn principally from the United States, France, Great Britain, and to a lesser extent Brazil. The traditional standards approach competes with cost-benefit analysis and with systemic safety for influence; in addition, an emergent approach that analyzes accident causes in terms of social relations of work is detected. From Bhopal to Chernobyl, new technologies subject civilian populations to risks of catastrophic accidents, and the action of safety professionals comes under the spotlight. The analysis constructed permits new understandings of the past and the future of these professions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
DwyerT.Life and Death at Work: Industrial Accidents as a Case of Socially Produced Error. Plenum, New York, 1991.
2.
AlburyD.SchwartzJ.Partial Progress—The Politics of Science and Technology. Pluto, London, 1982.
3.
HirschmanA.Exit, Voice and Loyalty. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1970.
4.
AshfordN. A.Crisis in the Workplace. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1976.
5.
StinchcombeA.Social structure and organizations. In Handbook of Organizations, edited by MarchJ. G., pp. 142–193. Rand McNally, Chicago, 1965.
6.
TouraineA.The Post Industrial Society. Random House, New York, 1971.
7.
AltmanS.Growing pains: A portrait of developing occupational safety and health inAmerica. Job Safety and Health4(8): 24–32, 1976.
8.
NobleD. F.America by Design. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1977.
9.
De BloisL.How the Safety Movement Began. Unpublished manuscript, no date (1931?). [Held in the library of the National Safety Council, Chicago.]
10.
HeinrichH. W.Industrial Accident Prevention: A Scientific Approach, Ed. 4. McGraw Hill, New York, 1959.
11.
MoweryH. W.Cause and prevention of industrial casualty. Ind. Manage.53: 177–189, 1917.
12.
HeinrichH. W.Industrial Accident Prevention: A Scientific Approach. McGraw Hill, New York, 1931.
13.
HagglundG.Some Factors Contributing to Wisconsin Industrial Injuries. Ph.D. thesis, Department of Industrial Relations, University of Wisconsin, 1966.
14.
FreidsonE.Profession of Medicine. Harper & Row, New York, 1970.
15.
BirdF. E.GermainG. L.Damage Control. American Management Association, New York, 1966.
16.
BastiasH.Introdución a la ingeniería de prevención de perdidas. Associação Brasileira de Prevenção de Acidentes, São Paulo, 1978.
17.
Congresso Nacional de Prevenção de Acidentes do Trabalho. Anais do XIX CONPAT. FUNDACENTRO, São Paulo, 1980.
WaltersV.Company doctor's perceptions and responses to conflicting pressures from labor and management. Soc. Probl.30: 1–12, 1982.
23.
BermanD.Death on the Job. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1978.
24.
JufféM.A corps perdu. Seuil, Paris, 1980.
25.
CarterJ. T.Fifty years of medicine in the workplace. J. Soc. Occup. Med., Jubilee Issue, 1985, pp. 4–22.
26.
BagnaraS.BioccaM.MazzonisD.Trends in occupational health and safety policy in Italy. Int. J. Health Serv. 11: 431–450, 1981.
27.
OddoneI.Ambiente di Lavoro. Editrice Sindacale Italiana, Rome, 1977.
28.
MilanaccioA.RicolfiL.Lotte Operate e Ambiente di Lavoro. Giulio Einaudi, Turin, 1976.
29.
WalshD. C.Corporate Physicians. Yale University Press, New Haven, 1987.
30.
ChapanisA.Human engineering. In Encyclopaedia of Occupational Health and Safety, pp. 1061–1064. International Labour Organization, Geneva, 1983.
31.
RibeillG.Les débuts de l'ergonomie en France à la veille de la Première Guerre Mondiale. Mouvement social113: 3–36, 1980.
32.
LavilleA.L'ergonomie. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, 1976.
33.
de MontmollinM.L'analyse du travail, l'ergonomie la “qualité de la vie de travail” les Américains et nous. Travail humain45: 119–124, 1982.
34.
LavilleA.Personal communication, November 7, 1984.
35.
BurawoyM.Manufacturing Consent. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1979.
36.
EdwardsR.Contested Terrain: The Transformation of the Workplace in the Twentieth Century. Basic Books, New York, 1979.
37.
HerrickN. Q.QuinnR. P.The Working Conditions Survey as a source of social indicators. Monthly Labor Rev. 94(4): 15–24, 1971.
38.
DonnellyP. G.The origins of the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970. Soc. Probl.30: 13–25, 1982.
39.
ClutterbuckR. C.The state of industrial ill-health in the United Kingdom. In Health and Work under Capitalism: An International Perspective, edited by NavarroV.BermanD., pp. 141–151. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 1983.
40.
YarrowM.The labor process in coal mining: Struggle for control. In Case Studies on the Labor Process, edited by ZimbalistA., pp. 170–192. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1979.
41.
FayeJ.-P.Lutte des classes à Dunkerque. Galilée, Paris, 1973.
42.
ReasonsC.RossL.PatersonC.Assault on the Worker: Occupational Safety and Health in Canada. Butterworths, Toronto, 1981.
43.
NavarroV.The determinants of social policy: A case study: Regulating health and safety at the workplace in Sweden. Int. J. Health Serv. 13: 517–561, 1983.
44.
ThomasP.Taming the Concrete Jungle. New South Wales Branch of the Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders' Laborers Federation, Sydney, 1973.
45.
BaldamusW.Alienation, anomie and industrial accidents. In Social and Educational Research in Action, edited by WilsonM. J., pp. 104–140. Longman/Open University Press, London, 1979.
46.
SaillardY.SamierA. SerbertUne analyse sectorielle des accidents du travail. Economie et statistique73: 67–74, 1975.
47.
CohnA.Acidentes do Trabalho: Uma Forma de Violência. Brasiliense, São Paulo, 1985.
48.
PossasC.Saúde e Trabalho: A crise da Previdência Social. Graal, Rio de Janeiro, 1981.
49.
HaleA. R.HaleM.A Review of the Industrial Accident Research Literature. Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 1972.
50.
ShortJ. F.The social fabric at risk: Toward the social transformation of risk analysis. Am. Sociol. Rev.49: 711–725, 1984.
51.
SingletonW. T.Accidents and the progress of technology. J. Occup. Accidents4: 91–102, 1982.
52.
SmithR. S.The impact of OSHA inspections on manufacturing injury rates. J. Hum. Resources14: 145–170, 1979.
53.
Occupational Safety and Health2(2): 16, 1986.
54.
Danger comes cheaper. The Economist, November 14, 1987, p. 68.
55.
NicholsT.Industrial safety in Britain and the 1974 Health and Safety at Work Act: The case of manufacturing. Int. J. Soc. Law18: 317–342, 1990.
56.
Sistema Federal de Inspeção do Trabalho. Revista de Inspeção do Trabalho2(2): 63, 1989.
57.
Les accidents du travail en 1984. Travail et sécurité12: 658–672, December 1986.
58.
SingletonW. T.Occupational safety and health systems: A three country comparison. Int. Labour Rev. 122:155–168, 1983.
59.
The First 75 Years [special supplement]. Professional Safety, October 1986.
60.
de KeyserV.Editorial. Société d'ergonomie de langue française—Bulletin de liaison32: 3–5, 1984.
61.
GuerinF.Letter. Société d'ergonomie de langue française—Bulletin de liaison32: 5–6, 1984.
62.
WrightC.Cost containment through health promotion programs. J. Occup. Med.24: 965–968, 1982.
63.
McDonaghT.The physician as manager. J. Occup. Med.24: 99–103, 1982.
64.
By-laws of the System Safety Society. Hazard Prevention22(5): 22–25, 1986.
RosenstockL.HeyerN. H.Emergence of occupational medical services outside the workplace. Am. J. Ind. Med.3: 217–223, 1982.
67.
AssennatoG.NavarroV.Workers' participation and control in Italy: The case of occupational medicine. In Health and Work under Capitalism: An International Perspective, edited by NavarroV.BermanD., pp. 152–167. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 1983.
68.
DuclosD.La santé au travail comme thème d'action militante: L'expérience des groupes C.O.S.H. aux Etats-Unis. Sociologie du travail2: 177–194, 1984 (1987).
69.
RinefortF. C.A new look at occupational safety: A cost-benefit analysis of selected Texas industries. In Readings in Industrial Accident Prevention, edited by PetersenD.GoodaleJ., pp. 36–48. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1980.
70.
HirschhornL.Beyond Mechanization: Work and Technology in a Poslindustrial Age. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1984.
71.
BorzeixA.Syndicalisme et organisation du travail. Centre National des Arts et Métiers, Paris, 1980.
72.
PerrowC.Normal Accidents. Basic Books, New York.
73.
New York Times, December 12, 1987, p. A7.
74.
WeickK. E.Organizational culture as a source of high reliability. California Manage. Rev.29(2): 112–127, 1987.
75.
RobertsK. H.Managing high reliability organizations. California Manage. Rev.32(4): 101–113, 1990.
