This article reviews ten of the most common mental health-related arguments against assisted death and applies them to the withholding/withdrawal of treatment to determine if the concerns expressed are truly unique to assisted death. After this analysis it is suggested that the mandatory involvement of a mental health professional can alleviate many of the concerns specifically associated with assisted death and that a mental health professional may also be helpful in situations involving the withholding/withdrawal of treatment.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlpersA., & LoB. (1997). Does it make clinical sense to equate terminally ill patients who require life-sustaining interventions with those who do not?Journal of the American Medical Association, 277, 1705–1708.
2.
American Psychological Association. (1997, July). Terminal illness and hastened death requests: The important role of the mental health professional. Washington, DC: Author. (Reprinted in Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 28, 544–547 [1997].)
3.
AngellM. (1997). The Supreme Court and physician-assisted suicide—The ultimate right. New England Journal of Medicine, 336, 50–53.
4.
BackA. L.WallaceJ. I.StarksH. E., & PearlmanR. A. (1996). Physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia in Washington state: Patient requests and physician responses. Journal of the American Medical Association, 275, 919–925.
5.
BeeryL. C.PrigersonH. G.BierhalsA. J.SantucciL. M.NewsomJ. T.MacIejewskiP. K.RappS. R.FasiczkaA., & ReynoldsC. F.III. (1997). Traumatic grief, depression and caregiving of elderly spouses of the terminally ill. Omega, 35, 261–279.
6.
BlockS. D., & BillingsJ. A. (1995). Patient requests for euthanasia and assisted suicide in terminal illness. Psychosomatics, 36, 445–457.
7.
Brief of the American Suicide Foundation. (1996, November). Filed with the Supreme Court of the United States, October, 1996 term for Washington v. Glucksberg and Vacco v. Quill.
8.
BrownJ. H.HenteleffP.BarakatS., & RoweC. J. (1986). Is it normal for terminally ill patients to desire death?American Journal of Psychiatry, 143, 208–211.
9.
CainC., & KiskaT. (1998, Nov. 4). Assisted suicide: Religion key factor in Proposal B defeat. Detroit News.
10.
ChochinovH. M.WilsonK. G.EnnsM.MowchunN.LanderS.LevittM., & ClinchJ. J. (1995). Desire for death in the terminally ill. American Journal of Psychiatry, 152, 1185–1191.
11.
ConwellY.DubersteinP. R.CoxC.HerrmannJ. H.ForbesN. T., & CaineE. D. (1996). Relationships of age and Axis I diagnoses in victims of completed suicide: A psychological autopsy study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 1001–1008.
12.
CookeM.GourlayL.ColletteL.BoccellariA.ChesneyM. A., & FolkmanS. (1998). Informal caregivers and the intention to hasten AIDS-related death. Archives of Internal Medicine, 158, 69–75.
13.
EmanuelE. J., & BattinM. P. (1998). What are the potential cost savings from legalizing physician-assisted suicide?New England Journal of Medicine, 339, 167–172.
14.
EmanuelE. J.FaircloughD. L.DanielsE. R., & ClarridgeB. R. (1996). Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: Attitudes and experiences of oncology patients, oncologists, and the public. Lancet, 347, 1805–1810.
15.
GanziniL.LeeM. A.HeintzR. T.BloomJ. D., & FennD. S. (1994). The effect of depression treatment on elderly patients' preferences for life-sustaining medical therapy. American Journal of Psychiatry, 151, 1631–1636.
16.
GrissoT., & AppelbaumP. S. (1998). Assessing competence to consent to treatment: A guide for physicians and other health professionals. New York: Oxford.
17.
HooperS. C.VaughanK. J.TennantC. C., & PerzJ. M. (1996). Major depression and refusal of life-sustaining treatment in the elderly. Medical Journal of Australia, 165, 416–419.
18.
JamisonS. (1995). Final acts of love: Families, friends and assisted dying. New York: Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam.
19.
JamisonS. (1997). Assisted suicide: A decision-making guide for health professionals. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
20.
KleespiesP. M., & MoriD. L. (1998). Life and death decisions: Refusing life-sustaining treatment. In KleespiesP. M. (Ed.), Emergencies in mental health practice: Evaluation and management (pp. 145–173). New York: Guilford.
21.
LeeM., & GanziniL. (1994). The effect of recovery from depression on preferences for life-sustaining therapy in older patients. Journal of Gerontology, 49 (1), M15–M21.
22.
LeeM. A., & TolleS. W. (1996). Oregon's assisted suicide vote: The silver lining. Annals of Internal Medicine, 124, 267–269.
23.
LesterD. (1995). Counseling the suicidal person in the modern age: Direct decision therapy. Crisis Intervention, 2, 159–165.
24.
LesterD. (1997). Easing the legacy of suicide: Counselor assisted suicide. Changes, 15, 134–139.
25.
MayoD. J. (1998). Rational suicide?Journal of Personal and Interpersonal Loss, 3, 193–203.
26.
McCartneyJ. R. (1978). Suicide vs right to refuse treatment in the chronically ill. Psychosomatics, 19, 548–551.
27.
MeiselA. (1997). Physician-assisted suicide: A common law roadmap for state courts. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 24, 817–857.
28.
MoskowitzE. H. (1997). Mental illness, physical illness, and the legalization of physician-assisted suicide. Fordham Urban Law Journal, 24, 781–794.
29.
OgdenR. (1994a). Euthanasia, assisted suicide & AIDS. New Westminster, British Columbia: Peroglyphics.
30.
OgdenR. (1994b). Palliative care and euthanasia: A continuum of care?Journal of Palliative Care, 10, 82–85.
31.
Oregon Death with Dignity Act. (1995). Or. Rev. Stat. § 127.800–127.995.
32.
OrentlicherD. (1996). The legalization of physician-assisted suicide. New England Journal of Medicine, 335, 663–667.
33.
OrentlicherD. (1997). The Supreme Court and physician-assisted suicide: Rejecting assisted suicide but embracing euthanasia. New England Journal of Medicine, 337, 1236–1239.
34.
PeruzziN.CanaparyA., & BongarB. (1996). Physician-assisted suicide: The role of mental health professionals. Ethics and Behavior, 6, 353–366.
35.
PrestonT. A., & MeroR. (1996). Observations concerning terminally ill patients who choose suicide. Journal of Pharmaceutical Care in Pain & Symptom Control, 4, 183–192.
36.
QuillT. E.LoB., & BrockD. W. (1997). Palliative options of last resort: A comparison of voluntarily stopping eating and drinking, terminal sedation, physician-assisted suicide, and voluntary active euthanasia. Journal of the American Medical Association, 278, 2099–2104.
37.
RyanC. J. (1996). Depression, decisions and the desire to die. Medical Journal of Australia, 165, 411.
38.
SilvermanE.RangeL., & OverholserJ. (1994). Bereavement from suicide as compared to other forms of bereavement. Omega, 30, 41–51.
39.
SullivanM. D.GanziniL., & YoungnerS. J. (1998). Should psychiatrists serve as gatekeepers for physician-assisted suicide?Hastings Center Report, 28, 24–31.
40.
SullivanM. D., & YoungnerS. J. (1994). Depression, competence, and the right to refuse lifesaving medical treatment. American Journal of Psychiatry, 151, 971–978.
41.
Task Force to Improve the Care of Terminally Ill Oregonians (Ed.) (1998). The Oregon Death with Dignity Act: A guidebook for health care providers. Portland, OR: Center for Ethics in Health Care, Oregon Health Sciences University.
42.
TolleS. W. (1998). Care of the dying: Clinical and financial lessons from the Oregon experience. Annals of Internal Medicine, 128, 567–568.
43.
Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1985). Springfield, MA: Merriam-Webster.
44.
WerthJ. L.Jr. (1996). Rational suicide? Implications for mental health professionals. Washington, DC: Taylor & Francis.
45.
WerthJ. L.Jr. (Ed.) (1999a). Contemporary perspectives on rational suicide. Washington, DC: Taylor & Francis.
46.
WerthJ. L.Jr. (1999b). The role of the mental health professional in helping significant others of persons who are assisted in death. Death Studies.
47.
WerthJ. L.Jr. (1999c). When is a mental health professional competent to assess a person's decision to hasten death?Ethics and Behavior.
48.
WerthJ. L.Jr.BenjaminG. A. H., & FarrenkopfT. (in press). Requests for assisted death: Guidelines for assessing mental capacity and impaired judgment. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law.
49.
WerthJ. L.Jr., & GordonJ. R. (1998). Helping at the end of life: Hastened death and the mental health professional. In VandeCreekL.KnappS., & JacksonT. L. (Eds.), Innovations in clinical practice: A sourcebook (Vol. 16) (pp. 385–398). Sarasota, FL: Professional Resources Press.
50.
WerthJ. L.Jr.HoldwickD. J.MountM. K., & PitmanL. J. (1997, April). The legacy of hastened death. American Association of Suicidology Convention, Memphis, TN.
