Borderlands between Neurology and Psychiatry: Observations in a Neurological Hospital

Abstract

This article describes psychiatric liaison, in its clinical and teaching aspects, at the Montreal Neurological Institute. Referral patterns are illustrated by data on 200 neurological and neurosurgical patients referred for psychiatric consultation. Our total patient material of nearly 1000 such patients seen in consultation and a joint weekly teaching session provide the basis for comprehensive discussion of the borderlands between neurology and psychiatry. It is concluded that close collaboration between these two disciplines is advantageous to both, in terms of improved clinical training of residents, identification of promising areas for interdisciplinary research, and better overall patient care. These gains justify the development of such liaison in other centers.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Severinghaus

: A medical discipline takes stock. Arch Neurol (Chicago) 17: 461–70, 1967.

Woodger

: Biology and Language. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1952.

Rose

: The current status of education for neurology. Trans Amer Neurol Ass 94: 1–10, 1969.

Wilson

Wells

Irigaray

: Should psychiatry and neurology integrate? Amer J Psychiat 128: 617–22, 1971.

Lipowski

: Consultation-liaison psychiatry in general hospital. Comprehens Psychiat 12: 461–65, 1971.

Lipowski

: Psychiatric liaison with neurology and neurosurgery. Amer J Psychiat (in press)

Teitelbaum

: Psychosomatic Neurology. New York, Grune & Stratton, 1964.

Kligerman

McKegney

: Patterns of psychiatric consultation in two general hospitals. Psychiat in Med 2: 126–32, 1971.

Lipowski

: Review of consultation psychiatry and psychosomatic medicine: II. Clinical aspects. Psychosom Med 29: 201–24, 1967.

10.

Cleghorn

: Hysteria: Multiple manifestations of semantic confusion. Canad Psychiat Ass J 14: 539–51, 1969.

11.

Engel

: Conversion symptoms, Signs and Symptoms. 5th ed. Edited by MacBryde

Blacklow

. Philadelphia, Lippincott, 1970, pp 650–68

12.

Aring

: Observations on multiple sclerosis and conversion hysteria. Brain 88: 663–74, 1965.

13.

Nicol

: Masks of hysteria, medical and neurological. NY State J Med 69: 1883–87, 1969.

14.

Stevens

: Conversion hysteria: A neurologic emergency. Mayo Clin Proc 43: 54–64, 1968.

15.

Ziegler

: Neurological disease and hysteria: The differential diagnosis. Int J Neuropsychiat 3: 388–96, 1967.

16.

Liske

Forster

: Pseudoseizures: A problem in the diagnosis and management of epileptic patients. Neurology (Minneap) 14: 41–9, 1964.

17.

Niedermeyer

Blumer

Holscher

Walker

: Classical hysterical seizures facilitated by anticonvulsant toxicity. Psychiat Clin 3: 71–84, 1970.

18.

Kirshner

Kaplan

: Conversion as a manifestation of crisis in life situation: A report on seven cases of ataxia and paralysis of the lower extremities. Comprehens Psychiat 11: 260–66, 1970.

19.

Fullerton

Munsat

: Pseudo-myasthenia gravis: A conversion reaction. J Nerv Ment Dis 142: 78–86, 1966.

20.

Weinstein

Lyerly

: Conversion hysteria following brain injury. Arch Neurol (Chicago) 15: 545–48, 1966.

21.

Slater

: Diagnosis of “hysteria.” Brit Med J 1: 1395–99, 1965.

22.

Cleghorn

Curtis

: Psychosomatic accompaniments of latent and manifest depressive affect. Canad Psychiat Ass J 4 (Suppl): 13–28, 1959.

23.

Gallemore

Jr Wilson

: The complaint of pain in the clinical setting of affective disorders. Sth Med J 62: 551–55, 1969.

24.

Ling

Oftedal

Weinberg

: Depressive illness in childhood presenting as severe headache. Amer J Dis Child 120: 122–24, 1970.

25.

Levine

: Depression, back pain, and disc protrusion. Dis Nerv Syst 32: 41–45, 1971.

26.

Lascelles

: Atypical facial pain and depression. Brit J Psychiat 112: 651–59, 1966.

27.

Engel

: Pain, Signs and Symptoms. 5th ed. Edited by MacBryde

Blacklow

. Philadelphia, Lippincott, 1970, pp 44–61

28.

Lipowski

: Psychosocial aspects of disease. Ann Intern Med 71: 1197–206, 1969.

29.

MacRae

: Isolated fear: A temporal lobe aura. Neurology (Minneap) 4: 497–505, 1954.

30.

Weiner

: Emotional aspects of chronic tension headache: A study of soldiers and their dependents. Headache 9: 162–71, 1969.

31.

Flor-Henry

: Psychosis and temporal lobe epilepsy. Epilepsia (Amst) 10: 363–95, 1969.

32.

Slater

: The schizophrenia-like illnesses of epilepsy, Current Problems in Neuropsychiatry. Edited by Herrington

. Ashford, Kent, Headley, 1969, pp 77–81

33.

Lipowski

(ed): Psychosocial Aspects of Physical Illness, Advances in Psychosomatic Medicine, Vol. 8 (in press)

34.

Davison

Bagley

: Schizophrenia-like psychoses associated with organic disorders of the central nervous system: A review of the literature, Current Problems in Neuropsychiatry. Edited by Herrington

. Ashford, Kent, Headley, 1969, pp 113–84

35.

Misra

Hay

: Encephalitis presenting as acute schizophrenia. Brit Med J 1: 532–33, 1971.

36.

Sobin

Ozer

: Mental disorders in acute encephalitis. J Mt Sinai Hosp 33: 73–82, 1966.

37.

Glaser

Pincus

: Limbic encephalitis. J Nerv Ment Dis 149: 59–67, 1969.

38.

Montreal Neurological Institute and Montreal Neurological Hospital: Thirty-fifth annual report, 1969–1970.

39.

Lipowski

: Delirium, clouding of consciousness and confusion. J Nerv Ment Dis 145: 227–55, 1967.

40.

Engel

Romano

: Delirium, a syndrome of cerebral insufficiency. J Chron Dis 9: 260–77, 1959.

41.

Bower

: The differential diagnosis of dementia. Med J Austr 2: 623–26, 1971.

42.

Victor

Adams

Collins

: The Wernicke-Korsakoff Syndrome. Philadelphia, Davis, 1971.

43.

Vijayan

Cuanang

Dreyfus

: Dementia, current concepts. Calif Med 111: 208–16, 1969.

44.

Lowy

Engelsmann

Lipowski

: Cognitive functioning in a medical ward population (in press)

45.

Lipowski

: Physical illness, the individual and the coping processes. Psychiat in Med 1: 91–102, 1970.

46.

Lipowski

: Review of consultation psychiatry and psychosomatic medicine: III. Theoretical issues. Psychosom Med 30: 395–422, 1968.

47.

Janis

: Psychological Stress. New York, Wiley, 1958.

48.

Wadeson

: Anxiety in the dreams of a neurosurgical patient. Arch Gen Psychiat 14: 249–52, 1966.

49.

Horowitz

: Psychosocial Function in Epilepsy. Springfield, Illinois, Charles C Thomas, 1970.

50.

Penman

: Pain as an old friend. Lancet 1: 633–36, 1954.

51.

Winston

Hirschenfang

Fine

Stern

: Patterns of psychological decompensation in patients with spinal cord syndromes. Dis Nerv Syst 30: 824–32, 1969.

52.

Brolley

Hollender

: Psychological problems of patients with myasthenia gravis. J Nerv Ment Dis 122: 178–84, 1955.

53.

Hirschenfang

Goldberg

Benton

: Psychological aspects of patients with facial paralysis. Dis Nerv Syst 30: 257–61, 1969.

54.

Hirschenfang

Shulman

Benton

: Psychosocial factors influencing the rehabilitation of the hemiplegic patient. Dis Nerv Syst 29: 373–79, 1968.

55.

Surridge

: An investigation into some psychiatric aspects of multiple sclerosis. Brit J Psychiat 115: 749–64, 1969.

56.

Mindham

RHS

: Psychiatric symptoms in Parkinsonism. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiat 33: 188–91, 1970.

57.

Tikofsky

: Emotional and intellectual considerations in the rehabilitation of stroke patients. Paper presented at Texas Institute for Rehabilitation and Research, Houston, Texas, January 20, 1966.

58.

Hoerner

Horowitz

: Diagnosis, prognosis, and rehabilitation in patients with aphasia. J Amer Med Ass 166: 1573–76, 1958.

59.

Visotsky

Hamburg

Goss

Lebovits

: Coping behavior under extreme stress. Arch Gen Psychiat 5: 423–48, 1961.

60.

Lishman

: Brain damage in relation to psychiatric disability after head injury. Brit J Psychiat 114: 373–410, 1968.

61.

La Baw

: Denial inside out: Subjective experience with anosognosia in closed head injury. Psychiatry 32: 174–91, 1969.

62.

Whitehead

: Science and the Modern World. New York, Macmillan, 1926, p 23