Political Devolution and the Health Services in Great Britain

Abstract

This article reviews the effects of political devolution on health care in the countries of Great Britain at the end of the first term of the new political institutions created in 1999. In the light of the powers transferred, an assessment is made of the nature and extent of policy autonomy exercised by the devolved administrations. The author considers the question of whether political devolution is leading to local variations in health care provision that threaten established concepts of equity in a U.K. National Health Service. Policy areas discussed include the personal care of older people, mental health, governance, competition, the role of the private sector, and the health care workforce. Also discussed are the dynamics of intergovernmental relations in the longer term, including the effects of the developing European Union. The article concludes by assessing the extent to which the individual countries within Great Britain are likely to develop health care systems with distinctive identities.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cabinet Office. Your Region, Your Choice: Revitalising the English Regions. Stationery Office, London, 2002.

Woods

K. J.

Health policy and the NHS in the UK 1997–2002. In Devolution in Practice, ed. Adams

and Robinson

, pp. 25–59. Institute of Public Policy Research and Economic and Social Research Council, London, 2002.

Banting

, and Corbett

Health Policy and Federalism. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal and Kingston, 2002.

Cameron

, and Dixon

J. M.

, Postcode prescribing is alive and well in Scotland. BMJ 325: 101, 2002.

Wanless

Securing Our Future Health: Interim Report. H.M. Treasury, London, 2001.

Wanless

Securing Our Future Health: Taking a Long-Term View. H.M. Treasury, London, 2002.

Osmond

From corporate body to virtual parliament. In The State of the Nations 2003, ed. Hazell

, pp. 13–47. Imprint Academic, Exeter, England, 2003.

Bell

, and Christie

The Barnett Formula: Nobody's child? In The State of the Nations 2001, ed. Trench

. Imprint Academic, Exeter, England, 2001.

Scott

P. H.

In Bed with an Elephant. Saltire Society Booklet, Edinburgh, 1985.

10.

Kennedy

In Bed with an Elephant: A Journey Through Scotland's Past and Present. Corgi Books, London, 1996.

11.

Osmond

In search of stability: Coalition politics in the second year of the National Assembly for Wales. In The State of the Nations 2001, ed. Trench

. Imprint Academic, Exeter, England, 2001.

12.

Simeon

Free personal care: Policy divergence and social citizenship. In The State of the Nations 2003, ed. Hazell

. Imprint Academic, Exeter, England, 2003.

13.

Department of Health. A Service with Ambitions. Stationery Office, London, 1997.

14.

The Scottish Office, Department of Health. Designed to Care. Stationery Office, Edinburgh, 1997.

15.

Department of Health. Delivering the NHS Plan. Cmnd Paper 5503. Stationery Office, London, 2002.

16.

Secretary of State for Health (Alan Milburn). Shifting the Balance of Power in the NHS. Speech at the launch of the NHS Modernisation Agency, April 25, 2002. Department of Health, London, 2002. www.doh.gov.uk/speeches.

17.

Milburn

Redefining the NHS. Speech to the New Health Network, January 15, 2002. Department of Health, London, 2002. www.doh.gov.uk/speeches.

18.

Department of Health. A Guide to Foundation Trusts. December 2002. www.doh.gov.uk.

19.

Scottish Executive Department of Health. Partnership for Care: Scotland's Health White Paper. Stationery Office, Edinburgh, 2003.

20.

Woods

K. J.

A Critical Appraisal of Accountability Structures in Integrated Healthcare Systems. Scottish Executive Department of Health, Glasgow, 2002. www.show.scot.nhs.uk/sehd/publications/DC20021001CritApprAccount.pdf.

21.

H.M. Treasury, Chancellor of the Exchequer (Gordon Brown). A Modern Agenda for Prosperity and Reform. Speech to the Social Market Foundation, February 3, 2003. www.hm-treasury.gov.uk.

22.

Gaffney

, PFI and the NHS—Is there an economic case? BMJ 319: 116–119, 1999.

23.

H.M. Treasury. Spending Review Report 2000. London, 2002. www.hm-treasury.gov.uk.

24.

Scottish Parliament. Written Answers SW1–5574, July 24, 2000.

25.

Mossialos

, and McKee

EU Law and the Social Character of Health Care P.I.E—Peter Lang, Brussels, 2002.

26.

Mossialos

McKee

, and Baeten

The Impact of EU Law on Health Care Systems. P.I.E—Peter Lang, Brussels, 2002.

27.

Douglas

Richardson

, and Robson

A Better Way. Reform: Commission on the Reform of Public Services, London, 2003. www.reformbritain.com.

28.

Jeffrey

Uniformity and diversity in policy provision: Insights from the US, Germany and Canada. In Devolution in Practice, ed. Adams

and Robinson

, pp. 176–197. Institute of Public Policy Research and Economic and Social Research Council, London, 2002.