Phenomenological evidence for olfactory sensation in the absence of appropriate stimulation—imagery—is inconclusive and draws most support from reports of olfactory hallucinations. The current study examined whether more convincing phenomenological evidence could be obtained from normal participants, by studying reports of their olfactory dreams. A questionnaire approach (N = 284) revealed that olfactory dreams were uncommon, had features similar to actual olfaction (emotive and brief), were representative of odors encountered in everyday life, and were positively related to self-report volitional imagery ability. In addition, a sub-group (N = 116) also completed an odor identification test. Participants who experienced olfactory dreams were significantly better at identifying odors, an effect not mediated by motivational or attentional factors. These findings suggest people can experience olfactory images although their occurrence may be governed by the strength of connections between olfactory and semantic memory—notoriously weak in olfaction.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CainW. S., To Know with the Nose: Keys to Odor Identification, Science, 203, pp. 468–470, 1979.
2.
DesorJ. A.BeauchampG. K., The Human Capacity to Transmit Olfactory Information, Perception and Psychophysics, 16, pp. 551–556, 1974.
3.
LarssonM., Semantic Factors in Episodic Recognition of Common Odors in Early and Late Childhood: A Review, Chemical Senses, 22, pp. 623–633, 1997.
4.
LawlessH. T.EngenT., Associations to Odors: Interference, Mnemonics and Verbal Labelling, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory, 33, pp. 52–59, 1997.
5.
EngenT., Odor Sensation and Memory, Praeger, New York, 1991.
6.
WhiteT. L., Olfactory Memory: The Long and the Short of It, Chemical Senses, 23, pp. 433–441, 1998.
7.
BaddeleyA.AndradeJ., Working Memory and the Vividness of Imagery, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 129, pp. 126–145, 2000.
8.
LorigT. S., On the Similarity of Odor and Language Perception, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 23, pp. 391–398, 1999.
9.
CrowderR. G.SchabF. R., Imagery for Odors, in Memory for Odors, SchabF. R.CrowderR. G. (eds.), LEA, New Jersey, pp. 93–107, 1995.
10.
HerzR. S., Verbal Coding in Olfactory versus Nonolfactory Cognition, Memory & Cognition, 28, pp. 957–964, 2000.
11.
BarrettT. R.CaylorM. R., Verbal Hallucinations in Normals, V: Perceived Reality Characteristics, Personality and Individual Differences, 25, pp. 209–221, 1998.
12.
BarodawalaS.MulleyG. P., Visual Hallucinations, Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London, 31, pp. 42–48, 1997.
13.
FischmanL. G., Dreams, Hallucinogenic Drug States, and Schizophrenia: A Psychological and Biological Comparison, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 9, pp. 73–94, 1983.
14.
HorowitzM. J., Hallucinations: An Information-processing Approach, in Hallucinations: Behavior, Experience and Theory, SiegelR. K. (ed.), John Wiley, Toronto, pp. 163–195, 1975.
15.
AndradeC.SrinathS.AndradeC., True Hallucinations in Non-Psychotic States, Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 34, pp. 704–706, 1989.
16.
FinkeR. A., Levels of Equivalence in Imagery and Perception, Psychological Review, 87, pp. 113–132, 1980.
17.
FinkeR. A., Theories Relating Mental Imagery to Perception, Psychological Bulletin, 98, pp. 236–259, 1985.
18.
KerrN. H., Mental Imagery, Dreams and Perception, in Dreaming as Cognition, CavalleroC.FoulkesD. (eds.), Harvester Wheatsheaf, New York, pp. 18–37, 1993.
19.
SmithJ. D., The Auditory Hallucinations of Schizophrenia, in Auditory Imagery, RiesbergD. (ed.), LEA, New Jersey, pp. 151–178, 1992.
20.
WeissA. P.HeckersS., Neuroimaging of Hallucinations: A Review of the Literature, Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging Section, 92, pp. 61–74, 1999.
21.
RichardsonJ. T. E., Imagery, Psychology Press, Hove, United Kingdom, 1999.
22.
BrowerD., The Experimental Study of Imagery: II. The Relative Predominance of Various Imagery Modalities, The Journal of General Psychology, 37, pp. 199–200, 1947.
23.
SheehanP. W., A Shortened Form of Betts' Questionnaire upon Mental Imagery, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 23, pp. 386–389, 1967.
24.
AshtonR.WhiteK. D.LawH., The Measurement of Imagery Vividness: Effects of Format and Order on Betts' Questionnaire upon Mental Imagery, Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, 10, pp. 68–78, 1978.
25.
AshtonR.WhiteK. D., Sex Differences in Imagery Vividness: An Artefact of the Test, British Journal of Psychology, 71, pp. 35–38, 1980.
26.
LawlessH. T., Olfactory Psychophysics, in Tasting and Smelling, BeauchampG. K.BartoshukL. (eds.), Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 125–175, 1997.
27.
OhayonM. M., Prevalence of Hallucinations and Their Pathological Associations in the General Population, Psychiatry Research, 97, pp. 153–164, 2000.
28.
GilbertA. N.CrouchM.KempS. E., Olfactory and Visual Mental Imagery, Journal of Mental Imagery, 22, pp. 137–146, 1998.
29.
Di VestaF. J.IngersollG.SunshineP., A Factor Analysis of Imagery Tests, Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 10, pp. 471–479, 1971.
30.
McDermottK. B.RoedigerH. L., Effects of Imagery on Perceptual Implicit Memory Tests, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition, 20, pp. 1379–1390, 1994.
31.
McKelvieS. J., The VVIQ as a Psychometric Test of Individual Differences in Visual Imagery Vividness: A Critical Review and Plea for Direction, Journal of Mental Imagery, 19, pp. 1–106, 1995.
32.
LymanB. J., A Mind's Nose Makes Scents: Evidence for the Existence of Olfactory Imagery (Doctoral dissertation, University of Notre Dame), Dissertation Abstracts International, 48, p. 2807B, 1988.
33.
DjordjevicJ.ZatorreR.PetridesM.Jones-GotmanM., The Mind's Nose: Effects of Odor and Visual Imagery on Odor Detection, Psychological Science, 15, pp. 143–148, 2004.
34.
LymanB. J.McDanielsM. A., Memory for Odors and Odor Names: Modalities of Elaboration and Imagery, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition, 16, pp. 656–664, 1990.
35.
BancaudJ.Brunet-BourginF.ChauvelP.HalgrenE., Anatomical Origins of déjà vu and Vivid “Memories” in Human Temporal Lobe Epilepsy, Brain, 117, pp. 71–90, 1994.
36.
FisherS., An Investigation of Alleged Conditioning Phenomena Under Hypnosis, Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis, 3, pp. 71–103, 1955.
37.
MarksL. E., The Unity of the Senses, Academic Press, London, 1978.
38.
GreenbergM. S., Olfactory Hallucinations, in Science of Olfaction, SerbyM. J.ChoborK. L. (eds.), Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 467–499, 1995.
39.
TooneB. K., Psychomotor Seizures, Arterio-venous Malformation and the Olfactory Reference Syndrome, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 58, pp. 61–66, 1978.
40.
EfronR., The Effect of Olfactory Stimuli in Arresting Uncinate Fits, Brain, 79, pp. 267–281, 1956.
41.
DalyD., Uncinate Fits, Neurology, 8, pp. 250–260, 1958.
42.
EmbrilJ. A.CamfieldP.ArtsobH.ChaseD. P., Powassan Virus Encephalitis Resembling Herpes Simplex Encephalitis, Archives of Internal Medicine, 143, pp. 341–343, 1983.
43.
ScullyR. E.GaldabiniJ. J.McNeelyB. U., Case 44–1979, New England Journal of Medicine, 301, pp. 987–994, 1979.
44.
RubertS. L.HollenderM. H.MehrhofE. G., Olfactory Hallucinations, Archives of General Psychiatry, 5, pp. 313–318, 1961.
45.
CrosleyC. J.DhamoonS., Migrainous Olfactory Aura in a Family, Archives of Neurology, 40, p. 459, 1983.
46.
BursteinA., Olfactory Hallucinations, Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 38, p. 80, 1987.
47.
NesseR. M.CarliT.CurtisG. C.KleinmanP. D., Pseudohallucinations in Cancer Chemotherapy Patients, American Journal of Psychiatry, 140, pp. 483–485, 1983.
48.
CalkinsM. W., Statistics of Dreams, American Journal of Psychology, 5, pp. 311–343, 1893.
49.
WeedS. C.HallamF. M., Minor Studies from the Psychological Laboratory of Wellesley College, American Journal of Psychology, 7, pp. 405–411, 1896.
50.
KnappP. H., Sensory Impressions in Dreams, Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 25, pp. 325–347, 1956.
51.
SnyderF., The Phenomenology of Dreaming, in The Psychodynamic Implications of the Physiological Studies of Dreams, MadowL.SnowL. H. (eds.), C. C. Thomas, Illinois, pp. 124–151, 1970.
52.
HurovitzC. S.DunnS.DomhoffG. W.FissH., The Dreams of Blind Men and Women: A Replication and Extension of Previous Findings, Dreaming, 9, pp. 183–193, 1999.
53.
TrotterK.DallasK.VerdoneP., Olfactory Stimuli and Their Effects on REM Dreams, Psychiatric Journal of the University of Ottawa, 13, pp. 94–96, 1988.
54.
ZadraA. L.NielsenT. A.DondeiD. C., Prevalence of Auditory, Olfactory and Gustatory Experiences in Home Dreams, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 87, pp. 819–826, 1998.
55.
EngenT., The Perception of Odors, Academic Press, New York, 1982.
56.
HintonP. B.HenleyT. B., Cognitive and Affective components of Stimuli Produced in Three Modes, Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 31, pp. 595–598, 1993.
57.
WrzesniewskiA.McCauleyC.RozinP., Odor and Affect: Individual Differences in the Impact of Odor on Liking for Places, Things and People, Chemical Senses, 24, pp. 713–721, 1999.
58.
MarksD. F., Visual Imagery Differences in the Recall of Pictures, British Journal of Psychology, 64, pp. 17–24, 1973.
59.
PierceJ.HalpernB., Orthonasal and Retronasal Odorant Identification Based upon Vapor Phase Input from Common Substances, Chemical Senses, 21, pp. 529–543, 1996.
60.
DotyR. L.ShamanP.ApplebaumS. L.GibersonR.SikorskiL.RosenbergL., Smell Identification Ability: Changes with Age, Science, 226, pp. 1441–1443, 1984.
61.
GilbertA. N.WysockiC. J., The Smell Survey, National Geographic, 172, pp. 514–525, 1987.
62.
CainW. S., Odor Identification by Males and Females: Predictions vs Performance, Chemical Senses, 7, pp. 129–142, 1982.
63.
De WijkR.CainW. S., Odor Identification by Name and by Edibility: Life Span Development and Safety, Human Factors, 36, pp. 182–187, 1994.
64.
DotyR. L.SmithR.McKeownD. A.RajJ., Tests of Human Olfactory Function: Principal Components Analysis Suggests that Most Measure a Common Source of Variance, Perception & Psychophysics, 56, pp. 701–708, 1994.
65.
HomewoodJ.StevensonR. J., Differences in Naming Accuracy of Odors Presented to the Left and Right Nostrils, Biological Psychology, 58, pp. 65–73, 2001.
66.
CrowneD. P.MarlowD., A New Scale of Social Desirability Independent of Psychopathology, Journal of Consulting Psychology, 24, pp. 349–354, 1960.
67.
BassoA.BisiachE.LuzzattiC., Loss of Mental Imagery: A Case Study, Neuropsychologia, 18, pp. 435–442, 1980.
68.
WilsonD. A.StevensonR. J., Olfactory Perceptual Learning: The Critical Role of Memory in Odor Discrimination, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 27, pp. 307–328, 2003.
69.
StevensonR. J.BoakesR. A., A Mnemonic Theory of Odor Perception, Psychological Review, 110, pp. 340–364, 2003.
70.
CowanN., Evolving Conceptions of Memory Storage, Selective Attention, and Their Mutual Constraints within the Human Information Processing System, Psychological Bulletin, 104, pp. 163–191, 1988.
71.
KosslynS. M.GanisG.ThompsonW. L., Mental Imagery: Against the Nihilistic Hypothesis, Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 7, pp. 109–111, 2003.
72.
ElmesD. G., Is There an Inner Nose?Chemical Senses, 23, pp. 443–445, 1998.
73.
AlgomD.CainW. S., Remembered Odors and Mental Mixtures: Tapping Reservoirs of Olfactory Knowledge, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception & Performance, 17, pp. 1104–1119, 1991.
74.
KwapilT. R.ChapmanJ. P.ChapmanL. J.MillerM. B., Deviant Olfactory Experiences as Indicators of Risk for Psychosis, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 22, pp. 371–382, 1996.
75.
MohrC.HubenerF.LaskaM., Deviant Olfactory Experiences, Magical Ideation, and Olfactory Sensitivity: A Study with Healthy German and Japanese Subjects, Psychiatry Research, 111, pp. 21–33, 2002.
76.
KellyP. H., Defective Inhibition of Dream Event Memory Formation: A Hypothesized Mechanism in the Onset and Progression of Symptoms of Schizophrenia, Brain Research Bulletin, 46, pp. 189–197, 1998.
