Theories of the Welfare State: A Critique

Abstract

The article considers three major non-Marxist explanations of the modern welfare state: functionalist sociological theories, economic theories of government policy, and pluralist theories of democracy. Each is subjected to a critique and all are found wanting, in that none can satisfactorily explain the observable similarities and differences in state welfare intervention within advanced capitalist countries. Functionalist theories can explain the dominant trends at work within all countries, but not the immense diversity in state policies which still persists. Economic and pluralist theories can explain the diversity but not the determinant trends. This failing is related to the separation of objective and subjective aspects in historical explanation: the first school objectifies history, the second subjectifies it. The article concludes by asserting, but not arguing, that a Marxist approach offers a more fruitful way of understanding the welfare state, insofar as it rejects this separation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Briggs

The welfare state in historical perspective. Reprinted in The Welfare State, edited by Schottland

, Harper and Row, New York, 1977.

Expenditure Trends in OECD Countries 1960–1980. Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, 1972.

Gough

State expenditure in advanced capitalism. New Left Review No. 92: 56–64, 1975.

Chester

T. E.

Health care: Problems and priorities. Executive. Graduate School of Business and Public Administration, Cornell University, Fall 1976.

Kaim-Caudle

Comparative Social Policy and Social Security. Martin Robertson, London, 1973.

Goldthorpe

J. H.

The development of social policy in England, 1800–1914. In Transactions of the Fifth World Congress of Sociology, p. 45. International Sociological Association, Louvain, 1964.

Carr

E. H.

What Is History? Penguin, Harmondsworth, 1964.

Jones

G. Stedman

History: The poverty of empiricism. In Ideology in Social Science, edited by Blackburn

, Fontana, London, 1972.

Marshall

T. H.

Citizenship and social class. In Sociology at the Crossroads. Heinemann, London, 1963.

10.

Wilensky

H. L.

Lebeaux

C. N.

Industrial Society and Social Welfare. Glencoe Free Press, New York, 1965.

11.

Galbraith

J. K.

The New Industrial State, Introduction and Ch. 1. Penguin, Harmondsworth, 1969.

12.

Carrier

Kendall

Social policy and social change. Journal of Social Policy, Vol. 2, part 3, 1973.

13.

Gilbert

B. B.

The Evolution of National Insurance in Great Britain. Michael Joseph, London, 1966.

14.

Wilensky

H. L.

The Welfare State and Equality. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1975.

15.

Macpherson

C. B.

Politics: Post-liberal democracy. Reprinted in Ideology and Social Science, edited by Blackburn

, Fontana, London, 1972.

16.

Friedman

Capitalism and Freedom. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1962.

17.

O'Connor

Scientific and ideological elements in the economic theory of government policy. Reprinted in A Critique of Economic Theory, edited by Hunt

Schwartz

, Penquin, Harmondsworth, 1972.

18.

Barry

B. M.

Sociologists, Economists, and Democracy. Collier-Macmillan, London, 1970.

19.

Culyer

A. J.

The Economics of Social Policy, Ch. 4. Martin Robertson, London, 1973.

20.

Peacock

A. T.

Wiseman

The Growth of Public Expenditures in the U.K., Ed. 2. Allen and Unwin, London, 1967.

21.

Culyer

A. J.

, editor. Economic Policies and Social Goals. Martin Robertson, London, 1974.

22.

Titmuss

R. M.

Problems of Social Policy (A Volume of the Official History of the Second World War). Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 1950.

23.

Galbraith

J. K.

American Capitalism: The Concept of Countervailing Power. Penguin, Harmondsworth, 1963.

24.

Eckstein

The English Health Service: Its Origins, Structure and Achievements. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1959.

25.

Hall

Land

Parker

Webb

Change, Choice and Conflict in Social Policy. Heinemann, London, 1975.

26.

Wedderburn

Facts and theories of the welfare state. In The Socialist Register 1965, edited by Miliband

Saville

, p. 138. Merlin Press, London, 1965.

27.

George

Wilding

Social values, social class and social policy. Social and Economic Administration, Vol. 6, No. 3, 1972.

28.

Miliband

The State in Capitalist Society. Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London, 1969.

29.

Gouldner

The Coming Crisis in Western Sociology. Heinemann, London, 1970.

30.

Rex

Key Problems of Sociological Theory. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1961.

31.

Hobsbawm

E. J.

Karl Marx's contribution to historiography. In Ideology and Social Science, edited by Blackburn

, Fontana, London, 1972.